Linux-ARM-MSM Archive on lore.kernel.org
 help / color / Atom feed
* [PATCH] qcom: Add firmware files for Adreno A200
@ 2019-09-04 11:26 Fabio Estevam
  2019-09-04 12:09 ` Nicolas Dechesne
  0 siblings, 1 reply; 6+ messages in thread
From: Fabio Estevam @ 2019-09-04 11:26 UTC (permalink / raw)
  To: jwboyer
  Cc: jcrouse, robdclark, linux-firmware, jonathan, cphealy, freedreno,
	linux-arm-msm, Fabio Estevam

Add firmware files for Adreno A200. 

These firmware files are needed for running the adreno kernel
driver on i.MX51 and i.MX53 SoCs.

Signed-off-by: Fabio Estevam <festevam@gmail.com>
---
 WHENCE             |   2 ++
 qcom/yamato_pfp.fw | Bin 0 -> 1156 bytes
 qcom/yamato_pm4.fw | Bin 0 -> 9220 bytes
 3 files changed, 2 insertions(+)
 create mode 100644 qcom/yamato_pfp.fw
 create mode 100644 qcom/yamato_pm4.fw

diff --git a/WHENCE b/WHENCE
index a8ec628..5e46d33 100644
--- a/WHENCE
+++ b/WHENCE
@@ -4418,6 +4418,8 @@ File: qcom/a530_zap.b00
 File: qcom/a530_zap.b01
 File: qcom/a530_zap.b02
 File: qcom/a530_zap.mdt
+File: qcom/yamato_pfp.fw
+File: qcom/yamato_pm4.fw
 
 Licence: Redistributable. See LICENSE.qcom and qcom/NOTICE.txt for details
 
diff --git a/qcom/yamato_pfp.fw b/qcom/yamato_pfp.fw
new file mode 100644
index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..61a576eb997ce2ee0d32b135adc5d8c789d8e118
GIT binary patch
literal 1156
zcmaKr%WG3X7{!10-ZY7A3K1$6=_76G1N!h4AK=1^>7q~<E%;a!K{qZG{{WkEu`Vig
znc9aU-RVwT2qFk+Q_@myY|Wy$6#N(5N<A}4Y7An+@Xef=?>pywGZ*xWlo-D@qsc1s
zPiBZtq;Lo<?)jnc0FONz87grhu?2;tYGjUXtrI+jc!`*Bk|n%g5tAFK<$08Cey`T`
zvx)jy!_iTK&JzB^96f&7=Jy2U|K?k+gt(ON1sa9FwHhv?DgHb|R9rnZ-6s0-6jM&z
z<oUHc%}p<2ua40-x6P;G0z=6yT7xAz^XG{8D<toSI0F%~&MtQ~T=}{_nNy9j>b=By
z8`b=UTDGpZL%olqwSLyuMi<gPtom*~LmSJCbZV|Tu6+Mc?V^V9)FoZr!s@x6yK8%C
z_Iu;H3)M*(Z_;Vjwjatfch;}iOVyu=r@M4c9_##P#7|+_;(b9#$`3g#E&H)G(&EW#
zxHmG)zn>;t$l(^GuMl!ic#FAX%}uRm#-DUZ1hd+EFuQ1Z%pKHqw^N~=sumk-JviU7
z&1%0qeGi$+F4LlD>Nu(BfzF~^Ik@AK4f|)~+w9LSVPYeflWINSJtW>%jmAE-X`N`o
z($Z#o#}~_Q`saDO4AgL=$zW+=$D6RMuoF#~Id3&ZPDx9}ei!DQJAO!1<Cne}H@=}a
zw84=e&!8{|-Sa>8&3oD$%MmN&SySBjIZa%1lT+oXSj=m{xNPnN27?{z{g3~>S}*2o
z+!Sjl6<_79MgKjLeBh|wK|hyBla<>kPV$Ih9y6j|j?+bkAujSpCsw$^Yp(K*QPvsb
aBNKdPk}Yn^%`G{<%{x^na)+4oG>_jjN)4X?

literal 0
HcmV?d00001

diff --git a/qcom/yamato_pm4.fw b/qcom/yamato_pm4.fw
new file mode 100644
index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..b45ea20ba5773ef6da25e21abd29914ea9162c07
GIT binary patch
literal 9220
zcmeHMU2I%O6+Y{%UFT-AU2k1ujB&@i>-9SF&jM9cEJ3bFYHh4aq;GvR>H~i&R3H_K
z5Otf75}?qOh&)jG$6sG~=>rdaC@Ulc0tr>TAbx8k3J4@36+}TQTE1^)&b@QTyG{^A
zykxAs_uMnzIdkUBnKM5Y5qZ}cBT_bfkhUc9lzsoTBr<i%SQ?MgR4=3PnMxVY!9Zkj
zs{_iHp8Q-%V)C+gYfkUTJ!4MRB%QwUAG&=-Ns*Cy0@<xx_8|NPv}H@h_3^buk=3od
ztwX(3!185BGQ8wIk&&{-$_-A4Y>aKF61?{+{P@??#kOKQ^LA6hMQS3=y7wpO))1Zl
z4D7E$WD54PTsoAGR|((X_sMs~^(&N}M1@Hf`yPPT-t-!tH{ho_iBb9%&={{2FL@Jw
zjmWl>;L+7Fe;YiQwvT@&c#NSKe;0VuBltHD;qQPK_6wgf=KKEN*i1c)VcKc+RGqKt
z6S<#>I26u{UJx^$9%38CWC1_pb;|!h=lJWSGxTBThvaqD|Gqxw-6&rn&pfEP$i=py
z3uOR<G$!%6YpO0jL8qp!`JpV0t@q1UeIBSy8&tc}EXHthk5<g4{d+-M{d2jVcBp68
zC_0{}$w#$jKJDM9dKPj$%b}k6T+djZZ{_<Y&#Qmzowgd05;$j5ehlzyBn~scq}9H&
zo6Us=Au^7isp}k{l$OseH-X<8%d?M2fBGzV@blB^XMAGr8@}AUp1IA^=kZ*cx!2}!
zGRFOSL3(Y*@Wp8(&FUGs2$JKK@q0O+IU(btdy1$1%AXAQ^?)yi_%1lEoISc?3D|!r
zwEyLv<FoSYshpNslUe~j{8}^2C#)W&6Z|iQZB6(*Oc@ckPFZr&^zECEX-9J&EzO1g
z-($)Xj^k3*jVZ@^sqQdn>#Vj#|FryAe2bWw+z;VcG>#k8qNMQE_8EB&B*!A-b1Xcc
zW0CRcbI)g6%C}?T`5X)7gB10@9hYrq4{ScCHWMRZZp601^6Vp(C-4S-=p6s}cp3YU
zooxQ1L;XzFugmtkw%^Z|KkNAqpiw_x<aXF!ocopUsnYpCkH{Oy=2$enEa_PGN8pXJ
zpQ~IenC~2r9|P~oj%;#JP+s)&9U+jlWyh;%XYx~v7I{_*`;GFSJ)int0d2=FlKt6m
z*|AvG#zQ3gtKqVhSa!&op8R&WY!b^dUq!x6em`7xB9@&PBCD9lSCh(DU&+C-k<f%m
z{F+G+w%9M#{MgB<AZB#mbrqejQmHM0Y!KTw+>uHalUIvv>KPKZ*BX-=dsGwo%I;&y
zr#-KcVEO;q!(q0C_DsV6N5L7EXR7C8{{FK`=%2&Ts_We-oou)k=J_zU`!m!4<KCEa
zIs8W88x0pTXiGW`$ETi7G`||?3&Uy37*=E97HJnT<z)g|`}h-<kE-);bZcDLFRQZ$
zWww;1u!pHAUv?Yq+_sfsyOp<42}-G!=c_~QeBC+h^~8QFW$otsWU6Y<Ia%h4#R*4~
z-)X!JPgi39XdgLeS;9W@TgMLkuZQuV{6C?AkY5gL!~SP3MLlGnP|TGVzWp1OrGA``
z=1w|HLI087uC0yE%X?<K*S8h!G2&djBX_Xlwxs@zSH<N7*z<X{hn0HP7$C6poX8k!
z`L&*TyH$7lG&w`s`L-Hhp!4BSr}}|rwCc|Pz?>h3c{4Cgzb7%EFPa9P?tItr?Lzi5
zDm!>Lbo%{34Y=maqQ%qxr5P7*wl99Zu=1PpnGIi5J?z)=w(FPGqx&N0(LL=^VAKz=
z;d3fWo!ZAy{$Y{}WIsJjmU@1e+xDnpLfb^Tvc7qNP+O)}jeXO%8}D>uVHrW*h}OHx
z{aHNh&sSDfvOAD$zr?jZjMZ*&{wAMPoxa_}z&E1(|2f4#|D#lhGUey>4CtnhG4f;C
zhcj6hxBQGTpN%kVBF0<-hB?6;cY5sk#nTf3pL-<5Oa?UjrF<^hN*@Vmj#u37<;*rW
zAKe~i5lAil=_i3fTzyT)-PZI>%C~K++US#>!cTqmH>glNF{|6}vA%WtoTC0`px+hO
zclI~7^I2!Z<Erx(V9fSnN;%l}W##i*_uKSUtmiqaXK-SDGt2pXJwH<PL$|H)#WJh>
zFb2?8AqUE;vzY=%dWJ8%Uy9p(LHp?Q+fBf!uXwkkG-Jcm8!2A4oUOUJ!$XqJQ;uVH
ze}ZMX>Ca7r!Qe{JudpwWNb%FM|BOa|HmZvXz}uh8&{)IkpC!iUAI6F1SPDH-Gkn1?
z@|_RitL*H?s&l6^e&Kwixt$o4z=%}(@Ei0zq~nXv!h9D$uXzut<HbCgpZysF8`SH|
zUh-=yv1RYrA3*N{zP{k%0kkX^@s(eAd}ThBUxKFowFQHxySG^m?o@eaNSzdk+nwj&
z+OpSi?e5A!?fx!k_vHiHB}{W5e3j)!HWl0O7l0W*if8`UI|r^KYjXxq`uwHA`esjF
z0iI*6c&?|4#}X9auK=ITDX9f_JMWFoYwUYyC+EBBk7H)s&nfUPXbb=@6FL8yVyRYh
zF>lv9e@8?;v43uKV`SDhU97&kSiHynfxlM??PpF?`>DU{*9+z!<<qyyhwR0$FH!t2
z0ZRWoQpBXNl{JVNZ`<GhL)$oZYC~un$5Huc_pxHT2DMpfk^<%nMU1lz{A|86#tQqf
z5qBd|-_awhKb!CT)_ZvB)H}~TBs<LaKI_qL7V`+L%;%)z@m+-vt>5ZyeBB+zX;}x~
zj&*^r7`Bq%!$dkOw?cMETb57B?o3ZMf#H6y>-T;(PW(L>`R!mI7@d6*%DR&F`5rr3
zycde>NlpOI9MxU0?sV<8d(s<jXL3?)^Er?gC{wM};@Mu;^R3Rd(`o789xt-F@^<Lp
zcrE$+I@0Yqw~r;gypYo?ZAWw8zT(eT@p($ubckkipZKLlmn@XBbo^Zt$D)(*;fszT
z0ObJ8q_KztG5-EMwoPL=K6fWQ)ye<M<h15AHrOd`@a4;1ayR_Oel2_Z87F$*>wM_W
z2o#8Xp4>@UTT=Us&ShoIMT+@AhTrM)|B}jA3TMOWhco`JWrzQ#2=g8*E8frC2d=dZ
zS+=Z3eZ0@>oa(0XG16FIR^RHzF`Ub+Qk(4_(#IZ^c1tb}N%Ic>QvgHu8=99G1I!zr
zi1<XSPVQ0l|Dn`>Y}@ICo@a`B48;n0CbW%pYR_Qsz)QLg*1$h@e3#Xfy{tO<UGeb{
zwne_$27Z>)_P6yQp|(tQjeWDNRo@o-eywM&%T#WQ%Pp2X;EeVak3TYLEEIMY_QUx9
zqvg9te~$lq0_I8W`>?x(r!pIM1KI23bq`$kK<I&9X$(uVn=FnRMSqtmKwd1}Ep>5w
za^l+s*`HWUYwZ4^I_qL&rhs>CJukJ=9PD7(D%kV9tV_@8{7C6>+4dM`=gpQ+`X5sE
l^kJ#ukL4Y57ixAa{T)yr9DB?*aBv?-_5Eu6ah%T`=HI~S@q7RP

