From: Alexei Starovoitov <alexei.starovoitov@gmail.com> To: Linus Torvalds <torvalds@linux-foundation.org> Cc: "Eric W. Biederman" <ebiederm@xmission.com>, Kees Cook <keescook@chromium.org>, Tetsuo Handa <penguin-kernel@i-love.sakura.ne.jp>, Andrew Morton <akpm@linux-foundation.org>, Alexei Starovoitov <ast@kernel.org>, David Miller <davem@davemloft.net>, Al Viro <viro@zeniv.linux.org.uk>, bpf <bpf@vger.kernel.org>, linux-fsdevel <linux-fsdevel@vger.kernel.org>, Daniel Borkmann <daniel@iogearbox.net>, Jakub Kicinski <kuba@kernel.org>, Masahiro Yamada <yamada.masahiro@socionext.com>, Gary Lin <GLin@suse.com>, Bruno Meneguele <bmeneg@redhat.com> Subject: Re: [RFC][PATCH] net/bpfilter: Remove this broken and apparently unmantained Date: Sat, 6 Jun 2020 18:49:36 -0700 Message-ID: <20200607014935.vhd3scr4qmawq7no@ast-mbp> (raw) In-Reply-To: <CAHk-=wi=rpNZMeubhq2un3rCMAiOL8A+FZpdPnwFLEY09XGgAQ@mail.gmail.com> On Sat, Jun 06, 2020 at 03:33:14PM -0700, Linus Torvalds wrote: > On Sat, Jun 6, 2020 at 1:20 PM Alexei Starovoitov > <alexei.starovoitov@gmail.com> wrote: > > > > Please mention specific bugs and let's fix them. > > Well, Eric did mention one explicit bug, and several "looks dodgy" bugs. > > And the fact is, this isn't used. > > It's clever, and I like the concept, but it was probably a mistake to > do this as a user-mode-helper thing. > > If people really convert netfilter rules to bpf, they'll likely do so > in user space. This bpfilter thing hasn't gone anywhere, and it _has_ > caused problems. > > So Alexei, I think the burden of proof is not on Eric, but on you. > > Eric's claim is that > > (a) it has bugs (and yes, he pointed to at lelast one) the patch from March 12 ? I thought it landed long ago. Is there an issue with it? 'handling is questionable' is not very constructive. > (b) it's not doing anything useful true. > (b) it's a maintenance issue for execve, which is what Eric maintains. I'm not aware of execve issues. I don't remember being cc-ed on them. To me this 'lets remove everything' patch comes out of nowhere with a link to three month old patch as a justification. > So you can't just dismiss this, ignore the reported bug, and say > "we'll fix them". > > That only answers (a) (well, it _would_ have answered (a)., except you > actually didn't even read Eric's report of existing bugs). > > What is your answer to (b)-(c)? So far we had two attempts at converting netfilter rules to bpf. Both ended up with user space implementation and short cuts. bpf side didn't have loops and couldn't support 10k+ rules. That is what stalled the effort. imo it's a pointless corner case, but to be a true replacement people kept bringing it up as something valid. Now we have bpf iterator concept and soon bpf will be able to handle millions of rules. Also folks are also realizing that this effort has to be project managed appropriately. Will it materialize in patches tomorrow? Unlikely. Probably another 6 month at least. Also outside of netfilter conversion we've started /proc extension effort that will use the same umh facility. It won't be ready tomorrow as well, but both need umh. initrd