linux-xfs.vger.kernel.org archive mirror
 help / color / mirror / Atom feed
* [LSF/MM/BPF TOPIC] SLOB+SLAB allocators removal and future SLUB improvements
@ 2023-03-14  8:05 Vlastimil Babka
  2023-03-14 13:06 ` Matthew Wilcox
                   ` (3 more replies)
  0 siblings, 4 replies; 13+ messages in thread
From: Vlastimil Babka @ 2023-03-14  8:05 UTC (permalink / raw)
  To: lsf-pc, linux-fsdevel, linux-mm, linux-block, bpf, linux-xfs
  Cc: David Rientjes, Christoph Lameter, Pekka Enberg, Joonsoo Kim,
	Hyeonggon Yoo, Roman Gushchin

As you're probably aware, my plan is to get rid of SLOB and SLAB, leaving
only SLUB going forward. The removal of SLOB seems to be going well, there
were no objections to the deprecation and I've posted v1 of the removal
itself [1] so it could be in -next soon.

The immediate benefit of that is that we can allow kfree() (and kfree_rcu())
to free objects from kmem_cache_alloc() - something that IIRC at least xfs
people wanted in the past, and SLOB was incompatible with that.

For SLAB removal I haven't yet heard any objections (but also didn't
deprecate it yet) but if there are any users due to particular workloads
doing better with SLAB than SLUB, we can discuss why those would regress and
what can be done about that in SLUB.

Once we have just one slab allocator in the kernel, we can take a closer
look at what the users are missing from it that forces them to create own
allocators (e.g. BPF), and could be considered to be added as a generic
implementation to SLUB.

Thanks,
Vlastimil

[1] https://lore.kernel.org/all/20230310103210.22372-1-vbabka@suse.cz/

^ permalink raw reply	[flat|nested] 13+ messages in thread

* Re: [LSF/MM/BPF TOPIC] SLOB+SLAB allocators removal and future SLUB improvements
  2023-03-14  8:05 [LSF/MM/BPF TOPIC] SLOB+SLAB allocators removal and future SLUB improvements Vlastimil Babka
@ 2023-03-14 13:06 ` Matthew Wilcox
  2023-03-15  2:54 ` Roman Gushchin
                   ` (2 subsequent siblings)
  3 siblings, 0 replies; 13+ messages in thread
From: Matthew Wilcox @ 2023-03-14 13:06 UTC (permalink / raw)
  To: Vlastimil Babka
  Cc: lsf-pc, linux-fsdevel, linux-mm, linux-block, bpf, linux-xfs,
	David Rientjes, Christoph Lameter, Pekka Enberg, Joonsoo Kim,
	Hyeonggon Yoo, Roman Gushchin

On Tue, Mar 14, 2023 at 09:05:13AM +0100, Vlastimil Babka wrote:
> The immediate benefit of that is that we can allow kfree() (and kfree_rcu())
> to free objects from kmem_cache_alloc() - something that IIRC at least xfs
> people wanted in the past, and SLOB was incompatible with that.
> 
> For SLAB removal I haven't yet heard any objections (but also didn't
> deprecate it yet) but if there are any users due to particular workloads
> doing better with SLAB than SLUB, we can discuss why those would regress and
> what can be done about that in SLUB.
> 
> Once we have just one slab allocator in the kernel, we can take a closer
> look at what the users are missing from it that forces them to create own
> allocators (e.g. BPF), and could be considered to be added as a generic
> implementation to SLUB.

With kfree() now working on kmem_cache_alloc(), I'd like to re-propose
the introduction of a generic free() function which can free any
allocated object.  It starts out looking a lot like kvfree(), but
can be enhanced to cover other things ... here's a version I did from
2018 before giving up on it when I realised slob made it impossible:

+/**
+ * free() - Free memory
+ * @ptr: Pointer to memory
+ *
+ * This function can free almost any type of memory.  It can safely be
+ * called on:
+ * * NULL pointers.
+ * * Pointers to read-only data (will do nothing).
+ * * Pointers to memory allocated from kmalloc().
+ * * Pointers to memory allocated from kmem_cache_alloc().
+ * * Pointers to memory allocated from vmalloc().
+ * * Pointers to memory allocated from alloc_percpu().
+ * * Pointers to memory allocated from __get_free_pages().
+ * * Pointers to memory allocated from page_frag_alloc().
+ *
+ * It cannot free memory allocated by dma_pool_alloc() or dma_alloc_coherent().
+ */
+void free(const void *ptr)
+{
+       struct page *page;
+
+       if (unlikely(ZERO_OR_NULL_PTR(ptr)))
+               return;
+       if (is_kernel_rodata((unsigned long)ptr))
+               return;
+
+       page = virt_to_head_page(ptr);
+       if (likely(PageSlab(page)))
+               return kmem_cache_free(page->slab_cache, (void *)ptr);
+
+       if (is_vmalloc_addr(ptr))
+               return vfree(ptr);
+       if (is_kernel_percpu_address((unsigned long)ptr))
+               free_percpu((void __percpu *)ptr);
+       if (put_page_testzero(page))
+               __put_page(page);
+}
+EXPORT_SYMBOL(free);

Looking at it now, I'd also include a test for stack memory (and do
nothing if it is)

There are some prep patches that I'm not including here to clear out
the use of 'free' as a function name (some conflicting identifiers named
'free') and a fun one to set a SLAB_PAGE_DTOR on compound pages.

^ permalink raw reply	[flat|nested] 13+ messages in thread

* Re: [LSF/MM/BPF TOPIC] SLOB+SLAB allocators removal and future SLUB improvements
  2023-03-14  8:05 [LSF/MM/BPF TOPIC] SLOB+SLAB allocators removal and future SLUB improvements Vlastimil Babka
  2023-03-14 13:06 ` Matthew Wilcox
@ 2023-03-15  2:54 ` Roman Gushchin
  2023-03-16  8:18   ` Vlastimil Babka
  2023-03-22 12:30 ` Binder Makin
       [not found] ` <CAANmLtzajny8ZK_QKVYOxLc8L9gyWG6Uu7YyL-CR-qfwphVTzg@mail.gmail.com>
  3 siblings, 1 reply; 13+ messages in thread
From: Roman Gushchin @ 2023-03-15  2:54 UTC (permalink / raw)
  To: Vlastimil Babka
  Cc: lsf-pc, linux-fsdevel, linux-mm, linux-block, bpf, linux-xfs,
	David Rientjes, Christoph Lameter, Pekka Enberg, Joonsoo Kim,
	Hyeonggon Yoo

On Tue, Mar 14, 2023 at 09:05:13AM +0100, Vlastimil Babka wrote:
> As you're probably aware, my plan is to get rid of SLOB and SLAB, leaving
> only SLUB going forward. The removal of SLOB seems to be going well, there
> were no objections to the deprecation and I've posted v1 of the removal
> itself [1] so it could be in -next soon.
> 
> The immediate benefit of that is that we can allow kfree() (and kfree_rcu())
> to free objects from kmem_cache_alloc() - something that IIRC at least xfs
> people wanted in the past, and SLOB was incompatible with that.
> 
> For SLAB removal I haven't yet heard any objections (but also didn't
> deprecate it yet) but if there are any users due to particular workloads
> doing better with SLAB than SLUB, we can discuss why those would regress and
> what can be done about that in SLUB.
> 
> Once we have just one slab allocator in the kernel, we can take a closer
> look at what the users are missing from it that forces them to create own
> allocators (e.g. BPF), and could be considered to be added as a generic
> implementation to SLUB.

I guess eventually we want to merge the percpu allocator too.

^ permalink raw reply	[flat|nested] 13+ messages in thread

* Re: [LSF/MM/BPF TOPIC] SLOB+SLAB allocators removal and future SLUB improvements
  2023-03-15  2:54 ` Roman Gushchin
@ 2023-03-16  8:18   ` Vlastimil Babka
  2023-03-16 20:20     ` Roman Gushchin
  0 siblings, 1 reply; 13+ messages in thread
From: Vlastimil Babka @ 2023-03-16  8:18 UTC (permalink / raw)
  To: Roman Gushchin
  Cc: lsf-pc, linux-fsdevel, linux-mm, linux-block, bpf, linux-xfs,
	David Rientjes, Christoph Lameter, Pekka Enberg, Joonsoo Kim,
	Hyeonggon Yoo

On 3/15/23 03:54, Roman Gushchin wrote:
> On Tue, Mar 14, 2023 at 09:05:13AM +0100, Vlastimil Babka wrote:
>> As you're probably aware, my plan is to get rid of SLOB and SLAB, leaving
>> only SLUB going forward. The removal of SLOB seems to be going well, there
>> were no objections to the deprecation and I've posted v1 of the removal
>> itself [1] so it could be in -next soon.
>> 
>> The immediate benefit of that is that we can allow kfree() (and kfree_rcu())
>> to free objects from kmem_cache_alloc() - something that IIRC at least xfs
>> people wanted in the past, and SLOB was incompatible with that.
>> 
>> For SLAB removal I haven't yet heard any objections (but also didn't
>> deprecate it yet) but if there are any users due to particular workloads
>> doing better with SLAB than SLUB, we can discuss why those would regress and
>> what can be done about that in SLUB.
>> 
>> Once we have just one slab allocator in the kernel, we can take a closer
>> look at what the users are missing from it that forces them to create own
>> allocators (e.g. BPF), and could be considered to be added as a generic
>> implementation to SLUB.
> 
> I guess eventually we want to merge the percpu allocator too.

What exactly do you mean here, probably not mm/percpu.c which is too
different from slab, but some kind of per-cpu object cache on top of slab?

^ permalink raw reply	[flat|nested] 13+ messages in thread

* Re: [LSF/MM/BPF TOPIC] SLOB+SLAB allocators removal and future SLUB improvements
  2023-03-16  8:18   ` Vlastimil Babka
@ 2023-03-16 20:20     ` Roman Gushchin
  0 siblings, 0 replies; 13+ messages in thread
From: Roman Gushchin @ 2023-03-16 20:20 UTC (permalink / raw)
  To: Vlastimil Babka
  Cc: lsf-pc, linux-fsdevel, linux-mm, linux-block, bpf, linux-xfs,
	David Rientjes, Christoph Lameter, Pekka Enberg, Joonsoo Kim,
	Hyeonggon Yoo


On Thu, Mar 16, 2023 at 09:18:11AM +0100, Vlastimil Babka wrote:
> On 3/15/23 03:54, Roman Gushchin wrote:
> > On Tue, Mar 14, 2023 at 09:05:13AM +0100, Vlastimil Babka wrote:
> >> As you're probably aware, my plan is to get rid of SLOB and SLAB, leaving
> >> only SLUB going forward. The removal of SLOB seems to be going well, there
> >> were no objections to the deprecation and I've posted v1 of the removal
> >> itself [1] so it could be in -next soon.
> >> 
> >> The immediate benefit of that is that we can allow kfree() (and kfree_rcu())
> >> to free objects from kmem_cache_alloc() - something that IIRC at least xfs
> >> people wanted in the past, and SLOB was incompatible with that.
> >> 
> >> For SLAB removal I haven't yet heard any objections (but also didn't
> >> deprecate it yet) but if there are any users due to particular workloads
> >> doing better with SLAB than SLUB, we can discuss why those would regress and
> >> what can be done about that in SLUB.
> >> 
> >> Once we have just one slab allocator in the kernel, we can take a closer
> >> look at what the users are missing from it that forces them to create own
> >> allocators (e.g. BPF), and could be considered to be added as a generic
> >> implementation to SLUB.
> > 
> > I guess eventually we want to merge the percpu allocator too.
> 
> What exactly do you mean here, probably not mm/percpu.c

Actually, I mean mm/percpu.c

> which is too different from slab

It is currently, but mostly for historical reasons, I guess.

In fact, all is needed (I drastically simplify here) is to replicate
an allocation for each cpu, which can be done by having special slab_caches
with a set of pages per cpu. I believe that in the long run the percpu allocator
can greatly benefit from it. The need for the performance and fragmentation avoidance
improvements grows with the increased number of percpu applications.

But it's not a small project by any means and to my knowledge nobody is actively
working on it, so my comment can be ignored now.

Thanks!

^ permalink raw reply	[flat|nested] 13+ messages in thread

* Re: [LSF/MM/BPF TOPIC] SLOB+SLAB allocators removal and future SLUB improvements
  2023-03-14  8:05 [LSF/MM/BPF TOPIC] SLOB+SLAB allocators removal and future SLUB improvements Vlastimil Babka
  2023-03-14 13:06 ` Matthew Wilcox
  2023-03-15  2:54 ` Roman Gushchin
@ 2023-03-22 12:30 ` Binder Makin
  2023-04-04 16:03   ` Vlastimil Babka
       [not found] ` <CAANmLtzajny8ZK_QKVYOxLc8L9gyWG6Uu7YyL-CR-qfwphVTzg@mail.gmail.com>
  3 siblings, 1 reply; 13+ messages in thread
From: Binder Makin @ 2023-03-22 12:30 UTC (permalink / raw)
  To: Vlastimil Babka
  Cc: lsf-pc, linux-fsdevel, linux-mm, linux-block, bpf, linux-xfs,
	David Rientjes, Christoph Lameter, Pekka Enberg, Joonsoo Kim,
	Hyeonggon Yoo, Roman Gushchin

Was looking at SLAB removal and started by running A/B tests of SLAB
vs SLUB.  Please note these are only preliminary results.

These were run using 6.1.13 configured for SLAB/SLUB.
Machines were standard datacenter servers.

Hackbench shows completion time, so smaller is better.
On all others larger is better.
https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/e/2PACX-1vQ47Mekl8BOp3ekCefwL6wL8SQiv6Qvp5avkU2ssQSh41gntjivE-aKM4PkwzkC4N_s_MxUdcsokhhz/pubhtml

Some notes:
SUnreclaim and SReclaimable shows unreclaimable and reclaimable memory.
Substantially higher with SLUB, but I believe that is to be expected.

Various results showing a 5-10% degradation with SLUB.  That feels
concerning to me, but I'm not sure what others' tolerance would be.

redis results on AMD show some pretty bad degredations.  10-20% range
netpipe on Intel also has issues.. 10-17%


On Tue, Mar 14, 2023 at 4:05 AM Vlastimil Babka <vbabka@suse.cz> wrote:
>
> As you're probably aware, my plan is to get rid of SLOB and SLAB, leaving
> only SLUB going forward. The removal of SLOB seems to be going well, there
> were no objections to the deprecation and I've posted v1 of the removal
> itself [1] so it could be in -next soon.
>
> The immediate benefit of that is that we can allow kfree() (and kfree_rcu())
> to free objects from kmem_cache_alloc() - something that IIRC at least xfs
> people wanted in the past, and SLOB was incompatible with that.
>
> For SLAB removal I haven't yet heard any objections (but also didn't
> deprecate it yet) but if there are any users due to particular workloads
> doing better with SLAB than SLUB, we can discuss why those would regress and
> what can be done about that in SLUB.
>
> Once we have just one slab allocator in the kernel, we can take a closer
> look at what the users are missing from it that forces them to create own
> allocators (e.g. BPF), and could be considered to be added as a generic
> implementation to SLUB.
>
> Thanks,
> Vlastimil
>
> [1] https://lore.kernel.org/all/20230310103210.22372-1-vbabka@suse.cz/
>

^ permalink raw reply	[flat|nested] 13+ messages in thread

* Re: [LSF/MM/BPF TOPIC] SLOB+SLAB allocators removal and future SLUB improvements
       [not found] ` <CAANmLtzajny8ZK_QKVYOxLc8L9gyWG6Uu7YyL-CR-qfwphVTzg@mail.gmail.com>
@ 2023-03-22 13:02   ` Hyeonggon Yoo
  2023-03-22 13:24     ` Binder Makin
  2023-03-22 13:30     ` Binder Makin
  0 siblings, 2 replies; 13+ messages in thread
From: Hyeonggon Yoo @ 2023-03-22 13:02 UTC (permalink / raw)
  To: Binder Makin
  Cc: Vlastimil Babka, lsf-pc, linux-fsdevel, linux-mm, linux-block,
	bpf, linux-xfs, David Rientjes, Christoph Lameter, Pekka Enberg,
	Joonsoo Kim, Roman Gushchin

On Wed, Mar 22, 2023 at 08:15:28AM -0400, Binder Makin wrote:
> Was looking at SLAB removal and started by running A/B tests of SLAB vs
> SLUB.  Please note these are only preliminary results.
> 
> These were run using 6.1.13 configured for SLAB/SLUB.
> Machines were standard datacenter servers.
> 
> Hackbench shows completion time, so smaller is better.
> On all others larger is better.
> https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/e/2PACX-1vQ47Mekl8BOp3ekCefwL6wL8SQiv6Qvp5avkU2ssQSh41gntjivE-aKM4PkwzkC4N_s_MxUdcsokhhz/pubhtml
>
> Some notes:
> SUnreclaim and SReclaimable shows unreclaimable and reclaimable memory.
> Substantially higher with SLUB, but I believe that is to be expected.
> 
> Various results showing a 5-10% degradation with SLUB.  That feels
> concerning to me, but I'm not sure what others' tolerance would be.

Hello Binder,

Thank you for sharing the data on which workloads
SLUB performs worse than SLAB. This information is critical for
improving SLUB and deprecating SLAB.

By the way, it appears that the spreadsheet is currently set to private.
Could you make it public for me to access?

I am really interested in performing similar experiments on my machines
to obtain comparable data that can be utilized to enhance SLUB.

Thanks,
Hyeonggon

> redis results on AMD show some pretty bad degredations.  10-20% range
> netpipe on Intel also has issues.. 10-17%
> 
> On Tue, Mar 14, 2023 at 4:05 AM Vlastimil Babka <vbabka@suse.cz> wrote:
> 
> > As you're probably aware, my plan is to get rid of SLOB and SLAB, leaving
> > only SLUB going forward. The removal of SLOB seems to be going well, there
> > were no objections to the deprecation and I've posted v1 of the removal
> > itself [1] so it could be in -next soon.
> >
> > The immediate benefit of that is that we can allow kfree() (and
> > kfree_rcu())
> > to free objects from kmem_cache_alloc() - something that IIRC at least xfs
> > people wanted in the past, and SLOB was incompatible with that.
> >
> > For SLAB removal I haven't yet heard any objections (but also didn't
> > deprecate it yet) but if there are any users due to particular workloads
> > doing better with SLAB than SLUB, we can discuss why those would regress
> > and
> > what can be done about that in SLUB.
> >
> > Once we have just one slab allocator in the kernel, we can take a closer
> > look at what the users are missing from it that forces them to create own
> > allocators (e.g. BPF), and could be considered to be added as a generic
> > implementation to SLUB.
> >
> > Thanks,
> > Vlastimil
> >
> > [1] https://lore.kernel.org/all/20230310103210.22372-1-vbabka@suse.cz/

^ permalink raw reply	[flat|nested] 13+ messages in thread

* Re: [LSF/MM/BPF TOPIC] SLOB+SLAB allocators removal and future SLUB improvements
  2023-03-22 13:02   ` Hyeonggon Yoo
@ 2023-03-22 13:24     ` Binder Makin
  2023-03-22 13:30     ` Binder Makin
  1 sibling, 0 replies; 13+ messages in thread
From: Binder Makin @ 2023-03-22 13:24 UTC (permalink / raw)
  To: Hyeonggon Yoo
  Cc: Vlastimil Babka, lsf-pc, linux-fsdevel, linux-mm, linux-block,
	bpf, linux-xfs, David Rientjes, Christoph Lameter, Pekka Enberg,
	Joonsoo Kim, Roman Gushchin

[-- Attachment #1: Type: text/plain, Size: 3006 bytes --]

Blah, sorry..  gotta find a better way to share stuff.
Not as pretty but I assume everyone swings CSV.


On Wed, Mar 22, 2023 at 9:02 AM Hyeonggon Yoo <42.hyeyoo@gmail.com> wrote:
>
> On Wed, Mar 22, 2023 at 08:15:28AM -0400, Binder Makin wrote:
> > Was looking at SLAB removal and started by running A/B tests of SLAB vs
> > SLUB.  Please note these are only preliminary results.
> >
> > These were run using 6.1.13 configured for SLAB/SLUB.
> > Machines were standard datacenter servers.
> >
> > Hackbench shows completion time, so smaller is better.
> > On all others larger is better.
> > https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/e/2PACX-1vQ47Mekl8BOp3ekCefwL6wL8SQiv6Qvp5avkU2ssQSh41gntjivE-aKM4PkwzkC4N_s_MxUdcsokhhz/pubhtml
> >
> > Some notes:
> > SUnreclaim and SReclaimable shows unreclaimable and reclaimable memory.
> > Substantially higher with SLUB, but I believe that is to be expected.
> >
> > Various results showing a 5-10% degradation with SLUB.  That feels
> > concerning to me, but I'm not sure what others' tolerance would be.
>
> Hello Binder,
>
> Thank you for sharing the data on which workloads
> SLUB performs worse than SLAB. This information is critical for
> improving SLUB and deprecating SLAB.
>
> By the way, it appears that the spreadsheet is currently set to private.
> Could you make it public for me to access?
>
> I am really interested in performing similar experiments on my machines
> to obtain comparable data that can be utilized to enhance SLUB.
>
> Thanks,
> Hyeonggon
>
> > redis results on AMD show some pretty bad degredations.  10-20% range
> > netpipe on Intel also has issues.. 10-17%
> >
> > On Tue, Mar 14, 2023 at 4:05 AM Vlastimil Babka <vbabka@suse.cz> wrote:
> >
> > > As you're probably aware, my plan is to get rid of SLOB and SLAB, leaving
> > > only SLUB going forward. The removal of SLOB seems to be going well, there
> > > were no objections to the deprecation and I've posted v1 of the removal
> > > itself [1] so it could be in -next soon.
> > >
> > > The immediate benefit of that is that we can allow kfree() (and
> > > kfree_rcu())
> > > to free objects from kmem_cache_alloc() - something that IIRC at least xfs
> > > people wanted in the past, and SLOB was incompatible with that.
> > >
> > > For SLAB removal I haven't yet heard any objections (but also didn't
> > > deprecate it yet) but if there are any users due to particular workloads
> > > doing better with SLAB than SLUB, we can discuss why those would regress
> > > and
> > > what can be done about that in SLUB.
> > >
> > > Once we have just one slab allocator in the kernel, we can take a closer
> > > look at what the users are missing from it that forces them to create own
> > > allocators (e.g. BPF), and could be considered to be added as a generic
> > > implementation to SLUB.
> > >
> > > Thanks,
> > > Vlastimil
> > >
> > > [1] https://lore.kernel.org/all/20230310103210.22372-1-vbabka@suse.cz/

[-- Attachment #2: slab vs slub - INTEL.csv --]
[-- Type: text/csv, Size: 44977 bytes --]

