[PATCH v2 04/21] documentation, blksnap: Block Devices Snapshots Module

From: Sergei Shtepa <sergei.shtepa@veeam.com>
To: <axboe@kernel.dk>, <corbet@lwn.net>
Cc: <linux-block@vger.kernel.org>, <linux-doc@vger.kernel.org>,
	<linux-kernel@vger.kernel.org>,
	Sergei Shtepa <sergei.shtepa@veeam.com>
Subject: [PATCH v2 04/21] documentation, blksnap:  Block Devices Snapshots Module
Date: Fri, 9 Dec 2022 15:23:14 +0100	[thread overview]
Message-ID: <20221209142331.26395-5-sergei.shtepa@veeam.com> (raw)
In-Reply-To: <20221209142331.26395-1-sergei.shtepa@veeam.com>

The document contains:
* Describes the purpose of the mechanism
* Description of features
* Description of algorithms
* Recommendations about using the module from the user-space side
* Reference to module interface description

Signed-off-by: Sergei Shtepa <sergei.shtepa@veeam.com>
---
 Documentation/block/blksnap.rst | 348 ++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
 Documentation/block/index.rst   |   1 +
 2 files changed, 349 insertions(+)
 create mode 100644 Documentation/block/blksnap.rst

diff --git a/Documentation/block/blksnap.rst b/Documentation/block/blksnap.rst
new file mode 100644
index 000000000000..fdc9c698d2ea
--- /dev/null
+++ b/Documentation/block/blksnap.rst
@@ -0,0 +1,348 @@
+.. SPDX-License-Identifier: GPL-2.0
+
+========================================
+Block Devices Snapshots Module (blksnap)
+========================================
+
+Introduction
+============
+
+At first glance, there is no novelty in the idea of creating snapshots for
+block devices. The Linux kernel already has mechanisms for creating snapshots.
+Device Mapper includes dm-snap, which allows to create snapshots of block
+devices. BTRFS supports snapshots at the file system level. However, both
+of these options have flaws that do not allow to use them as a universal
+tool for creating backups.
+
+Device Mapper flaws:
+
+- Block devices must have LVM markup.
+  If no logical volumes were created during system installation, then dm-snap
+  cannot be applied.
+- To store snapshot differences of one logical volume, it is necessary to
+  reserve a fixed range of sectors on a reserved empty logical volume.
+  Firstly, it is required that the system has enough space unoccupied by the
+  file system, which rarely occurs on real servers. Secondly, as a rule,
+  it is necessary to create snapshots for all logical volumes at once, which
+  requires dividing this reserved space between several logical volumes.
+  This space can be divided equally or proportionally to the size. But
+  the load on different disks is usually uneven. As a result, a snapshot
+  overflow may occur for one of the block devices, while for others all
+  the reserved space may remain free. This complicates management of the
+  difference storage and makes it almost impossible to create a coherent
+  snapshot of multiple logical volumes.
+
+BTRFS flaws:
+
+- Snapshots create a persistent image of the file system, not a block device.
+  Such a snapshot is only applicable for a file backup.
+- When synchronizing the snapshot subvolume with the backup subvolume, reading
+  the differences leads to random access to the block device, which leads
+  to decrease in efficiency compared to direct copying of the block device.
+- BTRFS allows to get an incremental backup [#btrfs_increment]_, but it is
+  necessary to keep a snapshot of the previous backup cycle on the system,
+  which leads to excessive consumption of disk space.
+- If there is not enough free space on the file system while holding the
+  snapshot, new data cannot be saved, which leads to a server malfunction.
+
+Features of the blksnap module:
+
+- Change tracker
+- Snapshots at the block device level
+- Dynamic allocation of space for storing differences
+- Snapshot overflow resistance
+- Coherent snapshot of multiple block devices
+
+
+For a more detailed description of the features, see the `Features`_ section.
+
+The listed set of features allows to achieve the key goals of the backup tool:
+
+- Simplicity and versatility of use
+- Reliability
+- Minimal consumption of system resources during backup
+- Minimal time required for recovery or replication of the entire system
+
+Features
+========
+
+Change tracker
+--------------
+
+The change tracker allows to determine which blocks were changed during the
+time between the last snapshot created and any of the previous snapshots.