literal 0
HcmV?d00001

-- 
2.17.1


^ permalink raw reply	[flat|nested] 6+ messages in thread

* Re: [PATCH] qcom: Add firmware files for Adreno A200
  2019-09-04 11:26 [PATCH] qcom: Add firmware files for Adreno A200 Fabio Estevam
@ 2019-09-04 12:09 ` Nicolas Dechesne
  2019-09-04 14:39   ` Rob Clark
  2019-09-04 15:34   ` Josh Boyer
  0 siblings, 2 replies; 6+ messages in thread
From: Nicolas Dechesne @ 2019-09-04 12:09 UTC (permalink / raw)
  To: Fabio Estevam, Bjorn Andersson
  Cc: Josh Boyer, Jordan Crouse, robdclark, Linux Firmware, jonathan,
	cphealy, freedreno, linux-arm-msm

hi Fabio,

On Wed, Sep 4, 2019 at 1:27 PM Fabio Estevam <festevam@gmail.com> wrote:
>
> Add firmware files for Adreno A200.
>
> These firmware files are needed for running the adreno kernel
> driver on i.MX51 and i.MX53 SoCs.
>
> Signed-off-by: Fabio Estevam <festevam@gmail.com>
> ---
>  WHENCE             |   2 ++
>  qcom/yamato_pfp.fw | Bin 0 -> 1156 bytes
>  qcom/yamato_pm4.fw | Bin 0 -> 9220 bytes
>  3 files changed, 2 insertions(+)
>  create mode 100644 qcom/yamato_pfp.fw
>  create mode 100644 qcom/yamato_pm4.fw
>
> diff --git a/WHENCE b/WHENCE
> index a8ec628..5e46d33 100644
> --- a/WHENCE
> +++ b/WHENCE
> @@ -4418,6 +4418,8 @@ File: qcom/a530_zap.b00
>  File: qcom/a530_zap.b01
>  File: qcom/a530_zap.b02
>  File: qcom/a530_zap.mdt
> +File: qcom/yamato_pfp.fw
> +File: qcom/yamato_pm4.fw

Where did you get these files from in the first place? On which
devices do you expect these firmware files to work? We were recently
discussing how to structure /lib/firmware/qcom more carefully. And the
general consensus that we reached with Rob C. and Bjorn is that if a
firmware is expected to work on a specific device (maybe it is signed)
it should be placed in /lib/firmware/qcom/<device> and if it's
unsigned and can be used on several devices based on the same SoC (dev
boards, ..) then it should be /lib/firmware/qcom/<SOC>.

>
>  Licence: Redistributable. See LICENSE.qcom and qcom/NOTICE.txt for details

Are they really distributed under these license terms? That's a
specific license that we came up with with Qualcomm a couple of years
ago based on their Dragonboard offers.