benchmark_name,metric_name,min,max,mean,median,p1,p2,p5,p10,p90,p95,p98,p99
hackbench,hackbench_thread_sockets_max,9.46%,9.49%,9.65%,9.76%,9.46%,9.46%,9.47%,9.48%,9.58%,9.53%,9.51%,9.50%
hackbench,hackbench_thread_sockets_234,9.46%,9.49%,9.65%,9.76%,9.46%,9.46%,9.47%,9.48%,9.58%,9.53%,9.51%,9.50%
hackbench,hackbench_thread_pipes_max,6.81%,0.93%,1.65%,-1.92%,6.64%,6.48%,5.98%,5.19%,0.68%,0.80%,0.88%,0.90%
hackbench,hackbench_thread_pipes_234,6.81%,0.93%,1.65%,-1.92%,6.64%,6.48%,5.98%,5.19%,0.68%,0.80%,0.88%,0.90%
hackbench,hackbench_process_sockets_max,9.70%,8.73%,9.41%,9.55%,9.69%,9.68%,9.65%,9.59%,9.24%,8.98%,8.83%,8.78%
hackbench,hackbench_process_sockets_234,9.70%,8.73%,9.41%,9.55%,9.69%,9.68%,9.65%,9.59%,9.24%,8.98%,8.83%,8.78%
hackbench,hackbench_process_pipes_max,-4.27%,-2.15%,-2.62%,-2.39%,-4.22%,-4.17%,-4.02%,-3.78%,-1.83%,-1.99%,-2.09%,-2.12%
hackbench,hackbench_process_pipes_234,-4.27%,-2.15%,-2.62%,-2.39%,-4.22%,-4.17%,-4.02%,-3.78%,-1.83%,-1.99%,-2.09%,-2.12%
hackbench,SUnreclaim,65.56%,8.63%,40.68%,30.53%,64.10%,62.71%,58.94%,52.91%,96.21%,40.75%,19.48%,13.79%
hackbench,SReclaimable,10.40%,9.29%,9.63%,6.85%,10.40%,10.41%,10.41%,10.06%,12.72%,11.13%,10.01%,9.65%
,,,,,,,,,,,,,
benchmark_name,metric_name,min,max,mean,median,p1,p2,p5,p10,p90,p95,p98,p99
unixbench,unixbench_syscall_max,-0.44%,0.75%,0.77%,1.50%,-0.38%,-0.32%,-0.15%,0.14%,0.86%,0.80%,0.77%,0.76%
unixbench,unixbench_syscall_1,-0.44%,0.75%,0.77%,1.50%,-0.38%,-0.32%,-0.15%,0.14%,0.86%,0.80%,0.77%,0.76%
unixbench,unixbench_spawn_max,2.89%,1.60%,2.09%,1.93%,2.86%,2.84%,2.76%,2.64%,1.67%,1.63%,1.61%,1.61%
unixbench,unixbench_spawn_1,2.89%,1.60%,2.09%,1.93%,2.86%,2.84%,2.76%,2.64%,1.67%,1.63%,1.61%,1.61%
unixbench,unixbench_pipe_max,2.65%,0.60%,1.03%,0.75%,2.60%,2.55%,2.40%,2.14%,0.29%,0.45%,0.54%,0.57%
unixbench,unixbench_pipe_1,2.65%,0.60%,1.03%,0.75%,2.60%,2.55%,2.40%,2.14%,0.29%,0.45%,0.54%,0.57%
unixbench,unixbench_execl_max,1.54%,1.02%,1.29%,1.30%,1.53%,1.53%,1.52%,1.50%,1.07%,1.04%,1.03%,1.02%
unixbench,unixbench_execl_1,1.54%,1.02%,1.29%,1.30%,1.53%,1.53%,1.52%,1.50%,1.07%,1.04%,1.03%,1.02%
unixbench,unixbench_dhry2reg_max,-2.27%,-1.34%,-1.72%,-1.64%,-2.26%,-2.25%,-2.21%,-2.14%,-1.37%,-1.35%,-1.34%,-1.34%
unixbench,unixbench_dhry2reg_lbr_max,-0.23%,0.65%,-0.10%,-0.41%,-0.23%,-0.24%,-0.25%,-0.26%,0.32%,0.48%,0.58%,0.62%
unixbench,unixbench_dhry2reg_lbr_1,-0.23%,0.65%,-0.10%,-0.41%,-0.23%,-0.24%,-0.25%,-0.26%,0.32%,0.48%,0.58%,0.62%
unixbench,unixbench_dhry2reg_1,-2.27%,-1.34%,-1.72%,-1.64%,-2.26%,-2.25%,-2.21%,-2.14%,-1.37%,-1.35%,-1.34%,-1.34%
unixbench,SUnreclaim,62.80%,31.41%,37.32%,39.12%,30.99%,31.51%,32.54%,35.00%,36.93%,36.08%,34.54%,34.08%
unixbench,SReclaimable,8.82%,6.32%,5.84%,6.08%,6.11%,6.08%,3.26%,5.35%,6.23%,6.11%,5.98%,5.92%
,,,,,,,,,,,,,
benchmark_name,metric_name,min,max,mean,median,p1,p2,p5,p10,p90,p95,p98,p99
will-it-scale,writeseek3_scalability,17.86%,17.86%,17.86%,17.86%,17.86%,17.86%,17.86%,17.86%,17.86%,17.86%,17.86%,17.86%
will-it-scale,writeseek3_per_thread_ops,-3.43%,-3.43%,-3.43%,-3.43%,-3.43%,-3.43%,-3.43%,-3.43%,-3.43%,-3.43%,-3.43%,-3.43%
will-it-scale,writeseek3_per_process_ops,-1.06%,-1.06%,-1.06%,-1.06%,-1.06%,-1.06%,-1.06%,-1.06%,-1.06%,-1.06%,-1.06%,-1.06%
will-it-scale,writeseek2_scalability,1.44%,1.44%,1.44%,1.44%,1.44%,1.44%,1.44%,1.44%,1.44%,1.44%,1.44%,1.44%
will-it-scale,writeseek2_per_thread_ops,-5.63%,-5.63%,-5.63%,-5.63%,-5.63%,-5.63%,-5.63%,-5.63%,-5.63%,-5.63%,-5.63%,-5.63%
will-it-scale,writeseek2_per_process_ops,-4.72%,-4.72%,-4.72%,-4.72%,-4.72%,-4.72%,-4.72%,-4.72%,-4.72%,-4.72%,-4.72%,-4.72%
will-it-scale,writeseek1_scalability,5.76%,5.76%,5.76%,5.76%,5.76%,5.76%,5.76%,5.76%,5.76%,5.76%,5.76%,5.76%
will-it-scale,writeseek1_per_thread_ops,-4.02%,-4.02%,-4.02%,-4.02%,-4.02%,-4.02%,-4.02%,-4.02%,-4.02%,-4.02%,-4.02%,-4.02%
will-it-scale,writeseek1_per_process_ops,-4.03%,-4.03%,-4.03%,-4.03%,-4.03%,-4.03%,-4.03%,-4.03%,-4.03%,-4.03%,-4.03%,-4.03%
will-it-scale,write1_scalability,1.87%,1.87%,1.87%,1.87%,1.87%,1.87%,1.87%,1.87%,1.87%,1.87%,1.87%,1.87%
will-it-scale,write1_per_thread_ops,-4.21%,-4.21%,-4.21%,-4.21%,-4.21%,-4.21%,-4.21%,-4.21%,-4.21%,-4.21%,-4.21%,-4.21%
will-it-scale,write1_per_process_ops,-4.15%,-4.15%,-4.15%,-4.15%,-4.15%,-4.15%,-4.15%,-4.15%,-4.15%,-4.15%,-4.15%,-4.15%
will-it-scale,unlink2_scalability,14.71%,14.71%,14.71%,14.71%,14.71%,14.71%,14.71%,14.71%,14.71%,14.71%,14.71%,14.71%
will-it-scale,unlink2_per_thread_ops,0.24%,0.24%,0.24%,0.24%,0.24%,0.24%,0.24%,0.24%,0.24%,0.24%,0.24%,0.24%
will-it-scale,unlink2_per_process_ops,1.29%,1.29%,1.29%,1.29%,1.29%,1.29%,1.29%,1.29%,1.29%,1.29%,1.29%,1.29%
will-it-scale,unlink1_scalability,5.79%,5.79%,5.79%,5.79%,5.79%,5.79%,5.79%,5.79%,5.79%,5.79%,5.79%,5.79%
will-it-scale,unlink1_per_thread_ops,-5.42%,-5.42%,-5.42%,-5.42%,-5.42%,-5.42%,-5.42%,-5.42%,-5.42%,-5.42%,-5.42%,-5.42%
will-it-scale,unlink1_per_process_ops,-5.32%,-5.32%,-5.32%,-5.32%,-5.32%,-5.32%,-5.32%,-5.32%,-5.32%,-5.32%,-5.32%,-5.32%
will-it-scale,unix1_scalability,1.94%,1.94%,1.94%,1.94%,1.94%,1.94%,1.94%,1.94%,1.94%,1.94%,1.94%,1.94%
will-it-scale,unix1_per_thread_ops,-2.33%,-2.33%,-2.33%,-2.33%,-2.33%,-2.33%,-2.33%,-2.33%,-2.33%,-2.33%,-2.33%,-2.33%
will-it-scale,unix1_per_process_ops,-0.65%,-0.65%,-0.65%,-0.65%,-0.65%,-0.65%,-0.65%,-0.65%,-0.65%,-0.65%,-0.65%,-0.65%
will-it-scale,signal1_scalability,4.87%,4.87%,4.87%,4.87%,4.87%,4.87%,4.87%,4.87%,4.87%,4.87%,4.87%,4.87%
will-it-scale,signal1_per_thread_ops,0.70%,0.70%,0.70%,0.70%,0.70%,0.70%,0.70%,0.70%,0.70%,0.70%,0.70%,0.70%
will-it-scale,signal1_per_process_ops,-2.13%,-2.13%,-2.13%,-2.13%,-2.13%,-2.13%,-2.13%,-2.13%,-2.13%,-2.13%,-2.13%,-2.13%
will-it-scale,sched_yield_scalability,4.52%,4.52%,4.52%,4.52%,4.52%,4.52%,4.52%,4.52%,4.52%,4.52%,4.52%,4.52%
will-it-scale,sched_yield_per_thread_ops,-2.48%,-2.48%,-2.48%,-2.48%,-2.48%,-2.48%,-2.48%,-2.48%,-2.48%,-2.48%,-2.48%,-2.48%
will-it-scale,sched_yield_per_process_ops,-2.69%,-2.69%,-2.69%,-2.69%,-2.69%,-2.69%,-2.69%,-2.69%,-2.69%,-2.69%,-2.69%,-2.69%
will-it-scale,readseek3_scalability,4.88%,4.88%,4.88%,4.88%,4.88%,4.88%,4.88%,4.88%,4.88%,4.88%,4.88%,4.88%
will-it-scale,readseek3_per_thread_ops,-3.83%,-3.83%,-3.83%,-3.83%,-3.83%,-3.83%,-3.83%,-3.83%,-3.83%,-3.83%,-3.83%,-3.83%
will-it-scale,readseek3_per_process_ops,-3.55%,-3.55%,-3.55%,-3.55%,-3.55%,-3.55%,-3.55%,-3.55%,-3.55%,-3.55%,-3.55%,-3.55%
will-it-scale,readseek2_scalability,8.09%,8.09%,8.09%,8.09%,8.09%,8.09%,8.09%,8.09%,8.09%,8.09%,8.09%,8.09%
will-it-scale,readseek2_per_thread_ops,-2.18%,-2.18%,-2.18%,-2.18%,-2.18%,-2.18%,-2.18%,-2.18%,-2.18%,-2.18%,-2.18%,-2.18%
will-it-scale,readseek2_per_process_ops,-4.68%,-4.68%,-4.68%,-4.68%,-4.68%,-4.68%,-4.68%,-4.68%,-4.68%,-4.68%,-4.68%,-4.68%
will-it-scale,readseek1_scalability,5.59%,5.59%,5.59%,5.59%,5.59%,5.59%,5.59%,5.59%,5.59%,5.59%,5.59%,5.59%
will-it-scale,readseek1_per_thread_ops,-3.56%,-3.56%,-3.56%,-3.56%,-3.56%,-3.56%,-3.56%,-3.56%,-3.56%,-3.56%,-3.56%,-3.56%
will-it-scale,readseek1_per_process_ops,-3.95%,-3.95%,-3.95%,-3.95%,-3.95%,-3.95%,-3.95%,-3.95%,-3.95%,-3.95%,-3.95%,-3.95%
will-it-scale,read2_scalability,-2.07%,-2.07%,-2.07%,-2.07%,-2.07%,-2.07%,-2.07%,-2.07%,-2.07%,-2.07%,-2.07%,-2.07%
will-it-scale,read2_per_thread_ops,-2.39%,-2.39%,-2.39%,-2.39%,-2.39%,-2.39%,-2.39%,-2.39%,-2.39%,-2.39%,-2.39%,-2.39%
will-it-scale,read2_per_process_ops,-0.53%,-0.53%,-0.53%,-0.53%,-0.53%,-0.53%,-0.53%,-0.53%,-0.53%,-0.53%,-0.53%,-0.53%
will-it-scale,read1_scalability,3.23%,3.23%,3.23%,3.23%,3.23%,3.23%,3.23%,3.23%,3.23%,3.23%,3.23%,3.23%
will-it-scale,read1_per_thread_ops,-2.59%,-2.59%,-2.59%,-2.59%,-2.59%,-2.59%,-2.59%,-2.59%,-2.59%,-2.59%,-2.59%,-2.59%
will-it-scale,read1_per_process_ops,-2.59%,-2.59%,-2.59%,-2.59%,-2.59%,-2.59%,-2.59%,-2.59%,-2.59%,-2.59%,-2.59%,-2.59%
will-it-scale,pwrite3_scalability,10.46%,10.46%,10.46%,10.46%,10.46%,10.46%,10.46%,10.46%,10.46%,10.46%,10.46%,10.46%
will-it-scale,pwrite3_per_thread_ops,-5.43%,-5.43%,-5.43%,-5.43%,-5.43%,-5.43%,-5.43%,-5.43%,-5.43%,-5.43%,-5.43%,-5.43%
will-it-scale,pwrite3_per_process_ops,-3.84%,-3.84%,-3.84%,-3.84%,-3.84%,-3.84%,-3.84%,-3.84%,-3.84%,-3.84%,-3.84%,-3.84%
will-it-scale,pwrite2_scalability,5.01%,5.01%,5.01%,5.01%,5.01%,5.01%,5.01%,5.01%,5.01%,5.01%,5.01%,5.01%
will-it-scale,pwrite2_per_thread_ops,-4.83%,-4.83%,-4.83%,-4.83%,-4.83%,-4.83%,-4.83%,-4.83%,-4.83%,-4.83%,-4.83%,-4.83%
will-it-scale,pwrite2_per_process_ops,-7.44%,-7.44%,-7.44%,-7.44%,-7.44%,-7.44%,-7.44%,-7.44%,-7.44%,-7.44%,-7.44%,-7.44%
will-it-scale,pwrite1_scalability,2.94%,2.94%,2.94%,2.94%,2.94%,2.94%,2.94%,2.94%,2.94%,2.94%,2.94%,2.94%
will-it-scale,pwrite1_per_thread_ops,-3.58%,-3.58%,-3.58%,-3.58%,-3.58%,-3.58%,-3.58%,-3.58%,-3.58%,-3.58%,-3.58%,-3.58%
will-it-scale,pwrite1_per_process_ops,-3.12%,-3.12%,-3.12%,-3.12%,-3.12%,-3.12%,-3.12%,-3.12%,-3.12%,-3.12%,-3.12%,-3.12%
will-it-scale,pthread_mutex2_scalability,4.04%,4.04%,4.04%,4.04%,4.04%,4.04%,4.04%,4.04%,4.04%,4.04%,4.04%,4.04%
will-it-scale,pthread_mutex2_per_thread_ops,-3.56%,-3.56%,-3.56%,-3.56%,-3.56%,-3.56%,-3.56%,-3.56%,-3.56%,-3.56%,-3.56%,-3.56%
will-it-scale,pthread_mutex2_per_process_ops,-4.25%,-4.25%,-4.25%,-4.25%,-4.25%,-4.25%,-4.25%,-4.25%,-4.25%,-4.25%,-4.25%,-4.25%
will-it-scale,pthread_mutex1_scalability,5.58%,5.58%,5.58%,5.58%,5.58%,5.58%,5.58%,5.58%,5.58%,5.58%,5.58%,5.58%
will-it-scale,pthread_mutex1_per_thread_ops,-6.18%,-6.18%,-6.18%,-6.18%,-6.18%,-6.18%,-6.18%,-6.18%,-6.18%,-6.18%,-6.18%,-6.18%
will-it-scale,pthread_mutex1_per_process_ops,-3.82%,-3.82%,-3.82%,-3.82%,-3.82%,-3.82%,-3.82%,-3.82%,-3.82%,-3.82%,-3.82%,-3.82%
will-it-scale,pread3_scalability,3.82%,3.82%,3.82%,3.82%,3.82%,3.82%,3.82%,3.82%,3.82%,3.82%,3.82%,3.82%
will-it-scale,pread3_per_thread_ops,-5.78%,-5.78%,-5.78%,-5.78%,-5.78%,-5.78%,-5.78%,-5.78%,-5.78%,-5.78%,-5.78%,-5.78%
will-it-scale,pread3_per_process_ops,-4.92%,-4.92%,-4.92%,-4.92%,-4.92%,-4.92%,-4.92%,-4.92%,-4.92%,-4.92%,-4.92%,-4.92%
will-it-scale,pread2_scalability,5.81%,5.81%,5.81%,5.81%,5.81%,5.81%,5.81%,5.81%,5.81%,5.81%,5.81%,5.81%
will-it-scale,pread2_per_thread_ops,-4.90%,-4.90%,-4.90%,-4.90%,-4.90%,-4.90%,-4.90%,-4.90%,-4.90%,-4.90%,-4.90%,-4.90%
will-it-scale,pread2_per_process_ops,-1.96%,-1.96%,-1.96%,-1.96%,-1.96%,-1.96%,-1.96%,-1.96%,-1.96%,-1.96%,-1.96%,-1.96%
will-it-scale,pread1_scalability,4.71%,4.71%,4.71%,4.71%,4.71%,4.71%,4.71%,4.71%,4.71%,4.71%,4.71%,4.71%
will-it-scale,pread1_per_thread_ops,-3.76%,-3.76%,-3.76%,-3.76%,-3.76%,-3.76%,-3.76%,-3.76%,-3.76%,-3.76%,-3.76%,-3.76%
will-it-scale,pread1_per_process_ops,-3.65%,-3.65%,-3.65%,-3.65%,-3.65%,-3.65%,-3.65%,-3.65%,-3.65%,-3.65%,-3.65%,-3.65%
will-it-scale,posix_semaphore1_scalability,4.71%,4.71%,4.71%,4.71%,4.71%,4.71%,4.71%,4.71%,4.71%,4.71%,4.71%,4.71%
will-it-scale,posix_semaphore1_per_thread_ops,-4.17%,-4.17%,-4.17%,-4.17%,-4.17%,-4.17%,-4.17%,-4.17%,-4.17%,-4.17%,-4.17%,-4.17%
will-it-scale,posix_semaphore1_per_process_ops,-4.17%,-4.17%,-4.17%,-4.17%,-4.17%,-4.17%,-4.17%,-4.17%,-4.17%,-4.17%,-4.17%,-4.17%
will-it-scale,poll2_scalability,3.74%,3.74%,3.74%,3.74%,3.74%,3.74%,3.74%,3.74%,3.74%,3.74%,3.74%,3.74%
will-it-scale,poll2_per_thread_ops,-1.17%,-1.17%,-1.17%,-1.17%,-1.17%,-1.17%,-1.17%,-1.17%,-1.17%,-1.17%,-1.17%,-1.17%
will-it-scale,poll2_per_process_ops,-4.73%,-4.73%,-4.73%,-4.73%,-4.73%,-4.73%,-4.73%,-4.73%,-4.73%,-4.73%,-4.73%,-4.73%
will-it-scale,poll1_scalability,5.33%,5.33%,5.33%,5.33%,5.33%,5.33%,5.33%,5.33%,5.33%,5.33%,5.33%,5.33%
will-it-scale,poll1_per_thread_ops,-3.72%,-3.72%,-3.72%,-3.72%,-3.72%,-3.72%,-3.72%,-3.72%,-3.72%,-3.72%,-3.72%,-3.72%
will-it-scale,poll1_per_process_ops,-3.22%,-3.22%,-3.22%,-3.22%,-3.22%,-3.22%,-3.22%,-3.22%,-3.22%,-3.22%,-3.22%,-3.22%
will-it-scale,pipe1_scalability,5.30%,5.30%,5.30%,5.30%,5.30%,5.30%,5.30%,5.30%,5.30%,5.30%,5.30%,5.30%
will-it-scale,pipe1_per_thread_ops,-3.55%,-3.55%,-3.55%,-3.55%,-3.55%,-3.55%,-3.55%,-3.55%,-3.55%,-3.55%,-3.55%,-3.55%
will-it-scale,pipe1_per_process_ops,-3.62%,-3.62%,-3.62%,-3.62%,-3.62%,-3.62%,-3.62%,-3.62%,-3.62%,-3.62%,-3.62%,-3.62%
will-it-scale,page_fault3_scalability,4.24%,4.24%,4.24%,4.24%,4.24%,4.24%,4.24%,4.24%,4.24%,4.24%,4.24%,4.24%
will-it-scale,page_fault3_per_thread_ops,-3.13%,-3.13%,-3.13%,-3.13%,-3.13%,-3.13%,-3.13%,-3.13%,-3.13%,-3.13%,-3.13%,-3.13%
will-it-scale,page_fault3_per_process_ops,-2.61%,-2.61%,-2.61%,-2.61%,-2.61%,-2.61%,-2.61%,-2.61%,-2.61%,-2.61%,-2.61%,-2.61%
will-it-scale,page_fault2_scalability,8.05%,8.05%,8.05%,8.05%,8.05%,8.05%,8.05%,8.05%,8.05%,8.05%,8.05%,8.05%
will-it-scale,page_fault2_per_thread_ops,-9.76%,-9.76%,-9.76%,-9.76%,-9.76%,-9.76%,-9.76%,-9.76%,-9.76%,-9.76%,-9.76%,-9.76%
will-it-scale,page_fault2_per_process_ops,-7.31%,-7.31%,-7.31%,-7.31%,-7.31%,-7.31%,-7.31%,-7.31%,-7.31%,-7.31%,-7.31%,-7.31%
will-it-scale,page_fault1_scalability,7.40%,7.40%,7.40%,7.40%,7.40%,7.40%,7.40%,7.40%,7.40%,7.40%,7.40%,7.40%
will-it-scale,page_fault1_per_thread_ops,-0.63%,-0.63%,-0.63%,-0.63%,-0.63%,-0.63%,-0.63%,-0.63%,-0.63%,-0.63%,-0.63%,-0.63%
will-it-scale,page_fault1_per_process_ops,1.33%,1.33%,1.33%,1.33%,1.33%,1.33%,1.33%,1.33%,1.33%,1.33%,1.33%,1.33%
will-it-scale,open2_scalability,12.64%,12.64%,12.64%,12.64%,12.64%,12.64%,12.64%,12.64%,12.64%,12.64%,12.64%,12.64%
will-it-scale,open2_per_thread_ops,-3.55%,-3.55%,-3.55%,-3.55%,-3.55%,-3.55%,-3.55%,-3.55%,-3.55%,-3.55%,-3.55%,-3.55%
will-it-scale,open2_per_process_ops,-0.50%,-0.50%,-0.50%,-0.50%,-0.50%,-0.50%,-0.50%,-0.50%,-0.50%,-0.50%,-0.50%,-0.50%
will-it-scale,open1_scalability,13.87%,13.87%,13.87%,13.87%,13.87%,13.87%,13.87%,13.87%,13.87%,13.87%,13.87%,13.87%
will-it-scale,open1_per_thread_ops,-1.32%,-1.32%,-1.32%,-1.32%,-1.32%,-1.32%,-1.32%,-1.32%,-1.32%,-1.32%,-1.32%,-1.32%
will-it-scale,open1_per_process_ops,-0.95%,-0.95%,-0.95%,-0.95%,-0.95%,-0.95%,-0.95%,-0.95%,-0.95%,-0.95%,-0.95%,-0.95%
will-it-scale,mmap2_scalability,6.98%,6.98%,6.98%,6.98%,6.98%,6.98%,6.98%,6.98%,6.98%,6.98%,6.98%,6.98%
will-it-scale,mmap2_per_thread_ops,-5.24%,-5.24%,-5.24%,-5.24%,-5.24%,-5.24%,-5.24%,-5.24%,-5.24%,-5.24%,-5.24%,-5.24%
will-it-scale,mmap2_per_process_ops,-1.93%,-1.93%,-1.93%,-1.93%,-1.93%,-1.93%,-1.93%,-1.93%,-1.93%,-1.93%,-1.93%,-1.93%
will-it-scale,mmap1_scalability,7.07%,7.07%,7.07%,7.07%,7.07%,7.07%,7.07%,7.07%,7.07%,7.07%,7.07%,7.07%
will-it-scale,mmap1_per_thread_ops,-5.20%,-5.20%,-5.20%,-5.20%,-5.20%,-5.20%,-5.20%,-5.20%,-5.20%,-5.20%,-5.20%,-5.20%
will-it-scale,mmap1_per_process_ops,-2.05%,-2.05%,-2.05%,-2.05%,-2.05%,-2.05%,-2.05%,-2.05%,-2.05%,-2.05%,-2.05%,-2.05%
will-it-scale,malloc2_scalability,4.74%,4.74%,4.74%,4.74%,4.74%,4.74%,4.74%,4.74%,4.74%,4.74%,4.74%,4.74%
will-it-scale,malloc2_per_thread_ops,-4.25%,-4.25%,-4.25%,-4.25%,-4.25%,-4.25%,-4.25%,-4.25%,-4.25%,-4.25%,-4.25%,-4.25%
will-it-scale,malloc2_per_process_ops,-4.25%,-4.25%,-4.25%,-4.25%,-4.25%,-4.25%,-4.25%,-4.25%,-4.25%,-4.25%,-4.25%,-4.25%
