From mboxrd@z Thu Jan 1 00:00:00 1970 Return-Path: Received: (majordomo@vger.kernel.org) by vger.kernel.org via listexpand id S1757809Ab2F0UbE (ORCPT ); Wed, 27 Jun 2012 16:31:04 -0400 Received: from e28smtp09.in.ibm.com ([122.248.162.9]:54060 "EHLO e28smtp09.in.ibm.com" rhost-flags-OK-OK-OK-OK) by vger.kernel.org with ESMTP id S1753768Ab2F0UbB (ORCPT ); Wed, 27 Jun 2012 16:31:01 -0400 Message-ID: <4FEB6D1E.7090204@linux.vnet.ibm.com> Date: Thu, 28 Jun 2012 01:59:18 +0530 From: Raghavendra K T Organization: IBM User-Agent: Mozilla/5.0 (X11; Linux x86_64; rv:10.0.1) Gecko/20120216 Thunderbird/10.0.1 MIME-Version: 1.0 To: Andrew Jones , Avi Kivity , Ingo Molnar CC: Rik van Riel , Marcelo Tosatti , Srikar , Srivatsa Vaddagiri , Peter Zijlstra , "Nikunj A. Dadhania" , KVM , LKML , Gleb Natapov , chegu_vinod@hp.com, Jeremy Fitzhardinge Subject: Re: [PATCH] kvm: handle last_boosted_vcpu = 0 case with benchmark detail attachment References: <20120619202047.26191.40429.sendpatchset@codeblue> <20120619165104.2a4574f8@annuminas.surriel.com> <4FE22E9E.7070206@linux.vnet.ibm.com> <4FE304D0.5000202@linux.vnet.ibm.com> <20120622151149.GA9077@turtle.usersys.redhat.com> <4FE4DCEA.1050701@linux.vnet.ibm.com> <4FE60C41.5020907@linux.vnet.ibm.com> <4FEB6CAC.1020406@linux.vnet.ibm.com> In-Reply-To: <4FEB6CAC.1020406@linux.vnet.ibm.com> Content-Type: multipart/mixed; boundary="------------050300070005050801020408" x-cbid: 12062720-2674-0000-0000-0000050C1BA3 Sender: linux-kernel-owner@vger.kernel.org List-ID: X-Mailing-List: linux-kernel@vger.kernel.org This is a multi-part message in MIME format. --------------050300070005050801020408 Content-Type: text/plain; charset=ISO-8859-1; format=flowed Content-Transfer-Encoding: 7bit On 06/28/2012 01:57 AM, Raghavendra K T wrote: > On 06/24/2012 12:04 AM, Raghavendra K T wrote: >> On 06/23/2012 02:30 AM, Raghavendra K T wrote: >>> On 06/22/2012 08:41 PM, Andrew Jones wrote: [...] > > (benchmark values will be