>
> diff --git a/qcom/yamato_pfp.fw b/qcom/yamato_pfp.fw
> new file mode 100644
> index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..61a576eb997ce2ee0d32b135adc5d8c789d8e118
> GIT binary patch
> literal 1156
> zcmaKr%WG3X7{!10-ZY7A3K1$6=_76G1N!h4AK=1^>7q~<E%;a!K{qZG{{WkEu`Vig
> znc9aU-RVwT2qFk+Q_@myY|Wy$6#N(5N<A}4Y7An+@Xef=?>pywGZ*xWlo-D@qsc1s
> zPiBZtq;Lo<?)jnc0FONz87grhu?2;tYGjUXtrI+jc!`*Bk|n%g5tAFK<$08Cey`T`
> zvx)jy!_iTK&JzB^96f&7=Jy2U|K?k+gt(ON1sa9FwHhv?DgHb|R9rnZ-6s0-6jM&z
> z<oUHc%}p<2ua40-x6P;G0z=6yT7xAz^XG{8D<toSI0F%~&MtQ~T=}{_nNy9j>b=By
> z8`b=UTDGpZL%olqwSLyuMi<gPtom*~LmSJCbZV|Tu6+Mc?V^V9)FoZr!s@x6yK8%C
> z_Iu;H3)M*(Z_;Vjwjatfch;}iOVyu=r@M4c9_##P#7|+_;(b9#$`3g#E&H)G(&EW#
> zxHmG)zn>;t$l(^GuMl!ic#FAX%}uRm#-DUZ1hd+EFuQ1Z%pKHqw^N~=sumk-JviU7
> z&1%0qeGi$+F4LlD>Nu(BfzF~^Ik@AK4f|)~+w9LSVPYeflWINSJtW>%jmAE-X`N`o
> z($Z#o#}~_Q`saDO4AgL=$zW+=$D6RMuoF#~Id3&ZPDx9}ei!DQJAO!1<Cne}H@=}a
> zw84=e&!8{|-Sa>8&3oD$%MmN&SySBjIZa%1lT+oXSj=m{xNPnN27?{z{g3~>S}*2o
> z+!Sjl6<_79MgKjLeBh|wK|hyBla<>kPV$Ih9y6j|j?+bkAujSpCsw$^Yp(K*QPvsb
> aBNKdPk}Yn^%`G{<%{x^na)+4oG>_jjN)4X?
>
> literal 0
> HcmV?d00001
>
> diff --git a/qcom/yamato_pm4.fw b/qcom/yamato_pm4.fw
> new file mode 100644
> index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..b45ea20ba5773ef6da25e21abd29914ea9162c07
> GIT binary patch
> literal 9220
> zcmeHMU2I%O6+Y{%UFT-AU2k1ujB&@i>-9SF&jM9cEJ3bFYHh4aq;GvR>H~i&R3H_K
> z5Otf75}?qOh&)jG$6sG~=>rdaC@Ulc0tr>TAbx8k3J4@36+}TQTE1^)&b@QTyG{^A
> zykxAs_uMnzIdkUBnKM5Y5qZ}cBT_bfkhUc9lzsoTBr<i%SQ?MgR4=3PnMxVY!9Zkj
> zs{_iHp8Q-%V)C+gYfkUTJ!4MRB%QwUAG&=-Ns*Cy0@<xx_8|NPv}H@h_3^buk=3od
> ztwX(3!185BGQ8wIk&&{-$_-A4Y>aKF61?{+{P@??#kOKQ^LA6hMQS3=y7wpO))1Zl
> z4D7E$WD54PTsoAGR|((X_sMs~^(&N}M1@Hf`yPPT-t-!tH{ho_iBb9%&={{2FL@Jw
> zjmWl>;L+7Fe;YiQwvT@&c#NSKe;0VuBltHD;qQPK_6wgf=KKEN*i1c)VcKc+RGqKt
> z6S<#>I26u{UJx^$9%38CWC1_pb;|!h=lJWSGxTBThvaqD|Gqxw-6&rn&pfEP$i=py
> z3uOR<G$!%6YpO0jL8qp!`JpV0t@q1UeIBSy8&tc}EXHthk5<g4{d+-M{d2jVcBp68
> zC_0{}$w#$jKJDM9dKPj$%b}k6T+djZZ{_<Y&#Qmzowgd05;$j5ehlzyBn~scq}9H&
> zo6Us=Au^7isp}k{l$OseH-X<8%d?M2fBGzV@blB^XMAGr8@}AUp1IA^=kZ*cx!2}!
> zGRFOSL3(Y*@Wp8(&FUGs2$JKK@q0O+IU(btdy1$1%AXAQ^?)yi_%1lEoISc?3D|!r
> zwEyLv<FoSYshpNslUe~j{8}^2C#)W&6Z|iQZB6(*Oc@ckPFZr&^zECEX-9J&EzO1g
> z-($)Xj^k3*jVZ@^sqQdn>#Vj#|FryAe2bWw+z;VcG>#k8qNMQE_8EB&B*!A-b1Xcc
> zW0CRcbI)g6%C}?T`5X)7gB10@9hYrq4{ScCHWMRZZp601^6Vp(C-4S-=p6s}cp3YU
> zooxQ1L;XzFugmtkw%^Z|KkNAqpiw_x<aXF!ocopUsnYpCkH{Oy=2$enEa_PGN8pXJ
> zpQ~IenC~2r9|P~oj%;#JP+s)&9U+jlWyh;%XYx~v7I{_*`;GFSJ)int0d2=FlKt6m
> z*|AvG#zQ3gtKqVhSa!&op8R&WY!b^dUq!x6em`7xB9@&PBCD9lSCh(DU&+C-k<f%m
> z{F+G+w%9M#{MgB<AZB#mbrqejQmHM0Y!KTw+>uHalUIvv>KPKZ*BX-=dsGwo%I;&y
> zr#-KcVEO;q!(q0C_DsV6N5L7EXR7C8{{FK`=%2&Ts_We-oou)k=J_zU`!m!4<KCEa
> zIs8W88x0pTXiGW`$ETi7G`||?3&Uy37*=E97HJnT<z)g|`}h-<kE-);bZcDLFRQZ$
> zWww;1u!pHAUv?Yq+_sfsyOp<42}-G!=c_~QeBC+h^~8QFW$otsWU6Y<Ia%h4#R*4~
> z-)X!JPgi39XdgLeS;9W@TgMLkuZQuV{6C?AkY5gL!~SP3MLlGnP|TGVzWp1OrGA``
> z=1w|HLI087uC0yE%X?<K*S8h!G2&djBX_Xlwxs@zSH<N7*z<X{hn0HP7$C6poX8k!
> z`L&*TyH$7lG&w`s`L-Hhp!4BSr}}|rwCc|Pz?>h3c{4Cgzb7%EFPa9P?tItr?Lzi5
> zDm!>Lbo%{34Y=maqQ%qxr5P7*wl99Zu=1PpnGIi5J?z)=w(FPGqx&N0(LL=^VAKz=
> z;d3fWo!ZAy{$Y{}WIsJjmU@1e+xDnpLfb^Tvc7qNP+O)}jeXO%8}D>uVHrW*h}OHx
> z{aHNh&sSDfvOAD$zr?jZjMZ*&{wAMPoxa_}z&E1(|2f4#|D#lhGUey>4CtnhG4f;C
> zhcj6hxBQGTpN%kVBF0<-hB?6;cY5sk#nTf3pL-<5Oa?UjrF<^hN*@Vmj#u37<;*rW
> zAKe~i5lAil=_i3fTzyT)-PZI>%C~K++US#>!cTqmH>glNF{|6}vA%WtoTC0`px+hO
> zclI~7^I2!Z<Erx(V9fSnN;%l}W##i*_uKSUtmiqaXK-SDGt2pXJwH<PL$|H)#WJh>
> zFb2?8AqUE;vzY=%dWJ8%Uy9p(LHp?Q+fBf!uXwkkG-Jcm8!2A4oUOUJ!$XqJQ;uVH
> ze}ZMX>Ca7r!Qe{JudpwWNb%FM|BOa|HmZvXz}uh8&{)IkpC!iUAI6F1SPDH-Gkn1?
> z@|_RitL*H?s&l6^e&Kwixt$o4z=%}(@Ei0zq~nXv!h9D$uXzut<HbCgpZysF8`SH|
> zUh-=yv1RYrA3*N{zP{k%0kkX^@s(eAd}ThBUxKFowFQHxySG^m?o@eaNSzdk+nwj&
> z+OpSi?e5A!?fx!k_vHiHB}{W5e3j)!HWl0O7l0W*if8`UI|r^KYjXxq`uwHA`esjF
> z0iI*6c&?|4#}X9auK=ITDX9f_JMWFoYwUYyC+EBBk7H)s&nfUPXbb=@6FL8yVyRYh
> zF>lv9e@8?;v43uKV`SDhU97&kSiHynfxlM??PpF?`>DU{*9+z!<<qyyhwR0$FH!t2
> z0ZRWoQpBXNl{JVNZ`<GhL)$oZYC~un$5Huc_pxHT2DMpfk^<%nMU1lz{A|86#tQqf
> z5qBd|-_awhKb!CT)_ZvB)H}~TBs<LaKI_qL7V`+L%;%)z@m+-vt>5ZyeBB+zX;}x~
> zj&*^r7`Bq%!$dkOw?cMETb57B?o3ZMf#H6y>-T;(PW(L>`R!mI7@d6*%DR&F`5rr3
> zycde>NlpOI9MxU0?sV<8d(s<jXL3?)^Er?gC{wM};@Mu;^R3Rd(`o789xt-F@^<Lp
> zcrE$+I@0Yqw~r;gypYo?ZAWw8zT(eT@p($ubckkipZKLlmn@XBbo^Zt$D)(*;fszT
> z0ObJ8q_KztG5-EMwoPL=K6fWQ)ye<M<h15AHrOd`@a4;1ayR_Oel2_Z87F$*>wM_W
> z2o#8Xp4>@UTT=Us&ShoIMT+@AhTrM)|B}jA3TMOWhco`JWrzQ#2=g8*E8frC2d=dZ
> zS+=Z3eZ0@>oa(0XG16FIR^RHzF`Ub+Qk(4_(#IZ^c1tb}N%Ic>QvgHu8=99G1I!zr
> zi1<XSPVQ0l|Dn`>Y}@ICo@a`B48;n0CbW%pYR_Qsz)QLg*1$h@e3#Xfy{tO<UGeb{
> zwne_$27Z>)_P6yQp|(tQjeWDNRo@o-eywM&%T#WQ%Pp2X;EeVak3TYLEEIMY_QUx9
> zqvg9te~$lq0_I8W`>?x(r!pIM1KI23bq`$kK<I&9X$(uVn=FnRMSqtmKwd1}Ep>5w
> za^l+s*`HWUYwZ4^I_qL&rhs>CJukJ=9PD7(D%kV9tV_@8{7C6>+4dM`=gpQ+`X5sE
> l^kJ#ukL4Y57ixAa{T)yr9DB?*aBv?-_5Eu6ah%T`=HI~S@q7RP
>
> literal 0
> HcmV?d00001
>
> --
> 2.17.1
>

^ permalink raw reply	[flat|nested] 6+ messages in thread

* Re: [PATCH] qcom: Add firmware files for Adreno A200
  2019-09-04 12:09 ` Nicolas Dechesne
@ 2019-09-04 14:39   ` Rob Clark
  2019-09-04 15:34   ` Josh Boyer
  1 sibling, 0 replies; 6+ messages in thread
From: Rob Clark @ 2019-09-04 14:39 UTC (permalink / raw)
  To: Nicolas Dechesne
  Cc: Fabio Estevam, Bjorn Andersson, Josh Boyer, Jordan Crouse,
	Linux Firmware, jonathan, cphealy, freedreno, linux-arm-msm

On Wed, Sep 4, 2019 at 5:09 AM Nicolas Dechesne
<nicolas.dechesne@linaro.org> wrote:
>
> hi Fabio,
>
> On Wed, Sep 4, 2019 at 1:27 PM Fabio Estevam <festevam@gmail.com> wrote:
> >
> > Add firmware files for Adreno A200.
> >
> > These firmware files are needed for running the adreno kernel
> > driver on i.MX51 and i.MX53 SoCs.
> >
> > Signed-off-by: Fabio Estevam <festevam@gmail.com>
> > ---
> >  WHENCE             |   2 ++
> >  qcom/yamato_pfp.fw | Bin 0 -> 1156 bytes
> >  qcom/yamato_pm4.fw | Bin 0 -> 9220 bytes
> >  3 files changed, 2 insertions(+)
> >  create mode 100644 qcom/yamato_pfp.fw
> >  create mode 100644 qcom/yamato_pm4.fw
> >
> > diff --git a/WHENCE b/WHENCE
> > index a8ec628..5e46d33 100644
> > --- a/WHENCE
> > +++ b/WHENCE
> > @@ -4418,6 +4418,8 @@ File: qcom/a530_zap.b00
> >  File: qcom/a530_zap.b01
> >  File: qcom/a530_zap.b02
> >  File: qcom/a530_zap.mdt
> > +File: qcom/yamato_pfp.fw
> > +File: qcom/yamato_pm4.fw
>
> Where did you get these files from in the first place? On which
> devices do you expect these firmware files to work? We were recently
> discussing how to structure /lib/firmware/qcom more carefully. And the
> general consensus that we reached with Rob C. and Bjorn is that if a
> firmware is expected to work on a specific device (maybe it is signed)
> it should be placed in /lib/firmware/qcom/<device> and if it's
> unsigned and can be used on several devices based on the same SoC (dev
> boards, ..) then it should be /lib/firmware/qcom/<SOC>.

fwiw, the pfp/pm4 fw (later replaced by sqe) are not signed, so
/lib/firmware/qcom/ location is fine for these