is not an option due to operational constraints. We need a way to ship kernel tarball where bpf things are ready at boot. I suspect /proc extensions patches will land sooner. Couple month ago people used umh to do ovs->xdp translatation. It didn't land. People argued that the same thing can be achieved in user space and they were correct. So you're right that for most folks user space is the answer. But there are cases where kernel has to have these things before systemd starts.
next prev parent reply index Thread overview: 193+ messages / expand[flat|nested] mbox.gz Atom feed top [not found] <20200329005528.xeKtdz2A0%akpm@linux-foundation.org> [not found] ` <13fb3ab7-9ab1-b25f-52f2-40a6ca5655e1@i-love.sakura.ne.jp> [not found] ` <202006051903.C44988B@keescook> 2020-06-06 19:20 ` Eric W. Biederman 2020-06-06 20:19 ` Alexei Starovoitov 2020-06-06 22:33 ` Linus Torvalds 2020-06-07 1:49 ` Alexei Starovoitov [this message] 2020-06-07 2:19 ` Linus Torvalds 2020-06-07 16:09 ` Eric W. Biederman 2020-06-08 16:20 ` Alexei Starovoitov 2020-06-08 16:40 ` Greg KH 2020-06-08 18:35 ` Kees Cook 2020-06-09 1:26 ` Alexei Starovoitov 2020-06-09 15:37 ` Kees Cook 2020-06-09 19:51 ` Eric W. Biederman 2020-06-07 2:31 ` Tetsuo Handa 2020-06-08 16:23 ` Alexei Starovoitov 2020-06-08 23:22 ` Tetsuo Handa 2020-06-09 1:28 ` Alexei Starovoitov 2020-06-09 5:29 ` Tetsuo Handa 2020-06-09 22:32 ` Alexei Starovoitov 2020-06-09 23:30 ` Tetsuo Handa 2020-06-10 0:05 ` Alexei Starovoitov 2020-06-10 3:08 ` Tetsuo Handa 2020-06-10 3:32 ` Alexei Starovoitov 2020-06-10 7:30 ` Tetsuo Handa 2020-06-10 16:24 ` Casey Schaufler 2020-06-09 20:02 ` Eric W. Biederman 2020-06-09 23:56 ` Alexei Starovoitov 2020-06-10 21:12 ` Eric W. Biederman 2020-06-11 23:31 ` Alexei Starovoitov 2020-06-12 0:57 ` Tetsuo Handa 2020-06-13 3:38 ` Alexei Starovoitov 2020-06-13 4:22 ` Tetsuo Handa 2020-06-13 14:08 ` Eric W. Biederman 2020-06-13 15:33 ` Alexei Starovoitov 2020-06-13 16:14 ` Alexei Starovoitov 2020-06-14 14:51 ` Eric W. Biederman 2020-06-16 1:55 ` Alexei Starovoitov 2020-06-16 16:21 ` Alexei Starovoitov 2020-06-23 18:04 ` Eric W. Biederman 2020-06-23 18:35 ` Alexei Starovoitov 2020-06-23 18:53 ` Eric W. Biederman 2020-06-23 19:40 ` Alexei Starovoitov 2020-06-24 1:51 ` Tetsuo Handa 2020-06-24 4:00 ` Alexei Starovoitov 2020-06-24 4:58 ` Tetsuo Handa 2020-06-24 6:39 ` Alexei Starovoitov 2020-06-24 7:05 ` Tetsuo Handa 2020-06-24 15:41 ` Casey Schaufler 2020-06-24 17:54 ` Alexei Starovoitov 2020-06-24 19:48 ` Casey Schaufler 2020-06-24 6:05 ` Alexei Starovoitov 2020-06-24 14:18 ` Alexei Starovoitov 2020-06-24 12:13 ` Eric W. Biederman 2020-06-24 14:26 ` Alexei Starovoitov 2020-06-24 23:14 ` Tetsuo Handa 2020-06-25 1:35 ` Alexei Starovoitov 2020-06-25 6:38 ` Tetsuo Handa 2020-06-25 9:57 ` Greg KH 2020-06-25 11:03 ` Tetsuo Handa 2020-06-25 12:07 ` Greg KH 2020-06-25 14:21 ` Tetsuo Handa 2020-06-25 19:34 ` David Miller 2020-06-26 1:36 ` Linus Torvalds 2020-06-26 1:51 ` Alexei Starovoitov 2020-06-26 4:58 ` Tetsuo Handa 2020-06-26 5:41 ` Alexei Starovoitov 2020-06-26 6:20 ` Tetsuo Handa 2020-06-26 6:39 ` Alexei Starovoitov 2020-06-26 12:51 ` [PATCH 