will-it-scale,malloc1_scalability,7.31%,7.31%,7.31%,7.31%,7.31%,7.31%,7.31%,7.31%,7.31%,7.31%,7.31%,7.31%
will-it-scale,malloc1_per_thread_ops,-3.73%,-3.73%,-3.73%,-3.73%,-3.73%,-3.73%,-3.73%,-3.73%,-3.73%,-3.73%,-3.73%,-3.73%
will-it-scale,malloc1_per_process_ops,-0.39%,-0.39%,-0.39%,-0.39%,-0.39%,-0.39%,-0.39%,-0.39%,-0.39%,-0.39%,-0.39%,-0.39%
will-it-scale,lseek2_scalability,5.11%,5.11%,5.11%,5.11%,5.11%,5.11%,5.11%,5.11%,5.11%,5.11%,5.11%,5.11%
will-it-scale,lseek2_per_thread_ops,-4.42%,-4.42%,-4.42%,-4.42%,-4.42%,-4.42%,-4.42%,-4.42%,-4.42%,-4.42%,-4.42%,-4.42%
will-it-scale,lseek2_per_process_ops,-4.51%,-4.51%,-4.51%,-4.51%,-4.51%,-4.51%,-4.51%,-4.51%,-4.51%,-4.51%,-4.51%,-4.51%
will-it-scale,lseek1_scalability,2.83%,2.83%,2.83%,2.83%,2.83%,2.83%,2.83%,2.83%,2.83%,2.83%,2.83%,2.83%
will-it-scale,lseek1_per_thread_ops,-4.58%,-4.58%,-4.58%,-4.58%,-4.58%,-4.58%,-4.58%,-4.58%,-4.58%,-4.58%,-4.58%,-4.58%
will-it-scale,lseek1_per_process_ops,-5.08%,-5.08%,-5.08%,-5.08%,-5.08%,-5.08%,-5.08%,-5.08%,-5.08%,-5.08%,-5.08%,-5.08%
will-it-scale,lock1_scalability,5.94%,5.94%,5.94%,5.94%,5.94%,5.94%,5.94%,5.94%,5.94%,5.94%,5.94%,5.94%
will-it-scale,lock1_per_thread_ops,-0.49%,-0.49%,-0.49%,-0.49%,-0.49%,-0.49%,-0.49%,-0.49%,-0.49%,-0.49%,-0.49%,-0.49%
will-it-scale,lock1_per_process_ops,-1.26%,-1.26%,-1.26%,-1.26%,-1.26%,-1.26%,-1.26%,-1.26%,-1.26%,-1.26%,-1.26%,-1.26%
will-it-scale,getppid1_scalability,3.77%,3.77%,3.77%,3.77%,3.77%,3.77%,3.77%,3.77%,3.77%,3.77%,3.77%,3.77%
will-it-scale,getppid1_per_thread_ops,-4.64%,-4.64%,-4.64%,-4.64%,-4.64%,-4.64%,-4.64%,-4.64%,-4.64%,-4.64%,-4.64%,-4.64%
will-it-scale,getppid1_per_process_ops,-3.83%,-3.83%,-3.83%,-3.83%,-3.83%,-3.83%,-3.83%,-3.83%,-3.83%,-3.83%,-3.83%,-3.83%
will-it-scale,futex4_scalability,4.61%,4.61%,4.61%,4.61%,4.61%,4.61%,4.61%,4.61%,4.61%,4.61%,4.61%,4.61%
will-it-scale,futex4_per_thread_ops,-4.03%,-4.03%,-4.03%,-4.03%,-4.03%,-4.03%,-4.03%,-4.03%,-4.03%,-4.03%,-4.03%,-4.03%
will-it-scale,futex4_per_process_ops,-3.94%,-3.94%,-3.94%,-3.94%,-3.94%,-3.94%,-3.94%,-3.94%,-3.94%,-3.94%,-3.94%,-3.94%
will-it-scale,futex3_scalability,4.68%,4.68%,4.68%,4.68%,4.68%,4.68%,4.68%,4.68%,4.68%,4.68%,4.68%,4.68%
will-it-scale,futex3_per_thread_ops,-4.00%,-4.00%,-4.00%,-4.00%,-4.00%,-4.00%,-4.00%,-4.00%,-4.00%,-4.00%,-4.00%,-4.00%
will-it-scale,futex3_per_process_ops,-3.73%,-3.73%,-3.73%,-3.73%,-3.73%,-3.73%,-3.73%,-3.73%,-3.73%,-3.73%,-3.73%,-3.73%
will-it-scale,futex2_scalability,3.18%,3.18%,3.18%,3.18%,3.18%,3.18%,3.18%,3.18%,3.18%,3.18%,3.18%,3.18%
will-it-scale,futex2_per_thread_ops,-3.84%,-3.84%,-3.84%,-3.84%,-3.84%,-3.84%,-3.84%,-3.84%,-3.84%,-3.84%,-3.84%,-3.84%
will-it-scale,futex2_per_process_ops,-3.72%,-3.72%,-3.72%,-3.72%,-3.72%,-3.72%,-3.72%,-3.72%,-3.72%,-3.72%,-3.72%,-3.72%
will-it-scale,futex1_scalability,4.55%,4.55%,4.55%,4.55%,4.55%,4.55%,4.55%,4.55%,4.55%,4.55%,4.55%,4.55%
will-it-scale,futex1_per_thread_ops,-3.41%,-3.41%,-3.41%,-3.41%,-3.41%,-3.41%,-3.41%,-3.41%,-3.41%,-3.41%,-3.41%,-3.41%
will-it-scale,futex1_per_process_ops,-3.40%,-3.40%,-3.40%,-3.40%,-3.40%,-3.40%,-3.40%,-3.40%,-3.40%,-3.40%,-3.40%,-3.40%
will-it-scale,eventfd1_scalability,6.45%,6.45%,6.45%,6.45%,6.45%,6.45%,6.45%,6.45%,6.45%,6.45%,6.45%,6.45%
will-it-scale,eventfd1_per_thread_ops,-4.63%,-4.63%,-4.63%,-4.63%,-4.63%,-4.63%,-4.63%,-4.63%,-4.63%,-4.63%,-4.63%,-4.63%
will-it-scale,eventfd1_per_process_ops,-5.34%,-5.34%,-5.34%,-5.34%,-5.34%,-5.34%,-5.34%,-5.34%,-5.34%,-5.34%,-5.34%,-5.34%
will-it-scale,dup1_scalability,2.58%,2.58%,2.58%,2.58%,2.58%,2.58%,2.58%,2.58%,2.58%,2.58%,2.58%,2.58%
will-it-scale,dup1_per_thread_ops,-1.07%,-1.07%,-1.07%,-1.07%,-1.07%,-1.07%,-1.07%,-1.07%,-1.07%,-1.07%,-1.07%,-1.07%
will-it-scale,dup1_per_process_ops,-4.52%,-4.52%,-4.52%,-4.52%,-4.52%,-4.52%,-4.52%,-4.52%,-4.52%,-4.52%,-4.52%,-4.52%
will-it-scale,context_switch1_scalability,2.94%,2.94%,2.94%,2.94%,2.94%,2.94%,2.94%,2.94%,2.94%,2.94%,2.94%,2.94%
will-it-scale,context_switch1_per_thread_ops,-1.18%,-1.18%,-1.18%,-1.18%,-1.18%,-1.18%,-1.18%,-1.18%,-1.18%,-1.18%,-1.18%,-1.18%
will-it-scale,context_switch1_per_process_ops,-2.63%,-2.63%,-2.63%,-2.63%,-2.63%,-2.63%,-2.63%,-2.63%,-2.63%,-2.63%,-2.63%,-2.63%
will-it-scale,brk1_scalability,6.83%,6.83%,6.83%,6.83%,6.83%,6.83%,6.83%,6.83%,6.83%,6.83%,6.83%,6.83%
will-it-scale,brk1_per_thread_ops,-2.40%,-2.40%,-2.40%,-2.40%,-2.40%,-2.40%,-2.40%,-2.40%,-2.40%,-2.40%,-2.40%,-2.40%
will-it-scale,brk1_per_process_ops,-4.42%,-4.42%,-4.42%,-4.42%,-4.42%,-4.42%,-4.42%,-4.42%,-4.42%,-4.42%,-4.42%,-4.42%
will-it-scale,SUnreclaim,65.77%,6.35%,24.89%,28.06%,64.09%,-29.67%,-31.36%,25.42%,26.74%,25.23%,21.10%,17.64%
will-it-scale,SReclaimable,8.11%,2.22%,1.97%,4.19%,5.27%,-38.20%,-40.16%,-3.13%,4.14%,5.34%,3.24%,3.23%
,,,,,,,,,,,,,
benchmark_name,metric_name,min,max,mean,median,p1,p2,p5,p10,p90,p95,p98,p99
kernbench,kernbench_user_max,-0.11%,0.14%,0.02%,0.00%,-0.11%,-0.10%,-0.10%,-0.08%,0.12%,0.13%,0.13%,0.13%
kernbench,kernbench_user_112,-0.11%,0.14%,0.02%,0.00%,-0.11%,-0.10%,-0.10%,-0.08%,0.12%,0.13%,0.13%,0.13%
kernbench,kernbench_syst_max,-0.18%,-0.77%,-0.49%,-0.52%,-0.18%,-0.19%,-0.21%,-0.24%,-0.72%,-0.74%,-0.76%,-0.77%
kernbench,kernbench_syst_112,-0.18%,-0.77%,-0.49%,-0.52%,-0.18%,-0.19%,-0.21%,-0.24%,-0.72%,-0.74%,-0.76%,-0.77%
kernbench,kernbench_elsp_max,-0.16%,0.18%,0.04%,0.04%,-0.15%,-0.15%,-0.13%,-0.10%,0.16%,0.17%,0.17%,0.18%
kernbench,kernbench_elsp_112,-0.16%,0.18%,0.04%,0.04%,-0.15%,-0.15%,-0.13%,-0.10%,0.16%,0.17%,0.17%,0.18%
kernbench,SUnreclaim,60.51%,14.73%,19.54%,14.54%,50.35%,44.93%,40.23%,43.07%,14.42%,14.43%,14.45%,14.49%
kernbench,SReclaimable,8.34%,1.47%,2.42%,1.19%,7.81%,7.38%,5.91%,6.18%,0.88%,1.06%,1.34%,1.43%
,,,,,,,,,,,,,
benchmark_name,metric_name,min,max,mean,median,p1,p2,p5,p10,p90,p95,p98,p99
specjbb2015,specjbb2015_single_SLA_minus,4.44%,4.44%,4.44%,4.44%,4.44%,4.44%,4.44%,4.44%,4.44%,4.44%,4.44%,4.44%
specjbb2015,specjbb2015_single_SLA_maxus,-1.11%,-1.11%,-1.11%,-1.11%,-1.11%,-1.11%,-1.11%,-1.11%,-1.11%,-1.11%,-1.11%,-1.11%
specjbb2015,specjbb2015_single_SLA_75000us,-1.97%,-1.97%,-1.97%,-1.97%,-1.97%,-1.97%,-1.97%,-1.97%,-1.97%,-1.97%,-1.97%,-1.97%
specjbb2015,specjbb2015_single_SLA_50000us,2.82%,2.82%,2.82%,2.82%,2.82%,2.82%,2.82%,2.82%,2.82%,2.82%,2.82%,2.82%
specjbb2015,specjbb2015_single_SLA_25000us,-5.73%,-5.73%,-5.73%,-5.73%,-5.73%,-5.73%,-5.73%,-5.73%,-5.73%,-5.73%,-5.73%,-5.73%
specjbb2015,specjbb2015_single_SLA_10000us,4.44%,4.44%,4.44%,4.44%,4.44%,4.44%,4.44%,4.44%,4.44%,4.44%,4.44%,4.44%
specjbb2015,specjbb2015_single_SLA_100000us,-1.11%,-1.11%,-1.11%,-1.11%,-1.11%,-1.11%,-1.11%,-1.11%,-1.11%,-1.11%,-1.11%,-1.11%
specjbb2015,specjbb2015_single_Max_JOPS,1.08%,1.08%,1.08%,1.08%,1.08%,1.08%,1.08%,1.08%,1.08%,1.08%,1.08%,1.08%
specjbb2015,specjbb2015_single_Critical_JOPS,-0.37%,-0.37%,-0.37%,-0.37%,-0.37%,-0.37%,-0.37%,-0.37%,-0.37%,-0.37%,-0.37%,-0.37%
specjbb2015,SUnreclaim,64.22%,31.81%,31.60%,31.91%,28.47%,27.49%,28.60%,29.82%,32.42%,32.32%,32.24%,32.15%
specjbb2015,SReclaimable,8.62%,6.07%,5.66%,5.93%,4.85%,3.03%,2.79%,5.59%,5.72%,5.60%,5.43%,5.22%
,,,,,,,,,,,,,
benchmark_name,metric_name,min,max,mean,median,p1,p2,p5,p10,p90,p95,p98,p99
redis,redis_small_max_SPOP,-2.01%,-0.71%,-2.75%,-3.68%,-2.08%,-2.16%,-2.38%,-2.76%,-1.83%,-1.27%,-0.94%,-0.82%
redis,redis_small_max_SET,-6.13%,-5.61%,-3.80%,-3.48%,-5.94%,-5.75%,-5.17%,-4.21%,-4.35%,-4.98%,-5.36%,-5.48%
redis,redis_small_max_SADD,-0.39%,-5.42%,-2.49%,-1.85%,-0.39%,-0.40%,-0.41%,-0.43%,-4.87%,-5.15%,-5.31%,-5.37%
redis,redis_small_max_PING_INLINE,-8.50%,-5.71%,-3.40%,-0.29%,-8.24%,-7.97%,-7.19%,-5.88%,-3.69%,-4.71%,-5.32%,-5.51%
redis,redis_small_max_PING_BULK,-3.87%,-0.70%,-1.91%,-2.43%,-3.84%,-3.81%,-3.72%,-3.57%,-0.27%,-0.49%,-0.61%,-0.66%
redis,redis_small_max_MSET_10,4.86%,-2.53%,1.32%,3.07%,4.68%,4.50%,3.97%,3.10%,-1.12%,-1.83%,-2.25%,-2.39%
redis,redis_small_max_LRANGE_600,0.89%,-1.66%,0.57%,1.05%,0.91%,0.92%,0.96%,1.03%,-0.45%,-1.06%,-1.42%,-1.54%
redis,redis_small_max_LRANGE_500,0.93%,-2.03%,0.42%,0.82%,0.93%,0.92%,0.90%,0.88%,-0.58%,-1.31%,-1.74%,-1.88%
redis,redis_small_max_LRANGE_300,0.90%,-0.83%,0.45%,1.00%,0.90%,0.89%,0.87%,0.84%,-0.32%,-0.58%,-0.73%,-0.78%
redis,redis_small_max_LRANGE_100,1.92%,-1.90%,0.35%,0.76%,1.87%,1.81%,1.64%,1.37%,-0.94%,-1.43%,-1.71%,-1.81%
redis,redis_small_max_LPUSH,3.37%,-3.11%,0.20%,1.27%,3.16%,2.96%,2.34%,1.35%,-3.06%,-3.09%,-3.10%,-3.11%
redis,redis_small_max_LPOP,-1.03%,-5.65%,-2.34%,-1.72%,-1.03%,-1.04%,-1.05%,-1.07%,-4.21%,-4.94%,-5.37%,-5.51%
redis,redis_small_max_INCR,-2.81%,-1.42%,-0.47%,3.32%,-2.78%,-2.75%,-2.67%,-2.52%,-0.64%,-1.03%,-1.26%,-1.34%
redis,redis_small_max_GET,-2.98%,-3.29%,-3.86%,-3.94%,-3.12%,-3.26%,-3.69%,-4.39%,-3.04%,-3.17%,-3.24%,-3.27%
redis,redis_small_112_SPOP,-2.01%,-0.71%,-2.75%,-3.68%,-2.08%,-2.16%,-2.38%,-2.76%,-1.83%,-1.27%,-0.94%,-0.82%
redis,redis_small_112_SET,-6.13%,-5.61%,-3.80%,-3.48%,-5.94%,-5.75%,-5.17%,-4.21%,-4.35%,-4.98%,-5.36%,-5.48%
redis,redis_small_112_SADD,-0.39%,-5.42%,-2.49%,-1.85%,-0.39%,-0.40%,-0.41%,-0.43%,-4.87%,-5.15%,-5.31%,-5.37%
redis,redis_small_112_PING_INLINE,-8.50%,-5.71%,-3.40%,-0.29%,-8.24%,-7.97%,-7.19%,-5.88%,-3.69%,-4.71%,-5.32%,-5.51%
redis,redis_small_112_PING_BULK,-3.87%,-0.70%,-1.91%,-2.43%,-3.84%,-3.81%,-3.72%,-3.57%,-0.27%,-0.49%,-0.61%,-0.66%
redis,redis_small_112_MSET_10,4.86%,-2.53%,1.32%,3.07%,4.68%,4.50%,3.97%,3.10%,-1.12%,-1.83%,-2.25%,-2.39%
redis,redis_small_112_LRANGE_600,0.89%,-1.66%,0.57%,1.05%,0.91%,0.92%,0.96%,1.03%,-0.45%,-1.06%,-1.42%,-1.54%
redis,redis_small_112_LRANGE_500,0.93%,-2.03%,0.42%,0.82%,0.93%,0.92%,0.90%,0.88%,-0.58%,-1.31%,-1.74%,-1.88%
redis,redis_small_112_LRANGE_300,0.90%,-0.83%,0.45%,1.00%,0.90%,0.89%,0.87%,0.84%,-0.32%,-0.58%,-0.73%,-0.78%
redis,redis_small_112_LRANGE_100,1.92%,-1.90%,0.35%,0.76%,1.87%,1.81%,1.64%,1.37%,-0.94%,-1.43%,-1.71%,-1.81%
redis,redis_small_112_LPUSH,3.37%,-3.11%,0.20%,1.27%,3.16%,2.96%,2.34%,1.35%,-3.06%,-3.09%,-3.10%,-3.11%
redis,redis_small_112_LPOP,-1.03%,-5.65%,-2.34%,-1.72%,-1.03%,-1.04%,-1.05%,-1.07%,-4.21%,-4.94%,-5.37%,-5.51%
redis,redis_small_112_INCR,-2.81%,-1.42%,-0.47%,3.32%,-2.78%,-2.75%,-2.67%,-2.52%,-0.64%,-1.03%,-1.26%,-1.34%
redis,redis_small_112_GET,-2.98%,-3.29%,-3.86%,-3.94%,-3.12%,-3.26%,-3.69%,-4.39%,-3.04%,-3.17%,-3.24%,-3.27%
redis,redis_medium_max_SPOP,-2.28%,-3.66%,-2.65%,-2.30%,-2.32%,-2.35%,-2.44%,-2.60%,-2.97%,-3.32%,-3.53%,-3.59%
redis,redis_medium_max_SET,-3.84%,-4.27%,-3.92%,-5.13%,-3.74%,-3.65%,-3.35%,-2.86%,-4.52%,-4.39%,-4.32%,-4.30%
redis,redis_medium_max_SADD,-4.45%,-1.93%,-3.15%,-2.91%,-4.42%,-4.39%,-4.30%,-4.16%,-2.26%,-2.09%,-2.00%,-1.96%
redis,redis_medium_max_PING_INLINE,-2.88%,-1.23%,-1.53%,-1.31%,-2.80%,-2.73%,-2.49%,-2.11%,-1.25%,-1.24%,-1.23%,-1.23%
redis,redis_medium_max_PING_BULK,-0.31%,-4.41%,-2.54%,-2.76%,-0.32%,-0.33%,-0.36%,-0.41%,-4.42%,-4.41%,-4.41%,-4.41%
redis,redis_medium_max_MSET_10,-3.62%,-2.27%,-2.87%,-2.69%,-3.62%,-3.61%,-3.61%,-3.59%,-2.25%,-2.26%,-2.27%,-2.27%
redis,redis_medium_max_LRANGE_600,2.77%,-0.29%,1.48%,1.50%,2.73%,2.69%,2.57%,2.37%,0.50%,0.10%,-0.14%,-0.22%
redis,redis_medium_max_LRANGE_500,4.66%,2.61%,2.76%,1.85%,4.59%,4.51%,4.28%,3.89%,2.37%,2.49%,2.56%,2.59%
redis,redis_medium_max_LRANGE_300,11.72%,2.54%,5.29%,2.93%,11.53%,11.35%,10.79%,9.87%,2.60%,2.57%,2.55%,2.54%
redis,redis_medium_max_LRANGE_100,2.80%,-0.61%,1.35%,1.88%,2.76%,2.73%,2.62%,2.45%,-0.04%,-0.33%,-0.50%,-0.55%
redis,redis_medium_max_LPUSH,-2.47%,-2.37%,-2.48%,-2.89%,-2.49%,-2.52%,-2.60%,-2.73%,-2.18%,-2.27%,-2.33%,-2.35%
redis,redis_medium_max_LPOP,-0.62%,-3.71%,-3.09%,-3.65%,-0.74%,-0.85%,-1.19%,-1.76%,-3.81%,-3.76%,-3.73%,-3.72%
redis,redis_medium_max_INCR,-3.77%,-5.70%,-4.22%,-3.46%,-3.76%,-3.75%,-3.72%,-3.67%,-5.25%,-5.48%,-5.61%,-5.65%
redis,redis_medium_max_GET,-2.94%,-2.13%,-3.10%,-4.47%,-2.96%,-2.97%,-3.01%,-3.07%,-2.36%,-2.25%,-2.18%,-2.16%
redis,redis_medium_112_SPOP,-2.28%,-3.66%,-2.65%,-2.30%,-2.32%,-2.35%,-2.44%,-2.60%,-2.97%,-3.32%,-3.53%,-3.59%
redis,redis_medium_112_SET,-3.84%,-4.27%,-3.92%,-5.13%,-3.74%,-3.65%,-3.35%,-2.86%,-4.52%,-4.39%,-4.32%,-4.30%
redis,redis_medium_112_SADD,-4.45%,-1.93%,-3.15%,-2.91%,-4.42%,-4.39%,-4.30%,-4.16%,-2.26%,-2.09%,-2.00%,-1.96%
redis,redis_medium_112_PING_INLINE,-2.88%,-1.23%,-1.53%,-1.31%,-2.80%,-2.73%,-2.49%,-2.11%,-1.25%,-1.24%,-1.23%,-1.23%
redis,redis_medium_112_PING_BULK,-0.31%,-4.41%,-2.54%,-2.76%,-0.32%,-0.33%,-0.36%,-0.41%,-4.42%,-4.41%,-4.41%,-4.41%
redis,redis_medium_112_MSET_10,-3.62%,-2.27%,-2.87%,-2.69%,-3.62%,-3.61%,-3.61%,-3.59%,-2.25%,-2.26%,-2.27%,-2.27%
redis,redis_medium_112_LRANGE_600,2.77%,-0.29%,1.48%,1.50%,2.73%,2.69%,2.57%,2.37%,0.50%,0.10%,-0.14%,-0.22%
redis,redis_medium_112_LRANGE_500,4.66%,2.61%,2.76%,1.85%,4.59%,4.51%,4.28%,3.89%,2.37%,2.49%,2.56%,2.59%
redis,redis_medium_112_LRANGE_300,11.72%,2.54%,5.29%,2.93%,11.53%,11.35%,10.79%,9.87%,2.60%,2.57%,2.55%,2.54%
redis,redis_medium_112_LRANGE_100,2.80%,-0.61%,1.35%,1.88%,2.76%,2.73%,2.62%,2.45%,-0.04%,-0.33%,-0.50%,-0.55%
redis,redis_medium_112_LPUSH,-2.47%,-2.37%,-2.48%,-2.89%,-2.49%,-2.52%,-2.60%,-2.73%,-2.18%,-2.27%,-2.33%,-2.35%
redis,redis_medium_112_LPOP,-0.62%,-3.71%,-3.09%,-3.65%,-0.74%,-0.85%,-1.19%,-1.76%,-3.81%,-3.76%,-3.73%,-3.72%
redis,redis_medium_112_INCR,-3.77%,-5.70%,-4.22%,-3.46%,-3.76%,-3.75%,-3.72%,-3.67%,-5.25%,-5.48%,-5.61%,-5.65%
redis,redis_medium_112_GET,-2.94%,-2.13%,-3.10%,-4.47%,-2.96%,-2.97%,-3.01%,-3.07%,-2.36%,-2.25%,-2.18%,-2.16%
redis,SUnreclaim,58.05%,31.45%,33.74%,34.09%,35.41%,29.24%,30.39%,31.98%,34.10%,33.78%,33.18%,32.48%
redis,SReclaimable,6.14%,7.38%,6.49%,6.88%,4.97%,4.78%,5.98%,6.16%,6.92%,6.71%,7.32%,7.13%
,,,,,,,,,,,,,
benchmark_name,metric_name,min,max,mean,median,p1,p2,p5,p10,p90,p95,p98,p99
stream,stream_single_triad,2.12%,1.44%,1.55%,1.10%,2.10%,2.08%,2.02%,1.92%,1.37%,1.40%,1.42%,1.43%
stream,stream_single_copy,2.05%,1.59%,1.79%,1.74%,2.04%,2.04%,2.02%,1.99%,1.62%,1.60%,1.59%,1.59%
stream,stream_single_cale,2.36%,0.73%,1.51%,1.46%,2.35%,2.33%,2.27%,2.18%,0.87%,0.80%,0.76%,0.75%
stream,stream_single_add,1.82%,1.18%,1.41%,1.24%,1.81%,1.80%,1.76%,1.70%,1.19%,1.19%,1.18%,1.18%
stream,stream_omp_nodes_triad,2.26%,0.36%,1.09%,0.68%,2.22%,2.19%,2.10%,1.94%,0.42%,0.39%,0.37%,0.37%
stream,stream_omp_nodes_spread_triad,0.63%,0.52%,0.58%,0.59%,0.62%,0.62%,0.62%,0.62%,0.54%,0.53%,0.53%,0.53%
stream,stream_omp_nodes_spread_copy,1.15%,1.29%,1.18%,1.08%,1.15%,1.15%,1.15%,1.14%,1.25%,1.27%,1.28%,1.29%
stream,stream_omp_nodes_spread_cale,1.49%,1.56%,1.50%,1.43%,1.49%,1.49%,1.49%,1.48%,1.54%,1.55%,1.56%,1.56%
stream,stream_omp_nodes_spread_add,0.88%,0.61%,0.79%,0.88%,0.88%,0.88%,0.88%,0.88%,0.67%,0.64%,0.63%,0.62%
stream,stream_omp_nodes_copy,2.13%,0.35%,0.99%,0.53%,2.10%,2.07%,1.97%,1.81%,0.39%,0.37%,0.36%,0.36%
stream,stream_omp_nodes_cale,2.75%,0.72%,1.44%,0.87%,2.71%,2.68%,2.56%,2.37%,0.75%,0.73%,0.72%,0.72%
stream,stream_omp_nodes_add,2.10%,0.53%,1.06%,0.56%,2.07%,2.04%,1.94%,1.79%,0.54%,0.54%,0.54%,0.54%