attached in reply to this mail) --------------050300070005050801020408 Content-Type: application/x-bzip; name="pv_benchmark_summary.bz2" Content-Transfer-Encoding: base64 Content-Disposition: attachment; filename="pv_benchmark_summary.bz2" QlpoOTFBWSZTWZveEIoAPLX/7f7wIXDK///yP2ffyv//3/QAxCAAAEAAAMAAAAhgJF55Xu95 1z2fe++vvQdOQAPfab3jva7DvrAAAK947bgBUPrRoA1QNAZUAKQlKEVVQKqgQFQVUKhUVAvv qPrRAEgdaqgcGp6AmIkRIkAAAAaABoAAAAAANTxASRKEaTIaD1AABkGQ0AANADQABqY0jSin 7KTU00bNKABoAABoAAAAAAJNJEghGRT2pqaZDQaaAAyGjQAAAA0ABEoQQTTQNCmMIGiGGpoe kAaMjQZG1GmnpGjQFKkjRMERgqexNJtCnlDxJk8U9QekAAAAADTIc4J/w/yeeRkYRK14eJQ7 GBZgXAkCkGITEVF3UQYg3vJ2KUxrWteTk7MtdyUurW6nPzE5SBzpAKbIG+oPXL0M6cC46Z6N cgNRAYdRAowAUFIolkIIQYKiSlKCpFFKKJFFJIkACCHs0BkgoAR1z7e32s613d8XtuaHlcfl 8Ww+FKQ7USrhoJIyyAOTIwycZVCgbSeNUSXb+oHIHyn378ZfhPGSQR939RHwFHxMBRwEViCP mAeEsANcP0w51X2mKIXxYJQp9l/BovI0WLzTEYbeNTCYWzm2LIMgyJIkiyJmNABtDpAMuWwB jZc9rVWCZqyoi1jJF1vWO8MD17SbxfORhdIGWxYrnu+5RiUzFmlGuoaHqqKsOYrjhda2oENk NlhIaQF1IaoEIBIEgJOoPpeevGLgBPXJQy4CFu+MZtrMRam1/oWqmY2rwtRiXW4rft5eXDx7 A1ofbBCASNE6BIAqkUU8Z/1NBADvm0gqkintQEpAaLUFLxtCEkelW/a4qV8FgQyCrdWgq2gq +fqe4xkGJIEwAQ30GCgg2F25Cvi0EZBL+pMESOzgHTr7A2WZdE9DzE1SehXpoSJzWcBjIkOk F9IRnKQGYmWybvau9LGXJx3M7DX0n0/n/XPy2pdJtJ0RCfoyuNIANDQiR3ncyECB+GYkozDx W8gjXtbDurl5W1u1omU4k6LHqT4POiUMvrfenXl3Pbvl0zXXqEQCkOaCsU5RRGCIxhi2htq1 0xiazwCt4YFYXP6PBBPCHgmwClUCp35VyAUtayyJatCq2BaWA1UIc/2hPfJ4JO/wzv7+x15t cdkPEhJ5AlRY3u9Hlw06yhTeOLgiyAqi1KkFVWnqAOC0WUs9JAlIEqJDAaoMCprI0KQIwJ3e S/OJ9iANL9iBDAa+ibdtBzY1XwRJJG0QiUHwu93SLosKdjRimXW7qNy0Taa4t432YaEeOWYK omWY4qIKOrR3hzzXFbLaJJCPjgs8JiEBpEAmpYAtwHwahT4gclMO2wyEDaGnI5ZDCQqkGXCJ BIdumZWUuZydc2Gec8Z4SQDyTzPloW+pIFgT0kUgKRRRMSBQjVRVDzjCVinNK4o3ly9H5+rx xTBeWjMFFjHjN66KKC70ZiYLmnhyaRbqzDCy3SaegY166uRREYfAaAcwjpUyHJIopywzOLca ZvJthuOy2VWsOFGM22QcYpQNp72g+xEQU2EozUKKIIhESLA3bfs7ANhNga5t4BlKDJ14ANSZ F2irBT05boAzqj88kk43JwhUIpsIEyyOZMBDhRVEXhJgRYTujbUWW0olimsBFjFhZMYvDMyt LawE30nVSYWeuev7BsJD+g2Bp0qmrZXEYhDjQOrU1BTCPEUMKiyoZo6rDOfVl0Z6U/adqyKb