[U-Boot-Users] [PATCH 00/07 v2]: Add mpc7448hpc2 (Taiga) board support

[Wolfgang Denk <wd@denx.de>]

Hello,

in message <1164593553.28194.2.camel@localhost.localdomain> you wrote:
> 
> 	How about the progress of mpc7448hpc2 board in u-boot?

I had a look at your code.

I see a few problems:

1) it does not merge cleanly  with the current top of tree in the git
   repo; there are conflicts with common/cfi_flash.c

2) there are lots of coding style violations: C++ comments in
   drivers/tsi108_i2c.cand include/configs/mpc7448hpc2.h; trailing
   white space in board/mpc7448hpc2/asm_init.S,
   board/mpc7448hpc2/mpc7448hpc2.c, board/mpc7448hpc2/tsi108_init.c,
   cpu/74xx_7xx/cpu.c, cpu/74xx_7xx/speed.c, doc/README.mpc7448hpc2,
   drivers/tsi108_i2c.c, include/configs/mpc7448hpc2.h,
   include/tsi108.h; indentation not by TABs at least in
   board/mpc7448hpc2/asm_init.S, include/configs/mpc7448hpc2.h;
   trailing empty lines in doc/README.mpc7448hpc2.

   Note that these are just examples; the same problems may be present
   in other files as well. Please check ALL your code.

   Also, you don't place spaces as reqyired by the Coding Style (for
   example, we normally have spaces before the '(' of a function
   call).

   Also, the Coding Style discourages using '{ ... }' for simple
   one-line conditionals.

3) Your Makefiles don't support building in a separate directory

4) Indentation looks not nice. For example, in
   board/mpc7448hpc2/asm_init.S we have:

	+    mfspr   r3,1014         /* read MSSCR0 */
	+    rlwinm. r3,r3,27,31,31  /* get processor ID number */
	+    mtspr   SPRN_PIR,r3     /* Save CPU ID */
	+    sync
	+    bne init_done
	+    b do_tsi108_init

   This is not indented by TAB's, and why don;t you align the
   arguments of the "bne" and "b" instructions like the rest?

   Or take this:

   	+#define READ_SPD(byte_num)     \
	+       addis r3, 0, byte_num at l;\
	+       or      r3, r3, r10;\
	+       ori r3, r3, 0x0A;\
	+       stw r3, SD_I2C_CTRL1(r4);\
	+       li r3, I2C_CNTRL2_START;\
	+       stw r3, SD_I2C_CTRL2(r4);\
	+       eieio;\
	+       sync;\
	+       li r3, 0x100;\ 

   Or this:

   	+       READ_SPD(12)    /* get Refresh Rate */
	+       beq check_next_slot
	+       li r5, ERR_RFRSH_RATE
	+       cmpi 0,0,r3,SPD_MIN_RFRSH
	+       ble spd_fail
	+       cmpi 0,0,r3,SPD_MAX_RFRSH
	+       bgt spd_fail
	+       addi r3,r3,-SPD_MIN_RFRSH
	+       rlwinm r3,r3,2,0,31
	+       lis r5,refresh_rates at h
	+       ori r5,r5,refresh_rates at l
	+       lwzx r5,r5,r3   /* get refresh rate in nSec */
	+       divwu r5,r5,r9  /* calculate # of SDC clocks */
	+       stw r5,SD_REFRESH(r4)   /* Set refresh rate */

   Sorry, but I consider this unreadable.

5) board/mpc7448hpc2/mpc7448hpc2.c contains yet another memory test.
   Do we really need another copy of this code?

6) Some files - like mpc7448hpc2/tsi108_init.c - contain deep magic
   with little or no comments (see for example function
   board_early_init_f()). I guess you want to add some more comments
   here and there...

7) The output of your code seems to be pretty different from what we
   have on other boards; see again board_early_init_f():

   	+       printf("BUS!   %d MHz\n", get_board_bus_clk() / 1000000);
	+       printf("MEM!   %d MHz\n", gd->mem_clk / 1000000);

   Can you please try keeping the look and feel we have on most other
   boards?

8) Your code adds some data structures globally (like
   hid1_7447A_multipliers_x_10[] in cpu/74xx_7xx/speed.c) which are
   probably not needed for all processors. Maybe you can use some
   #ifdef's here to prevent adding lots of dead code / data to most
   board configurations?

9) The login here looks weird to me - is this correct?
   cpu/74xx_7xx/speed.c:
   	...
	+#ifdef CFG_CONFIG_BUS_CLK
	+       gd->bus_clk = get_board_bus_clk();
	+#else
	+       gd->bus_clk = CFG_BUS_CLK;
	+#endif 

10) Please keep your line length within the allowed limits.

11) Please don't define CONFIG_ETHADDR / CONFIG_ETH1ADDR in your board
    config file. It is really evil when all boards have the same MAC
    addresses. Also, are the addresses you used officially assigned
    ones?

    Same is for CONFIG_IPADDR, CONFIG_SERVERIP, CONFIG_NETMASK,
    CONFIG_GATEWAYIP - it may save some time to have these set during
    development, but for a public source version I don't ever want to
    see these.

12) In lib_ppc/extable.c you add code with a "#ifdef
    CFG_EXCEPTION_AFTER_RELOCATE; there is absolutely no explanation
    nor comment anywhere why you think this is necessary.



Please clean up and resubmit.

Best regards,

Wolfgang Denk

-- 
Software Engineering:  Embedded and Realtime Systems,  Embedded Linux
Phone: (+49)-8142-66989-10 Fax: (+49)-8142-66989-80 Email: wd at denx.de
"Am besten betrachten Sie Fehlermeldungen als eine  Art  Psycho-Test,
mit  dem  herausgefunden  werden soll, wie belastbar Sie sind."
 - Dr. R. Wonneberger, Kompaktf?hrer LaTeX, Kap. 1.6: Fehlermeldungen