stream,stream_omp_llcs_triad,1.24%,0.79%,1.14%,1.40%,1.24%,1.25%,1.26%,1.27%,0.91%,0.85%,0.82%,0.80%
stream,stream_omp_llcs_spread_triad,0.65%,0.15%,0.34%,0.23%,0.64%,0.63%,0.61%,0.57%,0.16%,0.15%,0.15%,0.15%
stream,stream_omp_llcs_spread_copy,1.04%,0.92%,0.96%,0.92%,1.04%,1.04%,1.03%,1.02%,0.92%,0.92%,0.92%,0.92%
stream,stream_omp_llcs_spread_cale,0.95%,0.81%,0.84%,0.75%,0.95%,0.94%,0.93%,0.91%,0.80%,0.81%,0.81%,0.81%
stream,stream_omp_llcs_spread_add,0.66%,0.46%,0.55%,0.53%,0.65%,0.65%,0.64%,0.63%,0.47%,0.46%,0.46%,0.46%
stream,stream_omp_llcs_copy,2.16%,0.75%,1.45%,1.44%,2.15%,2.14%,2.09%,2.02%,0.89%,0.82%,0.78%,0.77%
stream,stream_omp_llcs_cale,1.69%,0.58%,1.26%,1.52%,1.68%,1.68%,1.67%,1.65%,0.77%,0.67%,0.62%,0.60%
stream,stream_omp_llcs_add,0.78%,0.82%,0.91%,1.12%,0.78%,0.79%,0.81%,0.85%,0.88%,0.85%,0.84%,0.83%
stream,SUnreclaim,64.35%,27.31%,28.12%,27.21%,51.76%,46.02%,32.05%,26.48%,27.64%,27.63%,27.49%,27.49%
stream,SReclaimable,8.62%,8.07%,7.69%,7.27%,10.02%,10.99%,9.02%,7.91%,7.79%,7.91%,8.11%,8.07%
,,,,,,,,,,,,,
benchmark_name,metric_name,min,max,mean,median,p1,p2,p5,p10,p90,p95,p98,p99
netpipe,netpipe_tput_min,-4.45%,-3.66%,-2.89%,-0.61%,-4.37%,-4.29%,-4.05%,-3.65%,-3.07%,-3.37%,-3.54%,-3.60%
netpipe,netpipe_tput_max,-18.12%,0.26%,-6.17%,-0.70%,-17.77%,-17.42%,-16.37%,-14.62%,0.07%,0.16%,0.22%,0.24%
netpipe,netpipe_tput_99,0.03%,-4.13%,-1.54%,-0.33%,0.03%,0.02%,0.00%,-0.04%,-3.40%,-3.77%,-3.99%,-4.06%
netpipe,netpipe_tput_98307,-5.31%,-1.60%,-5.12%,-8.66%,-5.38%,-5.45%,-5.67%,-6.02%,-2.95%,-2.27%,-1.87%,-1.73%
netpipe,netpipe_tput_98304,-5.91%,1.09%,-4.28%,-8.23%,-5.96%,-6.01%,-6.15%,-6.39%,-0.75%,0.17%,0.72%,0.90%
netpipe,netpipe_tput_98301,-3.84%,1.57%,-3.92%,-9.65%,-3.96%,-4.09%,-4.47%,-5.08%,-0.62%,0.48%,1.13%,1.35%
netpipe,netpipe_tput_96,-1.44%,-3.92%,-1.79%,0.10%,-1.41%,-1.37%,-1.28%,-1.12%,-3.15%,-3.53%,-3.77%,-3.84%
netpipe,netpipe_tput_93,-1.90%,-4.10%,-1.76%,0.83%,-1.85%,-1.79%,-1.62%,-1.34%,-3.15%,-3.63%,-3.91%,-4.00%
netpipe,netpipe_tput_8388611,-18.12%,0.26%,-6.17%,-0.70%,-17.77%,-17.42%,-16.37%,-14.62%,0.07%,0.16%,0.22%,0.24%
netpipe,netpipe_tput_8388608,-17.77%,0.19%,-6.14%,-0.87%,-17.43%,-17.09%,-16.08%,-14.39%,-0.03%,0.08%,0.14%,0.17%
netpipe,netpipe_tput_8388605,-16.14%,0.06%,-5.57%,-0.65%,-15.83%,-15.52%,-14.59%,-13.04%,-0.08%,-0.01%,0.03%,0.04%
netpipe,netpipe_tput_8195,-3.86%,-4.03%,-3.50%,-2.58%,-3.83%,-3.80%,-3.73%,-3.60%,-3.75%,-3.89%,-3.97%,-4.00%
netpipe,netpipe_tput_8192,-2.07%,-3.15%,-2.86%,-3.33%,-2.09%,-2.12%,-2.20%,-2.33%,-3.18%,-3.17%,-3.16%,-3.15%
netpipe,netpipe_tput_8189,-1.27%,-7.65%,-4.44%,-4.03%,-1.33%,-1.39%,-1.56%,-1.84%,-6.96%,-7.31%,-7.51%,-7.58%
netpipe,netpipe_tput_8,0.10%,-4.44%,-1.63%,-0.35%,0.09%,0.08%,0.05%,0.01%,-3.66%,-4.05%,-4.29%,-4.37%
netpipe,netpipe_tput_786435,-9.95%,-0.39%,-4.05%,-1.96%,-9.78%,-9.62%,-9.13%,-8.32%,-0.70%,-0.55%,-0.46%,-0.42%
netpipe,netpipe_tput_786432,-9.82%,-1.61%,-4.07%,-0.91%,-9.64%,-9.46%,-8.91%,-8.01%,-1.47%,-1.54%,-1.58%,-1.59%
netpipe,netpipe_tput_786429,-11.18%,-0.71%,-4.11%,-0.49%,-10.96%,-10.75%,-10.11%,-9.04%,-0.67%,-0.69%,-0.70%,-0.71%
netpipe,netpipe_tput_771,1.27%,-5.66%,-2.31%,-2.08%,1.20%,1.13%,0.91%,0.55%,-4.97%,-5.32%,-5.52%,-5.59%
netpipe,netpipe_tput_768,0.84%,-4.66%,-2.17%,-2.32%,0.77%,0.70%,0.50%,0.16%,-4.21%,-4.44%,-4.57%,-4.62%
netpipe,netpipe_tput_765,1.75%,-6.14%,-2.05%,-1.16%,1.68%,1.62%,1.43%,1.12%,-5.19%,-5.67%,-5.96%,-6.05%
netpipe,netpipe_tput_67,-0.10%,-3.45%,-0.92%,0.96%,-0.08%,-0.06%,0.01%,0.12%,-2.60%,-3.03%,-3.28%,-3.37%
netpipe,netpipe_tput_65539,-0.80%,-0.81%,-0.66%,-0.34%,-0.79%,-0.78%,-0.75%,-0.71%,-0.73%,-0.77%,-0.79%,-0.80%
netpipe,netpipe_tput_65536,-0.44%,10.62%,3.55%,-0.18%,-0.44%,-0.43%,-0.42%,-0.39%,8.58%,9.60%,10.21%,10.42%
netpipe,netpipe_tput_65533,0.38%,1.90%,-0.36%,-3.47%,0.29%,0.20%,-0.05%,-0.47%,0.89%,1.40%,1.70%,1.80%
netpipe,netpipe_tput_64,1.29%,-3.13%,-0.53%,0.46%,1.27%,1.25%,1.20%,1.12%,-2.44%,-2.79%,-2.99%,-3.06%
netpipe,netpipe_tput_6291459,-17.62%,0.24%,-6.08%,-0.90%,-17.28%,-16.95%,-15.94%,-14.27%,0.01%,0.12%,0.19%,0.22%
netpipe,netpipe_tput_6291456,-17.14%,0.01%,-5.94%,-0.70%,-16.81%,-16.48%,-15.49%,-13.85%,-0.13%,-0.06%,-0.02%,0.00%
netpipe,netpipe_tput_6291453,-17.30%,-0.15%,-6.06%,-0.76%,-16.96%,-16.63%,-15.64%,-13.98%,-0.27%,-0.21%,-0.18%,-0.16%
netpipe,netpipe_tput_6147,0.50%,-6.35%,-2.83%,-2.30%,0.44%,0.38%,0.21%,-0.07%,-5.58%,-5.97%,-6.20%,-6.28%
netpipe,netpipe_tput_6144,-0.05%,-8.11%,-3.46%,-1.72%,-0.08%,-0.12%,-0.22%,-0.39%,-6.92%,-7.52%,-7.88%,-7.99%
netpipe,netpipe_tput_6141,0.88%,-6.80%,-2.94%,-2.50%,0.81%,0.74%,0.53%,0.18%,-5.98%,-6.39%,-6.64%,-6.72%
netpipe,netpipe_tput_61,1.11%,-3.31%,-0.39%,1.26%,1.12%,1.12%,1.13%,1.14%,-2.43%,-2.87%,-3.13%,-3.22%
netpipe,netpipe_tput_6,0.42%,-4.76%,-1.51%,0.04%,0.41%,0.40%,0.38%,0.34%,-3.84%,-4.30%,-4.57%,-4.67%
netpipe,netpipe_tput_524291,-9.87%,-0.25%,-3.34%,0.06%,-9.67%,-9.47%,-8.87%,-7.88%,-0.19%,-0.22%,-0.24%,-0.24%
netpipe,netpipe_tput_524288,-9.21%,-0.35%,-3.02%,0.47%,-9.02%,-8.82%,-8.24%,-7.27%,-0.19%,-0.27%,-0.32%,-0.34%
netpipe,netpipe_tput_524285,-9.33%,0.32%,-3.19%,-0.59%,-9.16%,-8.99%,-8.46%,-7.59%,0.14%,0.23%,0.29%,0.30%
netpipe,netpipe_tput_515,1.31%,-5.42%,-2.04%,-1.57%,1.25%,1.19%,1.00%,0.70%,-4.68%,-5.05%,-5.28%,-5.35%
netpipe,netpipe_tput_512,-0.11%,-4.91%,-2.34%,-1.75%,-0.15%,-0.18%,-0.29%,-0.46%,-4.30%,-4.60%,-4.78%,-4.84%
netpipe,netpipe_tput_51,0.97%,-3.60%,-0.78%,0.53%,0.96%,0.95%,0.92%,0.88%,-2.81%,-3.21%,-3.44%,-3.52%
netpipe,netpipe_tput_509,0.93%,-5.86%,-2.57%,-2.36%,0.86%,0.79%,0.57%,0.23%,-5.18%,-5.52%,-5.73%,-5.79%
netpipe,netpipe_tput_49155,-3.18%,5.26%,1.32%,1.67%,-3.08%,-2.98%,-2.68%,-2.18%,4.55%,4.91%,5.12%,5.19%
netpipe,netpipe_tput_49152,0.06%,-4.91%,-1.99%,-0.35%,0.06%,0.05%,0.02%,-0.02%,-4.16%,-4.54%,-4.77%,-4.84%
netpipe,netpipe_tput_49149,6.45%,-4.99%,0.02%,0.38%,6.31%,6.17%,5.76%,5.09%,-4.05%,-4.53%,-4.81%,-4.90%
netpipe,netpipe_tput_48,0.58%,-3.38%,-0.76%,0.71%,0.58%,0.58%,0.59%,0.61%,-2.60%,-2.99%,-3.23%,-3.30%
netpipe,netpipe_tput_45,0.81%,-3.92%,-0.96%,0.45%,0.80%,0.79%,0.77%,0.73%,-3.08%,-3.50%,-3.76%,-3.84%
netpipe,netpipe_tput_4194307,-14.94%,-0.46%,-5.43%,-0.96%,-14.66%,-14.38%,-13.53%,-12.13%,-0.56%,-0.51%,-0.48%,-0.47%
netpipe,netpipe_tput_4194304,-15.12%,-0.60%,-5.45%,-0.69%,-14.83%,-14.54%,-13.67%,-12.22%,-0.62%,-0.61%,-0.60%,-0.60%
netpipe,netpipe_tput_4194301,-15.18%,-0.45%,-5.55%,-1.09%,-14.90%,-14.62%,-13.77%,-12.35%,-0.58%,-0.51%,-0.47%,-0.46%
netpipe,netpipe_tput_4099,-0.58%,-4.00%,-2.43%,-2.57%,-0.63%,-0.67%,-0.79%,-1.00%,-3.72%,-3.86%,-3.94%,-3.97%
netpipe,netpipe_tput_4096,-0.16%,-2.24%,-1.12%,-0.91%,-0.17%,-0.19%,-0.23%,-0.31%,-1.98%,-2.11%,-2.19%,-2.21%
netpipe,netpipe_tput_4093,1.20%,-3.75%,-1.37%,-1.37%,1.14%,1.09%,0.93%,0.67%,-3.29%,-3.52%,-3.66%,-3.71%
netpipe,netpipe_tput_4,1.82%,-3.71%,-1.09%,-1.11%,1.76%,1.70%,1.51%,1.21%,-3.21%,-3.46%,-3.61%,-3.66%
netpipe,netpipe_tput_393219,-9.08%,-1.41%,-3.93%,-1.36%,-8.92%,-8.77%,-8.30%,-7.53%,-1.40%,-1.40%,-1.41%,-1.41%
netpipe,netpipe_tput_393216,-8.79%,-0.84%,-3.74%,-1.63%,-8.65%,-8.50%,-8.07%,-7.35%,-1.00%,-0.92%,-0.87%,-0.86%
netpipe,netpipe_tput_393213,-9.38%,-0.01%,-4.18%,-3.18%,-9.25%,-9.13%,-8.76%,-8.13%,-0.64%,-0.33%,-0.14%,-0.08%
netpipe,netpipe_tput_387,0.50%,-5.04%,-2.41%,-2.40%,0.44%,0.37%,0.19%,-0.11%,-4.53%,-4.79%,-4.94%,-4.99%
netpipe,netpipe_tput_384,1.46%,-5.58%,-1.89%,-1.14%,1.41%,1.35%,1.19%,0.91%,-4.73%,-5.16%,-5.42%,-5.50%
netpipe,netpipe_tput_381,0.97%,-4.33%,-1.84%,-1.87%,0.91%,0.85%,0.67%,0.37%,-3.86%,-4.10%,-4.24%,-4.29%
netpipe,netpipe_tput_35,1.27%,-4.42%,-1.30%,-0.47%,1.24%,1.20%,1.09%,0.91%,-3.66%,-4.04%,-4.27%,-4.34%
netpipe,netpipe_tput_32771,-0.82%,-8.90%,-5.74%,-6.91%,-0.95%,-1.08%,-1.47%,-2.11%,-8.53%,-8.72%,-8.83%,-8.86%
netpipe,netpipe_tput_32768,-2.27%,-7.63%,-5.68%,-6.79%,-2.37%,-2.46%,-2.74%,-3.21%,-7.47%,-7.55%,-7.60%,-7.62%
netpipe,netpipe_tput_32765,-2.38%,-7.98%,-6.16%,-7.77%,-2.50%,-2.61%,-2.95%,-3.51%,-7.94%,-7.96%,-7.98%,-7.98%
netpipe,netpipe_tput_32,1.72%,-3.67%,-1.09%,-1.05%,1.66%,1.60%,1.42%,1.14%,-3.16%,-3.42%,-3.57%,-3.62%
netpipe,netpipe_tput_3145731,-15.41%,-0.30%,-5.51%,-0.86%,-15.12%,-14.83%,-13.95%,-12.50%,-0.41%,-0.35%,-0.32%,-0.31%
netpipe,netpipe_tput_3145728,-14.82%,-0.37%,-5.17%,-0.36%,-14.53%,-14.24%,-13.37%,-11.93%,-0.37%,-0.37%,-0.37%,-0.37%
netpipe,netpipe_tput_3145725,-13.96%,-0.34%,-4.89%,-0.45%,-13.69%,-13.42%,-12.60%,-11.25%,-0.36%,-0.35%,-0.34%,-0.34%
netpipe,netpipe_tput_3075,-0.41%,-1.51%,-1.45%,-2.39%,-0.45%,-0.49%,-0.61%,-0.82%,-1.68%,-1.60%,-1.55%,-1.53%
netpipe,netpipe_tput_3072,-1.07%,-0.66%,-2.18%,-4.75%,-1.15%,-1.23%,-1.46%,-1.84%,-1.47%,-1.06%,-0.82%,-0.74%
netpipe,netpipe_tput_3069,-0.13%,-2.46%,-2.41%,-4.51%,-0.22%,-0.31%,-0.59%,-1.04%,-2.86%,-2.66%,-2.54%,-2.50%
netpipe,netpipe_tput_3,1.04%,-3.84%,-1.55%,-1.62%,0.98%,0.93%,0.76%,0.48%,-3.41%,-3.63%,-3.76%,-3.80%
netpipe,netpipe_tput_29,1.23%,-3.98%,-1.16%,-0.49%,1.20%,1.16%,1.05%,0.88%,-3.30%,-3.64%,-3.84%,-3.91%
netpipe,netpipe_tput_27,0.37%,-3.43%,-1.04%,0.11%,0.36%,0.36%,0.34%,0.31%,-2.74%,-3.09%,-3.29%,-3.36%
netpipe,netpipe_tput_262147,-1.91%,-0.29%,-2.07%,-4.01%,-1.96%,-2.01%,-2.15%,-2.37%,-1.03%,-0.66%,-0.44%,-0.37%
netpipe,netpipe_tput_262144,-4.51%,-2.75%,-4.37%,-5.89%,-4.54%,-4.57%,-4.66%,-4.81%,-3.37%,-3.06%,-2.88%,-2.81%
netpipe,netpipe_tput_262141,-3.98%,-1.56%,-3.95%,-6.35%,-4.03%,-4.08%,-4.24%,-4.50%,-2.51%,-2.03%,-1.75%,-1.66%
netpipe,netpipe_tput_259,0.63%,-3.98%,-1.38%,-0.56%,0.60%,0.58%,0.50%,0.38%,-3.32%,-3.65%,-3.85%,-3.92%
netpipe,netpipe_tput_256,0.85%,-3.38%,-1.03%,-0.31%,0.83%,0.80%,0.73%,0.61%,-2.79%,-3.09%,-3.26%,-3.32%
netpipe,netpipe_tput_253,-0.12%,-3.47%,-1.52%,-0.82%,-0.14%,-0.15%,-0.19%,-0.27%,-2.95%,-3.21%,-3.36%,-3.41%
netpipe,netpipe_tput_24579,-2.46%,-7.33%,-5.68%,-6.96%,-2.55%,-2.65%,-2.93%,-3.40%,-7.26%,-7.30%,-7.32%,-7.32%
netpipe,netpipe_tput_24576,-2.79%,-7.09%,-5.69%,-6.92%,-2.88%,-2.97%,-3.23%,-3.66%,-7.06%,-7.08%,-7.08%,-7.09%
netpipe,netpipe_tput_24573,-1.44%,-6.43%,-5.76%,-9.01%,-1.60%,-1.77%,-2.26%,-3.06%,-6.93%,-6.68%,-6.53%,-6.48%
netpipe,netpipe_tput_24,1.16%,-3.42%,-0.76%,0.20%,1.14%,1.12%,1.06%,0.96%,-2.72%,-3.07%,-3.28%,-3.35%
netpipe,netpipe_tput_21,0.78%,-3.82%,-0.71%,1.15%,0.79%,0.79%,0.82%,0.85%,-2.87%,-3.35%,-3.63%,-3.73%
netpipe,netpipe_tput_2097155,-12.92%,-0.74%,-4.63%,-0.28%,-12.67%,-12.42%,-11.66%,-10.39%,-0.65%,-0.69%,-0.72%,-0.73%
netpipe,netpipe_tput_2097152,-13.84%,-0.82%,-4.98%,-0.35%,-13.57%,-13.30%,-12.49%,-11.13%,-0.72%,-0.77%,-0.80%,-0.81%
netpipe,netpipe_tput_2097149,-13.92%,-0.78%,-4.98%,-0.30%,-13.65%,-13.38%,-12.56%,-11.20%,-0.68%,-0.73%,-0.76%,-0.77%
netpipe,netpipe_tput_2051,-1.84%,-1.52%,-2.29%,-3.49%,-1.88%,-1.91%,-2.01%,-2.18%,-1.91%,-1.71%,-1.60%,-1.56%
netpipe,netpipe_tput_2048,-1.83%,-1.93%,-2.75%,-4.47%,-1.88%,-1.94%,-2.10%,-2.37%,-2.43%,-2.18%,-2.03%,-1.98%
netpipe,netpipe_tput_2045,-1.40%,-2.10%,-1.29%,-0.35%,-1.38%,-1.36%,-1.29%,-1.19%,-1.76%,-1.93%,-2.03%,-2.07%
netpipe,netpipe_tput_2,1.63%,-2.89%,-0.87%,-1.12%,1.57%,1.51%,1.34%,1.05%,-2.55%,-2.72%,-2.82%,-2.85%
netpipe,netpipe_tput_196611,0.04%,-10.09%,-8.12%,-12.97%,-0.27%,-0.57%,-1.46%,-2.90%,-10.63%,-10.36%,-10.19%,-10.14%
netpipe,netpipe_tput_196608,0.66%,-8.88%,-6.42%,-9.92%,0.42%,0.18%,-0.53%,-1.68%,-9.07%,-8.98%,-8.92%,-8.90%
netpipe,netpipe_tput_196605,0.53%,-8.27%,-6.02%,-9.29%,0.31%,0.09%,-0.57%,-1.64%,-8.46%,-8.36%,-8.31%,-8.29%
netpipe,netpipe_tput_195,1.35%,-4.33%,-1.43%,-1.02%,1.30%,1.25%,1.10%,0.85%,-3.69%,-4.01%,-4.20%,-4.27%
netpipe,netpipe_tput_192,1.86%,-4.31%,-1.25%,-0.95%,1.80%,1.74%,1.56%,1.27%,-3.66%,-3.99%,-4.18%,-4.25%
netpipe,netpipe_tput_19,0.00%,-3.27%,-1.30%,-0.50%,-0.01%,-0.02%,-0.06%,-0.11%,-2.74%,-3.01%,-3.17%,-3.22%
netpipe,netpipe_tput_189,0.32%,-4.41%,-1.65%,-0.60%,0.30%,0.28%,0.22%,0.13%,-3.68%,-4.05%,-4.27%,-4.34%
netpipe,netpipe_tput_16387,-2.47%,-4.89%,-4.52%,-6.05%,-2.54%,-2.62%,-2.85%,-3.22%,-5.11%,-5.00%,-4.93%,-4.91%
netpipe,netpipe_tput_16384,-3.69%,-3.22%,-4.08%,-5.33%,-3.72%,-3.76%,-3.86%,-4.03%,-3.63%,-3.43%,-3.31%,-3.26%
netpipe,netpipe_tput_16381,-1.60%,-3.77%,-3.65%,-5.45%,-1.68%,-1.76%,-2.00%,-2.40%,-4.10%,-3.94%,-3.84%,-3.81%
netpipe,netpipe_tput_16,-1.67%,-3.18%,-1.83%,-0.56%,-1.65%,-1.62%,-1.56%,-1.44%,-2.68%,-2.93%,-3.08%,-3.13%
netpipe,netpipe_tput_1572867,-13.58%,-0.18%,-4.76%,-0.62%,-13.31%,-13.05%,-12.27%,-10.96%,-0.27%,-0.22%,-0.19%,-0.19%
netpipe,netpipe_tput_1572864,-13.74%,0.02%,-4.61%,-0.20%,-13.46%,-13.19%,-12.37%,-11.01%,-0.02%,0.00%,0.01%,0.02%
netpipe,netpipe_tput_1572861,-13.59%,-0.19%,-4.76%,-0.54%,-13.33%,-13.07%,-12.28%,-10.98%,-0.26%,-0.23%,-0.21%,-0.20%
netpipe,netpipe_tput_1539,-2.32%,-5.73%,-3.34%,-1.81%,-2.31%,-2.30%,-2.27%,-2.22%,-4.98%,-5.36%,-5.58%,-5.66%
netpipe,netpipe_tput_1536,-3.82%,-5.47%,-4.37%,-3.75%,-3.82%,-3.82%,-3.82%,-3.81%,-5.13%,-5.30%,-5.40%,-5.43%
netpipe,netpipe_tput_1533,-1.13%,-5.47%,-2.73%,-1.40%,-1.14%,-1.14%,-1.16%,-1.19%,-4.69%,-5.09%,-5.32%,-5.40%
netpipe,netpipe_tput_131075,2.88%,-1.90%,-2.69%,-8.44%,2.63%,2.38%,1.62%,0.40%,-3.19%,-2.54%,-2.15%,-2.03%
netpipe,netpipe_tput_131072,3.14%,-2.54%,-2.66%,-7.96%,2.89%,2.65%,1.91%,0.71%,-3.61%,-3.07%,-2.75%,-2.65%
netpipe,netpipe_tput_131069,3.26%,-2.87%,-2.65%,-7.61%,3.01%,2.77%,2.04%,0.85%,-3.79%,-3.33%,-3.05%,-2.96%
netpipe,netpipe_tput_131,-0.13%,-4.90%,-2.09%,-1.01%,-0.15%,-0.16%,-0.22%,-0.31%,-4.15%,-4.53%,-4.75%,-4.82%
netpipe,netpipe_tput_13,-0.26%,-4.46%,-1.80%,-0.49%,-0.27%,-0.27%,-0.29%,-0.31%,-3.69%,-4.08%,-4.31%,-4.38%
netpipe,netpipe_tput_128,0.54%,-4.34%,-1.43%,-0.24%,0.52%,0.51%,0.46%,0.38%,-3.55%,-3.94%,-4.18%,-4.26%
netpipe,netpipe_tput_125,0.44%,-5.09%,-1.76%,-0.34%,0.43%,0.41%,0.36%,0.28%,-4.18%,-4.64%,-4.91%,-5.00%
netpipe,netpipe_tput_12291,-0.91%,-4.05%,-3.62%,-5.73%,-1.01%,-1.12%,-1.42%,-1.93%,-4.38%,-4.21%,-4.12%,-4.08%
netpipe,netpipe_tput_12288,-1.23%,-3.60%,-2.98%,-4.01%,-1.29%,-1.35%,-1.52%,-1.81%,-3.68%,-3.64%,-3.62%,-3.61%
netpipe,netpipe_tput_12285,-0.44%,-4.48%,-3.44%,-5.22%,-0.54%,-0.64%,-0.94%,-1.44%,-4.62%,-4.55%,-4.51%,-4.49%
netpipe,netpipe_tput_12,-0.41%,-3.52%,-1.46%,-0.32%,-0.41%,-0.41%,-0.40%,-0.39%,-2.90%,-3.21%,-3.40%,-3.46%
netpipe,netpipe_tput_1048579,-12.27%,-0.12%,-4.10%,0.04%,-12.02%,-11.77%,-11.03%,-9.80%,-0.09%,-0.11%,-0.12%,-0.12%
netpipe,netpipe_tput_1048576,-12.31%,-0.23%,-4.06%,0.32%,-12.05%,-11.80%,-11.04%,-9.78%,-0.12%,-0.18%,-0.21%,-0.22%
netpipe,netpipe_tput_1048573,-12.60%,-0.50%,-4.61%,-0.80%,-12.36%,-12.12%,-11.41%,-10.23%,-0.56%,-0.53%,-0.51%,-0.50%
netpipe,netpipe_tput_1027,1.58%,-7.04%,-2.31%,-0.78%,1.53%,1.48%,1.33%,1.07%,-5.86%,-6.45%,-6.81%,-6.92%
netpipe,netpipe_tput_1024,0.70%,-6.27%,-2.29%,-0.78%,0.67%,0.64%,0.54%,0.39%,-5.23%,-5.75%,-6.06%,-6.16%
netpipe,netpipe_tput_1021,0.15%,-5.38%,-1.76%,0.36%,0.15%,0.15%,0.17%,0.19%,-4.30%,-4.84%,-5.17%,-5.27%
netpipe,netpipe_tput_1,-4.45%,-3.66%,-2.89%,-0.61%,-4.37%,-4.29%,-4.05%,-3.65%,-3.07%,-3.37%,-3.54%,-3.60%