e4AV9TAJJCJIiboyEbYqwFErRRSVqKClUUopIr6pW2WGQ1UDky5wFhtCDwY5bbwC8gC0EXJn DT3da77i6+tnJPHLicetr6LzgEHV19+nU6dXcMWLYuHoztN9RjehXWodpqalBRDNH1rbvWzo AJSLADWvqQn7iKGgNM3q/fV9ofbv7/C94oqRtXVNxHxA3D1VY3aiHWaapzB2Bk1n4n6Hvoml eLgHnpAyqRjvhR9TWnlncSPGqcCYcY6tgjcvRHEk8vIvJcSHMQJvNIuJdLJtNxNzcOk8bXir n13a2HfN7UO3s4WoAtKTUALxFsLqYA7vwV9Oer5w8DzHiUwtwwzESmFKUwxG8RP1B8/1RVE0 GvX35HL+tq+qPreLK8LzllLx1FuJ6ZCcnHgVnVkL1oVns2yqapPYYSAEXPeL031e7ltyinax 1ZiQ1JtnDtW2MKYSAZOwJdjZjKOU8zGLi4siJWRMUSDd2qm3NVVm3U4KgtS7VinUIRcmjbMg jARDhGpnMJOTOKMmok4su8bkNCFIoXlRILBCy5ug1NupLxiraQVyzRTEh3EPGkzNr8brX41w wrjhju9s2NZUDmOaInvHhAe7QJBD2iPJ4+7b7PF4flCTYCwKtoq4/VjGMSRkZDrmfnyds6vf 5ONUTpHBCcEOHi4C1YULr63VUy2foiCD9E8+gRG4MEEuHolweaJGWVBqokXYsKEzzZvY4BhB WiSIkXu7SCGXdMKhgrBWTWPc0QBZUZeBijcTk2LIjJY3mRgwRJiJIRdu7GDcy3btDDGrDhQy 3khmlDuC3HKKyqMuKWwXghM7DwUpDusc1dRZq0wVNtiReKUU8jTywb3VjDtiTyhRnROHVUzM mooNZZ2XM6hMxAVhRAijAInHr1btBcitzQwbGCAW3o1XW2Xt03YdsYK3XuIZLmME7CgiNjS7 pWLYpN2wtxZMAqDHNFDHUaRGSJGZZV6g2mFO1bssiY5DY0EJqoguJVxgt2LxhksTmVY3loU7 NXWVNQFrVYkKXLt1m62NZw6LM8SrZMPcODE4ZswKpLbBIbUCybXINAPmXWiVb4ksV1saaW5V DIk1kF5jehaRlWItQUNJozKWJVMqEzQq4yYe7lVMoYxGzl7Jt3YucbyK2Aqp8jYVMspJ5Gox k6FRqxNEQ9yMxZRmwg7wwMhPBuBDZLqgXFULkOdjRMjGJN1FWJECLuUDeqzgTR2hdRbhVEiw bRgBPXuszWNY4ho3OqGd0YLkRs8QiAbFjNuLpy2HIqt/39/X60UO0qvkUHdUNDl0lA0aM9RF dOvWtKBV/LNZkFH5bknd2uGhEjZE0jdTIFKymotMCY8Xn0LvZJJwI9Eurd8usCcEkiHuISBR 1rRyW0xNYlszowJbZa5LwDP3QiiwlyK4EXFHNxsGLrak0IbgRrfWCVXVxtqTSvlO/JCruoSh sjWta0tYIDIH+zrWhoMoh+5y0m7DJWoABWsyJcq/hq+/veUhXasUKeUlcA54uT6ASSwKw7Du JgkYd7hmvJouFmu+us0n0+ZZnkH6H6E6ekScTUhE0bgoGI1pjCKXNpk96/DC6UECbhLKax1r dFkWlBQJysvCacCzT8Yl3gGwDBtcfM1G4iNOASLurUGSCqFbtwrFXApcuhAhpQMk2UhSw3G3 wzzEEKszwEVcQs1MEjkynuDXs8PJ5MzlC3xAgahTp8CFaFZiQrlxRnSteawZSyhBBOGGEkcq InGOaQIIlEoKhhzLeW8qVzNjjoJC2RNNFxxEQgENODuVS6g3Z2lvYzUO9HQcjXJw6WeSFjoj tO5uJ4rkcAypdeTWdxGs0UpvYE2ssXEZcRWP5wAIw56HryIXc2Lw13IyVOcw30DiTXekCkzS KLdiAhWsyWuw7DBjFBNrtMUfXCEYvZSIS9eCLGnShmZ5zDXlRsSFnaFTBpX1penczmVDSYt0 