BR,
-R

^ permalink raw reply	[flat|nested] 6+ messages in thread

* Re: [PATCH] qcom: Add firmware files for Adreno A200
  2019-09-04 12:09 ` Nicolas Dechesne
  2019-09-04 14:39   ` Rob Clark
@ 2019-09-04 15:34   ` Josh Boyer
  2019-09-06 15:09     ` Chris Healy
  1 sibling, 1 reply; 6+ messages in thread
From: Josh Boyer @ 2019-09-04 15:34 UTC (permalink / raw)
  To: Nicolas Dechesne
  Cc: Fabio Estevam, Bjorn Andersson, Jordan Crouse, robdclark,
	Linux Firmware, jonathan, cphealy, freedreno, linux-arm-msm

On Wed, Sep 4, 2019 at 8:09 AM Nicolas Dechesne
<nicolas.dechesne@linaro.org> wrote:
>
> hi Fabio,
>
> On Wed, Sep 4, 2019 at 1:27 PM Fabio Estevam <festevam@gmail.com> wrote:
> >
> > Add firmware files for Adreno A200.
> >
> > These firmware files are needed for running the adreno kernel
> > driver on i.MX51 and i.MX53 SoCs.
> >
> > Signed-off-by: Fabio Estevam <festevam@gmail.com>
> > ---
> >  WHENCE             |   2 ++
> >  qcom/yamato_pfp.fw | Bin 0 -> 1156 bytes
> >  qcom/yamato_pm4.fw | Bin 0 -> 9220 bytes
> >  3 files changed, 2 insertions(+)
> >  create mode 100644 qcom/yamato_pfp.fw
> >  create mode 100644 qcom/yamato_pm4.fw
> >
> > diff --git a/WHENCE b/WHENCE
> > index a8ec628..5e46d33 100644
> > --- a/WHENCE
> > +++ b/WHENCE
> > @@ -4418,6 +4418,8 @@ File: qcom/a530_zap.b00
> >  File: qcom/a530_zap.b01
> >  File: qcom/a530_zap.b02
> >  File: qcom/a530_zap.mdt
> > +File: qcom/yamato_pfp.fw
> > +File: qcom/yamato_pm4.fw
>
> Where did you get these files from in the first place? On which
> devices do you expect these firmware files to work? We were recently
> discussing how to structure /lib/firmware/qcom more carefully. And the
> general consensus that we reached with Rob C. and Bjorn is that if a
> firmware is expected to work on a specific device (maybe it is signed)
> it should be placed in /lib/firmware/qcom/<device> and if it's
> unsigned and can be used on several devices based on the same SoC (dev
> boards, ..) then it should be /lib/firmware/qcom/<SOC>.
>
> >
> >  Licence: Redistributable. See LICENSE.qcom and qcom/NOTICE.txt for details
>
> Are they really distributed under these license terms? That's a
> specific license that we came up with with Qualcomm a couple of years
> ago based on their Dragonboard offers.

So everyone understands, I'm not pulling this for now.  If there are
questions on provenance of the firmware and the license it's under,
that's a big red flag for me.  Ideally we'd see someone from qcom add
a Signed-off-by or otherwise acknowledge these are meant to be
redistributable.

josh

> > diff --git a/qcom/yamato_pfp.fw b/qcom/yamato_pfp.fw
> > new file mode 100644
> > index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..61a576eb997ce2ee0d32b135adc5d8c789d8e118
> > GIT binary patch
> > literal 1156
> > zcmaKr%WG3X7{!10-ZY7A3K1$6=_76G1N!h4AK=1^>7q~<E%;a!K{qZG{{WkEu`Vig
> > znc9aU-RVwT2qFk+Q_@myY|Wy$6#N(5N<A}4Y7An+@Xef=?>pywGZ*xWlo-D@qsc1s
> > zPiBZtq;Lo<?)jnc0FONz87grhu?2;tYGjUXtrI+jc!`*Bk|n%g5tAFK<$08Cey`T`
> > zvx)jy!_iTK&JzB^96f&7=Jy2U|K?k+gt(ON1sa9FwHhv?DgHb|R9rnZ-6s0-6jM&z
> > z<oUHc%}p<2ua40-x6P;G0z=6yT7xAz^XG{8D<toSI0F%~&MtQ~T=}{_nNy9j>b=By
> > z8`b=UTDGpZL%olqwSLyuMi<gPtom*~LmSJCbZV|Tu6+Mc?V^V9)FoZr!s@x6yK8%C
> > z_Iu;H3)M*(Z_;Vjwjatfch;}iOVyu=r@M4c9_##P#7|+_;(b9#$`3g#E&H)G(&EW#
> > zxHmG)zn>;t$l(^GuMl!ic#FAX%}uRm#-DUZ1hd+EFuQ1Z%pKHqw^N~=sumk-JviU7
> > z&1%0qeGi$+F4LlD>Nu(BfzF~^Ik@AK4f|)~+w9LSVPYeflWINSJtW>%jmAE-X`N`o
> > z($Z#o#}~_Q`saDO4AgL=$zW+=$D6RMuoF#~Id3&ZPDx9}ei!DQJAO!1<Cne}H@=}a
> > zw84=e&!8{|-Sa>8&3oD$%MmN&SySBjIZa%1lT+oXSj=m{xNPnN27?{z{g3~>S}*2o
> > z+!Sjl6<_79MgKjLeBh|wK|hyBla<>kPV$Ih9y6j|j?+bkAujSpCsw$^Yp(K*QPvsb
> > aBNKdPk}Yn^%`G{<%{x^na)+4oG>_jjN)4X?
> >
> > literal 0
> > HcmV?d00001
> >
> > diff --git a/qcom/yamato_pm4.fw b/qcom/yamato_pm4.fw
> > new file mode 100644
> > index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..b45ea20ba5773ef6da25e21abd29914ea9162c07
> > GIT binary patch
> > literal 9220
> > zcmeHMU2I%O6+Y{%UFT-AU2k1ujB&@i>-9SF&jM9cEJ3bFYHh4aq;GvR>H~i&R3H_K
> > z5Otf75}?qOh&)jG$6sG~=>rdaC@Ulc0tr>TAbx8k3J4@36+}TQTE1^)&b@QTyG{^A
> > zykxAs_uMnzIdkUBnKM5Y5qZ}cBT_bfkhUc9lzsoTBr<i%SQ?MgR4=3PnMxVY!9Zkj
> > zs{_iHp8Q-%V)C+gYfkUTJ!4MRB%QwUAG&=-Ns*Cy0@<xx_8|NPv}H@h_3^buk=3od
> > ztwX(3!185BGQ8wIk&&{-$_-A4Y>aKF61?{+{P@??#kOKQ^LA6hMQS3=y7wpO))1Zl
> > z4D7E$WD54PTsoAGR|((X_sMs~^(&N}M1@Hf`yPPT-t-!tH{ho_iBb9%&={{2FL@Jw
> > zjmWl>;L+7Fe;YiQwvT@&c#NSKe;0VuBltHD;qQPK_6wgf=KKEN*i1c)VcKc+RGqKt
> > z6S<#>I26u{UJx^$9%38CWC1_pb;|!h=lJWSGxTBThvaqD|Gqxw-6&rn&pfEP$i=py
> > z3uOR<G$!%6YpO0jL8qp!`JpV0t@q1UeIBSy8&tc}EXHthk5<g4{d+-M{d2jVcBp68
> > zC_0{}$w#$jKJDM9dKPj$%b}k6T+djZZ{_<Y&#Qmzowgd05;$j5ehlzyBn~scq}9H&
> > zo6Us=Au^7isp}k{l$OseH-X<8%d?M2fBGzV@blB^XMAGr8@}AUp1IA^=kZ*cx!2}!
> > zGRFOSL3(Y*@Wp8(&FUGs2$JKK@q0O+IU(btdy1$1%AXAQ^?)yi_%1lEoISc?3D|!r
> > zwEyLv<FoSYshpNslUe~j{8}^2C#)W&6Z|iQZB6(*Oc@ckPFZr&^zECEX-9J&EzO1g
> > z-($)Xj^k3*jVZ@^sqQdn>#Vj#|FryAe2bWw+z;VcG>#k8qNMQE_8EB&B*!A-b1Xcc
> > zW0CRcbI)g6%C}?T`5X)7gB10@9hYrq4{ScCHWMRZZp601^6Vp(C-4S-=p6s}cp3YU
> > zooxQ1L;XzFugmtkw%^Z|KkNAqpiw_x<aXF!ocopUsnYpCkH{Oy=2$enEa_PGN8pXJ
> > zpQ~IenC~2r9|P~oj%;#JP+s)&9U+jlWyh;%XYx~v7I{_*`;GFSJ)int0d2=FlKt6m
> > z*|AvG#zQ3gtKqVhSa!&op8R&WY!b^dUq!x6em`7xB9@&PBCD9lSCh(DU&+C-k<f%m
> > z{F+G+w%9M#{MgB<AZB#mbrqejQmHM0Y!KTw+>uHalUIvv>KPKZ*BX-=dsGwo%I;&y
> > zr#-KcVEO;q!(q0C_DsV6N5L7EXR7C8{{FK`=%2&Ts_We-oou)k=J_zU`!m!4<KCEa
> > zIs8W88x0pTXiGW`$ETi7G`||?3&Uy37*=E97HJnT<z)g|`}h-<kE-);bZcDLFRQZ$
> > zWww;1u!pHAUv?Yq+_sfsyOp<42}-G!=c_~QeBC+h^~8QFW$otsWU6Y<Ia%h4#R*4~
> > z-)X!JPgi39XdgLeS;9W@TgMLkuZQuV{6C?AkY5gL!~SP3MLlGnP|TGVzWp1OrGA``
> > z=1w|HLI087uC0yE%X?<K*S8h!G2&djBX_Xlwxs@zSH<N7*z<X{hn0HP7$C6poX8k!
> > z`L&*TyH$7lG&w`s`L-Hhp!4BSr}}|rwCc|Pz?>h3c{4Cgzb7%EFPa9P?tItr?Lzi5
> > zDm!>Lbo%{34Y=maqQ%qxr5P7*wl99Zu=1PpnGIi5J?z)=w(FPGqx&N0(LL=^VAKz=
> > z;d3fWo!ZAy{$Y{}WIsJjmU@1e+xDnpLfb^Tvc7qNP+O)}jeXO%8}D>uVHrW*h}OHx
> > z{aHNh&sSDfvOAD$zr?jZjMZ*&{wAMPoxa_}z&E1(|2f4#|D#lhGUey>4CtnhG4f;C
> > zhcj6hxBQGTpN%kVBF0<-hB?6;cY5sk#nTf3pL-<5Oa?UjrF<^hN*@Vmj#u37<;*rW
> > zAKe~i5lAil=_i3fTzyT)-PZI>%C~K++US#>!cTqmH>glNF{|6}vA%WtoTC0`px+hO
> > zclI~7^I2!Z<Erx(V9fSnN;%l}W##i*_uKSUtmiqaXK-SDGt2pXJwH<PL$|H)#WJh>
> > zFb2?8AqUE;vzY=%dWJ8%Uy9p(LHp?Q+fBf!uXwkkG-Jcm8!2A4oUOUJ!$XqJQ;uVH
> > ze}ZMX>Ca7r!Qe{JudpwWNb%FM|BOa|HmZvXz}uh8&{)IkpC!iUAI6F1SPDH-Gkn1?
> > z@|_RitL*H?s&l6^e&Kwixt$o4z=%}(@Ei0zq~nXv!h9D$uXzut<HbCgpZysF8`SH|
> > zUh-=yv1RYrA3*N{zP{k%0kkX^@s(eAd}ThBUxKFowFQHxySG^m?o@eaNSzdk+nwj&
> > z+OpSi?e5A!?fx!k_vHiHB}{W5e3j)!HWl0O7l0W*if8`UI|r^KYjXxq`uwHA`esjF
> > z0iI*6c&?|4#}X9auK=ITDX9f_JMWFoYwUYyC+EBBk7H)s&nfUPXbb=@6FL8yVyRYh
> > zF>lv9e@8?;v43uKV`SDhU97&kSiHynfxlM??PpF?`>DU{*9+z!<<qyyhwR0$FH!t2
> > z0ZRWoQpBXNl{JVNZ`<GhL)$oZYC~un$5Huc_pxHT2DMpfk^<%nMU1lz{A|86#tQqf
> > z5qBd|-_awhKb!CT)_ZvB)H}~TBs<LaKI_qL7V`+L%;%)z@m+-vt>5ZyeBB+zX;}x~
> > zj&*^r7`Bq%!$dkOw?cMETb57B?o3ZMf#H6y>-T;(PW(L>`R!mI7@d6*%DR&F`5rr3
> > zycde>NlpOI9MxU0?sV<8d(s<jXL3?)^Er?gC{wM};@Mu;^R3Rd(`o789xt-F@^<Lp
> > zcrE$+I@0Yqw~r;gypYo?ZAWw8zT(eT@p($ubckkipZKLlmn@XBbo^Zt$D)(*;fszT
> > z0ObJ8q_KztG5-EMwoPL=K6fWQ)ye<M<h15AHrOd`@a4;1ayR_Oel2_Z87F$*>wM_W
> > z2o#8Xp4>@UTT=Us&ShoIMT+@AhTrM)|B}jA3TMOWhco`JWrzQ#2=g8*E8frC2d=dZ
> > zS+=Z3eZ0@>oa(0XG16FIR^RHzF`Ub+Qk(4_(#IZ^c1tb}N%Ic>QvgHu8=99G1I!zr
> > zi1<XSPVQ0l|Dn`>Y}@ICo@a`B48;n0CbW%pYR_Qsz)QLg*1$h@e3#Xfy{tO<UGeb{
> > zwne_$27Z>)_P6yQp|(tQjeWDNRo@o-eywM&%T#WQ%Pp2X;EeVak3TYLEEIMY_QUx9
> > zqvg9te~$lq0_I8W`>?x(r!pIM1KI23bq`$kK<I&9X$(uVn=FnRMSqtmKwd1}Ep>5w
> > za^l+s*`HWUYwZ4^I_qL&rhs>CJukJ=9PD7(D%kV9tV_@8{7C6>+4dM`=gpQ+`X5sE
> > l^kJ#ukL4Y57ixAa{T)yr9DB?*aBv?-_5Eu6ah%T`=HI~S@q7RP
> >
> > literal 0
> > HcmV?d00001
> >
> > --
> > 2.17.1
> >