+Having a map of changes, it is enough to copy only the changed blocks, and
+no need to reread the entire block device completely. The change tracker
+allows to implement the logic of both incremental and differential backups.
+Incremental backup is critical for large file repositories whose size can be
+hundreds of terabytes and whose full backup time can take more than a day.
+On such servers, the use of backup tools without a change tracker becomes
+practically impossible.
+
+Snapshot at the block device level
+----------------------------------
+
+A snapshot at the block device level allows to simplify the backup algorithm
+and reduce consumption of system resources. It also allows to perform linear
+reading of disk space directly, which allows to achieve maximum reading speed
+with minimal use of processor time. At the same time, the versatility of
+creating snapshots for any block device is achieved, regardless of the file
+system located on it. The exceptions are BTRFS, ZFS and cluster file systems.
+
+Dynamic allocation of storage space for differences
+---------------------------------------------------
+
+To store differences, the module does not require a pre-reserved block
+device range. A range of sectors can be allocated on any block device
+immediately before creating a snapshot in individual files on the file
+system. In addition, the size of the difference storage can be increased
+after the snapshot is created by adding new sector ranges on block devices.
+Sector ranges can be allocated on any block devices of the system, including
+those on which the snapshot was created. A shared difference storage for
+all images of snapshot block devices allows to optimize the use of disk space.
+
+Snapshot overflow resistance
+----------------------------
+
+To create images of snapshots of block devices, the module stores blocks
+of the original block device that have been changed since the snapshot
+was taken. To do this, the module handles write requests and reads blocks
+that need to be overwritten. This algorithm guarantees safety of the data
+of the original block device in the event of an overflow of the snapshot,
+and even in the case of unpredictable critical errors. If a problem occurs
+during backup, the difference storage is released, the snapshot is closed,
+no backup is created, but the server continues to work.
+
+Coherent snapshot of multiple block devices
+-------------------------------------------
+
+A snapshot is created simultaneously for all block devices for which a backup
+is being created, ensuring their coherent state.
+
+
+Algorithms
+==========
+
+Overview
+--------
+
+The blksnap module is a block-level filter. It handles all write I/O units.
+The filter is attached to the block device when the snapshot is created
+for the first time. The change tracker marks all overwritten blocks.
+Information about the history of changes on the block device is available
+while holding the snapshot. The module reads the blocks that need to be
+overwritten and stores them in the difference storage. When reading from
+a snapshot image, reading is performed either from the original device or
+from the difference storage.
+
+Change tracking
+---------------
+
+A change tracker map is created for each block device. One byte
+of this map corresponds to one block. The block size is set by the
+``tracking_block_minimum_shift`` and ``tracking_block_maximum_count``
+module parameters. The ``tracking_block_minimum_shift`` parameter limits
+the minimum block size for tracking, while ``tracking_block_maximum_count``
+defines the maximum allowed number of blocks. The size of the change tracker
+block is determined depending on the size of the block device when adding
+a tracking device, that is, when the snapshot is taken for the first time.
+The block size must be a power of two.
+
+The byte of the change map stores a number from 0 to 255. This is the
+snapshot number, since the creation of which there have been changes in
+the block. Each time a snapshot is created, the number of the current
+snapshot is increased by one. This number is written to the cell of the
+change map when writing to the block. Thus, knowing the number of one of
+the previous snapshots and the number of the last snapshot, one can determine
+from the change map which blocks have been changed. When the number of the
+current change reaches the maximum allowed value for the map of 255, at the
+time when the next snapshot is created, the map of changes is reset to zero,
+and the number of the current snapshot is assigned the value 1. The change
+tracker is reset, and a new UUID is generated - a unique identifier of the
+snapshot generation. The snapshot generation identifier allows to identify
+that a change tracking reset has been performed.
+
+The change map has two copies. One copy is active, it tracks the current
+changes on the block device. The second copy is available for reading
+while the snapshot is being held, and contains the history up to the moment
+the snapshot is taken. Copies are synchronized at the moment of snapshot
+creation. After the snapshot is released, a second copy of the map is not
+needed, but it is not released, so as not to allocate memory for it again
+the next time the snapshot is created.