d1z7AhGciq5x0yW2qOnnR5X8r0oUfiADWv25yg4v9542TBR4gMFcBgunNek08WNKCCQzYzOg QkEKolmKE4oxgHpZT5uz8mCYHlglAyISE6l4OkwFULtEuY/Ff35CkO6T8Eu17uZhFWqrLMoU FcwEhZiMtLMVRS4sGgMdJA9e/fF9WEI8N3+/qSB6VIOlVB9QpNeTu72PPSAYKPyFEUDHtIEf Sx0cEh0fmnFLEcmnyiXUZCiA9/HPgFBnyiKk9jsemMUvtkVCaNFn7615zxAvXYJ06cOS6Eem ZhAIcqQiahlhyDglD1Help6yJ2shbq+zqvPPmxxE5pj1DJ7RNlStqkyLEMttxQKswUL3KrQm A+RJJdoBmEudYVBx7VSs3dPpa29pHtgSpW8A9RK+BvR1YSoabODm0J9DQFr61yFDN6Snfc6J OkCjkHA0ESd736l5Lztrd1qmU0wuZTIrPVx73UMDgWpdUuVCjVv/MmR432Z2+iM851tugi72 Hje+R774bKOXhyydFnvTOubTSj4wLBvU8ULQcO2hoUEHjtxodiWiT3bIyo4+fJEKh0Pi0EZY 36tnn2RPDj7dkeXVvauIREClB29+/fOXaoHmPJfvrpK+MiggjjMp8dRLeZCKHj0qj6QocdR4 d3QuiBr9pc6On9c46+49ah32tMrbFVSQI3MSQ2ksz2ABC5tvPH0er7WU7cA+ErmeDLvsjANR GCzeEnEK6ZNgl7tEUIv1B0jA4sSiJBZ50HjtemVgIwFnlSp9ZuzzKV5993M5BHU5WVq8Vwu3 3nmCIKbi0RlDO7JWLCekrrXKan5o+9QZswJIR3AV+KX04f5VPpCAre0SnXWN5nxy0RfQHgwh mppzNxTceSFGAvsQ/X3i6VGAVRDtChlQ/S+bYvC7GcacedKPe523gSKiyKHfFCQEBjXyRmEG Xjdy699lfSxuVb6D0LOuJ5xKHRi8LZxPSL2i7kYkkifA97o36ZXeLlpLaLYNmwWd8Lvhe2AY XdJ4HB0SAyEhqEPKzLXOmuZuo6SosBH6gX1T4ZcglmAwhAlH6mZY0sWkxGx8OOsOArLBuqpu W+GxHzlWQ2+NqzUnbjQDDaB9ZHp2S3k08I5CRQ5ncbl4HSXzlb2ofbKYS0oKOHTNuNjDbPXp x08tCeg8sgoWQOqBMpRjxITgqMMkbhVRk188TPjNcYMMTMJSPPlfrUj16DBF3DaVUqu/E3PG GKydXY96CBhV9CNdh6aWgI1Sm3RI4ABmxQIoioq0Vr485IqfLHa26h4utgNDsuB0iTyjUphy 4lBEUQBUCkuCDzsEha8QM9md7vgHCJe81FNBtrfayNGHuKVM+vjCJhUXkocBQtUNET6hyQJd iKVqA04nycYe3RsUbbx5DIZ1CSRmSsnBI2WelJuXXjVBCNCFQPC3re2D/K2rARvbQdeiIXTI YRm0orOUV2IdTd/BPajfAe2MbgWQ7v0vaBVQz5d7MTAhVnXvku2k8bqsjFWGel6+9CnTi3oL ITRQhFQkcG3r0LfzrMX1ZXmR1IjQG0qoofM8fo4dNwol9ksuhpAiS/WffUnpmA0WQ+qXuTqC qyV8bbfUAdQCFHrq784s+S55iC6VNeTDXaeJsnYSCEAI4W5xYza15fW2V1tKKGTcIECdxN0c 9CQEOwQ3FJXqCS/QlZLrL07jxe2eowKvaP5t3QPVUwZSjWyQDLBwo6OMrwUIHEHHUNDjAtvt 55KqTzZqzIYDrqk86cwjQ1OIaYFpFWHJVHLpoKCryx6yl9RG1FkJiivoLrhGtAzxdWOja1Wt dMJDlN7rJYSlQVss8zgADLCHZG5RcvNtDgHImaDgcA5LVPBlGAo6FGvegc7k+wKoaVMmqHJX kuUwezfKBywjXmOlfliwdbVO7WSPNzexF8qM1Dedg7QlVXavMNiRA2TtPZo32IXTWqIKC3MD