^ permalink raw reply	[flat|nested] 6+ messages in thread

* Re: [PATCH] qcom: Add firmware files for Adreno A200
  2019-09-04 15:34   ` Josh Boyer
@ 2019-09-06 15:09     ` Chris Healy
  2019-09-06 15:27       ` Nicolas Dechesne
  0 siblings, 1 reply; 6+ messages in thread
From: Chris Healy @ 2019-09-06 15:09 UTC (permalink / raw)
  To: Josh Boyer
  Cc: Nicolas Dechesne, Fabio Estevam, Bjorn Andersson, Jordan Crouse,
	robdclark, Linux Firmware, Jonathan Marek, freedreno,
	linux-arm-msm

Hi All,

I'll start by saying that I'm no expert on this subject!  My
understanding with this Adreno 2xx firmware though is that these two
firmware files are generally equivalent to what was distributed
previously in an include file in the following two files for the NXP
i.MX51 and i.MX53 which utilize the Adreno 200:

https://source.codeaurora.org/external/imx/linux-imx/tree/drivers/mxc/amd-gpu/common/pm4_microcode.inl?h=imx_2.6.35_1.1.0_caf&id=61ade304d0eddc3f44fb2ee0b2b7ccf3ffcf85d5
https://source.codeaurora.org/external/imx/linux-imx/tree/drivers/mxc/amd-gpu/common/pfp_microcode_nrt.inl?h=imx_2.6.35_1.1.0_caf&id=61ade304d0eddc3f44fb2ee0b2b7ccf3ffcf85d5

I'm not suggesting we don't get someone from qcom to provide a
Signed-off-by.  I'm only pointing out that it looks like this firmware
was previously made available and that it did have a license that
perhaps we can continue to use for this firmware that's also for the
Adreno 200?

