Re: [RFC 0/1] Allow MAC change on up interface

[Johannes Berg <johannes@sipsolutions.net>]

On Tue, 2019-08-20 at 15:53 -0400, James Prestwood wrote:

> > I thought so, but I had another thought later. It might be possible
> > to
> > set LIVE_ADDR_CHANGE, but then block it in mac80211 when the
> > interface
> > is already connected (or beaconing, or whatever, using the MAC
> > address
> > in some way - even while scanning, remain-on-channel is active, etc.)
> 
> Yeah that makes sense.
> 
> > I still think you'd have to bake it into the mac80211<->driver API
> > somehow, because we normally "add_interface()" with the MAC address,
> > and
> > nothing says that the driver cannot ignore the MAC address from that
> > point on. The fact that iwlwifi just copies it into every new
> > MAC_CTXT
> > command and the firmware actually accepts the update seems rather
> > accidental and therefore fragile to rely on.
> 
> I havent looked into the actual drivers WRT add_interface so I'll take
> a look. But I think I see the separation now and why it may not work
> for all drivers/firmwares the way I did it.
> 
> So are you thinking we need another driver method:
> "change_mac/set_mac"?

Perhaps. Let's continue that in the other sub-thread, where I replied in
more detail to Denis.

johannes