PY8EdvUxMbi5ZQp4UpBJL8RAQqAhLypVScdbeVtzSc3eHkVxwqnd8VgLdSWSUCoQt8ObEbD4 GCjsli+T01xi2CaldvtwCnojhB8xIxMQe+MC4CGKjWLvQ0EAKRndh+uhO66u9h9ZkRD5SMRV IwwPDdL81SWkMVCqKCqQ01nejBp3xQKs9vvbGJvrkHZci/S8l1cYrNBbxw0xWIHgMJGxLQXo EotxGzuzYTCFeQYZ1k8ROXz1uuvE8dKfh26GVWzAfZlo7MHfTt5HdIG9LQ4Gx33ykPirDYuK 76zeowjNpqZ8vYurlesHUkxSIlMwNK7vcJCsxNvkj/EDkqx1yq9VETkQ/jgbGQfXyFq2su7Y pfGR2ig+G7h5vgAE378D75nkWqW2TT7MucnHd3YU+YSoD3h3MU94FbKMNa553dqxUkJ/PyFH A+Kj+n2rOs9qAqu+2zqZuFV2ZQZsZwDwZD1mzGX2YRExFBRjqxRCymUW+eGYCk6OdU8IdQo4 z2ffwlVh7SUDFhNaAvnkNZ6DxmrYwjp+PIsNqVzdusQo8R6L8rzmUp7ygR49GSGxNQuRU2ll 4ciSS7u7IQrLsljBRMwmIfl35VHRi0LTwzi9qB7SymvNqk4SyhDIWIfiXuikIjucCcbiGw0c tZ2S4zmBIpQwJ6RMJc8vuJbPJwrcdLFZcIxULW1PSJWnUb7NB8MxblQ6b07RJUdoaAXNSW6s SryoS+RNouc3FVqRXYjqCZG8Ki+F82yiF3DAGRI2sd1sIZBvr9I2ZyAp3prBUOBg3Yb3qSNY /KjfBGltGkWFtuAAESwpK2agELve7DQqarXcCWyIsZ64JnL1l9nq6FeALbCKtrgwhokTYSHU rt8Hs821WFwQI3cTnlSHr7QkMUMYUIRL7bw6+WFUW7GtZISkwzGxrWtWLVuCDko6BwuQ3jFM 1EqXcxHA2fp56yp0PuTImHflGaB8PElNbm2vW1z0cxtiBHQvYqE4UwdaW6uiFDOAppIEpPZl nUQ2+MsuLWVyxbJcMhp0YkHDt56h4EcDQGuKQk943vzvkpuG8rrl8f3rQHdIS25WQUvUKRvP W1MUuN2EoWcKdcaAduEKVVdprMeMnyarjdarBE8HqxLNwDTkbyTTszdEQXc0zKqPoBDJFQ8M cGeubXZuhwRp3ZWZRBR0qYhPI5mNUoMcJAkEOgXNRBrD58JBw519lHyOeyPQ818I9IU0D2Di WbhkwhHwYR+OYWJypTfpjKkx6nuXU2+1ii630ABCOrmmdx4tgXV5wxb6Z0B+gjwm6VkbCRHM hQlqt6ghZkkodhjnVwCCOQL7GlHZ0HGiMUwewmZ0iNzvMvBe3D73dA7FZ3XmnRQ7LU0DE5W1 UPGI8HRMYpmdpFnkhwzaZQxHRVRgvZ3c2g2p2to6CIMj29BWTm/PTNiQZzpCEH0/jAWodWIm r02a56bRkcA6sHxEOOpWH33wqzPDoHPS47zfKhgh4OqtlMg8xdsjiOgaBCTCBQ1bqJDS1K3N K3q4GUvVAQNerIjYln46rAPXJ1Heo1TsjCMI6DawOJT4XheQ+8xwjNvAq5AmRsM0EqO3LjXt 8TrdMzCYljGaSj+N4kedila1XZy+Qry2wlKJeeDklNsyrWqsIU4vUegQODCiPKT2Ee1HXXzk XmT68wIUora0WDD3y2fzNsgs9IC9WGB2jhsgMXTNutq4UGWEJ93725RELQSh3shSKM0h47zM 3bhIxEjzZavdkBHiiYLS0wgikh1E0pSR4AAczVWyk42NYdblOb8SzbSnXm3ODR6HMHWr7IGj BGaH5Fv5ohnyRlxgqQqcrxI1QuwfXLiDocVtrnqRGx0am1ctdzJyztCzrrYlG4Cywo5k1A4z