Regards,

Chris

On Wed, Sep 4, 2019 at 8:35 AM Josh Boyer <jwboyer@kernel.org> wrote:
>
> On Wed, Sep 4, 2019 at 8:09 AM Nicolas Dechesne
> <nicolas.dechesne@linaro.org> wrote:
> >
> > hi Fabio,
> >
> > On Wed, Sep 4, 2019 at 1:27 PM Fabio Estevam <festevam@gmail.com> wrote:
> > >
> > > Add firmware files for Adreno A200.
> > >
> > > These firmware files are needed for running the adreno kernel
> > > driver on i.MX51 and i.MX53 SoCs.
> > >
> > > Signed-off-by: Fabio Estevam <festevam@gmail.com>
> > > ---
> > >  WHENCE             |   2 ++
> > >  qcom/yamato_pfp.fw | Bin 0 -> 1156 bytes
> > >  qcom/yamato_pm4.fw | Bin 0 -> 9220 bytes
> > >  3 files changed, 2 insertions(+)
> > >  create mode 100644 qcom/yamato_pfp.fw
> > >  create mode 100644 qcom/yamato_pm4.fw
> > >
> > > diff --git a/WHENCE b/WHENCE
> > > index a8ec628..5e46d33 100644
> > > --- a/WHENCE
> > > +++ b/WHENCE
> > > @@ -4418,6 +4418,8 @@ File: qcom/a530_zap.b00
> > >  File: qcom/a530_zap.b01
> > >  File: qcom/a530_zap.b02
> > >  File: qcom/a530_zap.mdt
> > > +File: qcom/yamato_pfp.fw
> > > +File: qcom/yamato_pm4.fw
> >
> > Where did you get these files from in the first place? On which
> > devices do you expect these firmware files to work? We were recently
> > discussing how to structure /lib/firmware/qcom more carefully. And the
> > general consensus that we reached with Rob C. and Bjorn is that if a
> > firmware is expected to work on a specific device (maybe it is signed)
> > it should be placed in /lib/firmware/qcom/<device> and if it's
> > unsigned and can be used on several devices based on the same SoC (dev
> > boards, ..) then it should be /lib/firmware/qcom/<SOC>.
> >
> > >
> > >  Licence: Redistributable. See LICENSE.qcom and qcom/NOTICE.txt for details
> >
> > Are they really distributed under these license terms? That's a
> > specific license that we came up with with Qualcomm a couple of years
> > ago based on their Dragonboard offers.
>
> So everyone understands, I'm not pulling this for now.  If there are
> questions on provenance of the firmware and the license it's under,
> that's a big red flag for me.  Ideally we'd see someone from qcom add
> a Signed-off-by or otherwise acknowledge these are meant to be
> redistributable.
>
> josh
>
> > > diff --git a/qcom/yamato_pfp.fw b/qcom/yamato_pfp.fw
> > > new file mode 100644
> > > index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..61a576eb997ce2ee0d32b135adc5d8c789d8e118
> > > GIT binary patch
> > > literal 1156
> > > zcmaKr%WG3X7{!10-ZY7A3K1$6=_76G1N!h4AK=1^>7q~<E%;a!K{qZG{{WkEu`Vig
> > > znc9aU-RVwT2qFk+Q_@myY|Wy$6#N(5N<A}4Y7An+@Xef=?>pywGZ*xWlo-D@qsc1s
> > > zPiBZtq;Lo<?)jnc0FONz87grhu?2;tYGjUXtrI+jc!`*Bk|n%g5tAFK<$08Cey`T`
> > > zvx)jy!_iTK&JzB^96f&7=Jy2U|K?k+gt(ON1sa9FwHhv?DgHb|R9rnZ-6s0-6jM&z
> > > z<oUHc%}p<2ua40-x6P;G0z=6yT7xAz^XG{8D<toSI0F%~&MtQ~T=}{_nNy9j>b=By
> > > z8`b=UTDGpZL%olqwSLyuMi<gPtom*~LmSJCbZV|Tu6+Mc?V^V9)FoZr!s@x6yK8%C
> > > z_Iu;H3)M*(Z_;Vjwjatfch;}iOVyu=r@M4c9_##P#7|+_;(b9#$`3g#E&H)G(&EW#
> > > zxHmG)zn>;t$l(^GuMl!ic#FAX%}uRm#-DUZ1hd+EFuQ1Z%pKHqw^N~=sumk-JviU7
> > > z&1%0qeGi$+F4LlD>Nu(BfzF~^Ik@AK4f|)~+w9LSVPYeflWINSJtW>%jmAE-X`N`o
> > > z($Z#o#}~_Q`saDO4AgL=$zW+=$D6RMuoF#~Id3&ZPDx9}ei!DQJAO!1<Cne}H@=}a
> > > zw84=e&!8{|-Sa>8&3oD$%MmN&SySBjIZa%1lT+oXSj=m{xNPnN27?{z{g3~>S}*2o
> > > z+!Sjl6<_79MgKjLeBh|wK|hyBla<>kPV$Ih9y6j|j?+bkAujSpCsw$^Yp(K*QPvsb
> > > aBNKdPk}Yn^%`G{<%{x^na)+4oG>_jjN)4X?
> > >
> > > literal 0
> > > HcmV?d00001
> > >
> > > diff --git a/qcom/yamato_pm4.fw b/qcom/yamato_pm4.fw
> > > new file mode 100644
> > > index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..b45ea20ba5773ef6da25e21abd29914ea9162c07
> > > GIT binary patch
> > > literal 9220
> > > zcmeHMU2I%O6+Y{%UFT-AU2k1ujB&@i>-9SF&jM9cEJ3bFYHh4aq;GvR>H~i&R3H_K
> > > z5Otf75}?qOh&)jG$6sG~=>rdaC@Ulc0tr>TAbx8k3J4@36+}TQTE1^)&b@QTyG{^A
> > > zykxAs_uMnzIdkUBnKM5Y5qZ}cBT_bfkhUc9lzsoTBr<i%SQ?MgR4=3PnMxVY!9Zkj
> > > zs{_iHp8Q-%V)C+gYfkUTJ!4MRB%QwUAG&=-Ns*Cy0@<xx_8|NPv}H@h_3^buk=3od
> > > ztwX(3!185BGQ8wIk&&{-$_-A4Y>aKF61?{+{P@??#kOKQ^LA6hMQS3=y7wpO))1Zl
> > > z4D7E$WD54PTsoAGR|((X_sMs~^(&N}M1@Hf`yPPT-t-!tH{ho_iBb9%&={{2FL@Jw
> > > zjmWl>;L+7Fe;YiQwvT@&c#NSKe;0VuBltHD;qQPK_6wgf=KKEN*i1c)VcKc+RGqKt
> > > z6S<#>I26u{UJx^$9%38CWC1_pb;|!h=lJWSGxTBThvaqD|Gqxw-6&rn&pfEP$i=py
> > > z3uOR<G$!%6YpO0jL8qp!`JpV0t@q1UeIBSy8&tc}EXHthk5<g4{d+-M{d2jVcBp68
> > > zC_0{}$w#$jKJDM9dKPj$%b}k6T+djZZ{_<Y&#Qmzowgd05;$j5ehlzyBn~scq}9H&
> > > zo6Us=Au^7isp}k{l$OseH-X<8%d?M2fBGzV@blB^XMAGr8@}AUp1IA^=kZ*cx!2}!
> > > zGRFOSL3(Y*@Wp8(&FUGs2$JKK@q0O+IU(btdy1$1%AXAQ^?)yi_%1lEoISc?3D|!r
> > > zwEyLv<FoSYshpNslUe~j{8}^2C#)W&6Z|iQZB6(*Oc@ckPFZr&^zECEX-9J&EzO1g
> > > z-($)Xj^k3*jVZ@^sqQdn>#Vj#|FryAe2bWw+z;VcG>#k8qNMQE_8EB&B*!A-b1Xcc
> > > zW0CRcbI)g6%C}?T`5X)7gB10@9hYrq4{ScCHWMRZZp601^6Vp(C-4S-=p6s}cp3YU
> > > zooxQ1L;XzFugmtkw%^Z|KkNAqpiw_x<aXF!ocopUsnYpCkH{Oy=2$enEa_PGN8pXJ
> > > zpQ~IenC~2r9|P~oj%;#JP+s)&9U+jlWyh;%XYx~v7I{_*`;GFSJ)int0d2=FlKt6m
> > > z*|AvG#zQ3gtKqVhSa!&op8R&WY!b^dUq!x6em`7xB9@&PBCD9lSCh(DU&+C-k<f%m
> > > z{F+G+w%9M#{MgB<AZB#mbrqejQmHM0Y!KTw+>uHalUIvv>KPKZ*BX-=dsGwo%I;&y
> > > zr#-KcVEO;q!(q0C_DsV6N5L7EXR7C8{{FK`=%2&Ts_We-oou)k=J_zU`!m!4<KCEa
> > > zIs8W88x0pTXiGW`$ETi7G`||?3&Uy37*=E97HJnT<z)g|`}h-<kE-);bZcDLFRQZ$
> > > zWww;1u!pHAUv?Yq+_sfsyOp<42}-G!=c_~QeBC+h^~8QFW$otsWU6Y<Ia%h4#R*4~
> > > z-)X!JPgi39XdgLeS;9W@TgMLkuZQuV{6C?AkY5gL!~SP3MLlGnP|TGVzWp1OrGA``
> > > z=1w|HLI087uC0yE%X?<K*S8h!G2&djBX_Xlwxs@zSH<N7*z<X{hn0HP7$C6poX8k!
> > > z`L&*TyH$7lG&w`s`L-Hhp!4BSr}}|rwCc|Pz?>h3c{4Cgzb7%EFPa9P?tItr?Lzi5
> > > zDm!>Lbo%{34Y=maqQ%qxr5P7*wl99Zu=1PpnGIi5J?z)=w(FPGqx&N0(LL=^VAKz=
> > > z;d3fWo!ZAy{$Y{}WIsJjmU@1e+xDnpLfb^Tvc7qNP+O)}jeXO%8}D>uVHrW*h}OHx
> > > z{aHNh&sSDfvOAD$zr?jZjMZ*&{wAMPoxa_}z&E1(|2f4#|D#lhGUey>4CtnhG4f;C
> > > zhcj6hxBQGTpN%kVBF0<-hB?6;cY5sk#nTf3pL-<5Oa?UjrF<^hN*@Vmj#u37<;*rW
> > > zAKe~i5lAil=_i3fTzyT)-PZI>%C~K++US#>!cTqmH>glNF{|6}vA%WtoTC0`px+hO
> > > zclI~7^I2!Z<Erx(V9fSnN;%l}W##i*_uKSUtmiqaXK-SDGt2pXJwH<PL$|H)#WJh>
> > > zFb2?8AqUE;vzY=%dWJ8%Uy9p(LHp?Q+fBf!uXwkkG-Jcm8!2A4oUOUJ!$XqJQ;uVH
> > > ze}ZMX>Ca7r!Qe{JudpwWNb%FM|BOa|HmZvXz}uh8&{)IkpC!iUAI6F1SPDH-Gkn1?
> > > z@|_RitL*H?s&l6^e&Kwixt$o4z=%}(@Ei0zq~nXv!h9D$uXzut<HbCgpZysF8`SH|
> > > zUh-=yv1RYrA3*N{zP{k%0kkX^@s(eAd}ThBUxKFowFQHxySG^m?o@eaNSzdk+nwj&
> > > z+OpSi?e5A!?fx!k_vHiHB}{W5e3j)!HWl0O7l0W*if8`UI|r^KYjXxq`uwHA`esjF
> > > z0iI*6c&?|4#}X9auK=ITDX9f_JMWFoYwUYyC+EBBk7H)s&nfUPXbb=@6FL8yVyRYh
> > > zF>lv9e@8?;v43uKV`SDhU97&kSiHynfxlM??PpF?`>DU{*9+z!<<qyyhwR0$FH!t2
> > > z0ZRWoQpBXNl{JVNZ`<GhL)$oZYC~un$5Huc_pxHT2DMpfk^<%nMU1lz{A|86#tQqf
> > > z5qBd|-_awhKb!CT)_ZvB)H}~TBs<LaKI_qL7V`+L%;%)z@m+-vt>5ZyeBB+zX;}x~
> > > zj&*^r7`Bq%!$dkOw?cMETb57B?o3ZMf#H6y>-T;(PW(L>`R!mI7@d6*%DR&F`5rr3
> > > zycde>NlpOI9MxU0?sV<8d(s<jXL3?)^Er?gC{wM};@Mu;^R3Rd(`o789xt-F@^<Lp
> > > zcrE$+I@0Yqw~r;gypYo?ZAWw8zT(eT@p($ubckkipZKLlmn@XBbo^Zt$D)(*;fszT
> > > z0ObJ8q_KztG5-EMwoPL=K6fWQ)ye<M<h15AHrOd`@a4;1ayR_Oel2_Z87F$*>wM_W
> > > z2o#8Xp4>@UTT=Us&ShoIMT+@AhTrM)|B}jA3TMOWhco`JWrzQ#2=g8*E8frC2d=dZ
> > > zS+=Z3eZ0@>oa(0XG16FIR^RHzF`Ub+Qk(4_(#IZ^c1tb}N%Ic>QvgHu8=99G1I!zr
> > > zi1<XSPVQ0l|Dn`>Y}@ICo@a`B48;n0CbW%pYR_Qsz)QLg*1$h@e3#Xfy{tO<UGeb{
> > > zwne_$27Z>)_P6yQp|(tQjeWDNRo@o-eywM&%T#WQ%Pp2X;EeVak3TYLEEIMY_QUx9
> > > zqvg9te~$lq0_I8W`>?x(r!pIM1KI23bq`$kK<I&9X$(uVn=FnRMSqtmKwd1}Ep>5w
> > > za^l+s*`HWUYwZ4^I_qL&rhs>CJukJ=9PD7(D%kV9tV_@8{7C6>+4dM`=gpQ+`X5sE
> > > l^kJ#ukL4Y57ixAa{T)yr9DB?*aBv?-_5Eu6ah%T`=HI~S@q7RP
> > >
> > > literal 0
> > > HcmV?d00001
> > >
> > > --
> > > 2.17.1
> > >

