Re: iPXE efi chainloading grub2 pxe efi file

[Andrei Borzenkov <arvidjaar@gmail.com>]

14.10.2015 21:09, Rivard, Matthew T пишет:
> Just going by these definitions of bootp and dhcp here:
> https://technet.microsoft.com/en-us/library/cc781243%28v=ws.10%29.aspx
>
> The net_bootp only works with a bootp enabled scope on the dhcp server after chaining from iPXE to grub2.   Without a "bootp" scope setup on the dhcp, calling net_bootp on the adapter fails to get an IP address.
>

What is "bootp enabled scope"? Do you refer to Windows DHCP server? 
Could you give link to manual that describes this setting?

> So, I guess I could more clearly word that the bootp protocol works when calling net_bootp, but standard dhcp isn't.
>

Could you make available network traces from both working and 
non-workign attempts?

>
> -----Original Message-----
> From: Andrei Borzenkov [mailto:arvidjaar@gmail.com]
> Sent: Wednesday, October 14, 2015 11:04 AM
> To: Rivard, Matthew T; The development of GNU GRUB
> Subject: Re: iPXE efi chainloading grub2 pxe efi file
>
> 14.10.2015 19:56, Rivard, Matthew T пишет:
>> Sorry, I thought I had replied back to this.
>>
>> I found a work around by calling net_bootp on the adapters (I wrote a manual block of 64 potential devices given that that's not an unrealistic number of adapter ports to be found in a server in our lab), and setting a bootp range on our DHCP server for that purpose.   Since there's no command in grub to simply tell it to do a standard DHCP on the adapters,
>
> Huh? net_bootp does standard DHCP on adapters (do not be confused by name). What do you mean by this?
>
>> this has been the only feasible workaround to make them play together nicely.
>>
>> Ironically, executing the chainload from iPXE via embedded script vs their shell has solved the issue with it hanging if multiple adapters have IP addresses in grub when loading off to a Linux Kernel.
>>
>>
>>
>> -----Original Message-----
>> From: Andrei Borzenkov [mailto:arvidjaar@gmail.com]
>> Sent: Tuesday, October 13, 2015 11:14 PM
>> To: Rivard, Matthew T; The development of GNU GRUB;
>> ipxe-devel@lists.ipxe.org; edk2-devel-01
>> Subject: Re: iPXE efi chainloading grub2 pxe efi file
>>
>> [Redirecting to grub-devel where similar problem is being discussed
>> right now and trying iPXE/EDK2 as well]
>>
>> 18.09.2015 22:59, Rivard, Matthew T пишет:
>>> Thanks, its loading the menu now, however, I appear to be hitting the
>>> same problem I was going from grub to ipxe.  The adapters are there,
>>> but won't autoconfigure,
>>
>> Exclusive SNP open used by iPXE quite likely tears down PXE information, so GRUB has nothing to autoconfigure card from.
>>
>>> and if I try to manually set an IP address, I see the debugging data start spewing from ipxe (which appears to be still running underneath grub) before the system eventually halts.
>>>
>>
>> Well, now we have two *applications* each holding exclusive open on adapter. I do not know details about iPXE but if there is any remote chance it does background polling we are back at square one.
>>
>> Unfortunately I do not really see what we can do in this case (iPXE =>
>> GRUB) from GRUB side. Switching GRUB to MNP may fix GRUB => iPXE case though. OTOH I do not know what happens long term. GRUB calls other image (let's say iPXE) passes control to it. Now firmware continues to queue packets for GRUB MNP instance, which GRUB never consumes. Does not really look good either.
>>
>> In principle the same is true for GRUB pure if it is left sitting in menu/CLI for a long time. And for every other active MNP instance.
>>
>>> I'll try your rollback, but was it mean to come out in the email as a long hash string?
>>>
>>
>> Did you have chance to test it?
>>
>>>
>>> -----Original Message-----
>>> From: Andrei Borzenkov [mailto:arvidjaar@gmail.com]
>>> Sent: Thursday, September 17, 2015 8:52 PM
>>> To: Rivard, Matthew T; help-grub@gnu.org
>>> Subject: Re: iPXE efi chainloading grub2 pxe efi file
>>>
>>> 18.09.2015 03:05, Rivard, Matthew T пишет:
>>>> I've got a good working EFI Grub2 efi Bootloader that works fine when its directly handed off to by the DHCP for PXE, however, if I attempt to chainload it from iPXE snponly.efi, it goes straight to the grub command prompt.
>>>>
>>>> I've tried embedding the grub.cfg file via -c on the grub-mkimage command, but it spews out the grub file as a stream of "command not found prompts" and then still goes to the grub command line.
>>>>
>>>
>>> Embedded config is processed very early, before normal.mod is loaded, so only commands available at rescue prompts are present.
>>>
>>>> If I try embedding all of the modules directly into grub.efi during mkimage, along with the config file, it then throws a grub_divmod64_full not found error.
>>>>
>>>
>>> Embedding all modules in grub.efi is usually wrong (not all modules can be loaded concurrently) either.
>>>
>>> Try creating standalone image with grub-mkstandalone. This image contains all grub modules in memory disk (as cpio archive) and grub is configured with $prefix pointing to this disk. You can also add own files, in particular put grub.cfg in memory disk.
>>>
>>>> What is the ideal way to chain load my grub.efi file from iPXE so that it works the same as if it was the direct handoff from the DHCP/TFTP server?
>>>>
>>>> Unfortunately, in order to allow for selecting either our EFI WDS Server or our EFI Linux Server, I have to use iPXE first, as chainloading snponly.efi from grub2 ends up with iPXE snp not being able to enumerate anything from the PCI Bus.
>>>>
>>>
>>> Hmm ... this actually sounds like exclusive SNP open (used by both
>>> iPXE and GRUB) messes something up. For testing you could try to
>>> revert
>>> 49426e9fd2e562c73a4f1206f32eff9e424a1a73 (and f348aee7b33dd85e7da62b497a96a7319a0bf9dd which depends on it) to see if it makes any difference.
>>>
>>>> Using git pulls for both that were from yesterday.
>>>>
>>>> Matt R.
>>>>
>>>>
>>>>
>>>>
>>>> _______________________________________________
>>>> Help-grub mailing list
>>>> Help-grub@gnu.org
>>>> https://lists.gnu.org/mailman/listinfo/help-grub
>>>>
>>>
>>
>