[-- Attachment #3: slab vs slub - ARM64.csv --]
[-- Type: text/csv, Size: 43572 bytes --]

benchmark_name,metric_name,min,max,mean,median,p1,p2,p5,p10,p90,p95,p98,p99
hackbench,hackbench_thread_sockets_max,-29.81%,-29.93%,-29.80%,-29.64%,-29.81%,-29.81%,-29.83%,-29.85%,-29.79%,-29.86%,-29.90%,-29.92%
hackbench,hackbench_thread_sockets_234,-29.81%,-29.93%,-29.80%,-29.64%,-29.81%,-29.81%,-29.83%,-29.85%,-29.79%,-29.86%,-29.90%,-29.92%
hackbench,hackbench_thread_pipes_max,-1.20%,-1.58%,-0.21%,1.09%,-1.19%,-1.18%,-1.16%,-1.13%,-0.98%,-1.28%,-1.46%,-1.52%
hackbench,hackbench_thread_pipes_234,-1.20%,-1.58%,-0.21%,1.09%,-1.19%,-1.18%,-1.16%,-1.13%,-0.98%,-1.28%,-1.46%,-1.52%
hackbench,hackbench_process_sockets_max,-31.01%,-31.75%,-31.69%,-31.79%,-31.06%,-31.11%,-31.26%,-31.50%,-31.85%,-31.80%,-31.77%,-31.76%
hackbench,hackbench_process_sockets_234,-31.01%,-31.75%,-31.69%,-31.79%,-31.06%,-31.11%,-31.26%,-31.50%,-31.85%,-31.80%,-31.77%,-31.76%
hackbench,hackbench_process_pipes_max,-0.51%,-1.18%,-0.78%,-0.60%,-0.54%,-0.57%,-0.66%,-0.81%,-1.07%,-1.12%,-1.16%,-1.17%
hackbench,hackbench_process_pipes_234,-0.51%,-1.18%,-0.78%,-0.60%,-0.54%,-0.57%,-0.66%,-0.81%,-1.07%,-1.12%,-1.16%,-1.17%
hackbench,SUnreclaim,49.25%,2.90%,-1.11%,-1.34%,33.93%,22.30%,8.51%,-15.78%,-4.23%,-1.63%,0.90%,1.90%
hackbench,SReclaimable,6.38%,2.58%,-3.18%,-1.06%,1.03%,-3.53%,-10.52%,-21.80%,1.64%,2.62%,2.79%,2.69%
,,,,,,,,,,,,,
benchmark_name,metric_name,min,max,mean,median,p1,p2,p5,p10,p90,p95,p98,p99
unixbench,unixbench_syscall_max,0.64%,0.48%,0.59%,0.62%,0.64%,0.64%,0.65%,0.65%,0.49%,0.49%,0.48%,0.48%
unixbench,unixbench_syscall_1,0.64%,0.48%,0.59%,0.62%,0.64%,0.64%,0.65%,0.65%,0.49%,0.49%,0.48%,0.48%
unixbench,unixbench_spawn_max,3.35%,5.32%,3.83%,2.95%,3.35%,3.34%,3.32%,3.28%,4.94%,5.13%,5.25%,5.29%
unixbench,unixbench_spawn_1,3.35%,5.32%,3.83%,2.95%,3.35%,3.34%,3.32%,3.28%,4.94%,5.13%,5.25%,5.29%
unixbench,unixbench_pipe_max,-0.01%,-0.02%,0.00%,0.01%,0.00%,0.00%,0.00%,0.01%,-0.02%,-0.02%,-0.02%,-0.02%
unixbench,unixbench_pipe_1,-0.01%,-0.02%,0.00%,0.01%,0.00%,0.00%,0.00%,0.01%,-0.02%,-0.02%,-0.02%,-0.02%
unixbench,unixbench_execl_max,4.19%,3.23%,3.52%,3.28%,4.18%,4.16%,4.11%,4.03%,3.18%,3.20%,3.22%,3.23%
unixbench,unixbench_execl_1,4.19%,3.23%,3.52%,3.28%,4.18%,4.16%,4.11%,4.03%,3.18%,3.20%,3.22%,3.23%
unixbench,unixbench_dhry2reg_max,0.00%,-0.02%,0.03%,0.05%,0.00%,0.00%,0.00%,0.00%,0.04%,0.01%,-0.01%,-0.01%
unixbench,unixbench_dhry2reg_lbr_max,-0.03%,0.01%,0.01%,0.02%,-0.03%,-0.02%,-0.01%,0.00%,0.00%,0.00%,0.01%,0.01%
unixbench,unixbench_dhry2reg_lbr_1,-0.03%,0.01%,0.01%,0.02%,-0.03%,-0.02%,-0.01%,0.00%,0.00%,0.00%,0.01%,0.01%
unixbench,unixbench_dhry2reg_1,0.00%,-0.02%,0.03%,0.05%,0.00%,0.00%,0.00%,0.00%,0.04%,0.01%,-0.01%,-0.01%
unixbench,SUnreclaim,53.46%,13.97%,18.79%,19.80%,17.81%,17.95%,18.40%,18.73%,15.27%,15.05%,14.74%,14.64%
unixbench,SReclaimable,5.49%,3.00%,2.52%,2.62%,2.49%,2.57%,2.58%,-2.61%,2.65%,2.48%,2.27%,1.93%
,,,,,,,,,,,,,
benchmark_name,metric_name,min,max,mean,median,p1,p2,p5,p10,p90,p95,p98,p99
will-it-scale,writeseek3_scalability,-7.60%,-7.60%,-7.60%,-7.60%,-7.60%,-7.60%,-7.60%,-7.60%,-7.60%,-7.60%,-7.60%,-7.60%
will-it-scale,writeseek3_per_thread_ops,6.62%,6.62%,6.62%,6.62%,6.62%,6.62%,6.62%,6.62%,6.62%,6.62%,6.62%,6.62%
will-it-scale,writeseek3_per_process_ops,3.01%,3.01%,3.01%,3.01%,3.01%,3.01%,3.01%,3.01%,3.01%,3.01%,3.01%,3.01%
will-it-scale,writeseek2_scalability,3.99%,3.99%,3.99%,3.99%,3.99%,3.99%,3.99%,3.99%,3.99%,3.99%,3.99%,3.99%
will-it-scale,writeseek2_per_thread_ops,3.98%,3.98%,3.98%,3.98%,3.98%,3.98%,3.98%,3.98%,3.98%,3.98%,3.98%,3.98%
will-it-scale,writeseek2_per_process_ops,3.92%,3.92%,3.92%,3.92%,3.92%,3.92%,3.92%,3.92%,3.92%,3.92%,3.92%,3.92%
will-it-scale,writeseek1_scalability,0.32%,0.32%,0.32%,0.32%,0.32%,0.32%,0.32%,0.32%,0.32%,0.32%,0.32%,0.32%
will-it-scale,writeseek1_per_thread_ops,2.12%,2.12%,2.12%,2.12%,2.12%,2.12%,2.12%,2.12%,2.12%,2.12%,2.12%,2.12%
will-it-scale,writeseek1_per_process_ops,4.01%,4.01%,4.01%,4.01%,4.01%,4.01%,4.01%,4.01%,4.01%,4.01%,4.01%,4.01%
will-it-scale,write1_scalability,0.32%,0.32%,0.32%,0.32%,0.32%,0.32%,0.32%,0.32%,0.32%,0.32%,0.32%,0.32%
will-it-scale,write1_per_thread_ops,3.50%,3.50%,3.50%,3.50%,3.50%,3.50%,3.50%,3.50%,3.50%,3.50%,3.50%,3.50%
will-it-scale,write1_per_process_ops,3.13%,3.13%,3.13%,3.13%,3.13%,3.13%,3.13%,3.13%,3.13%,3.13%,3.13%,3.13%
will-it-scale,unlink2_scalability,-5.64%,-5.64%,-5.64%,-5.64%,-5.64%,-5.64%,-5.64%,-5.64%,-5.64%,-5.64%,-5.64%,-5.64%
will-it-scale,unlink2_per_thread_ops,-0.37%,-0.37%,-0.37%,-0.37%,-0.37%,-0.37%,-0.37%,-0.37%,-0.37%,-0.37%,-0.37%,-0.37%
will-it-scale,unlink2_per_process_ops,-0.06%,-0.06%,-0.06%,-0.06%,-0.06%,-0.06%,-0.06%,-0.06%,-0.06%,-0.06%,-0.06%,-0.06%
will-it-scale,unlink1_scalability,0.48%,0.48%,0.48%,0.48%,0.48%,0.48%,0.48%,0.48%,0.48%,0.48%,0.48%,0.48%
will-it-scale,unlink1_per_thread_ops,3.00%,3.00%,3.00%,3.00%,3.00%,3.00%,3.00%,3.00%,3.00%,3.00%,3.00%,3.00%
will-it-scale,unlink1_per_process_ops,3.56%,3.56%,3.56%,3.56%,3.56%,3.56%,3.56%,3.56%,3.56%,3.56%,3.56%,3.56%
will-it-scale,unix1_scalability,-2.71%,-2.71%,-2.71%,-2.71%,-2.71%,-2.71%,-2.71%,-2.71%,-2.71%,-2.71%,-2.71%,-2.71%
will-it-scale,unix1_per_thread_ops,-0.67%,-0.67%,-0.67%,-0.67%,-0.67%,-0.67%,-0.67%,-0.67%,-0.67%,-0.67%,-0.67%,-0.67%
will-it-scale,unix1_per_process_ops,3.50%,3.50%,3.50%,3.50%,3.50%,3.50%,3.50%,3.50%,3.50%,3.50%,3.50%,3.50%
will-it-scale,signal1_scalability,-1.52%,-1.52%,-1.52%,-1.52%,-1.52%,-1.52%,-1.52%,-1.52%,-1.52%,-1.52%,-1.52%,-1.52%
will-it-scale,signal1_per_thread_ops,2.44%,2.44%,2.44%,2.44%,2.44%,2.44%,2.44%,2.44%,2.44%,2.44%,2.44%,2.44%
will-it-scale,signal1_per_process_ops,2.20%,2.20%,2.20%,2.20%,2.20%,2.20%,2.20%,2.20%,2.20%,2.20%,2.20%,2.20%
will-it-scale,sched_yield_scalability,0.00%,0.00%,0.00%,0.00%,0.00%,0.00%,0.00%,0.00%,0.00%,0.00%,0.00%,0.00%
will-it-scale,sched_yield_per_thread_ops,0.40%,0.40%,0.40%,0.40%,0.40%,0.40%,0.40%,0.40%,0.40%,0.40%,0.40%,0.40%
will-it-scale,sched_yield_per_process_ops,0.39%,0.39%,0.39%,0.39%,0.39%,0.39%,0.39%,0.39%,0.39%,0.39%,0.39%,0.39%
will-it-scale,readseek3_scalability,-1.27%,-1.27%,-1.27%,-1.27%,-1.27%,-1.27%,-1.27%,-1.27%,-1.27%,-1.27%,-1.27%,-1.27%
will-it-scale,readseek3_per_thread_ops,0.42%,0.42%,0.42%,0.42%,0.42%,0.42%,0.42%,0.42%,0.42%,0.42%,0.42%,0.42%
will-it-scale,readseek3_per_process_ops,0.36%,0.36%,0.36%,0.36%,0.36%,0.36%,0.36%,0.36%,0.36%,0.36%,0.36%,0.36%
will-it-scale,readseek2_scalability,-7.01%,-7.01%,-7.01%,-7.01%,-7.01%,-7.01%,-7.01%,-7.01%,-7.01%,-7.01%,-7.01%,-7.01%
will-it-scale,readseek2_per_thread_ops,0.01%,0.01%,0.01%,0.01%,0.01%,0.01%,0.01%,0.01%,0.01%,0.01%,0.01%,0.01%
will-it-scale,readseek2_per_process_ops,-1.04%,-1.04%,-1.04%,-1.04%,-1.04%,-1.04%,-1.04%,-1.04%,-1.04%,-1.04%,-1.04%,-1.04%
will-it-scale,readseek1_scalability,-0.36%,-0.36%,-0.36%,-0.36%,-0.36%,-0.36%,-0.36%,-0.36%,-0.36%,-0.36%,-0.36%,-0.36%
will-it-scale,readseek1_per_thread_ops,-0.21%,-0.21%,-0.21%,-0.21%,-0.21%,-0.21%,-0.21%,-0.21%,-0.21%,-0.21%,-0.21%,-0.21%
will-it-scale,readseek1_per_process_ops,0.18%,0.18%,0.18%,0.18%,0.18%,0.18%,0.18%,0.18%,0.18%,0.18%,0.18%,0.18%
will-it-scale,read2_scalability,1.44%,1.44%,1.44%,1.44%,1.44%,1.44%,1.44%,1.44%,1.44%,1.44%,1.44%,1.44%
will-it-scale,read2_per_thread_ops,0.10%,0.10%,0.10%,0.10%,0.10%,0.10%,0.10%,0.10%,0.10%,0.10%,0.10%,0.10%
will-it-scale,read2_per_process_ops,2.78%,2.78%,2.78%,2.78%,2.78%,2.78%,2.78%,2.78%,2.78%,2.78%,2.78%,2.78%
will-it-scale,read1_scalability,0.95%,0.95%,0.95%,0.95%,0.95%,0.95%,0.95%,0.95%,0.95%,0.95%,0.95%,0.95%
will-it-scale,read1_per_thread_ops,0.39%,0.39%,0.39%,0.39%,0.39%,0.39%,0.39%,0.39%,0.39%,0.39%,0.39%,0.39%
will-it-scale,read1_per_process_ops,0.02%,0.02%,0.02%,0.02%,0.02%,0.02%,0.02%,0.02%,0.02%,0.02%,0.02%,0.02%
will-it-scale,pwrite3_scalability,17.89%,17.89%,17.89%,17.89%,17.89%,17.89%,17.89%,17.89%,17.89%,17.89%,17.89%,17.89%
will-it-scale,pwrite3_per_thread_ops,6.15%,6.15%,6.15%,6.15%,6.15%,6.15%,6.15%,6.15%,6.15%,6.15%,6.15%,6.15%
will-it-scale,pwrite3_per_process_ops,3.70%,3.70%,3.70%,3.70%,3.70%,3.70%,3.70%,3.70%,3.70%,3.70%,3.70%,3.70%
will-it-scale,pwrite2_scalability,-5.45%,-5.45%,-5.45%,-5.45%,-5.45%,-5.45%,-5.45%,-5.45%,-5.45%,-5.45%,-5.45%,-5.45%
will-it-scale,pwrite2_per_thread_ops,5.53%,5.53%,5.53%,5.53%,5.53%,5.53%,5.53%,5.53%,5.53%,5.53%,5.53%,5.53%
will-it-scale,pwrite2_per_process_ops,5.41%,5.41%,5.41%,5.41%,5.41%,5.41%,5.41%,5.41%,5.41%,5.41%,5.41%,5.41%
will-it-scale,pwrite1_scalability,0.72%,0.72%,0.72%,0.72%,0.72%,0.72%,0.72%,0.72%,0.72%,0.72%,0.72%,0.72%
will-it-scale,pwrite1_per_thread_ops,4.38%,4.38%,4.38%,4.38%,4.38%,4.38%,4.38%,4.38%,4.38%,4.38%,4.38%,4.38%
will-it-scale,pwrite1_per_process_ops,3.71%,3.71%,3.71%,3.71%,3.71%,3.71%,3.71%,3.71%,3.71%,3.71%,3.71%,3.71%
will-it-scale,pthread_mutex2_scalability,-0.19%,-0.19%,-0.19%,-0.19%,-0.19%,-0.19%,-0.19%,-0.19%,-0.19%,-0.19%,-0.19%,-0.19%
will-it-scale,pthread_mutex2_per_thread_ops,0.06%,0.06%,0.06%,0.06%,0.06%,0.06%,0.06%,0.06%,0.06%,0.06%,0.06%,0.06%
will-it-scale,pthread_mutex2_per_process_ops,0.04%,0.04%,0.04%,0.04%,0.04%,0.04%,0.04%,0.04%,0.04%,0.04%,0.04%,0.04%
will-it-scale,pthread_mutex1_scalability,-0.06%,-0.06%,-0.06%,-0.06%,-0.06%,-0.06%,-0.06%,-0.06%,-0.06%,-0.06%,-0.06%,-0.06%
will-it-scale,pthread_mutex1_per_thread_ops,0.15%,0.15%,0.15%,0.15%,0.15%,0.15%,0.15%,0.15%,0.15%,0.15%,0.15%,0.15%
will-it-scale,pthread_mutex1_per_process_ops,0.01%,0.01%,0.01%,0.01%,0.01%,0.01%,0.01%,0.01%,0.01%,0.01%,0.01%,0.01%
will-it-scale,pread3_scalability,1.01%,1.01%,1.01%,1.01%,1.01%,1.01%,1.01%,1.01%,1.01%,1.01%,1.01%,1.01%
will-it-scale,pread3_per_thread_ops,0.06%,0.06%,0.06%,0.06%,0.06%,0.06%,0.06%,0.06%,0.06%,0.06%,0.06%,0.06%
will-it-scale,pread3_per_process_ops,-0.39%,-0.39%,-0.39%,-0.39%,-0.39%,-0.39%,-0.39%,-0.39%,-0.39%,-0.39%,-0.39%,-0.39%
will-it-scale,pread2_scalability,-7.69%,-7.69%,-7.69%,-7.69%,-7.69%,-7.69%,-7.69%,-7.69%,-7.69%,-7.69%,-7.69%,-7.69%
will-it-scale,pread2_per_thread_ops,0.32%,0.32%,0.32%,0.32%,0.32%,0.32%,0.32%,0.32%,0.32%,0.32%,0.32%,0.32%
will-it-scale,pread2_per_process_ops,0.81%,0.81%,0.81%,0.81%,0.81%,0.81%,0.81%,0.81%,0.81%,0.81%,0.81%,0.81%
will-it-scale,pread1_scalability,-0.13%,-0.13%,-0.13%,-0.13%,-0.13%,-0.13%,-0.13%,-0.13%,-0.13%,-0.13%,-0.13%,-0.13%
will-it-scale,pread1_per_thread_ops,-0.14%,-0.14%,-0.14%,-0.14%,-0.14%,-0.14%,-0.14%,-0.14%,-0.14%,-0.14%,-0.14%,-0.14%
will-it-scale,pread1_per_process_ops,-0.50%,-0.50%,-0.50%,-0.50%,-0.50%,-0.50%,-0.50%,-0.50%,-0.50%,-0.50%,-0.50%,-0.50%
will-it-scale,posix_semaphore1_scalability,-0.45%,-0.45%,-0.45%,-0.45%,-0.45%,-0.45%,-0.45%,-0.45%,-0.45%,-0.45%,-0.45%,-0.45%
will-it-scale,posix_semaphore1_per_thread_ops,-0.06%,-0.06%,-0.06%,-0.06%,-0.06%,-0.06%,-0.06%,-0.06%,-0.06%,-0.06%,-0.06%,-0.06%
will-it-scale,posix_semaphore1_per_process_ops,0.08%,0.08%,0.08%,0.08%,0.08%,0.08%,0.08%,0.08%,0.08%,0.08%,0.08%,0.08%
will-it-scale,poll2_scalability,-2.86%,-2.86%,-2.86%,-2.86%,-2.86%,-2.86%,-2.86%,-2.86%,-2.86%,-2.86%,-2.86%,-2.86%
will-it-scale,poll2_per_thread_ops,1.53%,1.53%,1.53%,1.53%,1.53%,1.53%,1.53%,1.53%,1.53%,1.53%,1.53%,1.53%
will-it-scale,poll2_per_process_ops,6.98%,6.98%,6.98%,6.98%,6.98%,6.98%,6.98%,6.98%,6.98%,6.98%,6.98%,6.98%
will-it-scale,poll1_scalability,-0.17%,-0.17%,-0.17%,-0.17%,-0.17%,-0.17%,-0.17%,-0.17%,-0.17%,-0.17%,-0.17%,-0.17%
will-it-scale,poll1_per_thread_ops,1.86%,1.86%,1.86%,1.86%,1.86%,1.86%,1.86%,1.86%,1.86%,1.86%,1.86%,1.86%
will-it-scale,poll1_per_process_ops,1.59%,1.59%,1.59%,1.59%,1.59%,1.59%,1.59%,1.59%,1.59%,1.59%,1.59%,1.59%
will-it-scale,pipe1_scalability,0.63%,0.63%,0.63%,0.63%,0.63%,0.63%,0.63%,0.63%,0.63%,0.63%,0.63%,0.63%
will-it-scale,pipe1_per_thread_ops,-0.46%,-0.46%,-0.46%,-0.46%,-0.46%,-0.46%,-0.46%,-0.46%,-0.46%,-0.46%,-0.46%,-0.46%
will-it-scale,pipe1_per_process_ops,-0.87%,-0.87%,-0.87%,-0.87%,-0.87%,-0.87%,-0.87%,-0.87%,-0.87%,-0.87%,-0.87%,-0.87%
will-it-scale,page_fault3_scalability,0.15%,0.15%,0.15%,0.15%,0.15%,0.15%,0.15%,0.15%,0.15%,0.15%,0.15%,0.15%
will-it-scale,page_fault3_per_thread_ops,0.72%,0.72%,0.72%,0.72%,0.72%,0.72%,0.72%,0.72%,0.72%,0.72%,0.72%,0.72%
will-it-scale,page_fault3_per_process_ops,0.83%,0.83%,0.83%,0.83%,0.83%,0.83%,0.83%,0.83%,0.83%,0.83%,0.83%,0.83%
will-it-scale,page_fault2_scalability,-1.30%,-1.30%,-1.30%,-1.30%,-1.30%,-1.30%,-1.30%,-1.30%,-1.30%,-1.30%,-1.30%,-1.30%
will-it-scale,page_fault2_per_thread_ops,-2.73%,-2.73%,-2.73%,-2.73%,-2.73%,-2.73%,-2.73%,-2.73%,-2.73%,-2.73%,-2.73%,-2.73%
will-it-scale,page_fault2_per_process_ops,0.26%,0.26%,0.26%,0.26%,0.26%,0.26%,0.26%,0.26%,0.26%,0.26%,0.26%,0.26%
will-it-scale,page_fault1_scalability,1.41%,1.41%,1.41%,1.41%,1.41%,1.41%,1.41%,1.41%,1.41%,1.41%,1.41%,1.41%
will-it-scale,page_fault1_per_thread_ops,-1.25%,-1.25%,-1.25%,-1.25%,-1.25%,-1.25%,-1.25%,-1.25%,-1.25%,-1.25%,-1.25%,-1.25%
will-it-scale,page_fault1_per_process_ops,0.11%,0.11%,0.11%,0.11%,0.11%,0.11%,0.11%,0.11%,0.11%,0.11%,0.11%,0.11%
will-it-scale,open2_scalability,16.74%,16.74%,16.74%,16.74%,16.74%,16.74%,16.74%,16.74%,16.74%,16.74%,16.74%,16.74%
will-it-scale,open2_per_thread_ops,-1.79%,-1.79%,-1.79%,-1.79%,-1.79%,-1.79%,-1.79%,-1.79%,-1.79%,-1.79%,-1.79%,-1.79%
will-it-scale,open2_per_process_ops,5.30%,5.30%,5.30%,5.30%,5.30%,5.30%,5.30%,5.30%,5.30%,5.30%,5.30%,5.30%
will-it-scale,open1_scalability,15.25%,15.25%,15.25%,15.25%,15.25%,15.25%,15.25%,15.25%,15.25%,15.25%,15.25%,15.25%
will-it-scale,open1_per_thread_ops,-3.63%,-3.63%,-3.63%,-3.63%,-3.63%,-3.63%,-3.63%,-3.63%,-3.63%,-3.63%,-3.63%,-3.63%
will-it-scale,open1_per_process_ops,4.70%,4.70%,4.70%,4.70%,4.70%,4.70%,4.70%,4.70%,4.70%,4.70%,4.70%,4.70%
will-it-scale,mmap2_scalability,2.36%,2.36%,2.36%,2.36%,2.36%,2.36%,2.36%,2.36%,2.36%,2.36%,2.36%,2.36%
will-it-scale,mmap2_per_thread_ops,8.22%,8.22%,8.22%,8.22%,8.22%,8.22%,8.22%,8.22%,8.22%,8.22%,8.22%,8.22%
will-it-scale,mmap2_per_process_ops,8.51%,8.51%,8.51%,8.51%,8.51%,8.51%,8.51%,8.51%,8.51%,8.51%,8.51%,8.51%
will-it-scale,mmap1_scalability,4.44%,4.44%,4.44%,4.44%,4.44%,4.44%,4.44%,4.44%,4.44%,4.44%,4.44%,4.44%
will-it-scale,mmap1_per_thread_ops,3.72%,3.72%,3.72%,3.72%,3.72%,3.72%,3.72%,3.72%,3.72%,3.72%,3.72%,3.72%
will-it-scale,mmap1_per_process_ops,10.09%,10.09%,10.09%,10.09%,10.09%,10.09%,10.09%,10.09%,10.09%,10.09%,10.09%,10.09%
will-it-scale,malloc2_scalability,-0.04%,-0.04%,-0.04%,-0.04%,-0.04%,-0.04%,-0.04%,-0.04%,-0.04%,-0.04%,-0.04%,-0.04%