^ permalink raw reply	[flat|nested] 6+ messages in thread

* Re: [PATCH] qcom: Add firmware files for Adreno A200
  2019-09-06 15:09     ` Chris Healy
@ 2019-09-06 15:27       ` Nicolas Dechesne
  0 siblings, 0 replies; 6+ messages in thread
From: Nicolas Dechesne @ 2019-09-06 15:27 UTC (permalink / raw)
  To: Chris Healy
  Cc: Josh Boyer, Fabio Estevam, Bjorn Andersson, Jordan Crouse,
	robdclark, Linux Firmware, Jonathan Marek, freedreno,
	linux-arm-msm

On Fri, Sep 6, 2019 at 5:09 PM Chris Healy <cphealy@gmail.com> wrote:
>
> Hi All,
>
> I'll start by saying that I'm no expert on this subject!  My
> understanding with this Adreno 2xx firmware though is that these two
> firmware files are generally equivalent to what was distributed
> previously in an include file in the following two files for the NXP
> i.MX51 and i.MX53 which utilize the Adreno 200:
>
> https://source.codeaurora.org/external/imx/linux-imx/tree/drivers/mxc/amd-gpu/common/pm4_microcode.inl?h=imx_2.6.35_1.1.0_caf&id=61ade304d0eddc3f44fb2ee0b2b7ccf3ffcf85d5
> https://source.codeaurora.org/external/imx/linux-imx/tree/drivers/mxc/amd-gpu/common/pfp_microcode_nrt.inl?h=imx_2.6.35_1.1.0_caf&id=61ade304d0eddc3f44fb2ee0b2b7ccf3ffcf85d5
>
> I'm not suggesting we don't get someone from qcom to provide a
> Signed-off-by.  I'm only pointing out that it looks like this firmware
> was previously made available and that it did have a license that
> perhaps we can continue to use for this firmware that's also for the
> Adreno 200?

I was not saying the firmware can't be distributed, I was just
pointing out that most likely using LICENSE.qcom was wrong. I was
involved when we created LICENSE.qcom and submitted it first, and I
know that the i.MX firmware can't be distributed with these license
terms. If the firmware have been released previously , especially on
codeaurora.org then they are definitely good candidates for
linux-firmware, but the license and WHENCE need to be adjusted
accordingly.