+
+Copy on write
+-------------
+
+Data is copied in blocks, or rather in chunks. The term "chunk" is used to
+avoid confusion with change tracker blocks and I/O blocks. In addition,
+the "chunk" in the blksnap module means about the same as the "chunk" in
+the dm-snap module.
+
+The size of the chunk is determined by the ``chunk_minimum_shift`` and
+``chunk_maximum_count`` module parameters. The ``chunk_minimum_shift``
+parameter limits the minimum size of the chunk, while ``chunk_maximum_count``
+defines the maximum allowed number of chunks. The size of the chunk is
+determined depending on the size of the block device at the time of taking the
+snapshot. The size of the chunk must be a power of two. One chunk is described
+by the ``struct chunk`` structure. An array of structures is created for each
+block device. The structure contains all the necessary information to copy
+the chunks data from the original block device to the difference storage.
+This information allows to describe the snapshot image. A semaphore is located
+in the structure, which allows synchronization of threads accessing the chunk.
+
+The block level has a feature. If a read I/O unit was sent, and a write I/O
+unit was sent after it, then a write can be performed first, and only then
+a read. Therefore, the copy-on-write algorithm is executed synchronously.
+If a write request is handled, the execution of this I/O unit will be
+delayed until the overwritten chunks are copied to the difference storage.
+But if, when handling a write I/O unit, it turns out that the recorded range
+of sectors has already been copied to the difference storage, then the I/O
+unit is simply passed.
+
+This algorithm allows to efficiently perform backups of systems that run
+Round Robin Database. Such databases can be overwritten several times during
+the system backup. Of course, the value of a backup of the RRD monitoring
+system data can be questioned. However, it is often a task to make a backup
+of the entire enterprise infrastructure in order to restore or replicate it
+entirely in case of problems.
+
+There is also a flaw in the algorithm. When overwriting at least one sector,
+an entire chunk is copied. Thus, a situation of rapid filling of the difference
+storage when writing data to a block device in small portions in random order
+is possible. This situation is possible in case of strong fragmentation of
+data on the file system. But it must be borne in mind that with such data
+fragmentation, performance of systems usually degrades greatly. So, this
+problem does not occur on real servers, although it can easily be created
+by artificial tests.
+
+Difference storage
+------------------
+
+The difference storage is a pool of disk space areas, and it is shared with
+all block devices in the snapshot. Therefore, there is no need to divide
+the difference storage area between block devices, and the difference storage
+itself can be located on different block devices.
+
+There is no need to allocate a large disk space immediately before creating
+a snapshot. Even while the snapshot is being held, the difference storage
+can be expanded. It is enough to have free space on the file system.
+
+Areas of disk space can be allocated on the file system using fallocate(),
+and the file location can be requested using Fiemap Ioctl or Fibmap Ioctl.
+Unfortunately, not all file systems support these mechanisms, but the most
+common XFS, EXT4 and BTRFS file systems support it. BTRFS requires additional
+conversion of virtual offsets to physical ones.
+
+While holding the snapshot, the user process can poll the status of the module.
+When free space in the difference storage is reduced to a threshold value, the
+module generates an event about it. The user process can prepare a new area
+and pass it to the module to expand the difference storage. The threshold
+value is determined as half of the value of the ``diff_storage_minimum``
+module parameter.
+
+If free space in the difference storage runs out, an event is generated about
+the overflow of the snapshot. Such a snapshot is considered corrupted, and
+read I/O units to snapshot images will be terminated with an error code.
+The difference storage stores outdated data required for snapshot images,
+so when the snapshot is overflowed, the backup process is interrupted,
+but the system maintains its operability without data loss.
+
+How to use
+==========
+
+Depending on the needs and the selected license, you can choose different
+options for managing the module:
+
+- Using ioctl directly
+- Using a static C++ library
+- Using the blksnap console tool
+
+Using ioctl
+-----------
+
+The module provides the ``include/uapi/blksnap.h`` header file. It describes
+all the available ioctl and structures for interacting with the module.
+Each ioctl and structure is documented in detail. The general algorithm
+for calling control requests is approximately the following:
+
+1. ``blk_snap_ioctl_snapshot_create`` initiates the snapshot
+   creation process.