will-it-scale,malloc2_per_thread_ops,0.03%,0.03%,0.03%,0.03%,0.03%,0.03%,0.03%,0.03%,0.03%,0.03%,0.03%,0.03%
will-it-scale,malloc2_per_process_ops,-0.07%,-0.07%,-0.07%,-0.07%,-0.07%,-0.07%,-0.07%,-0.07%,-0.07%,-0.07%,-0.07%,-0.07%
will-it-scale,malloc1_scalability,0.72%,0.72%,0.72%,0.72%,0.72%,0.72%,0.72%,0.72%,0.72%,0.72%,0.72%,0.72%
will-it-scale,malloc1_per_thread_ops,1.52%,1.52%,1.52%,1.52%,1.52%,1.52%,1.52%,1.52%,1.52%,1.52%,1.52%,1.52%
will-it-scale,malloc1_per_process_ops,1.28%,1.28%,1.28%,1.28%,1.28%,1.28%,1.28%,1.28%,1.28%,1.28%,1.28%,1.28%
will-it-scale,lseek2_scalability,0.17%,0.17%,0.17%,0.17%,0.17%,0.17%,0.17%,0.17%,0.17%,0.17%,0.17%,0.17%
will-it-scale,lseek2_per_thread_ops,0.23%,0.23%,0.23%,0.23%,0.23%,0.23%,0.23%,0.23%,0.23%,0.23%,0.23%,0.23%
will-it-scale,lseek2_per_process_ops,-0.94%,-0.94%,-0.94%,-0.94%,-0.94%,-0.94%,-0.94%,-0.94%,-0.94%,-0.94%,-0.94%,-0.94%
will-it-scale,lseek1_scalability,-0.24%,-0.24%,-0.24%,-0.24%,-0.24%,-0.24%,-0.24%,-0.24%,-0.24%,-0.24%,-0.24%,-0.24%
will-it-scale,lseek1_per_thread_ops,0.43%,0.43%,0.43%,0.43%,0.43%,0.43%,0.43%,0.43%,0.43%,0.43%,0.43%,0.43%
will-it-scale,lseek1_per_process_ops,-0.68%,-0.68%,-0.68%,-0.68%,-0.68%,-0.68%,-0.68%,-0.68%,-0.68%,-0.68%,-0.68%,-0.68%
will-it-scale,lock1_scalability,3.42%,3.42%,3.42%,3.42%,3.42%,3.42%,3.42%,3.42%,3.42%,3.42%,3.42%,3.42%
will-it-scale,lock1_per_thread_ops,6.19%,6.19%,6.19%,6.19%,6.19%,6.19%,6.19%,6.19%,6.19%,6.19%,6.19%,6.19%
will-it-scale,lock1_per_process_ops,10.83%,10.83%,10.83%,10.83%,10.83%,10.83%,10.83%,10.83%,10.83%,10.83%,10.83%,10.83%
will-it-scale,getppid1_scalability,0.28%,0.28%,0.28%,0.28%,0.28%,0.28%,0.28%,0.28%,0.28%,0.28%,0.28%,0.28%
will-it-scale,getppid1_per_thread_ops,-0.80%,-0.80%,-0.80%,-0.80%,-0.80%,-0.80%,-0.80%,-0.80%,-0.80%,-0.80%,-0.80%,-0.80%
will-it-scale,getppid1_per_process_ops,-0.39%,-0.39%,-0.39%,-0.39%,-0.39%,-0.39%,-0.39%,-0.39%,-0.39%,-0.39%,-0.39%,-0.39%
will-it-scale,futex4_scalability,0.10%,0.10%,0.10%,0.10%,0.10%,0.10%,0.10%,0.10%,0.10%,0.10%,0.10%,0.10%
will-it-scale,futex4_per_thread_ops,0.35%,0.35%,0.35%,0.35%,0.35%,0.35%,0.35%,0.35%,0.35%,0.35%,0.35%,0.35%
will-it-scale,futex4_per_process_ops,0.51%,0.51%,0.51%,0.51%,0.51%,0.51%,0.51%,0.51%,0.51%,0.51%,0.51%,0.51%
will-it-scale,futex3_scalability,1.45%,1.45%,1.45%,1.45%,1.45%,1.45%,1.45%,1.45%,1.45%,1.45%,1.45%,1.45%
will-it-scale,futex3_per_thread_ops,3.53%,3.53%,3.53%,3.53%,3.53%,3.53%,3.53%,3.53%,3.53%,3.53%,3.53%,3.53%
will-it-scale,futex3_per_process_ops,0.30%,0.30%,0.30%,0.30%,0.30%,0.30%,0.30%,0.30%,0.30%,0.30%,0.30%,0.30%
will-it-scale,futex2_scalability,0.91%,0.91%,0.91%,0.91%,0.91%,0.91%,0.91%,0.91%,0.91%,0.91%,0.91%,0.91%
will-it-scale,futex2_per_thread_ops,-0.23%,-0.23%,-0.23%,-0.23%,-0.23%,-0.23%,-0.23%,-0.23%,-0.23%,-0.23%,-0.23%,-0.23%
will-it-scale,futex2_per_process_ops,0.35%,0.35%,0.35%,0.35%,0.35%,0.35%,0.35%,0.35%,0.35%,0.35%,0.35%,0.35%
will-it-scale,futex1_scalability,-1.54%,-1.54%,-1.54%,-1.54%,-1.54%,-1.54%,-1.54%,-1.54%,-1.54%,-1.54%,-1.54%,-1.54%
will-it-scale,futex1_per_thread_ops,0.01%,0.01%,0.01%,0.01%,0.01%,0.01%,0.01%,0.01%,0.01%,0.01%,0.01%,0.01%
will-it-scale,futex1_per_process_ops,0.01%,0.01%,0.01%,0.01%,0.01%,0.01%,0.01%,0.01%,0.01%,0.01%,0.01%,0.01%
will-it-scale,eventfd1_scalability,-0.23%,-0.23%,-0.23%,-0.23%,-0.23%,-0.23%,-0.23%,-0.23%,-0.23%,-0.23%,-0.23%,-0.23%
will-it-scale,eventfd1_per_thread_ops,-0.31%,-0.31%,-0.31%,-0.31%,-0.31%,-0.31%,-0.31%,-0.31%,-0.31%,-0.31%,-0.31%,-0.31%
will-it-scale,eventfd1_per_process_ops,1.83%,1.83%,1.83%,1.83%,1.83%,1.83%,1.83%,1.83%,1.83%,1.83%,1.83%,1.83%
will-it-scale,dup1_scalability,-0.71%,-0.71%,-0.71%,-0.71%,-0.71%,-0.71%,-0.71%,-0.71%,-0.71%,-0.71%,-0.71%,-0.71%
will-it-scale,dup1_per_thread_ops,1.65%,1.65%,1.65%,1.65%,1.65%,1.65%,1.65%,1.65%,1.65%,1.65%,1.65%,1.65%
will-it-scale,dup1_per_process_ops,0.93%,0.93%,0.93%,0.93%,0.93%,0.93%,0.93%,0.93%,0.93%,0.93%,0.93%,0.93%
will-it-scale,context_switch1_scalability,0.54%,0.54%,0.54%,0.54%,0.54%,0.54%,0.54%,0.54%,0.54%,0.54%,0.54%,0.54%
will-it-scale,context_switch1_per_thread_ops,-0.52%,-0.52%,-0.52%,-0.52%,-0.52%,-0.52%,-0.52%,-0.52%,-0.52%,-0.52%,-0.52%,-0.52%
will-it-scale,context_switch1_per_process_ops,0.37%,0.37%,0.37%,0.37%,0.37%,0.37%,0.37%,0.37%,0.37%,0.37%,0.37%,0.37%
will-it-scale,brk1_scalability,-0.29%,-0.29%,-0.29%,-0.29%,-0.29%,-0.29%,-0.29%,-0.29%,-0.29%,-0.29%,-0.29%,-0.29%
will-it-scale,brk1_per_thread_ops,3.36%,3.36%,3.36%,3.36%,3.36%,3.36%,3.36%,3.36%,3.36%,3.36%,3.36%,3.36%
will-it-scale,brk1_per_process_ops,4.43%,4.43%,4.43%,4.43%,4.43%,4.43%,4.43%,4.43%,4.43%,4.43%,4.43%,4.43%
will-it-scale,SUnreclaim,50.56%,-2.53%,22.78%,23.56%,28.00%,22.35%,22.42%,21.11%,24.01%,23.05%,18.74%,16.41%
will-it-scale,SReclaimable,4.16%,1.70%,3.43%,3.57%,3.43%,2.42%,1.71%,2.16%,3.73%,10.66%,3.15%,2.13%
,,,,,,,,,,,,,
benchmark_name,metric_name,min,max,mean,median,p1,p2,p5,p10,p90,p95,p98,p99
kernbench,kernbench_user_max,-0.13%,-0.04%,-0.15%,-0.26%,-0.14%,-0.14%,-0.16%,-0.18%,-0.05%,-0.05%,-0.05%,-0.05%
kernbench,kernbench_user_64,-0.13%,-0.04%,-0.15%,-0.26%,-0.14%,-0.14%,-0.16%,-0.18%,-0.05%,-0.05%,-0.05%,-0.05%
kernbench,kernbench_syst_max,-1.51%,-0.88%,-1.40%,-1.65%,-1.50%,-1.49%,-1.45%,-1.39%,-1.23%,-1.05%,-0.95%,-0.91%
kernbench,kernbench_syst_64,-1.51%,-0.88%,-1.40%,-1.65%,-1.50%,-1.49%,-1.45%,-1.39%,-1.23%,-1.05%,-0.95%,-0.91%
kernbench,kernbench_elsp_max,-1.03%,0.21%,-0.40%,-0.50%,-1.02%,-1.01%,-0.99%,-0.96%,0.18%,0.19%,0.20%,0.21%
kernbench,kernbench_elsp_64,-1.03%,0.21%,-0.40%,-0.50%,-1.02%,-1.01%,-0.99%,-0.96%,0.18%,0.19%,0.20%,0.21%
kernbench,SUnreclaim,49.59%,5.39%,9.80%,8.08%,23.65%,14.77%,-1.91%,24.56%,5.71%,5.67%,5.53%,5.49%
kernbench,SReclaimable,5.33%,1.16%,1.61%,1.32%,-2.99%,-6.25%,-14.12%,4.11%,1.06%,1.14%,1.17%,1.18%
,,,,,,,,,,,,,
benchmark_name,metric_name,min,max,mean,median,p1,p2,p5,p10,p90,p95,p98,p99
specjbb2015,specjbb2015_single_SLA_minus,25.72%,25.72%,25.72%,25.72%,25.72%,25.72%,25.72%,25.72%,25.72%,25.72%,25.72%,25.72%
specjbb2015,specjbb2015_single_SLA_maxus,2.71%,2.71%,2.71%,2.71%,2.71%,2.71%,2.71%,2.71%,2.71%,2.71%,2.71%,2.71%
specjbb2015,specjbb2015_single_SLA_75000us,3.88%,3.88%,3.88%,3.88%,3.88%,3.88%,3.88%,3.88%,3.88%,3.88%,3.88%,3.88%
specjbb2015,specjbb2015_single_SLA_50000us,4.53%,4.53%,4.53%,4.53%,4.53%,4.53%,4.53%,4.53%,4.53%,4.53%,4.53%,4.53%
specjbb2015,specjbb2015_single_SLA_25000us,18.54%,18.54%,18.54%,18.54%,18.54%,18.54%,18.54%,18.54%,18.54%,18.54%,18.54%,18.54%
specjbb2015,specjbb2015_single_SLA_10000us,25.72%,25.72%,25.72%,25.72%,25.72%,25.72%,25.72%,25.72%,25.72%,25.72%,25.72%,25.72%
specjbb2015,specjbb2015_single_SLA_100000us,2.71%,2.71%,2.71%,2.71%,2.71%,2.71%,2.71%,2.71%,2.71%,2.71%,2.71%,2.71%
specjbb2015,specjbb2015_single_Max_JOPS,1.61%,1.61%,1.61%,1.61%,1.61%,1.61%,1.61%,1.61%,1.61%,1.61%,1.61%,1.61%
specjbb2015,specjbb2015_single_Critical_JOPS,10.70%,10.70%,10.70%,10.70%,10.70%,10.70%,10.70%,10.70%,10.70%,10.70%,10.70%,10.70%
specjbb2015,SUnreclaim,50.60%,14.13%,14.61%,14.58%,14.41%,14.35%,14.32%,14.47%,14.40%,14.40%,14.38%,14.31%
specjbb2015,SReclaimable,3.97%,2.83%,2.71%,2.57%,2.39%,2.58%,7.33%,2.35%,2.29%,2.20%,2.11%,2.07%
,,,,,,,,,,,,,
benchmark_name,metric_name,min,max,mean,median,p1,p2,p5,p10,p90,p95,p98,p99
redis,redis_small_max_SPOP,-1.00%,1.19%,0.81%,1.30%,-0.95%,-0.89%,-0.72%,-0.45%,1.55%,1.37%,1.26%,1.23%
redis,redis_small_max_SET,1.53%,-0.91%,1.09%,1.81%,1.55%,1.58%,1.66%,1.79%,-0.19%,-0.55%,-0.76%,-0.84%
redis,redis_small_max_SADD,3.96%,2.38%,2.83%,3.14%,3.88%,3.80%,3.55%,3.14%,2.53%,2.46%,2.41%,2.39%
redis,redis_small_max_PING_INLINE,3.99%,3.02%,3.21%,3.10%,3.95%,3.91%,3.78%,3.58%,3.00%,3.01%,3.01%,3.02%
redis,redis_small_max_PING_BULK,1.90%,3.17%,2.86%,3.12%,1.95%,2.00%,2.16%,2.43%,3.05%,3.11%,3.14%,3.15%
redis,redis_small_max_MSET_10,0.49%,4.69%,3.20%,3.03%,0.58%,0.67%,0.94%,1.38%,4.83%,4.76%,4.72%,4.70%
redis,redis_small_max_LRANGE_600,0.08%,0.63%,0.07%,0.06%,0.07%,0.07%,0.05%,0.03%,0.24%,0.43%,0.55%,0.59%
redis,redis_small_max_LRANGE_500,0.66%,0.51%,0.40%,0.21%,0.65%,0.64%,0.60%,0.54%,0.40%,0.46%,0.49%,0.50%
redis,redis_small_max_LRANGE_300,0.43%,0.41%,0.30%,-0.19%,0.43%,0.43%,0.44%,0.44%,0.41%,0.41%,0.41%,0.41%
redis,redis_small_max_LRANGE_100,0.72%,3.83%,1.78%,1.46%,0.73%,0.74%,0.78%,0.83%,3.05%,3.44%,3.67%,3.75%
redis,redis_small_max_LPUSH,1.77%,1.60%,2.14%,2.32%,1.84%,1.91%,2.13%,2.48%,1.82%,1.71%,1.64%,1.62%
redis,redis_small_max_LPOP,2.30%,-0.53%,0.92%,1.03%,2.29%,2.27%,2.23%,2.15%,-0.32%,-0.43%,-0.49%,-0.51%
redis,redis_small_max_INCR,2.41%,4.26%,2.97%,1.55%,2.43%,2.45%,2.51%,2.62%,4.03%,4.15%,4.21%,4.23%
redis,redis_small_max_GET,2.42%,1.71%,2.45%,2.97%,2.44%,2.46%,2.50%,2.59%,1.95%,1.83%,1.76%,1.74%
redis,redis_small_64_SPOP,-1.00%,1.19%,0.81%,1.30%,-0.95%,-0.89%,-0.72%,-0.45%,1.55%,1.37%,1.26%,1.23%
redis,redis_small_64_SET,1.53%,-0.91%,1.09%,1.81%,1.55%,1.58%,1.66%,1.79%,-0.19%,-0.55%,-0.76%,-0.84%
redis,redis_small_64_SADD,3.96%,2.38%,2.83%,3.14%,3.88%,3.80%,3.55%,3.14%,2.53%,2.46%,2.41%,2.39%
redis,redis_small_64_PING_INLINE,3.99%,3.02%,3.21%,3.10%,3.95%,3.91%,3.78%,3.58%,3.00%,3.01%,3.01%,3.02%
redis,redis_small_64_PING_BULK,1.90%,3.17%,2.86%,3.12%,1.95%,2.00%,2.16%,2.43%,3.05%,3.11%,3.14%,3.15%
redis,redis_small_64_MSET_10,0.49%,4.69%,3.20%,3.03%,0.58%,0.67%,0.94%,1.38%,4.83%,4.76%,4.72%,4.70%
redis,redis_small_64_LRANGE_600,0.08%,0.63%,0.07%,0.06%,0.07%,0.07%,0.05%,0.03%,0.24%,0.43%,0.55%,0.59%
redis,redis_small_64_LRANGE_500,0.66%,0.51%,0.40%,0.21%,0.65%,0.64%,0.60%,0.54%,0.40%,0.46%,0.49%,0.50%
redis,redis_small_64_LRANGE_300,0.43%,0.41%,0.30%,-0.19%,0.43%,0.43%,0.44%,0.44%,0.41%,0.41%,0.41%,0.41%
redis,redis_small_64_LRANGE_100,0.72%,3.83%,1.78%,1.46%,0.73%,0.74%,0.78%,0.83%,3.05%,3.44%,3.67%,3.75%
redis,redis_small_64_LPUSH,1.77%,1.60%,2.14%,2.32%,1.84%,1.91%,2.13%,2.48%,1.82%,1.71%,1.64%,1.62%
redis,redis_small_64_LPOP,2.30%,-0.53%,0.92%,1.03%,2.29%,2.27%,2.23%,2.15%,-0.32%,-0.43%,-0.49%,-0.51%
redis,redis_small_64_INCR,2.41%,4.26%,2.97%,1.55%,2.43%,2.45%,2.51%,2.62%,4.03%,4.15%,4.21%,4.23%
redis,redis_small_64_GET,2.42%,1.71%,2.45%,2.97%,2.44%,2.46%,2.50%,2.59%,1.95%,1.83%,1.76%,1.74%
redis,redis_medium_max_SPOP,3.41%,3.89%,2.56%,1.75%,3.35%,3.28%,3.08%,2.75%,3.13%,3.51%,3.73%,3.81%
redis,redis_medium_max_SET,1.18%,1.64%,1.40%,1.15%,1.18%,1.18%,1.18%,1.19%,1.71%,1.67%,1.65%,1.65%
redis,redis_medium_max_SADD,1.65%,0.17%,0.88%,0.31%,1.66%,1.67%,1.70%,1.75%,0.27%,0.22%,0.19%,0.18%
redis,redis_medium_max_PING_INLINE,0.72%,1.39%,1.44%,1.84%,0.72%,0.73%,0.74%,0.75%,1.81%,1.60%,1.48%,1.44%
redis,redis_medium_max_PING_BULK,0.94%,1.13%,0.98%,0.83%,0.95%,0.96%,0.98%,1.02%,1.03%,1.08%,1.11%,1.12%
redis,redis_medium_max_MSET_10,1.82%,1.36%,1.60%,1.38%,1.80%,1.79%,1.73%,1.64%,1.65%,1.50%,1.41%,1.38%
redis,redis_medium_max_LRANGE_600,0.25%,0.19%,0.27%,0.29%,0.25%,0.26%,0.27%,0.29%,0.22%,0.20%,0.19%,0.19%
redis,redis_medium_max_LRANGE_500,0.26%,0.13%,0.25%,0.42%,0.26%,0.26%,0.26%,0.27%,0.15%,0.14%,0.13%,0.13%
redis,redis_medium_max_LRANGE_300,0.48%,0.20%,0.34%,0.31%,0.47%,0.47%,0.45%,0.43%,0.27%,0.23%,0.21%,0.20%
redis,redis_medium_max_LRANGE_100,1.96%,2.15%,2.37%,2.42%,1.97%,1.99%,2.03%,2.10%,2.48%,2.31%,2.21%,2.18%
redis,redis_medium_max_LPUSH,2.30%,2.44%,2.23%,1.98%,2.32%,2.35%,2.43%,2.56%,1.86%,2.15%,2.32%,2.38%
redis,redis_medium_max_LPOP,2.75%,1.03%,1.77%,1.98%,2.73%,2.71%,2.66%,2.56%,0.95%,0.99%,1.01%,1.02%
redis,redis_medium_max_INCR,0.15%,2.09%,0.65%,0.43%,0.14%,0.12%,0.08%,0.01%,1.55%,1.82%,1.99%,2.04%
redis,redis_medium_max_GET,1.24%,3.14%,2.00%,2.15%,1.25%,1.27%,1.31%,1.39%,2.62%,2.88%,3.04%,3.09%
redis,redis_medium_64_SPOP,3.41%,3.89%,2.56%,1.75%,3.35%,3.28%,3.08%,2.75%,3.13%,3.51%,3.73%,3.81%
redis,redis_medium_64_SET,1.18%,1.64%,1.40%,1.15%,1.18%,1.18%,1.18%,1.19%,1.71%,1.67%,1.65%,1.65%
redis,redis_medium_64_SADD,1.65%,0.17%,0.88%,0.31%,1.66%,1.67%,1.70%,1.75%,0.27%,0.22%,0.19%,0.18%
redis,redis_medium_64_PING_INLINE,0.72%,1.39%,1.44%,1.84%,0.72%,0.73%,0.74%,0.75%,1.81%,1.60%,1.48%,1.44%
redis,redis_medium_64_PING_BULK,0.94%,1.13%,0.98%,0.83%,0.95%,0.96%,0.98%,1.02%,1.03%,1.08%,1.11%,1.12%
redis,redis_medium_64_MSET_10,1.82%,1.36%,1.60%,1.38%,1.80%,1.79%,1.73%,1.64%,1.65%,1.50%,1.41%,1.38%
redis,redis_medium_64_LRANGE_600,0.25%,0.19%,0.27%,0.29%,0.25%,0.26%,0.27%,0.29%,0.22%,0.20%,0.19%,0.19%
redis,redis_medium_64_LRANGE_500,0.26%,0.13%,0.25%,0.42%,0.26%,0.26%,0.26%,0.27%,0.15%,0.14%,0.13%,0.13%
redis,redis_medium_64_LRANGE_300,0.48%,0.20%,0.34%,0.31%,0.47%,0.47%,0.45%,0.43%,0.27%,0.23%,0.21%,0.20%
redis,redis_medium_64_LRANGE_100,1.96%,2.15%,2.37%,2.42%,1.97%,1.99%,2.03%,2.10%,2.48%,2.31%,2.21%,2.18%
redis,redis_medium_64_LPUSH,2.30%,2.44%,2.23%,1.98%,2.32%,2.35%,2.43%,2.56%,1.86%,2.15%,2.32%,2.38%
redis,redis_medium_64_LPOP,2.75%,1.03%,1.77%,1.98%,2.73%,2.71%,2.66%,2.56%,0.95%,0.99%,1.01%,1.02%
redis,redis_medium_64_INCR,0.15%,2.09%,0.65%,0.43%,0.14%,0.12%,0.08%,0.01%,1.55%,1.82%,1.99%,2.04%
redis,redis_medium_64_GET,1.24%,3.14%,2.00%,2.15%,1.25%,1.27%,1.31%,1.39%,2.62%,2.88%,3.04%,3.09%
redis,SUnreclaim,51.22%,15.85%,17.56%,17.65%,22.03%,16.42%,16.40%,17.23%,17.43%,17.35%,17.10%,16.57%
redis,SReclaimable,4.79%,2.92%,3.98%,2.48%,2.49%,2.77%,2.99%,3.22%,2.38%,2.36%,3.73%,4.70%
,,,,,,,,,,,,,
benchmark_name,metric_name,min,max,mean,median,p1,p2,p5,p10,p90,p95,p98,p99
stream,stream_single_triad,-2.84%,-2.94%,-2.76%,-2.50%,-2.83%,-2.83%,-2.81%,-2.77%,-2.85%,-2.90%,-2.93%,-2.93%
stream,stream_single_copy,0.34%,0.26%,0.34%,0.42%,0.34%,0.34%,0.35%,0.35%,0.29%,0.27%,0.26%,0.26%
stream,stream_single_cale,0.25%,0.32%,0.28%,0.28%,0.25%,0.25%,0.25%,0.25%,0.31%,0.32%,0.32%,0.32%
stream,stream_single_add,-3.05%,-2.97%,-2.80%,-2.39%,-3.04%,-3.03%,-2.99%,-2.92%,-2.85%,-2.91%,-2.94%,-2.95%
stream,stream_omp_nodes_triad,-3.10%,-4.17%,-2.42%,0.08%,-3.04%,-2.97%,-2.78%,-2.46%,-3.35%,-3.77%,-4.01%,-4.09%
stream,stream_omp_nodes_spread_triad,-4.21%,-4.50%,-4.33%,-4.29%,-4.21%,-4.21%,-4.22%,-4.23%,-4.46%,-4.48%,-4.49%,-4.49%
stream,stream_omp_nodes_spread_copy,-0.30%,-0.02%,-0.21%,-0.31%,-0.30%,-0.30%,-0.30%,-0.30%,-0.08%,-0.05%,-0.04%,-0.03%
stream,stream_omp_nodes_spread_cale,-0.49%,-0.25%,-0.50%,-0.77%,-0.50%,-0.50%,-0.52%,-0.55%,-0.35%,-0.30%,-0.27%,-0.26%
stream,stream_omp_nodes_spread_add,-4.13%,-3.91%,-4.02%,-4.01%,-4.13%,-4.13%,-4.12%,-4.11%,-3.93%,-3.92%,-3.92%,-3.91%
stream,stream_omp_nodes_copy,0.26%,0.14%,0.52%,1.15%,0.28%,0.30%,0.35%,0.44%,0.34%,0.24%,0.18%,0.16%
stream,stream_omp_nodes_cale,-0.34%,-0.18%,0.31%,1.46%,-0.30%,-0.26%,-0.16%,0.02%,0.14%,-0.02%,-0.11%,-0.14%