VmTgS9L4rD30OkIXIM3eUIy4dMuXqFNeqo89pjvutGuMQxIhoXEpraYMURRKMc+F7Fe6CqCz 8ajZQBHNw3loi8R4cbGaQ4qnm9owkVTXbRj03TXL2pw9I20MrjrRJFtx+rlPI9u+9kQghptX I86GSBvHlYrVPMitIeV255xxOoPBSCzxMxS76KFMHgXquV5HUZRswgQPe9pnRM6KDcCj6bdS hfnhNbbx35TNBJgwuneeBxe7ewOa6AtpB/DvfE4EBxvRJZ34yHEeXuYmD1yJG1qvbUVRopCN l453MQjBlD1wHJDGFC9uhtmj3vL7SBzCaF1Qjbb+b4jm1rDBFBY92xPasLyS826021mAjclJ lAZjoO9qy536gdw6WUiMBV8Qd0y79pjb419sE8ffxjBpCd6Ahg3oOdgjPc4HdsCD4xke/Gm2 IJ7DL9MIRaMBuXs7yntqSLu0Skithu9Bbb1q6VU5eM51wXHJDqClNgjdkxxb+Uzc2FGXddbT bPOhtTUYSCdysO6wmEYsvWxYdAGa2+m7tmrBF4aPCz8v5rnpVoRHLY8KUnT0NxQ2wZCwYHhC BmiXTs74zKqIlsTxIkYFOEZSMWdknwcQM0aqLfixjm6VkRNg9XivmmPAj1DO4a/Qy5bkGfLF wgLIgWrA3dRU/QODnPzABznyfqPUKyfV86LnaP1UWVlgwU6SnoaDAj+rUFKHoedrfOdl3O1a 2UH630NTFscXbBmRpKZ2Wz12VpKYKYKeewgy8mAiGYFKgpAgBfO55Qed5d+b4729SlKVtCQk 5hB+WlZZvl9bTMCermLx+w0+IEDEVYgicObw6UePA8WkFMQTolvSAaEXQGBmJ3dCBNTZAmid v1Se+TrO7y+f7+Jcxq224Wta2cgCwM69HrqItVR3KGOcFIA7IM1smpZLNFo0ZosVVt6EWWeB WaBkgKX0oU9PTOFzwHMDfjmVW4GbegEA82qjbXN/f3cL966gCzJSmyUAXEciq7Gxo6NlvVHQ OjFVfNwALr3gpvbmarjsApracyB48SnS3Y6xWM9iWaLG10lNPQK6HWiyFcRTUkuI3bs9orTl 5CmEXNo53GtLWU2B1cdzluMFzpJtKcS7Irfr5O925cU8PRcN+vIhh0LhYR2fQddtrPlx4dYX AMiHpJMauzlwi5PPlt9XKW9tIMUVzv7LdN2Op4O1o1isG/xIstedU4M9TT2VzL2+D5fYWlco rr4dfXc959pa1VyMRJix6SmpFx974ynbxoubPj3M9rueTPg/Fyd1v4pbKprdjrpZItQrfUGr AXPBFuEGyjUQajcIOFa8tKoLCryyiizcGyjSCDkKFI9bFMli6Kg3YBTJJZiuXnPNytyLOK7X fotfm02G4V8hTWJrawPHwE1t4k1EOcNv8C7SPraM17O80fJ3162hF1roKdJTRsDgQ9JaSZ0l 32FVlj34ywqmgDLkVXEBkHLns8mbRa9TJetF8RP6E4ENCwHbqWpiTiORhgw9Hw+n9j0n7c/u n7lH9zCQ/uAzUy9aiNRUaUXWC620cDeW1S3FOpVZFV4SXciwnlRd8CbckiEjIKxAts9kOijl 7Sq9wvAX6Ny36xjgSw3lPHkdSq/kUwHHo7mPo5PBXHqvHkBLDQdYFKG23DTo8htY+z1+zqd2 e22z7fb3vqz+foVXTjl5r4ybsE6uWi6yxGCxLAxgMWiKd/lBS+471wC34WpOzWp0gcwFaBJq 75NGspkWjBTxIvLe7GmUztTU81kFbRWlq0HcJNaLjwK3mrPy5q5OMhvuIVilq5OZVZh/4m/4 bkTGP341iuMsi2S5nI0hW34YRZsLPJlfcKZXDAXj92zWi2KL3r53IKwyqcaLK6eYhwKaK2V7 uE2rB7caOGXv9ywJ4KqKsWCiwiRUFWKpARV8afWtIZ/ddGiSH/xdyRThQkJveEIo --------------050300070005050801020408--