+2. ``blk_snap_ioctl_snapshot_append_storage`` allows to add the first range of
+   blocks to store changes.
+3. ``blk_snap_ioctl_snapshot_take`` creates block devices of block device
+   snapshot images.
+4. ``blk_snap_ioctl_snapshot_collect`` and
+   ``blk_snap_ioctl_snapshot_collect_images`` allow to match the original
+   block devices and their corresponding snapshot images.
+5. Snapshot images are being read from block devices whose numbers were received
+   when calling ``blk_snap_ioctl_snapshot_collect_images``. Snapshot images also
+   support the write operation. So, the file system on the snapshot image can be
+   mounted before backup, which allows to perform the necessary preprocessing.
+6. ``blk_snap_ioctl_tracker_collect`` and
+   ``blk_snap_ioctl_tracker_read_cbt_map`` allow to get data of the change
+   tracker. If a write operation was performed for the snapshot, then the change
+   tracker takes this into account. Therefore, it is necessary to receive
+   tracker data after write operations have been completed.
+7. ``blk_snap_ioctl_snapshot_wait_event`` allows to track the status of
+   snapshots and receive events about the requirement to expand the difference
+   storage or about snapshot overflow.
+8. The difference storage is expanded using
+   ``blk_snap_ioctl_snapshot_append_storage``.
+9. ``blk_snap_ioctl_snapshot_destroy`` releases the snapshot.
+10. If, after creating a backup, postprocessing is performed that changes the
+    backup blocks, it is necessary to mark such blocks as dirty in the change
+    tracker table. ``blk_snap_ioctl_tracker_mark_dirty_blocks`` is used for
+    this.
+11. It is possible to disable the change tracker from any block device using
+    ``blk_snap_ioctl_tracker_remove``.
+
+Static C++ library
+------------------
+
+The [#userspace_libs]_ library was created primarily to simplify creation of
+tests in C++, and it is also a good example of using the module interface.
+When creating applications, direct use of control calls is preferable.
+However, the library can be used in an application with a GPL-2+ license,
+or a library with an LGPL-2+ license can be created, with which even a
+proprietary application can be dynamically linked.
+
+blksnap console tool
+--------------------
+
+The blksnap [#userspace_tools]_ console tool allows to control the module
+from the command line. The tool contains detailed built-in help. To get
+the list of commands, enter the ``blksnap --help`` command. The ``blksnap
+<command name> --help`` command allows to get detailed information about the
+parameters of each command call. This option may be convenient when creating
+proprietary software, as it allows not to compile with the open source code.
+At the same time, the blksnap tool can be used for creating backup scripts.
+For example, rsync can be called to synchronize files on the file system of
+the mounted snapshot image and files in the archive on a file system that
+supports compression.
+
+Tests
+-----
+
+A set of tests was created for regression testing [#userspace_tests]_.
+Tests with simple algorithms that use the ``blksnap`` console tool to
+control the module are written in Bash. More complex testing algorithms
+are implemented in C++. Documentation [#userspace_tests_doc]_ about them
+can be found on the project repository.
+
+References
+==========
+
+.. [#btrfs_increment] https://btrfs.wiki.kernel.org/index.php/Incremental_Backup
+
+.. [#userspace_libs] https://github.com/veeam/blksnap/tree/master/lib/blksnap
+
+.. [#userspace_tools] https://github.com/veeam/blksnap/tree/master/tools/blksnap
+
+.. [#userspace_tests] https://github.com/veeam/blksnap/tree/master/tests
+
+.. [#userspace_tests_doc] https://github.com/veeam/blksnap/tree/master/doc
+
+Module interface description
+============================
+
+.. kernel-doc:: include/uapi/linux/blksnap.h
diff --git a/Documentation/block/index.rst b/Documentation/block/index.rst
index bef6de22d651..b5c1c1a679c1 100644
--- a/Documentation/block/index.rst
+++ b/Documentation/block/index.rst
@@ -11,6 +11,7 @@ Block
    biovecs
    blk-mq
    blkfilter
+   blksnap
    capability
    cmdline-partition
    data-integrity
-- 
2.20.1