stream,stream_omp_nodes_add,-3.20%,-3.76%,-2.16%,0.54%,-3.12%,-3.05%,-2.82%,-2.44%,-2.94%,-3.35%,-3.60%,-3.68%
stream,stream_omp_llcs_triad,-5.57%,-3.66%,-4.50%,-4.27%,-5.55%,-5.52%,-5.44%,-5.31%,-3.78%,-3.72%,-3.69%,-3.67%
stream,stream_omp_llcs_spread_triad,-3.91%,-3.67%,-3.80%,-3.82%,-3.91%,-3.91%,-3.90%,-3.89%,-3.70%,-3.68%,-3.67%,-3.67%
stream,stream_omp_llcs_spread_copy,0.38%,0.06%,0.17%,0.08%,0.37%,0.36%,0.35%,0.32%,0.07%,0.07%,0.06%,0.06%
stream,stream_omp_llcs_spread_cale,-0.17%,-0.05%,-0.08%,-0.02%,-0.17%,-0.16%,-0.15%,-0.14%,-0.04%,-0.04%,-0.05%,-0.05%
stream,stream_omp_llcs_spread_add,-3.73%,-3.60%,-3.66%,-3.64%,-3.73%,-3.72%,-3.72%,-3.71%,-3.61%,-3.61%,-3.60%,-3.60%
stream,stream_omp_llcs_copy,-0.25%,0.14%,-0.12%,-0.26%,-0.25%,-0.25%,-0.25%,-0.25%,0.06%,0.10%,0.13%,0.13%
stream,stream_omp_llcs_cale,-0.31%,-0.01%,-0.40%,-0.88%,-0.32%,-0.33%,-0.37%,-0.43%,-0.18%,-0.10%,-0.05%,-0.03%
stream,stream_omp_llcs_add,-5.38%,-3.46%,-4.32%,-4.13%,-5.36%,-5.33%,-5.26%,-5.13%,-3.60%,-3.53%,-3.49%,-3.48%
stream,SUnreclaim,48.08%,13.06%,13.94%,13.32%,33.30%,28.17%,16.89%,13.77%,13.24%,13.03%,13.02%,13.01%
stream,SReclaimable,4.93%,3.28%,2.83%,2.49%,4.29%,4.18%,2.70%,2.18%,3.80%,4.18%,3.41%,3.68%
,,,,,,,,,,,,,
benchmark_name,metric_name,min,max,mean,median,p1,p2,p5,p10,p90,p95,p98,p99
netpipe,netpipe_tput_min,-0.56%,1.25%,0.03%,-0.60%,-0.56%,-0.56%,-0.57%,-0.57%,0.88%,1.07%,1.18%,1.22%
netpipe,netpipe_tput_max,0.91%,3.29%,2.34%,2.81%,0.95%,0.99%,1.10%,1.29%,3.20%,3.25%,3.27%,3.28%
netpipe,netpipe_tput_99,-2.50%,-0.16%,-1.74%,-2.56%,-2.50%,-2.50%,-2.50%,-2.51%,-0.64%,-0.40%,-0.26%,-0.21%
netpipe,netpipe_tput_98307,1.41%,4.43%,3.60%,4.90%,1.49%,1.56%,1.77%,2.12%,4.52%,4.48%,4.45%,4.44%
netpipe,netpipe_tput_98304,-0.21%,4.72%,3.28%,5.31%,-0.10%,0.01%,0.34%,0.89%,4.84%,4.78%,4.74%,4.73%
netpipe,netpipe_tput_98301,-2.53%,1.73%,0.44%,2.08%,-2.44%,-2.35%,-2.07%,-1.60%,1.80%,1.77%,1.75%,1.74%
netpipe,netpipe_tput_96,-2.65%,-1.87%,-2.14%,-1.91%,-2.64%,-2.63%,-2.58%,-2.51%,-1.87%,-1.87%,-1.87%,-1.87%
netpipe,netpipe_tput_93,-2.76%,0.46%,-1.50%,-2.24%,-2.74%,-2.73%,-2.70%,-2.65%,-0.08%,0.19%,0.35%,0.41%
netpipe,netpipe_tput_8388611,0.91%,3.29%,2.34%,2.81%,0.95%,0.99%,1.10%,1.29%,3.20%,3.25%,3.27%,3.28%
netpipe,netpipe_tput_8388608,0.66%,4.19%,2.66%,3.11%,0.71%,0.76%,0.91%,1.15%,3.98%,4.08%,4.15%,4.17%
netpipe,netpipe_tput_8388605,1.29%,3.07%,2.42%,2.87%,1.32%,1.35%,1.45%,1.61%,3.03%,3.05%,3.07%,3.07%
netpipe,netpipe_tput_8195,0.01%,1.23%,0.41%,-0.01%,0.01%,0.01%,0.01%,0.01%,0.98%,1.10%,1.18%,1.20%
netpipe,netpipe_tput_8192,0.15%,1.23%,0.44%,-0.06%,0.15%,0.15%,0.13%,0.11%,0.97%,1.10%,1.18%,1.20%
netpipe,netpipe_tput_8189,0.04%,1.54%,0.55%,0.05%,0.04%,0.04%,0.04%,0.04%,1.25%,1.40%,1.49%,1.52%
netpipe,netpipe_tput_8,-0.38%,1.74%,0.36%,-0.29%,-0.38%,-0.38%,-0.38%,-0.37%,1.34%,1.54%,1.66%,1.70%
netpipe,netpipe_tput_786435,2.42%,2.56%,4.62%,8.93%,2.56%,2.69%,3.10%,3.76%,3.77%,3.16%,2.80%,2.68%
netpipe,netpipe_tput_786432,2.19%,2.09%,1.53%,0.28%,2.15%,2.11%,2.00%,1.80%,1.75%,1.92%,2.02%,2.06%
netpipe,netpipe_tput_786429,2.26%,-1.89%,-0.48%,-1.71%,2.18%,2.10%,1.85%,1.44%,-1.85%,-1.87%,-1.88%,-1.88%
netpipe,netpipe_tput_771,-1.54%,-2.56%,-1.74%,-1.09%,-1.53%,-1.52%,-1.50%,-1.45%,-2.27%,-2.42%,-2.50%,-2.53%
netpipe,netpipe_tput_768,-1.13%,-2.38%,-1.52%,-1.03%,-1.13%,-1.13%,-1.12%,-1.11%,-2.11%,-2.24%,-2.32%,-2.35%
netpipe,netpipe_tput_765,-1.21%,-1.40%,-1.17%,-0.89%,-1.20%,-1.20%,-1.18%,-1.15%,-1.30%,-1.35%,-1.38%,-1.39%
netpipe,netpipe_tput_67,-2.91%,1.19%,-1.42%,-2.56%,-2.90%,-2.90%,-2.87%,-2.84%,0.45%,0.82%,1.04%,1.12%
netpipe,netpipe_tput_65539,0.60%,0.43%,0.93%,1.78%,0.62%,0.64%,0.72%,0.83%,0.70%,0.57%,0.49%,0.46%
netpipe,netpipe_tput_65536,2.76%,0.29%,1.54%,1.60%,2.74%,2.72%,2.65%,2.53%,0.55%,0.42%,0.34%,0.31%
netpipe,netpipe_tput_65533,1.10%,0.46%,0.90%,1.14%,1.10%,1.10%,1.10%,1.11%,0.60%,0.53%,0.49%,0.48%
netpipe,netpipe_tput_64,-3.05%,-0.24%,-1.81%,-2.15%,-3.03%,-3.01%,-2.96%,-2.87%,-0.62%,-0.43%,-0.32%,-0.28%
netpipe,netpipe_tput_6291459,1.15%,2.83%,2.46%,3.38%,1.19%,1.24%,1.37%,1.60%,2.94%,2.88%,2.85%,2.84%
netpipe,netpipe_tput_6291456,0.52%,3.12%,2.30%,3.25%,0.57%,0.63%,0.79%,1.06%,3.15%,3.14%,3.13%,3.13%
netpipe,netpipe_tput_6291453,1.70%,3.94%,3.06%,3.53%,1.73%,1.77%,1.88%,2.06%,3.86%,3.90%,3.93%,3.94%
netpipe,netpipe_tput_6147,0.05%,0.96%,0.17%,-0.50%,0.04%,0.03%,0.00%,-0.06%,0.67%,0.81%,0.90%,0.93%
netpipe,netpipe_tput_6144,-0.06%,1.43%,0.31%,-0.46%,-0.06%,-0.07%,-0.10%,-0.14%,1.05%,1.24%,1.35%,1.39%
netpipe,netpipe_tput_6141,-0.07%,1.53%,0.39%,-0.30%,-0.07%,-0.08%,-0.09%,-0.11%,1.16%,1.35%,1.46%,1.49%
netpipe,netpipe_tput_61,-3.18%,-0.29%,-2.05%,-2.70%,-3.17%,-3.16%,-3.13%,-3.09%,-0.77%,-0.53%,-0.38%,-0.34%
netpipe,netpipe_tput_6,-0.33%,2.36%,0.65%,-0.10%,-0.33%,-0.32%,-0.31%,-0.28%,1.87%,2.12%,2.27%,2.32%
netpipe,netpipe_tput_524291,1.92%,1.04%,0.03%,-2.78%,1.82%,1.72%,1.43%,0.94%,0.28%,0.66%,0.89%,0.97%
netpipe,netpipe_tput_524288,1.75%,1.33%,0.16%,-2.53%,1.66%,1.57%,1.30%,0.86%,0.56%,0.95%,1.18%,1.25%
netpipe,netpipe_tput_524285,1.17%,1.19%,0.06%,-2.14%,1.10%,1.03%,0.83%,0.49%,0.53%,0.86%,1.06%,1.13%
netpipe,netpipe_tput_515,-0.71%,-1.21%,-1.10%,-1.38%,-0.72%,-0.73%,-0.77%,-0.84%,-1.25%,-1.23%,-1.22%,-1.22%
netpipe,netpipe_tput_512,-0.95%,-1.16%,-1.01%,-0.91%,-0.95%,-0.95%,-0.95%,-0.94%,-1.11%,-1.13%,-1.15%,-1.15%
netpipe,netpipe_tput_51,-3.54%,1.28%,-1.50%,-2.24%,-3.52%,-3.49%,-3.41%,-3.28%,0.58%,0.93%,1.14%,1.21%
netpipe,netpipe_tput_509,-0.49%,-1.20%,-0.99%,-1.28%,-0.51%,-0.53%,-0.57%,-0.65%,-1.21%,-1.21%,-1.20%,-1.20%
netpipe,netpipe_tput_49155,-1.69%,-0.08%,-0.68%,-0.28%,-1.66%,-1.63%,-1.55%,-1.41%,-0.12%,-0.10%,-0.09%,-0.08%
netpipe,netpipe_tput_49152,-0.32%,-0.02%,-0.21%,-0.28%,-0.32%,-0.32%,-0.32%,-0.31%,-0.07%,-0.05%,-0.03%,-0.02%
netpipe,netpipe_tput_49149,-2.36%,-0.27%,-1.32%,-1.35%,-2.34%,-2.32%,-2.26%,-2.16%,-0.49%,-0.38%,-0.32%,-0.29%
netpipe,netpipe_tput_48,-1.08%,0.75%,-0.98%,-2.63%,-1.11%,-1.14%,-1.24%,-1.40%,0.08%,0.41%,0.61%,0.68%
netpipe,netpipe_tput_45,-0.45%,-5.06%,-3.31%,-4.31%,-0.53%,-0.61%,-0.85%,-1.25%,-4.91%,-4.98%,-5.03%,-5.04%
netpipe,netpipe_tput_4194307,0.94%,4.09%,2.91%,3.68%,0.99%,1.05%,1.21%,1.49%,4.01%,4.05%,4.07%,4.08%
netpipe,netpipe_tput_4194304,1.14%,4.04%,2.87%,3.42%,1.18%,1.23%,1.37%,1.60%,3.91%,3.98%,4.01%,4.02%
netpipe,netpipe_tput_4194301,1.56%,3.67%,2.93%,3.53%,1.60%,1.64%,1.76%,1.96%,3.64%,3.65%,3.66%,3.66%
netpipe,netpipe_tput_4099,-0.31%,1.19%,0.18%,-0.34%,-0.31%,-0.31%,-0.31%,-0.32%,0.88%,1.04%,1.13%,1.16%
netpipe,netpipe_tput_4096,-0.04%,1.49%,0.56%,0.22%,-0.03%,-0.03%,-0.01%,0.01%,1.24%,1.37%,1.44%,1.47%
netpipe,netpipe_tput_4093,0.18%,1.60%,0.55%,-0.12%,0.17%,0.16%,0.15%,0.12%,1.25%,1.43%,1.53%,1.56%
netpipe,netpipe_tput_4,-0.62%,1.48%,0.22%,-0.21%,-0.61%,-0.60%,-0.58%,-0.54%,1.15%,1.32%,1.42%,1.45%
netpipe,netpipe_tput_393219,0.82%,0.94%,0.73%,0.44%,0.81%,0.80%,0.78%,0.74%,0.84%,0.89%,0.92%,0.93%
netpipe,netpipe_tput_393216,-0.26%,0.80%,0.35%,0.50%,-0.24%,-0.23%,-0.18%,-0.10%,0.74%,0.77%,0.79%,0.79%
netpipe,netpipe_tput_393213,0.51%,0.79%,0.89%,1.38%,0.52%,0.54%,0.59%,0.68%,0.91%,0.85%,0.82%,0.80%
netpipe,netpipe_tput_387,-0.81%,1.93%,0.12%,-0.77%,-0.81%,-0.81%,-0.81%,-0.80%,1.39%,1.66%,1.82%,1.87%
netpipe,netpipe_tput_384,-0.90%,2.01%,0.06%,-0.94%,-0.90%,-0.90%,-0.90%,-0.91%,1.42%,1.71%,1.89%,1.95%
netpipe,netpipe_tput_381,-0.47%,2.28%,0.41%,-0.57%,-0.47%,-0.48%,-0.48%,-0.49%,1.71%,1.99%,2.16%,2.22%
netpipe,netpipe_tput_35,-0.68%,-0.95%,-0.98%,-1.31%,-0.70%,-0.71%,-0.75%,-0.81%,-1.02%,-0.98%,-0.96%,-0.95%
netpipe,netpipe_tput_32771,0.90%,1.67%,1.32%,1.41%,0.91%,0.92%,0.95%,1.00%,1.62%,1.64%,1.66%,1.66%
netpipe,netpipe_tput_32768,0.84%,1.81%,1.22%,1.03%,0.84%,0.84%,0.86%,0.88%,1.65%,1.73%,1.77%,1.79%
netpipe,netpipe_tput_32765,0.71%,1.76%,1.00%,0.53%,0.71%,0.71%,0.70%,0.68%,1.51%,1.64%,1.71%,1.73%
netpipe,netpipe_tput_32,-0.63%,-1.11%,-0.94%,-1.09%,-0.64%,-0.65%,-0.68%,-0.73%,-1.11%,-1.11%,-1.11%,-1.11%
netpipe,netpipe_tput_3145731,1.60%,3.35%,2.91%,3.77%,1.64%,1.69%,1.82%,2.04%,3.44%,3.40%,3.37%,3.36%
netpipe,netpipe_tput_3145728,2.50%,3.29%,3.32%,4.15%,2.53%,2.56%,2.66%,2.83%,3.46%,3.38%,3.33%,3.31%
netpipe,netpipe_tput_3145725,2.16%,3.20%,3.26%,4.40%,2.21%,2.25%,2.39%,2.61%,3.44%,3.32%,3.25%,3.23%
netpipe,netpipe_tput_3075,0.32%,0.56%,0.51%,0.64%,0.33%,0.33%,0.35%,0.38%,0.57%,0.57%,0.56%,0.56%
netpipe,netpipe_tput_3072,-0.95%,-0.06%,-0.35%,-0.06%,-0.93%,-0.91%,-0.86%,-0.77%,-0.06%,-0.06%,-0.06%,-0.06%
netpipe,netpipe_tput_3069,-0.63%,-0.65%,-0.50%,-0.23%,-0.62%,-0.61%,-0.59%,-0.55%,-0.57%,-0.61%,-0.63%,-0.64%
netpipe,netpipe_tput_3,-1.19%,1.36%,-0.20%,-0.79%,-1.18%,-1.17%,-1.15%,-1.11%,0.93%,1.15%,1.27%,1.32%
netpipe,netpipe_tput_29,-1.13%,-0.24%,-0.89%,-1.30%,-1.13%,-1.13%,-1.14%,-1.16%,-0.45%,-0.35%,-0.29%,-0.26%
netpipe,netpipe_tput_27,-0.93%,-1.77%,-1.23%,-0.98%,-0.93%,-0.93%,-0.93%,-0.94%,-1.62%,-1.70%,-1.74%,-1.76%
netpipe,netpipe_tput_262147,-1.15%,0.76%,-0.47%,-1.02%,-1.15%,-1.14%,-1.14%,-1.12%,0.40%,0.58%,0.69%,0.72%
netpipe,netpipe_tput_262144,-1.08%,0.78%,-0.45%,-1.06%,-1.08%,-1.08%,-1.08%,-1.08%,0.41%,0.59%,0.70%,0.74%
netpipe,netpipe_tput_262141,-1.54%,0.40%,-0.74%,-1.10%,-1.53%,-1.53%,-1.50%,-1.45%,0.10%,0.25%,0.34%,0.37%
netpipe,netpipe_tput_259,-1.39%,-0.82%,-1.06%,-0.98%,-1.38%,-1.37%,-1.35%,-1.31%,-0.86%,-0.84%,-0.83%,-0.83%
netpipe,netpipe_tput_256,-1.19%,-1.59%,-1.41%,-1.44%,-1.20%,-1.20%,-1.22%,-1.24%,-1.56%,-1.58%,-1.59%,-1.59%
netpipe,netpipe_tput_253,-0.78%,-0.13%,-0.56%,-0.78%,-0.78%,-0.78%,-0.78%,-0.78%,-0.26%,-0.20%,-0.16%,-0.14%
netpipe,netpipe_tput_24579,0.35%,1.30%,0.55%,-0.01%,0.34%,0.34%,0.31%,0.28%,1.04%,1.17%,1.25%,1.28%
netpipe,netpipe_tput_24576,0.45%,1.45%,0.63%,-0.02%,0.44%,0.43%,0.40%,0.36%,1.15%,1.30%,1.39%,1.42%
netpipe,netpipe_tput_24573,0.33%,1.25%,0.48%,-0.13%,0.32%,0.31%,0.29%,0.24%,0.97%,1.11%,1.19%,1.22%
netpipe,netpipe_tput_24,-0.70%,-1.13%,-1.04%,-1.28%,-0.71%,-0.72%,-0.76%,-0.82%,-1.16%,-1.15%,-1.14%,-1.14%
netpipe,netpipe_tput_21,-0.80%,2.00%,0.14%,-0.80%,-0.80%,-0.80%,-0.80%,-0.80%,1.44%,1.72%,1.88%,1.94%
netpipe,netpipe_tput_2097155,3.03%,3.47%,2.90%,2.22%,3.01%,2.99%,2.94%,2.86%,3.22%,3.34%,3.42%,3.44%
netpipe,netpipe_tput_2097152,3.17%,3.21%,2.83%,2.11%,3.15%,3.12%,3.06%,2.95%,2.99%,3.10%,3.17%,3.19%
netpipe,netpipe_tput_2097149,2.98%,3.23%,2.77%,2.10%,2.96%,2.94%,2.89%,2.80%,3.01%,3.12%,3.19%,3.21%
netpipe,netpipe_tput_2051,-0.15%,0.73%,0.07%,-0.36%,-0.15%,-0.15%,-0.17%,-0.19%,0.51%,0.62%,0.69%,0.71%
netpipe,netpipe_tput_2048,-0.55%,1.29%,0.13%,-0.34%,-0.55%,-0.54%,-0.53%,-0.51%,0.96%,1.13%,1.22%,1.26%
netpipe,netpipe_tput_2045,-0.41%,1.81%,0.33%,-0.43%,-0.41%,-0.41%,-0.41%,-0.42%,1.37%,1.59%,1.72%,1.77%
netpipe,netpipe_tput_2,-0.76%,1.54%,0.30%,0.11%,-0.74%,-0.72%,-0.67%,-0.58%,1.26%,1.40%,1.48%,1.51%
netpipe,netpipe_tput_196611,-4.49%,-2.03%,-3.28%,-3.35%,-4.46%,-4.44%,-4.37%,-4.26%,-2.30%,-2.16%,-2.09%,-2.06%
netpipe,netpipe_tput_196608,-4.76%,-1.41%,-3.07%,-3.05%,-4.73%,-4.69%,-4.59%,-4.42%,-1.74%,-1.57%,-1.47%,-1.44%
netpipe,netpipe_tput_196605,-8.84%,-3.00%,-5.99%,-6.15%,-8.79%,-8.74%,-8.57%,-8.30%,-3.63%,-3.32%,-3.13%,-3.06%
netpipe,netpipe_tput_195,-1.34%,-0.99%,-1.29%,-1.53%,-1.35%,-1.35%,-1.36%,-1.38%,-1.10%,-1.04%,-1.01%,-1.00%
netpipe,netpipe_tput_192,-1.42%,-1.85%,-1.65%,-1.67%,-1.43%,-1.43%,-1.45%,-1.47%,-1.81%,-1.83%,-1.84%,-1.84%
netpipe,netpipe_tput_19,-0.65%,2.10%,0.31%,-0.52%,-0.65%,-0.64%,-0.64%,-0.62%,1.58%,1.84%,2.00%,2.05%
netpipe,netpipe_tput_189,-1.48%,-2.13%,-1.71%,-1.51%,-1.48%,-1.48%,-1.49%,-1.49%,-2.01%,-2.07%,-2.11%,-2.12%
netpipe,netpipe_tput_16387,-0.24%,0.70%,0.17%,0.03%,-0.23%,-0.23%,-0.21%,-0.18%,0.57%,0.63%,0.67%,0.69%
netpipe,netpipe_tput_16384,-0.17%,0.68%,0.23%,0.18%,-0.17%,-0.16%,-0.14%,-0.10%,0.58%,0.63%,0.66%,0.67%
netpipe,netpipe_tput_16381,-0.05%,0.70%,0.38%,0.48%,-0.04%,-0.03%,0.00%,0.06%,0.66%,0.68%,0.70%,0.70%
netpipe,netpipe_tput_16,-0.40%,-0.14%,-0.47%,-0.86%,-0.41%,-0.42%,-0.44%,-0.49%,-0.28%,-0.21%,-0.17%,-0.15%
netpipe,netpipe_tput_1572867,2.58%,3.76%,3.33%,3.65%,2.60%,2.63%,2.69%,2.80%,3.74%,3.75%,3.76%,3.76%
netpipe,netpipe_tput_1572864,2.65%,3.13%,3.05%,3.36%,2.67%,2.68%,2.72%,2.79%,3.18%,3.15%,3.14%,3.14%
netpipe,netpipe_tput_1572861,3.03%,3.20%,3.00%,2.76%,3.03%,3.02%,3.01%,2.98%,3.12%,3.16%,3.19%,3.20%
netpipe,netpipe_tput_1539,0.10%,1.60%,0.57%,0.01%,0.10%,0.09%,0.09%,0.08%,1.29%,1.45%,1.54%,1.57%
netpipe,netpipe_tput_1536,0.57%,1.12%,0.43%,-0.38%,0.55%,0.53%,0.48%,0.38%,0.82%,0.97%,1.06%,1.09%
netpipe,netpipe_tput_1533,-0.19%,0.19%,-0.07%,-0.20%,-0.19%,-0.19%,-0.19%,-0.19%,0.11%,0.15%,0.18%,0.18%
netpipe,netpipe_tput_131075,-5.79%,-1.95%,-3.48%,-2.71%,-5.73%,-5.67%,-5.48%,-5.18%,-2.10%,-2.02%,-1.98%,-1.96%
netpipe,netpipe_tput_131072,-6.20%,-1.89%,-3.72%,-3.09%,-6.14%,-6.08%,-5.89%,-5.58%,-2.13%,-2.01%,-1.94%,-1.91%
netpipe,netpipe_tput_131069,-5.93%,-2.29%,-3.73%,-2.97%,-5.87%,-5.81%,-5.63%,-5.34%,-2.43%,-2.36%,-2.32%,-2.31%
netpipe,netpipe_tput_131,-2.11%,-1.16%,-2.03%,-2.82%,-2.12%,-2.14%,-2.18%,-2.25%,-1.49%,-1.32%,-1.22%,-1.19%
netpipe,netpipe_tput_13,-0.59%,1.52%,0.03%,-0.87%,-0.59%,-0.60%,-0.62%,-0.64%,1.05%,1.29%,1.43%,1.48%
netpipe,netpipe_tput_128,-3.15%,-1.33%,-2.40%,-2.75%,-3.14%,-3.13%,-3.11%,-3.07%,-1.61%,-1.47%,-1.38%,-1.35%
netpipe,netpipe_tput_125,-2.15%,-0.59%,-1.83%,-2.78%,-2.16%,-2.17%,-2.21%,-2.27%,-1.02%,-0.80%,-0.67%,-0.63%
netpipe,netpipe_tput_12291,-0.26%,1.48%,0.37%,-0.12%,-0.26%,-0.26%,-0.25%,-0.23%,1.16%,1.32%,1.42%,1.45%
netpipe,netpipe_tput_12288,0.09%,1.50%,0.45%,-0.25%,0.08%,0.08%,0.05%,0.02%,1.15%,1.32%,1.43%,1.46%
netpipe,netpipe_tput_12285,-0.18%,0.18%,-0.01%,-0.02%,-0.18%,-0.18%,-0.17%,-0.15%,0.14%,0.16%,0.17%,0.17%
netpipe,netpipe_tput_12,-0.84%,1.88%,-0.02%,-1.09%,-0.84%,-0.85%,-0.86%,-0.89%,1.28%,1.58%,1.76%,1.82%
netpipe,netpipe_tput_1048579,3.38%,3.75%,3.33%,2.86%,3.37%,3.36%,3.33%,3.28%,3.57%,3.66%,3.71%,3.73%
netpipe,netpipe_tput_1048576,3.59%,3.91%,3.61%,3.32%,3.58%,3.58%,3.56%,3.53%,3.79%,3.85%,3.88%,3.89%
netpipe,netpipe_tput_1048573,3.86%,3.88%,3.80%,3.65%,3.86%,3.86%,3.84%,3.82%,3.83%,3.85%,3.87%,3.87%
netpipe,netpipe_tput_1027,-4.25%,-1.52%,-3.07%,-3.45%,-4.23%,-4.22%,-4.17%,-4.09%,-1.90%,-1.71%,-1.59%,-1.55%
netpipe,netpipe_tput_1024,-3.43%,-2.73%,-3.03%,-2.96%,-3.42%,-3.41%,-3.38%,-3.33%,-2.77%,-2.75%,-2.74%,-2.73%
netpipe,netpipe_tput_1021,-3.56%,-2.97%,-3.63%,-4.39%,-3.57%,-3.59%,-3.64%,-3.72%,-3.25%,-3.11%,-3.02%,-2.99%
netpipe,netpipe_tput_1,-0.56%,1.25%,0.03%,-0.60%,-0.56%,-0.56%,-0.57%,-0.57%,0.88%,1.07%,1.18%,1.22%