00/14] Make the user mode driver code a better citizen Eric W. Biederman 2020-06-26 12:53 ` [PATCH 01/14] umh: Capture the pid in umh_pipe_setup Eric W. Biederman 2020-06-26 12:53 ` [PATCH 02/14] umh: Move setting PF_UMH into umh_pipe_setup Eric W. Biederman 2020-06-26 12:54 ` [PATCH 03/14] umh: Rename the user mode driver helpers for clarity Eric W. Biederman 2020-06-26 12:54 ` [PATCH 04/14] umh: Remove call_usermodehelper_setup_file Eric W. Biederman 2020-06-26 12:55 ` [PATCH 05/14] umh: Separate the user mode driver and the user mode helper support Eric W. Biederman 2020-06-26 16:22 ` Tetsuo Handa 2020-06-26 16:45 ` Eric W. Biederman 2020-06-27 1:26 ` Tetsuo Handa 2020-06-27 4:21 ` Eric W. Biederman 2020-06-27 4:36 ` Tetsuo Handa 2020-06-26 12:55 ` [PATCH 06/14] umd: For clarity rename umh_info umd_info Eric W. Biederman 2020-06-26 15:37 ` Kees Cook 2020-06-26 16:31 ` Eric W. Biederman 2020-06-26 12:56 ` [PATCH 07/14] umd: Rename umd_info.cmdline umd_info.driver_name Eric W. Biederman 2020-06-26 12:56 ` [PATCH 08/14] umd: Transform fork_usermode_blob into fork_usermode_driver Eric W. Biederman 2020-06-26 12:57 ` [PATCH 09/14] umh: Stop calling do_execve_file Eric W. Biederman 2020-06-26 12:57 ` [PATCH 10/14] exec: Remove do_execve_file Eric W. Biederman 2020-06-26 12:58 ` [PATCH 11/14] bpfilter: Move bpfilter_umh back into init data Eric W. Biederman 2020-06-26 12:58 ` [PATCH 12/14] umd: Track user space drivers with struct pid Eric W. Biederman 2020-06-26 12:59 ` [PATCH 13/14] bpfilter: Take advantage of the facilities of " Eric W. Biederman 2020-06-26 12:59 ` [PATCH 14/14] umd: Remove exit_umh Eric W. Biederman 2020-06-26 13:48 ` [PATCH 00/14] Make the user mode driver code a better citizen Eric W. Biederman 2020-06-29 19:55 ` [PATCH v2 00/15] " Eric W. Biederman 2020-06-29 19:56 ` [PATCH v2 01/15] umh: Capture the pid in umh_pipe_setup Eric W. Biederman 2020-06-29 19:57 ` [PATCH v2 02/15] umh: Move setting PF_UMH into umh_pipe_setup Eric W. Biederman 2020-06-29 19:57 ` [PATCH v2 03/15] umh: Rename the user mode driver helpers for clarity Eric W. Biederman 2020-06-29 19:59 ` [PATCH v2 04/15] umh: Remove call_usermodehelper_setup_file Eric W. Biederman 2020-06-29 20:00 ` [PATCH v2 05/15] umh: Separate the user mode driver and the user mode helper support Eric W. Biederman 2020-06-30 16:58 ` Linus Torvalds 2020-07-01 17:18 ` Eric W. Biederman 2020-07-01 17:42 ` Alexei Starovoitov 2020-06-29 20:01 ` [PATCH v2 06/15] umd: For clarity rename umh_info umd_info Eric W. Biederman 2020-06-29 20:02 ` [PATCH v2 07/15] umd: Rename umd_info.cmdline umd_info.driver_name Eric W. Biederman 2020-06-29 20:03 ` [PATCH v2 08/15] umd: Transform fork_usermode_blob into fork_usermode_driver Eric W. Biederman 2020-06-29 20:03 ` [PATCH v2 09/15] umh: Stop calling do_execve_file Eric W. Biederman 2020-06-29 20:04 ` [PATCH v2 10/15] exec: Remove do_execve_file Eric W. Biederman 2020-06-30 5:43 ` Christoph Hellwig 2020-06-30 12:14 ` Eric W. Biederman 2020-06-30 13:38 ` Christoph Hellwig 2020-06-30 14:28 ` Eric W. Biederman 2020-06-30 16:55 ` Alexei Starovoitov 2020-06-29 20:05 ` [PATCH v2 11/15] bpfilter: Move