>
> Regards,
>
> Chris
>
> On Wed, Sep 4, 2019 at 8:35 AM Josh Boyer <jwboyer@kernel.org> wrote:
> >
> > On Wed, Sep 4, 2019 at 8:09 AM Nicolas Dechesne
> > <nicolas.dechesne@linaro.org> wrote:
> > >
> > > hi Fabio,
> > >
> > > On Wed, Sep 4, 2019 at 1:27 PM Fabio Estevam <festevam@gmail.com> wrote:
> > > >
> > > > Add firmware files for Adreno A200.
> > > >
> > > > These firmware files are needed for running the adreno kernel
> > > > driver on i.MX51 and i.MX53 SoCs.
> > > >
> > > > Signed-off-by: Fabio Estevam <festevam@gmail.com>
> > > > ---
> > > >  WHENCE             |   2 ++
> > > >  qcom/yamato_pfp.fw | Bin 0 -> 1156 bytes
> > > >  qcom/yamato_pm4.fw | Bin 0 -> 9220 bytes
> > > >  3 files changed, 2 insertions(+)
> > > >  create mode 100644 qcom/yamato_pfp.fw
> > > >  create mode 100644 qcom/yamato_pm4.fw
> > > >
> > > > diff --git a/WHENCE b/WHENCE
> > > > index a8ec628..5e46d33 100644
> > > > --- a/WHENCE
> > > > +++ b/WHENCE
> > > > @@ -4418,6 +4418,8 @@ File: qcom/a530_zap.b00
> > > >  File: qcom/a530_zap.b01
> > > >  File: qcom/a530_zap.b02
> > > >  File: qcom/a530_zap.mdt
> > > > +File: qcom/yamato_pfp.fw
> > > > +File: qcom/yamato_pm4.fw
> > >
> > > Where did you get these files from in the first place? On which
> > > devices do you expect these firmware files to work? We were recently
> > > discussing how to structure /lib/firmware/qcom more carefully. And the
> > > general consensus that we reached with Rob C. and Bjorn is that if a
> > > firmware is expected to work on a specific device (maybe it is signed)
> > > it should be placed in /lib/firmware/qcom/<device> and if it's
> > > unsigned and can be used on several devices based on the same SoC (dev
> > > boards, ..) then it should be /lib/firmware/qcom/<SOC>.
> > >
> > > >
> > > >  Licence: Redistributable. See LICENSE.qcom and qcom/NOTICE.txt for details
> > >
> > > Are they really distributed under these license terms? That's a
> > > specific license that we came up with with Qualcomm a couple of years
> > > ago based on their Dragonboard offers.
> >
> > So everyone understands, I'm not pulling this for now.  If there are
> > questions on provenance of the firmware and the license it's under,
> > that's a big red flag for me.  Ideally we'd see someone from qcom add
> > a Signed-off-by or otherwise acknowledge these are meant to be
> > redistributable.
> >
> > josh
> >
> > > > diff --git a/qcom/yamato_pfp.fw b/qcom/yamato_pfp.fw
> > > > new file mode 100644
> > > > index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..61a576eb997ce2ee0d32b135adc5d8c789d8e118
> > > > GIT binary patch
> > > > literal 1156
> > > > zcmaKr%WG3X7{!10-ZY7A3K1$6=_76G1N!h4AK=1^>7q~<E%;a!K{qZG{{WkEu`Vig
> > > > znc9aU-RVwT2qFk+Q_@myY|Wy$6#N(5N<A}4Y7An+@Xef=?>pywGZ*xWlo-D@qsc1s
> > > > zPiBZtq;Lo<?)jnc0FONz87grhu?2;tYGjUXtrI+jc!`*Bk|n%g5tAFK<$08Cey`T`
> > > > zvx)jy!_iTK&JzB^96f&7=Jy2U|K?k+gt(ON1sa9FwHhv?DgHb|R9rnZ-6s0-6jM&z
> > > > z<oUHc%}p<2ua40-x6P;G0z=6yT7xAz^XG{8D<toSI0F%~&MtQ~T=}{_nNy9j>b=By
> > > > z8`b=UTDGpZL%olqwSLyuMi<gPtom*~LmSJCbZV|Tu6+Mc?V^V9)FoZr!s@x6yK8%C
> > > > z_Iu;H3)M*(Z_;Vjwjatfch;}iOVyu=r@M4c9_##P#7|+_;(b9#$`3g#E&H)G(&EW#
> > > > zxHmG)zn>;t$l(^GuMl!ic#FAX%}uRm#-DUZ1hd+EFuQ1Z%pKHqw^N~=sumk-JviU7
> > > > z&1%0qeGi$+F4LlD>Nu(BfzF~^Ik@AK4f|)~+w9LSVPYeflWINSJtW>%jmAE-X`N`o
> > > > z($Z#o#}~_Q`saDO4AgL=$zW+=$D6RMuoF#~Id3&ZPDx9}ei!DQJAO!1<Cne}H@=}a
> > > > zw84=e&!8{|-Sa>8&3oD$%MmN&SySBjIZa%1lT+oXSj=m{xNPnN27?{z{g3~>S}*2o
> > > > z+!Sjl6<_79MgKjLeBh|wK|hyBla<>kPV$Ih9y6j|j?+bkAujSpCsw$^Yp(K*QPvsb
> > > > aBNKdPk}Yn^%`G{<%{x^na)+4oG>_jjN)4X?
> > > >
> > > > literal 0
> > > > HcmV?d00001
> > > >
> > > > diff --git a/qcom/yamato_pm4.fw b/qcom/yamato_pm4.fw
> > > > new file mode 100644
> > > > index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..b45ea20ba5773ef6da25e21abd29914ea9162c07
> > > > GIT binary patch
> > > > literal 9220
> > > > zcmeHMU2I%O6+Y{%UFT-AU2k1ujB&@i>-9SF&jM9cEJ3bFYHh4aq;GvR>H~i&R3H_K
> > > > z5Otf75}?qOh&)jG$6sG~=>rdaC@Ulc0tr>TAbx8k3J4@36+}TQTE1^)&b@QTyG{^A
> > > > zykxAs_uMnzIdkUBnKM5Y5qZ}cBT_bfkhUc9lzsoTBr<i%SQ?MgR4=3PnMxVY!9Zkj
> > > > zs{_iHp8Q-%V)C+gYfkUTJ!4MRB%QwUAG&=-Ns*Cy0@<xx_8|NPv}H@h_3^buk=3od
> > > > ztwX(3!185BGQ8wIk&&{-$_-A4Y>aKF61?{+{P@??#kOKQ^LA6hMQS3=y7wpO))1Zl
> > > > z4D7E$WD54PTsoAGR|((X_sMs~^(&N}M1@Hf`yPPT-t-!tH{ho_iBb9%&={{2FL@Jw
> > > > zjmWl>;L+7Fe;YiQwvT@&c#NSKe;0VuBltHD;qQPK_6wgf=KKEN*i1c)VcKc+RGqKt
> > > > z6S<#>I26u{UJx^$9%38CWC1_pb;|!h=lJWSGxTBThvaqD|Gqxw-6&rn&pfEP$i=py
> > > > z3uOR<G$!%6YpO0jL8qp!`JpV0t@q1UeIBSy8&tc}EXHthk5<g4{d+-M{d2jVcBp68
> > > > zC_0{}$w#$jKJDM9dKPj$%b}k6T+djZZ{_<Y&#Qmzowgd05;$j5ehlzyBn~scq}9H&
> > > > zo6Us=Au^7isp}k{l$OseH-X<8%d?M2fBGzV@blB^XMAGr8@}AUp1IA^=kZ*cx!2}!
> > > > zGRFOSL3(Y*@Wp8(&FUGs2$JKK@q0O+IU(btdy1$1%AXAQ^?)yi_%1lEoISc?3D|!r
> > > > zwEyLv<FoSYshpNslUe~j{8}^2C#)W&6Z|iQZB6(*Oc@ckPFZr&^zECEX-9J&EzO1g
> > > > z-($)Xj^k3*jVZ@^sqQdn>#Vj#|FryAe2bWw+z;VcG>#k8qNMQE_8EB&B*!A-b1Xcc
> > > > zW0CRcbI)g6%C}?T`5X)7gB10@9hYrq4{ScCHWMRZZp601^6Vp(C-4S-=p6s}cp3YU
> > > > zooxQ1L;XzFugmtkw%^Z|KkNAqpiw_x<aXF!ocopUsnYpCkH{Oy=2$enEa_PGN8pXJ
> > > > zpQ~IenC~2r9|P~oj%;#JP+s)&9U+jlWyh;%XYx~v7I{_*`;GFSJ)int0d2=FlKt6m
> > > > z*|AvG#zQ3gtKqVhSa!&op8R&WY!b^dUq!x6em`7xB9@&PBCD9lSCh(DU&+C-k<f%m
> > > > z{F+G+w%9M#{MgB<AZB#mbrqejQmHM0Y!KTw+>uHalUIvv>KPKZ*BX-=dsGwo%I;&y
> > > > zr#-KcVEO;q!(q0C_DsV6N5L7EXR7C8{{FK`=%2&Ts_We-oou)k=J_zU`!m!4<KCEa
> > > > zIs8W88x0pTXiGW`$ETi7G`||?3&Uy37*=E97HJnT<z)g|`}h-<kE-);bZcDLFRQZ$
> > > > zWww;1u!pHAUv?Yq+_sfsyOp<42}-G!=c_~QeBC+h^~8QFW$otsWU6Y<Ia%h4#R*4~
> > > > z-)X!JPgi39XdgLeS;9W@TgMLkuZQuV{6C?AkY5gL!~SP3MLlGnP|TGVzWp1OrGA``
> > > > z=1w|HLI087uC0yE%X?<K*S8h!G2&djBX_Xlwxs@zSH<N7*z<X{hn0HP7$C6poX8k!
> > > > z`L&*TyH$7lG&w`s`L-Hhp!4BSr}}|rwCc|Pz?>h3c{4Cgzb7%EFPa9P?tItr?Lzi5
> > > > zDm!>Lbo%{34Y=maqQ%qxr5P7*wl99Zu=1PpnGIi5J?z)=w(FPGqx&N0(LL=^VAKz=
> > > > z;d3fWo!ZAy{$Y{}WIsJjmU@1e+xDnpLfb^Tvc7qNP+O)}jeXO%8}D>uVHrW*h}OHx
> > > > z{aHNh&sSDfvOAD$zr?jZjMZ*&{wAMPoxa_}z&E1(|2f4#|D#lhGUey>4CtnhG4f;C
> > > > zhcj6hxBQGTpN%kVBF0<-hB?6;cY5sk#nTf3pL-<5Oa?UjrF<^hN*@Vmj#u37<;*rW
> > > > zAKe~i5lAil=_i3fTzyT)-PZI>%C~K++US#>!cTqmH>glNF{|6}vA%WtoTC0`px+hO
> > > > zclI~7^I2!Z<Erx(V9fSnN;%l}W##i*_uKSUtmiqaXK-SDGt2pXJwH<PL$|H)#WJh>
> > > > zFb2?8AqUE;vzY=%dWJ8%Uy9p(LHp?Q+fBf!uXwkkG-Jcm8!2A4oUOUJ!$XqJQ;uVH
> > > > ze}ZMX>Ca7r!Qe{JudpwWNb%FM|BOa|HmZvXz}uh8&{)IkpC!iUAI6F1SPDH-Gkn1?
> > > > z@|_RitL*H?s&l6^e&Kwixt$o4z=%}(@Ei0zq~nXv!h9D$uXzut<HbCgpZysF8`SH|
> > > > zUh-=yv1RYrA3*N{zP{k%0kkX^@s(eAd}ThBUxKFowFQHxySG^m?o@eaNSzdk+nwj&
> > > > z+OpSi?e5A!?fx!k_vHiHB}{W5e3j)!HWl0O7l0W*if8`UI|r^KYjXxq`uwHA`esjF
> > > > z0iI*6c&?|4#}X9auK=ITDX9f_JMWFoYwUYyC+EBBk7H)s&nfUPXbb=@6FL8yVyRYh
> > > > zF>lv9e@8?;v43uKV`SDhU97&kSiHynfxlM??PpF?`>DU{*9+z!<<qyyhwR0$FH!t2
> > > > z0ZRWoQpBXNl{JVNZ`<GhL)$oZYC~un$5Huc_pxHT2DMpfk^<%nMU1lz{A|86#tQqf
> > > > z5qBd|-_awhKb!CT)_ZvB)H}~TBs<LaKI_qL7V`+L%;%)z@m+-vt>5ZyeBB+zX;}x~
> > > > zj&*^r7`Bq%!$dkOw?cMETb57B?o3ZMf#H6y>-T;(PW(L>`R!mI7@d6*%DR&F`5rr3
> > > > zycde>NlpOI9MxU0?sV<8d(s<jXL3?)^Er?gC{wM};@Mu;^R3Rd(`o789xt-F@^<Lp
> > > > zcrE$+I@0Yqw~r;gypYo?ZAWw8zT(eT@p($ubckkipZKLlmn@XBbo^Zt$D)(*;fszT
> > > > z0ObJ8q_KztG5-EMwoPL=K6fWQ)ye<M<h15AHrOd`@a4;1ayR_Oel2_Z87F$*>wM_W
> > > > z2o#8Xp4>@UTT=Us&ShoIMT+@AhTrM)|B}jA3TMOWhco`JWrzQ#2=g8*E8frC2d=dZ
> > > > zS+=Z3eZ0@>oa(0XG16FIR^RHzF`Ub+Qk(4_(#IZ^c1tb}N%Ic>QvgHu8=99G1I!zr
> > > > zi1<XSPVQ0l|Dn`>Y}@ICo@a`B48;n0CbW%pYR_Qsz)QLg*1$h@e3#Xfy{tO<UGeb{
> > > > zwne_$27Z>)_P6yQp|(tQjeWDNRo@o-eywM&%T#WQ%Pp2X;EeVak3TYLEEIMY_QUx9
> > > > zqvg9te~$lq0_I8W`>?x(r!pIM1KI23bq`$kK<I&9X$(uVn=FnRMSqtmKwd1}Ep>5w
> > > > za^l+s*`HWUYwZ4^I_qL&rhs>CJukJ=9PD7(D%kV9tV_@8{7C6>+4dM`=gpQ+`X5sE
> > > > l^kJ#ukL4Y57ixAa{T)yr9DB?*aBv?-_5Eu6ah%T`=HI~S@q7RP
> > > >
> > > > literal 0
> > > > HcmV?d00001
> > > >
> > > > --
> > > > 2.17.1
> > > >

^ permalink raw reply	[flat|nested] 6+ messages in thread

end of thread, back to index

Thread overview: 6+ messages (download: mbox.gz / follow: Atom feed)
-- links below jump to the message on this page --
2019-09-04 11:26 [PATCH] qcom: Add firmware files for Adreno A200 Fabio Estevam
2019-09-04 12:09 ` Nicolas Dechesne
2019-09-04 14:39   ` Rob Clark
2019-09-04 15:34   ` Josh Boyer
2019-09-06 15:09     ` Chris Healy
2019-09-06 15:27       ` Nicolas Dechesne

Linux-ARM-MSM Archive on lore.kernel.org

Archives are clonable:
	git clone --mirror https://lore.kernel.org/linux-arm-msm/0 linux-arm-msm/git/0.git

	# If you have public-inbox 1.1+ installed, you may
	# initialize and index your mirror using the following commands:
	public-inbox-init -V2 linux-arm-msm linux-arm-msm/ https://lore.kernel.org/linux-arm-msm \
		linux-arm-msm@vger.kernel.org linux-arm-msm@archiver.kernel.org
	public-inbox-index linux-arm-msm


Newsgroup available over NNTP:
	nntp://nntp.lore.kernel.org/org.kernel.vger.linux-arm-msm


AGPL code for this site: git clone https://public-inbox.org/ public-inbox