Re: [PATCH 0/2] Add settle time support to mux-gpio

[Peter Rosin <peda@axentia.se>]

Hi!

On 2021-10-04 17:36, Vincent Whitchurch wrote:
> On one of our boards we use gpio-mux with iio-mux to read voltages using an
> ADC from a few different channels, and on this board the input voltage needs
> some time to stabilize after a switch of the mux.
> 
> This series add devicetree and driver support for this kind of hardware which
> requries a settle time after muxing.

It feels backwards to hide a universally useful thing like this fsleep in
drivers/mux/gpio.c. I think it belongs in drivers/iio/multiplexer/iio-mux.c
instead. Because the sleep is needed for the analog parts of the actual mux,
not the digital parts of the mux-controller.

However, currently the iio-mux does not know when the mux changes state (and
it can change state from "underneath" iio-mux by some other driver using the
same mux-control to drive some other mux).

But, fixing that so that the iio-mux knows if mux_control_select changes
the state (e.g. returning 1 instead of 0 on state changes) does not fix
this problem. Because the mux-control, again, can be used by some other
driver that changed its state right before the iio-mux selected it without
then needing a state change. And that could potentially happen quicker
than the prescribed fsleep.

So, fixing it needs some kind of new api that returns when the mux-control
changed its state last, e.g.
	ret = mux_control_select_stamp(mux, state, &stamp);
that does the same thing as mux_control_select, but also fills in a time
stamp for when the mux changed state.

Another similar option is to add an extra delay argument, e.g.
	ret = mux_control_select_delay(mux, stamp, delay_us);
that instead makes the call not return before the delay has passed since
the last state change, regardless who changed state. The mux-control would
need to keep track of when the last state changes happened of course, just
as in the above _select_stamp variant.

I think I like the last _select_delay variant best.

Cheers,
Peter