bpfilter_umh back into init data Eric W. Biederman 2020-06-29 20:06 ` [PATCH v2 12/15] umd: Track user space drivers with struct pid Eric W. Biederman 2020-06-29 20:06 ` [PATCH v2 13/15] bpfilter: Take advantage of the facilities of " Eric W. Biederman 2020-06-29 20:07 ` [PATCH v2 14/15] umd: Remove exit_umh Eric W. Biederman 2020-06-29 20:08 ` [PATCH v2 15/15] umd: Stop using split_argv Eric W. Biederman 2020-06-29 22:12 ` [PATCH v2 00/15] Make the user mode driver code a better citizen Alexei Starovoitov 2020-06-30 1:13 ` Eric W. Biederman 2020-06-30 6:16 ` Tetsuo Handa 2020-06-30 12:29 ` Eric W. Biederman 2020-06-30 13:21 ` Tetsuo Handa 2020-07-02 13:08 ` Eric W. Biederman 2020-07-02 13:40 ` Tetsuo Handa 2020-07-02 16:02 ` Eric W. Biederman 2020-07-03 13:19 ` Tetsuo Handa 2020-07-03 22:25 ` Eric W. Biederman 2020-07-04 6:57 ` Tetsuo Handa 2020-07-08 4:46 ` Eric W. Biederman 2020-06-30 16:52 ` Alexei Starovoitov 2020-07-01 17:12 ` Eric W. Biederman 2020-07-02 16:40 ` [PATCH v3 00/16] " Eric W. Biederman 2020-07-02 16:41 ` [PATCH v3 01/16] umh: Capture the pid in umh_pipe_setup Eric W. Biederman 2020-07-02 16:41 ` [PATCH v3 02/16] umh: Move setting PF_UMH into umh_pipe_setup Eric W. Biederman 2020-07-02 16:41 ` [PATCH v3 03/16] umh: Rename the user mode driver helpers for clarity Eric W. Biederman 2020-07-02 16:41 ` [PATCH v3 04/16] umh: Remove call_usermodehelper_setup_file Eric W. Biederman 2020-07-02 16:41 ` [PATCH v3 05/16] umh: Separate the user mode driver and the user mode helper support Eric W. Biederman 2020-07-02 16:41 ` [PATCH v3 06/16] umd: For clarity rename umh_info umd_info Eric W. Biederman 2020-07-02 16:41 ` [PATCH v3 07/16] umd: Rename umd_info.cmdline umd_info.driver_name Eric W. Biederman 2020-07-02 16:41 ` [PATCH v3 08/16] umd: Transform fork_usermode_blob into fork_usermode_driver Eric W. Biederman 2020-07-02 16:41 ` [PATCH v3 09/16] umh: Stop calling do_execve_file Eric W. Biederman 2020-07-02 16:41 ` [PATCH v3 10/16] exec: Remove do_execve_file Eric W. Biederman 2020-07-08 6:35 ` Luis Chamberlain 2020-07-08 12:41 ` Luis Chamberlain 2020-07-08 13:08 ` Eric W. Biederman 2020-07-08 13:32 ` Luis Chamberlain 2020-07-12 21:02 ` Pavel Machek 2020-07-02 16:41 ` [PATCH v3 11/16] bpfilter: Move bpfilter_umh back into init data Eric W. Biederman 2020-07-02 16:41 ` [PATCH v3 12/16] umd: Track user space drivers with struct pid Eric W. Biederman 2020-07-02 16:41 ` [PATCH v3 13/16] exit: Factor thread_group_exited out of pidfd_poll Eric W. Biederman 2020-07-03 20:30 ` Alexei Starovoitov 2020-07-03 21:37 ` Eric W. Biederman 2020-07-04 0:03 ` Alexei Starovoitov 2020-07-04 15:50 ` Christian Brauner 2020-07-07 17:09 ` Eric W. Biederman 2020-07-08 0:05 ` Daniel Borkmann 2020-07-08 3:50 ` Eric W. Biederman 2020-07-04 16:00 ` Christian Brauner 2020-07-02 16:41 ` [PATCH v3 14/16] bpfilter: Take advantage of the facilities of struct pid Eric W. Biederman 2020-07-02 16:41 ` [PATCH v3 15/16] umd: Remove exit_umh Eric W. Biederman 2020-07-02 16:41 ` [PATCH v3 16/16] umd: Stop using split_argv Eric W. Biederman 2020-07-02 23:51 ` [PATCH v3 00/16] Make the user mode driver code a better citizen Tetsuo Handa 2020-07-09 22:05 ` [merged][PATCH " Eric W. Biederman 2020-07-14 19:42 ` Alexei Starovoitov 2020-07-08 5:20 ` [PATCH v2 00/15] " Luis Chamberlain 2020-06-26 14:10 ` [PATCH 00/14] " Greg Kroah-Hartman 2020-06-26 16:40 ` Alexei Starovoitov 2020-06-26 17:17 ` Eric W. Biederman 2020-06-26 18:22 ` Alexei Starovoitov 2020-06-27 11:38 ` Tetsuo Handa 2020-06-27 12:59 ` Eric W. Biederman 2020-06-27 13:57 ` Tetsuo Handa 2020-06-28 19:44 ` Alexei Starovoitov 2020-06-29 2:20 ` Tetsuo Handa 2020-06-29 20:19 ` Eric W. Biederman 2020-06-30 6:28 ` Tetsuo Handa 2020-06-30 12:32 ` Eric W. Biederman 2020-06-30 16:48 ` Alexei Starovoitov 2020-06-30 21:54 ` Tetsuo Handa 2020-06-30 21:57 ` Alexei Starovoitov 2020-06-30 22:58 ` Tetsuo Handa 2020-06-25 12:56 ` [RFC][PATCH] net/bpfilter: Remove this broken and apparently unmantained Stephen Smalley 2020-06-25 13:25 ` Greg Kroah-Hartman 2020-06-25 14:26 ` Stephen Smalley 2020-06-25 14:36 ` Stephen Smalley 2020-06-25 15:21 ` Tetsuo Handa 2020-06-25 16:03 ` Stephen Smalley 2020-06-25 16:06 ` Casey Schaufler 2020-06-26 11:30 ` Eric W. Biederman 2020-06-07 5:58 ` Eric W. Biederman 2020-06-07 11:56 ` Eric W. Biederman 2020-06-08 16:35 ` Alexei Starovoitov 2020-06-08 16:33 ` Alexei Starovoitov 2020-06-06 20:43 ` Matthew Wilcox 2020-06-07 15:51 ` Eric W. Biederman 2020-06-07 1:13 ` Tetsuo Handa
Reply instructions: You may reply publicly to this message via plain-text email using any one of the following methods: * Save the following mbox file, import it into your mail client, and reply-to-all from there: mbox Avoid top-posting and favor interleaved quoting: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Posting_style#Interleaved_style * Reply using the --to, --cc, and --in-reply-to switches of git-send-email(1): git send-email \ --in-reply-to=20200607014935.vhd3scr4qmawq7no@ast-mbp \ --to=alexei.starovoitov@gmail.com \ --cc=GLin@suse.com \ --cc=akpm@linux-foundation.org \ --cc=ast@kernel.org \ --cc=bmeneg@redhat.com \ --cc=bpf@vger.kernel.org \ --cc=daniel@iogearbox.net \ --cc=davem@davemloft.net \ --cc=ebiederm@xmission.com \ --cc=keescook@chromium.org \ --cc=kuba@kernel.org \ --cc=linux-fsdevel@vger.kernel.org \ --cc=penguin-kernel@i-love.sakura.ne.jp \ --cc=torvalds@linux-foundation.org \ --cc=viro@zeniv.linux.org.uk \ --cc=yamada.masahiro@socionext.com \ /path/to/YOUR_REPLY https://kernel.org/pub/software/scm/git/docs/git-send-email.html * If your mail client supports setting the In-Reply-To header via mailto: links, try the mailto: link
Linux-Fsdevel Archive on lore.kernel.org Archives are clonable: git clone --mirror https://lore.kernel.org/linux-fsdevel/0 linux-fsdevel/git/0.git # If you have public-inbox 1.1+ installed, you may # initialize and index your mirror using the following commands: public-inbox-init -V2 linux-fsdevel linux-fsdevel/ https://lore.kernel.org/linux-fsdevel \ linux-fsdevel@vger.kernel.org public-inbox-index linux-fsdevel Example config snippet for mirrors Newsgroup available over NNTP: nntp://nntp.lore.kernel.org/org.kernel.vger.linux-fsdevel AGPL code for this site: git clone https://public-inbox.org/public-inbox.git