[-- Attachment #4: slab vs slub - AMD.csv --]
[-- Type: text/csv, Size: 30994 bytes --]

benchmark_name,metric_name,min,max,mean,median,p1,p2,p5,p10,p90,p95,p98,p99
hackbench,hackbench_thread_sockets_max,-79.15%,-78.24%,-78.71%,-79.02%,-79.13%,-79.12%,-79.08%,-79.02%,-78.28%,-78.26%,-78.25%,-78.25%
hackbench,hackbench_thread_sockets_234,-79.15%,-78.24%,-78.71%,-79.02%,-79.13%,-79.12%,-79.08%,-79.02%,-78.28%,-78.26%,-78.25%,-78.25%
hackbench,hackbench_thread_pipes_max,-1.67%,3.13%,-1.36%,-4.60%,-1.53%,-1.38%,-0.95%,-0.25%,3.49%,3.31%,3.20%,3.17%
hackbench,hackbench_thread_pipes_234,-1.67%,3.13%,-1.36%,-4.60%,-1.53%,-1.38%,-0.95%,-0.25%,3.49%,3.31%,3.20%,3.17%
hackbench,hackbench_process_sockets_max,-79.30%,-78.42%,-79.09%,-79.28%,-79.30%,-79.31%,-79.32%,-79.33%,-78.60%,-78.51%,-78.46%,-78.44%
hackbench,hackbench_process_sockets_234,-79.30%,-78.42%,-79.09%,-79.28%,-79.30%,-79.31%,-79.32%,-79.33%,-78.60%,-78.51%,-78.46%,-78.44%
hackbench,hackbench_process_pipes_max,0.32%,-2.05%,-1.17%,-1.75%,0.25%,0.19%,-0.02%,-0.34%,2.02%,-0.08%,-1.28%,-1.67%
hackbench,hackbench_process_pipes_234,0.32%,-2.05%,-1.17%,-1.75%,0.25%,0.19%,-0.02%,-0.34%,2.02%,-0.08%,-1.28%,-1.67%
hackbench,SUnreclaim,34.86%,-8.03%,13.61%,24.50%,34.32%,33.80%,32.29%,30.96%,-3.68%,-8.84%,-8.34%,-8.18%
hackbench,SReclaimable,22.50%,8.16%,10.48%,11.37%,21.71%,20.96%,18.87%,17.40%,5.37%,5.52%,7.10%,7.63%
,,,,,,,,,,,,,
benchmark_name,metric_name,min,max,mean,median,p1,p2,p5,p10,p90,p95,p98,p99
unixbench,unixbench_syscall_max,0.80%,0.61%,0.89%,1.21%,0.80%,0.79%,0.79%,0.77%,0.80%,0.70%,0.65%,0.63%
unixbench,unixbench_syscall_1,0.80%,0.61%,0.89%,1.21%,0.80%,0.79%,0.79%,0.77%,0.80%,0.70%,0.65%,0.63%
unixbench,unixbench_spawn_max,6.06%,6.27%,6.41%,6.76%,6.07%,6.08%,6.11%,6.16%,6.42%,6.35%,6.30%,6.29%
unixbench,unixbench_spawn_1,6.06%,6.27%,6.41%,6.76%,6.07%,6.08%,6.11%,6.16%,6.42%,6.35%,6.30%,6.29%
unixbench,unixbench_pipe_max,1.95%,1.72%,1.74%,1.70%,1.93%,1.92%,1.86%,1.78%,1.76%,1.74%,1.73%,1.73%
unixbench,unixbench_pipe_1,1.95%,1.72%,1.74%,1.70%,1.93%,1.92%,1.86%,1.78%,1.76%,1.74%,1.73%,1.73%
unixbench,unixbench_execl_max,-0.67%,-0.57%,-0.54%,-0.50%,-0.66%,-0.65%,-0.63%,-0.58%,-0.55%,-0.56%,-0.56%,-0.57%
unixbench,unixbench_execl_1,-0.67%,-0.57%,-0.54%,-0.50%,-0.66%,-0.65%,-0.63%,-0.58%,-0.55%,-0.56%,-0.56%,-0.57%
unixbench,unixbench_dhry2reg_max,-0.76%,1.71%,-0.11%,-0.53%,-0.76%,-0.76%,-0.75%,-0.73%,0.92%,1.31%,1.55%,1.63%
unixbench,unixbench_dhry2reg_lbr_max,-0.71%,-5.38%,-1.66%,-0.45%,-0.70%,-0.68%,-0.63%,-0.54%,-3.78%,-4.59%,-5.06%,-5.22%
unixbench,unixbench_dhry2reg_lbr_1,-0.71%,-5.38%,-1.66%,-0.45%,-0.70%,-0.68%,-0.63%,-0.54%,-3.78%,-4.59%,-5.06%,-5.22%
unixbench,unixbench_dhry2reg_1,-0.76%,1.71%,-0.11%,-0.53%,-0.76%,-0.76%,-0.75%,-0.73%,0.92%,1.31%,1.55%,1.63%
unixbench,SUnreclaim,35.01%,36.04%,36.61%,37.74%,29.01%,30.55%,31.81%,33.64%,37.29%,37.08%,36.86%,36.58%
unixbench,SReclaimable,25.34%,16.67%,18.01%,18.23%,14.72%,16.50%,17.38%,18.01%,17.95%,17.89%,17.72%,17.47%
,,,,,,,,,,,,,
benchmark_name,metric_name,min,max,mean,median,p1,p2,p5,p10,p90,p95,p98,p99
will-it-scale,writeseek3_scalability,-3.43%,-3.43%,-3.43%,-3.43%,-3.43%,-3.43%,-3.43%,-3.43%,-3.43%,-3.43%,-3.43%,-3.43%
will-it-scale,writeseek3_per_thread_ops,-1.35%,-1.35%,-1.35%,-1.35%,-1.35%,-1.35%,-1.35%,-1.35%,-1.35%,-1.35%,-1.35%,-1.35%
will-it-scale,writeseek3_per_process_ops,-0.17%,-0.17%,-0.17%,-0.17%,-0.17%,-0.17%,-0.17%,-0.17%,-0.17%,-0.17%,-0.17%,-0.17%
will-it-scale,writeseek2_scalability,1.28%,1.28%,1.28%,1.28%,1.28%,1.28%,1.28%,1.28%,1.28%,1.28%,1.28%,1.28%
will-it-scale,writeseek2_per_thread_ops,-0.16%,-0.16%,-0.16%,-0.16%,-0.16%,-0.16%,-0.16%,-0.16%,-0.16%,-0.16%,-0.16%,-0.16%
will-it-scale,writeseek2_per_process_ops,-0.50%,-0.50%,-0.50%,-0.50%,-0.50%,-0.50%,-0.50%,-0.50%,-0.50%,-0.50%,-0.50%,-0.50%
will-it-scale,writeseek1_scalability,-0.62%,-0.62%,-0.62%,-0.62%,-0.62%,-0.62%,-0.62%,-0.62%,-0.62%,-0.62%,-0.62%,-0.62%
will-it-scale,writeseek1_per_thread_ops,-0.49%,-0.49%,-0.49%,-0.49%,-0.49%,-0.49%,-0.49%,-0.49%,-0.49%,-0.49%,-0.49%,-0.49%
will-it-scale,writeseek1_per_process_ops,-0.39%,-0.39%,-0.39%,-0.39%,-0.39%,-0.39%,-0.39%,-0.39%,-0.39%,-0.39%,-0.39%,-0.39%
will-it-scale,write1_scalability,-1.39%,-1.39%,-1.39%,-1.39%,-1.39%,-1.39%,-1.39%,-1.39%,-1.39%,-1.39%,-1.39%,-1.39%
will-it-scale,write1_per_thread_ops,-0.90%,-0.90%,-0.90%,-0.90%,-0.90%,-0.90%,-0.90%,-0.90%,-0.90%,-0.90%,-0.90%,-0.90%
will-it-scale,write1_per_process_ops,-1.58%,-1.58%,-1.58%,-1.58%,-1.58%,-1.58%,-1.58%,-1.58%,-1.58%,-1.58%,-1.58%,-1.58%
will-it-scale,unlink2_scalability,22.54%,22.54%,22.54%,22.54%,22.54%,22.54%,22.54%,22.54%,22.54%,22.54%,22.54%,22.54%
will-it-scale,unlink2_per_thread_ops,7.55%,7.55%,7.55%,7.55%,7.55%,7.55%,7.55%,7.55%,7.55%,7.55%,7.55%,7.55%
will-it-scale,unlink2_per_process_ops,9.15%,9.15%,9.15%,9.15%,9.15%,9.15%,9.15%,9.15%,9.15%,9.15%,9.15%,9.15%
will-it-scale,unlink1_scalability,16.79%,16.79%,16.79%,16.79%,16.79%,16.79%,16.79%,16.79%,16.79%,16.79%,16.79%,16.79%
will-it-scale,unlink1_per_thread_ops,6.68%,6.68%,6.68%,6.68%,6.68%,6.68%,6.68%,6.68%,6.68%,6.68%,6.68%,6.68%
will-it-scale,unlink1_per_process_ops,6.03%,6.03%,6.03%,6.03%,6.03%,6.03%,6.03%,6.03%,6.03%,6.03%,6.03%,6.03%
will-it-scale,unix1_scalability,-10.85%,-10.85%,-10.85%,-10.85%,-10.85%,-10.85%,-10.85%,-10.85%,-10.85%,-10.85%,-10.85%,-10.85%
will-it-scale,unix1_per_thread_ops,-1.57%,-1.57%,-1.57%,-1.57%,-1.57%,-1.57%,-1.57%,-1.57%,-1.57%,-1.57%,-1.57%,-1.57%
will-it-scale,unix1_per_process_ops,-6.27%,-6.27%,-6.27%,-6.27%,-6.27%,-6.27%,-6.27%,-6.27%,-6.27%,-6.27%,-6.27%,-6.27%
will-it-scale,signal1_scalability,1.75%,1.75%,1.75%,1.75%,1.75%,1.75%,1.75%,1.75%,1.75%,1.75%,1.75%,1.75%
will-it-scale,signal1_per_thread_ops,0.72%,0.72%,0.72%,0.72%,0.72%,0.72%,0.72%,0.72%,0.72%,0.72%,0.72%,0.72%
will-it-scale,signal1_per_process_ops,1.07%,1.07%,1.07%,1.07%,1.07%,1.07%,1.07%,1.07%,1.07%,1.07%,1.07%,1.07%
will-it-scale,sched_yield_scalability,0.73%,0.73%,0.73%,0.73%,0.73%,0.73%,0.73%,0.73%,0.73%,0.73%,0.73%,0.73%
will-it-scale,sched_yield_per_thread_ops,0.68%,0.68%,0.68%,0.68%,0.68%,0.68%,0.68%,0.68%,0.68%,0.68%,0.68%,0.68%
will-it-scale,sched_yield_per_process_ops,0.87%,0.87%,0.87%,0.87%,0.87%,0.87%,0.87%,0.87%,0.87%,0.87%,0.87%,0.87%
will-it-scale,readseek3_scalability,-1.06%,-1.06%,-1.06%,-1.06%,-1.06%,-1.06%,-1.06%,-1.06%,-1.06%,-1.06%,-1.06%,-1.06%
will-it-scale,readseek3_per_thread_ops,0.28%,0.28%,0.28%,0.28%,0.28%,0.28%,0.28%,0.28%,0.28%,0.28%,0.28%,0.28%
will-it-scale,readseek3_per_process_ops,0.16%,0.16%,0.16%,0.16%,0.16%,0.16%,0.16%,0.16%,0.16%,0.16%,0.16%,0.16%
will-it-scale,readseek2_scalability,1.36%,1.36%,1.36%,1.36%,1.36%,1.36%,1.36%,1.36%,1.36%,1.36%,1.36%,1.36%
will-it-scale,readseek2_per_thread_ops,0.33%,0.33%,0.33%,0.33%,0.33%,0.33%,0.33%,0.33%,0.33%,0.33%,0.33%,0.33%
will-it-scale,readseek2_per_process_ops,0.38%,0.38%,0.38%,0.38%,0.38%,0.38%,0.38%,0.38%,0.38%,0.38%,0.38%,0.38%
will-it-scale,readseek1_scalability,-0.48%,-0.48%,-0.48%,-0.48%,-0.48%,-0.48%,-0.48%,-0.48%,-0.48%,-0.48%,-0.48%,-0.48%
will-it-scale,readseek1_per_thread_ops,1.08%,1.08%,1.08%,1.08%,1.08%,1.08%,1.08%,1.08%,1.08%,1.08%,1.08%,1.08%
will-it-scale,readseek1_per_process_ops,0.22%,0.22%,0.22%,0.22%,0.22%,0.22%,0.22%,0.22%,0.22%,0.22%,0.22%,0.22%
will-it-scale,read2_scalability,0.39%,0.39%,0.39%,0.39%,0.39%,0.39%,0.39%,0.39%,0.39%,0.39%,0.39%,0.39%
will-it-scale,read2_per_thread_ops,-0.03%,-0.03%,-0.03%,-0.03%,-0.03%,-0.03%,-0.03%,-0.03%,-0.03%,-0.03%,-0.03%,-0.03%
will-it-scale,read2_per_process_ops,2.46%,2.46%,2.46%,2.46%,2.46%,2.46%,2.46%,2.46%,2.46%,2.46%,2.46%,2.46%
will-it-scale,read1_scalability,-5.09%,-5.09%,-5.09%,-5.09%,-5.09%,-5.09%,-5.09%,-5.09%,-5.09%,-5.09%,-5.09%,-5.09%
will-it-scale,read1_per_thread_ops,3.85%,3.85%,3.85%,3.85%,3.85%,3.85%,3.85%,3.85%,3.85%,3.85%,3.85%,3.85%
will-it-scale,read1_per_process_ops,3.19%,3.19%,3.19%,3.19%,3.19%,3.19%,3.19%,3.19%,3.19%,3.19%,3.19%,3.19%
will-it-scale,pwrite3_scalability,-4.90%,-4.90%,-4.90%,-4.90%,-4.90%,-4.90%,-4.90%,-4.90%,-4.90%,-4.90%,-4.90%,-4.90%
will-it-scale,pwrite3_per_thread_ops,-0.93%,-0.93%,-0.93%,-0.93%,-0.93%,-0.93%,-0.93%,-0.93%,-0.93%,-0.93%,-0.93%,-0.93%
will-it-scale,pwrite3_per_process_ops,-0.46%,-0.46%,-0.46%,-0.46%,-0.46%,-0.46%,-0.46%,-0.46%,-0.46%,-0.46%,-0.46%,-0.46%
will-it-scale,pwrite2_scalability,2.44%,2.44%,2.44%,2.44%,2.44%,2.44%,2.44%,2.44%,2.44%,2.44%,2.44%,2.44%
will-it-scale,pwrite2_per_thread_ops,-0.80%,-0.80%,-0.80%,-0.80%,-0.80%,-0.80%,-0.80%,-0.80%,-0.80%,-0.80%,-0.80%,-0.80%
will-it-scale,pwrite2_per_process_ops,0.22%,0.22%,0.22%,0.22%,0.22%,0.22%,0.22%,0.22%,0.22%,0.22%,0.22%,0.22%
will-it-scale,pwrite1_scalability,-0.30%,-0.30%,-0.30%,-0.30%,-0.30%,-0.30%,-0.30%,-0.30%,-0.30%,-0.30%,-0.30%,-0.30%
will-it-scale,pwrite1_per_thread_ops,-0.95%,-0.95%,-0.95%,-0.95%,-0.95%,-0.95%,-0.95%,-0.95%,-0.95%,-0.95%,-0.95%,-0.95%
will-it-scale,pwrite1_per_process_ops,-0.16%,-0.16%,-0.16%,-0.16%,-0.16%,-0.16%,-0.16%,-0.16%,-0.16%,-0.16%,-0.16%,-0.16%
will-it-scale,pthread_mutex2_scalability,-0.06%,-0.06%,-0.06%,-0.06%,-0.06%,-0.06%,-0.06%,-0.06%,-0.06%,-0.06%,-0.06%,-0.06%
will-it-scale,pthread_mutex2_per_thread_ops,0.15%,0.15%,0.15%,0.15%,0.15%,0.15%,0.15%,0.15%,0.15%,0.15%,0.15%,0.15%
will-it-scale,pthread_mutex2_per_process_ops,-0.06%,-0.06%,-0.06%,-0.06%,-0.06%,-0.06%,-0.06%,-0.06%,-0.06%,-0.06%,-0.06%,-0.06%
will-it-scale,pthread_mutex1_scalability,-0.12%,-0.12%,-0.12%,-0.12%,-0.12%,-0.12%,-0.12%,-0.12%,-0.12%,-0.12%,-0.12%,-0.12%
will-it-scale,pthread_mutex1_per_thread_ops,0.04%,0.04%,0.04%,0.04%,0.04%,0.04%,0.04%,0.04%,0.04%,0.04%,0.04%,0.04%
will-it-scale,pthread_mutex1_per_process_ops,-0.03%,-0.03%,-0.03%,-0.03%,-0.03%,-0.03%,-0.03%,-0.03%,-0.03%,-0.03%,-0.03%,-0.03%
will-it-scale,pread3_scalability,-0.18%,-0.18%,-0.18%,-0.18%,-0.18%,-0.18%,-0.18%,-0.18%,-0.18%,-0.18%,-0.18%,-0.18%
will-it-scale,pread3_per_thread_ops,0.26%,0.26%,0.26%,0.26%,0.26%,0.26%,0.26%,0.26%,0.26%,0.26%,0.26%,0.26%
will-it-scale,pread3_per_process_ops,0.25%,0.25%,0.25%,0.25%,0.25%,0.25%,0.25%,0.25%,0.25%,0.25%,0.25%,0.25%
will-it-scale,pread2_scalability,-0.49%,-0.49%,-0.49%,-0.49%,-0.49%,-0.49%,-0.49%,-0.49%,-0.49%,-0.49%,-0.49%,-0.49%
will-it-scale,pread2_per_thread_ops,-0.84%,-0.84%,-0.84%,-0.84%,-0.84%,-0.84%,-0.84%,-0.84%,-0.84%,-0.84%,-0.84%,-0.84%
will-it-scale,pread2_per_process_ops,-0.68%,-0.68%,-0.68%,-0.68%,-0.68%,-0.68%,-0.68%,-0.68%,-0.68%,-0.68%,-0.68%,-0.68%
will-it-scale,pread1_scalability,-1.00%,-1.00%,-1.00%,-1.00%,-1.00%,-1.00%,-1.00%,-1.00%,-1.00%,-1.00%,-1.00%,-1.00%
will-it-scale,pread1_per_thread_ops,0.58%,0.58%,0.58%,0.58%,0.58%,0.58%,0.58%,0.58%,0.58%,0.58%,0.58%,0.58%
will-it-scale,pread1_per_process_ops,0.03%,0.03%,0.03%,0.03%,0.03%,0.03%,0.03%,0.03%,0.03%,0.03%,0.03%,0.03%
will-it-scale,posix_semaphore1_scalability,1.60%,1.60%,1.60%,1.60%,1.60%,1.60%,1.60%,1.60%,1.60%,1.60%,1.60%,1.60%
will-it-scale,posix_semaphore1_per_thread_ops,0.17%,0.17%,0.17%,0.17%,0.17%,0.17%,0.17%,0.17%,0.17%,0.17%,0.17%,0.17%
will-it-scale,posix_semaphore1_per_process_ops,0.42%,0.42%,0.42%,0.42%,0.42%,0.42%,0.42%,0.42%,0.42%,0.42%,0.42%,0.42%
will-it-scale,poll2_scalability,0.25%,0.25%,0.25%,0.25%,0.25%,0.25%,0.25%,0.25%,0.25%,0.25%,0.25%,0.25%
will-it-scale,poll2_per_thread_ops,8.50%,8.50%,8.50%,8.50%,8.50%,8.50%,8.50%,8.50%,8.50%,8.50%,8.50%,8.50%
will-it-scale,poll2_per_process_ops,-0.21%,-0.21%,-0.21%,-0.21%,-0.21%,-0.21%,-0.21%,-0.21%,-0.21%,-0.21%,-0.21%,-0.21%
will-it-scale,poll1_scalability,-0.16%,-0.16%,-0.16%,-0.16%,-0.16%,-0.16%,-0.16%,-0.16%,-0.16%,-0.16%,-0.16%,-0.16%
will-it-scale,poll1_per_thread_ops,-0.15%,-0.15%,-0.15%,-0.15%,-0.15%,-0.15%,-0.15%,-0.15%,-0.15%,-0.15%,-0.15%,-0.15%
will-it-scale,poll1_per_process_ops,-0.43%,-0.43%,-0.43%,-0.43%,-0.43%,-0.43%,-0.43%,-0.43%,-0.43%,-0.43%,-0.43%,-0.43%
will-it-scale,pipe1_scalability,1.59%,1.59%,1.59%,1.59%,1.59%,1.59%,1.59%,1.59%,1.59%,1.59%,1.59%,1.59%
will-it-scale,pipe1_per_thread_ops,0.48%,0.48%,0.48%,0.48%,0.48%,0.48%,0.48%,0.48%,0.48%,0.48%,0.48%,0.48%
will-it-scale,pipe1_per_process_ops,-0.59%,-0.59%,-0.59%,-0.59%,-0.59%,-0.59%,-0.59%,-0.59%,-0.59%,-0.59%,-0.59%,-0.59%
will-it-scale,page_fault3_scalability,-0.48%,-0.48%,-0.48%,-0.48%,-0.48%,-0.48%,-0.48%,-0.48%,-0.48%,-0.48%,-0.48%,-0.48%
will-it-scale,page_fault3_per_thread_ops,-0.37%,-0.37%,-0.37%,-0.37%,-0.37%,-0.37%,-0.37%,-0.37%,-0.37%,-0.37%,-0.37%,-0.37%
will-it-scale,page_fault3_per_process_ops,0.43%,0.43%,0.43%,0.43%,0.43%,0.43%,0.43%,0.43%,0.43%,0.43%,0.43%,0.43%
will-it-scale,page_fault2_scalability,-5.59%,-5.59%,-5.59%,-5.59%,-5.59%,-5.59%,-5.59%,-5.59%,-5.59%,-5.59%,-5.59%,-5.59%
will-it-scale,page_fault2_per_thread_ops,0.82%,0.82%,0.82%,0.82%,0.82%,0.82%,0.82%,0.82%,0.82%,0.82%,0.82%,0.82%
will-it-scale,page_fault2_per_process_ops,2.37%,2.37%,2.37%,2.37%,2.37%,2.37%,2.37%,2.37%,2.37%,2.37%,2.37%,2.37%
will-it-scale,page_fault1_scalability,0.08%,0.08%,0.08%,0.08%,0.08%,0.08%,0.08%,0.08%,0.08%,0.08%,0.08%,0.08%
will-it-scale,page_fault1_per_thread_ops,-0.22%,-0.22%,-0.22%,-0.22%,-0.22%,-0.22%,-0.22%,-0.22%,-0.22%,-0.22%,-0.22%,-0.22%
will-it-scale,page_fault1_per_process_ops,0.18%,0.18%,0.18%,0.18%,0.18%,0.18%,0.18%,0.18%,0.18%,0.18%,0.18%,0.18%
will-it-scale,open2_scalability,43.07%,43.07%,43.07%,43.07%,43.07%,43.07%,43.07%,43.07%,43.07%,43.07%,43.07%,43.07%
will-it-scale,open2_per_thread_ops,3.68%,3.68%,3.68%,3.68%,3.68%,3.68%,3.68%,3.68%,3.68%,3.68%,3.68%,3.68%
will-it-scale,open2_per_process_ops,19.04%,19.04%,19.04%,19.04%,19.04%,19.04%,19.04%,19.04%,19.04%,19.04%,19.04%,19.04%
will-it-scale,open1_scalability,49.17%,49.17%,49.17%,49.17%,49.17%,49.17%,49.17%,49.17%,49.17%,49.17%,49.17%,49.17%
will-it-scale,open1_per_thread_ops,0.84%,0.84%,0.84%,0.84%,0.84%,0.84%,0.84%,0.84%,0.84%,0.84%,0.84%,0.84%
will-it-scale,open1_per_process_ops,18.02%,18.02%,18.02%,18.02%,18.02%,18.02%,18.02%,18.02%,18.02%,18.02%,18.02%,18.02%
will-it-scale,mmap2_scalability,-0.22%,-0.22%,-0.22%,-0.22%,-0.22%,-0.22%,-0.22%,-0.22%,-0.22%,-0.22%,-0.22%,-0.22%
will-it-scale,mmap2_per_thread_ops,0.99%,0.99%,0.99%,0.99%,0.99%,0.99%,0.99%,0.99%,0.99%,0.99%,0.99%,0.99%
will-it-scale,mmap2_per_process_ops,2.29%,2.29%,2.29%,2.29%,2.29%,2.29%,2.29%,2.29%,2.29%,2.29%,2.29%,2.29%
will-it-scale,mmap1_scalability,-0.83%,-0.83%,-0.83%,-0.83%,-0.83%,-0.83%,-0.83%,-0.83%,-0.83%,-0.83%,-0.83%,-0.83%
will-it-scale,mmap1_per_thread_ops,1.95%,1.95%,1.95%,1.95%,1.95%,1.95%,1.95%,1.95%,1.95%,1.95%,1.95%,1.95%
will-it-scale,mmap1_per_process_ops,1.86%,1.86%,1.86%,1.86%,1.86%,1.86%,1.86%,1.86%,1.86%,1.86%,1.86%,1.86%
will-it-scale,malloc2_scalability,-0.55%,-0.55%,-0.55%,-0.55%,-0.55%,-0.55%,-0.55%,-0.55%,-0.55%,-0.55%,-0.55%,-0.55%
will-it-scale,malloc2_per_thread_ops,0.42%,0.42%,0.42%,0.42%,0.42%,0.42%,0.42%,0.42%,0.42%,0.42%,0.42%,0.42%
will-it-scale,malloc2_per_process_ops,0.38%,0.38%,0.38%,0.38%,0.38%,0.38%,0.38%,0.38%,0.38%,0.38%,0.38%,0.38%
will-it-scale,malloc1_scalability,-2.34%,-2.34%,-2.34%,-2.34%,-2.34%,-2.34%,-2.34%,-2.34%,-2.34%,-2.34%,-2.34%,-2.34%
will-it-scale,malloc1_per_thread_ops,0.30%,0.30%,0.30%,0.30%,0.30%,0.30%,0.30%,0.30%,0.30%,0.30%,0.30%,0.30%
will-it-scale,malloc1_per_process_ops,0.02%,0.02%,0.02%,0.02%,0.02%,0.02%,0.02%,0.02%,0.02%,0.02%,0.02%,0.02%
will-it-scale,lseek2_scalability,0.03%,0.03%,0.03%,0.03%,0.03%,0.03%,0.03%,0.03%,0.03%,0.03%,0.03%,0.03%
will-it-scale,lseek2_per_thread_ops,-0.20%,-0.20%,-0.20%,-0.20%,-0.20%,-0.20%,-0.20%,-0.20%,-0.20%,-0.20%,-0.20%,-0.20%
will-it-scale,lseek2_per_process_ops,-0.36%,-0.36%,-0.36%,-0.36%,-0.36%,-0.36%,-0.36%,-0.36%,-0.36%,-0.36%,-0.36%,-0.36%
will-it-scale,lseek1_scalability,-0.36%,-0.36%,-0.36%,-0.36%,-0.36%,-0.36%,-0.36%,-0.36%,-0.36%,-0.36%,-0.36%,-0.36%
will-it-scale,lseek1_per_thread_ops,0.06%,0.06%,0.06%,0.06%,0.06%,0.06%,0.06%,0.06%,0.06%,0.06%,0.06%,0.06%
will-it-scale,lseek1_per_process_ops,0.02%,0.02%,0.02%,0.02%,0.02%,0.02%,0.02%,0.02%,0.02%,0.02%,0.02%,0.02%
will-it-scale,lock1_scalability,5.75%,5.75%,5.75%,5.75%,5.75%,5.75%,5.75%,5.75%,5.75%,5.75%,5.75%,5.75%
will-it-scale,lock1_per_thread_ops,1.44%,1.44%,1.44%,1.44%,1.44%,1.44%,1.44%,1.44%,1.44%,1.44%,1.44%,1.44%
will-it-scale,lock1_per_process_ops,6.72%,6.72%,6.72%,6.72%,6.72%,6.72%,6.72%,6.72%,6.72%,6.72%,6.72%,6.72%
will-it-scale,getppid1_scalability,-0.34%,-0.34%,-0.34%,-0.34%,-0.34%,-0.34%,-0.34%,-0.34%,-0.34%,-0.34%,-0.34%,-0.34%
will-it-scale,getppid1_per_thread_ops,0.62%,0.62%,0.62%,0.62%,0.62%,0.62%,0.62%,0.62%,0.62%,0.62%,0.62%,0.62%
will-it-scale,getppid1_per_process_ops,0.00%,0.00%,0.00%,0.00%,0.00%,0.00%,0.00%,0.00%,0.00%,0.00%,0.00%,0.00%
will-it-scale,futex4_scalability,-0.33%,-0.33%,-0.33%,-0.33%,-0.33%,-0.33%,-0.33%,-0.33%,-0.33%,-0.33%,-0.33%,-0.33%
will-it-scale,futex4_per_thread_ops,-1.74%,-1.74%,-1.74%,-1.74%,-1.74%,-1.74%,-1.74%,-1.74%,-1.74%,-1.74%,-1.74%,-1.74%
will-it-scale,futex4_per_process_ops,0.10%,0.10%,0.10%,0.10%,0.10%,0.10%,0.10%,0.10%,0.10%,0.10%,0.10%,0.10%
will-it-scale,futex3_scalability,0.00%,0.00%,0.00%,0.00%,0.00%,0.00%,0.00%,0.00%,0.00%,0.00%,0.00%,0.00%
will-it-scale,futex3_per_thread_ops,-0.20%,-0.20%,-0.20%,-0.20%,-0.20%,-0.20%,-0.20%,-0.20%,-0.20%,-0.20%,-0.20%,-0.20%
will-it-scale,futex3_per_process_ops,0.16%,0.16%,0.16%,0.16%,0.16%,0.16%,0.16%,0.16%,0.16%,0.16%,0.16%,0.16%
will-it-scale,futex2_scalability,0.53%,0.53%,0.53%,0.53%,0.53%,0.53%,0.53%,0.53%,0.53%,0.53%,0.53%,0.53%
will-it-scale,futex2_per_thread_ops,-0.92%,-0.92%,-0.92%,-0.92%,-0.92%,-0.92%,-0.92%,-0.92%,-0.92%,-0.92%,-0.92%,-0.92%
will-it-scale,futex2_per_process_ops,-0.18%,-0.18%,-0.18%,-0.18%,-0.18%,-0.18%,-0.18%,-0.18%,-0.18%,-0.18%,-0.18%,-0.18%
will-it-scale,futex1_scalability,-0.47%,-0.47%,-0.47%,-0.47%,-0.47%,-0.47%,-0.47%,-0.47%,-0.47%,-0.47%,-0.47%,-0.47%
will-it-scale,futex1_per_thread_ops,-0.17%,-0.17%,-0.17%,-0.17%,-0.17%,-0.17%,-0.17%,-0.17%,-0.17%,-0.17%,-0.17%,-0.17%
will-it-scale,futex1_per_process_ops,0.22%,0.22%,0.22%,0.22%,0.22%,0.22%,0.22%,0.22%,0.22%,0.22%,0.22%,0.22%
will-it-scale,eventfd1_scalability,0.53%,0.53%,0.53%,0.53%,0.53%,0.53%,0.53%,0.53%,0.53%,0.53%,0.53%,0.53%
will-it-scale,eventfd1_per_thread_ops,-0.38%,-0.38%,-0.38%,-0.38%,-0.38%,-0.38%,-0.38%,-0.38%,-0.38%,-0.38%,-0.38%,-0.38%
will-it-scale,eventfd1_per_process_ops,-0.14%,-0.14%,-0.14%,-0.14%,-0.14%,-0.14%,-0.14%,-0.14%,-0.14%,-0.14%,-0.14%,-0.14%
will-it-scale,dup1_scalability,0.93%,0.93%,0.93%,0.93%,0.93%,0.93%,0.93%,0.93%,0.93%,0.93%,0.93%,0.93%
will-it-scale,dup1_per_thread_ops,-0.16%,-0.16%,-0.16%,-0.16%,-0.16%,-0.16%,-0.16%,-0.16%,-0.16%,-0.16%,-0.16%,-0.16%
will-it-scale,dup1_per_process_ops,0.04%,0.04%,0.04%,0.04%,0.04%,0.04%,0.04%,0.04%,0.04%,0.04%,0.04%,0.04%
will-it-scale,context_switch1_scalability,2.05%,2.05%,2.05%,2.05%,2.05%,2.05%,2.05%,2.05%,2.05%,2.05%,2.05%,2.05%
will-it-scale,context_switch1_per_thread_ops,1.55%,1.55%,1.55%,1.55%,1.55%,1.55%,1.55%,1.55%,1.55%,1.55%,1.55%,1.55%
will-it-scale,context_switch1_per_process_ops,4.03%,4.03%,4.03%,4.03%,4.03%,4.03%,4.03%,4.03%,4.03%,4.03%,4.03%,4.03%
will-it-scale,brk1_scalability,-2.98%,-2.98%,-2.98%,-2.98%,-2.98%,-2.98%,-2.98%,-2.98%,-2.98%,-2.98%,-2.98%,-2.98%
will-it-scale,brk1_per_thread_ops,14.86%,14.86%,14.86%,14.86%,14.86%,14.86%,14.86%,14.86%,14.86%,14.86%,14.86%,14.86%
will-it-scale,brk1_per_process_ops,4.42%,4.42%,4.42%,4.42%,4.42%,4.42%,4.42%,4.42%,4.42%,4.42%,4.42%,4.42%
will-it-scale,SUnreclaim,36.47%,46.20%,33.92%,33.58%,36.66%,36.74%,73.92%,29.09%,34.36%,34.26%,37.13%,38.71%
will-it-scale,SReclaimable,22.97%,13.14%,16.54%,15.17%,23.15%,24.11%,88.53%,14.67%,15.88%,12.58%,12.37%,13.01%
,,,,,,,,,,,,,
benchmark_name,metric_name,min,max,mean,median,p1,p2,p5,p10,p90,p95,p98,p99
kernbench,kernbench_user_max,-0.24%,-0.48%,-0.31%,-0.29%,-0.25%,-0.25%,-0.28%,-0.33%,-0.33%,-0.41%,-0.45%,-0.47%
kernbench,kernbench_user_256,-0.24%,-0.48%,-0.31%,-0.29%,-0.25%,-0.25%,-0.28%,-0.33%,-0.33%,-0.41%,-0.45%,-0.47%
kernbench,kernbench_syst_max,-1.69%,-1.43%,-1.40%,-1.20%,-1.67%,-1.66%,-1.62%,-1.56%,-1.39%,-1.41%,-1.42%,-1.42%
kernbench,kernbench_syst_256,-1.69%,-1.43%,-1.40%,-1.20%,-1.67%,-1.66%,-1.62%,-1.56%,-1.39%,-1.41%,-1.42%,-1.42%
kernbench,kernbench_elsp_max,0.31%,-0.80%,-0.38%,-0.24%,0.29%,0.26%,0.20%,0.09%,-0.84%,-0.82%,-0.81%,-0.80%
kernbench,kernbench_elsp_256,0.31%,-0.80%,-0.38%,-0.24%,0.29%,0.26%,0.20%,0.09%,-0.84%,-0.82%,-0.81%,-0.80%
kernbench,SUnreclaim,34.31%,16.15%,24.54%,26.57%,34.31%,34.31%,33.95%,33.99%,16.45%,16.24%,16.18%,16.16%
kernbench,SReclaimable,24.11%,10.16%,16.40%,15.78%,24.55%,24.98%,25.45%,26.11%,10.23%,10.20%,10.17%,10.17%
,,,,,,,,,,,,,
benchmark_name,metric_name,min,max,mean,median,p1,p2,p5,p10,p90,p95,p98,p99
specjbb2015,specjbb2015_single_SLA_minus,-6.43%,-6.43%,-6.43%,-6.43%,-6.43%,-6.43%,-6.43%,-6.43%,-6.43%,-6.43%,-6.43%,-6.43%
specjbb2015,specjbb2015_single_SLA_maxus,-7.31%,-7.31%,-7.31%,-7.31%,-7.31%,-7.31%,-7.31%,-7.31%,-7.31%,-7.31%,-7.31%,-7.31%
specjbb2015,specjbb2015_single_SLA_75000us,-4.91%,-4.91%,-4.91%,-4.91%,-4.91%,-4.91%,-4.91%,-4.91%,-4.91%,-4.91%,-4.91%,-4.91%
specjbb2015,specjbb2015_single_SLA_50000us,-5.91%,-5.91%,-5.91%,-5.91%,-5.91%,-5.91%,-5.91%,-5.91%,-5.91%,-5.91%,-5.91%,-5.91%
specjbb2015,specjbb2015_single_SLA_25000us,-2.28%,-2.28%,-2.28%,-2.28%,-2.28%,-2.28%,-2.28%,-2.28%,-2.28%,-2.28%,-2.28%,-2.28%
specjbb2015,specjbb2015_single_SLA_10000us,-6.43%,-6.43%,-6.43%,-6.43%,-6.43%,-6.43%,-6.43%,-6.43%,-6.43%,-6.43%,-6.43%,-6.43%
specjbb2015,specjbb2015_single_SLA_100000us,-7.31%,-7.31%,-7.31%,-7.31%,-7.31%,-7.31%,-7.31%,-7.31%,-7.31%,-7.31%,-7.31%,-7.31%
specjbb2015,specjbb2015_single_Max_JOPS,-8.98%,-8.98%,-8.98%,-8.98%,-8.98%,-8.98%,-8.98%,-8.98%,-8.98%,-8.98%,-8.98%,-8.98%
specjbb2015,specjbb2015_single_Critical_JOPS,-5.38%,-5.38%,-5.38%,-5.38%,-5.38%,-5.38%,-5.38%,-5.38%,-5.38%,-5.38%,-5.38%,-5.38%
specjbb2015,SUnreclaim,34.56%,34.11%,32.28%,33.39%,25.65%,25.63%,26.65%,28.26%,34.26%,34.27%,34.19%,34.20%
specjbb2015,SReclaimable,22.01%,18.81%,18.18%,18.92%,14.55%,14.65%,15.12%,15.51%,18.78%,18.66%,18.16%,17.68%
,,,,,,,,,,,,,
benchmark_name,metric_name,min,max,mean,median,p1,p2,p5,p10,p90,p95,p98,p99
redis,redis_small_max_SPOP,-9.12%,43.58%,17.56%,-6.73%,-8.26%,-7.40%,-4.88%,-0.79%,41.29%,42.45%,43.13%,43.36%
redis,redis_small_max_SET,-28.97%,6.61%,-5.26%,-15.78%,-27.87%,-26.77%,-23.51%,-18.15%,7.59%,7.09%,6.80%,6.70%
redis,redis_small_max_SADD,10.73%,-35.98%,-2.79%,17.02%,10.85%,10.97%,11.32%,11.87%,-22.27%,-29.80%,-33.64%,-34.83%
redis,redis_small_max_PING_INLINE,-1.39%,10.06%,2.20%,-4.30%,-1.23%,-1.07%,-0.58%,0.23%,6.95%,8.56%,9.47%,9.77%
redis,redis_small_max_PING_BULK,11.76%,-10.53%,5.10%,22.90%,11.61%,11.45%,10.99%,10.24%,-4.85%,-7.80%,-9.46%,-10.00%
redis,redis_small_max_MSET_10,-3.11%,-11.83%,-10.76%,-17.19%,-3.36%,-3.61%,-4.34%,-5.53%,-11.54%,-11.69%,-11.78%,-11.81%
redis,redis_small_max_LRANGE_600,0.87%,0.29%,0.80%,1.36%,0.87%,0.88%,0.89%,0.91%,0.39%,0.34%,0.31%,0.30%
redis,redis_small_max_LRANGE_500,0.53%,-0.95%,-0.01%,-0.02%,0.52%,0.52%,0.51%,0.50%,-0.59%,-0.77%,-0.88%,-0.91%
redis,redis_small_max_LRANGE_300,2.26%,1.28%,1.68%,1.12%,2.24%,2.22%,2.16%,2.05%,1.57%,1.42%,1.34%,1.31%
redis,redis_small_max_LRANGE_100,-14.97%,6.62%,-6.97%,-10.56%,-14.77%,-14.58%,-14.00%,-13.05%,1.35%,3.99%,5.57%,6.09%
redis,redis_small_max_LPUSH,-11.28%,5.64%,-3.39%,-10.89%,-10.14%,-9.00%,-5.66%,-0.32%,17.99%,11.41%,7.86%,6.74%
redis,redis_small_max_LPOP,2.16%,14.41%,8.81%,7.50%,2.11%,2.06%,1.91%,1.66%,15.53%,14.97%,14.63%,14.52%
redis,redis_small_max_INCR,25.51%,-9.65%,14.99%,22.49%,25.35%,25.20%,24.75%,24.03%,2.18%,-4.11%,-7.51%,-8.59%
redis,redis_small_max_GET,5.50%,28.25%,21.94%,39.46%,5.54%,5.58%,5.70%,5.90%,27.68%,27.97%,28.14%,28.20%
redis,redis_small_256_SPOP,-9.12%,43.58%,17.56%,-6.73%,-8.26%,-7.40%,-4.88%,-0.79%,41.29%,42.45%,43.13%,43.36%
redis,redis_small_256_SET,-28.97%,6.61%,-5.26%,-15.78%,-27.87%,-26.77%,-23.51%,-18.15%,7.59%,7.09%,6.80%,6.70%
redis,redis_small_256_SADD,10.73%,-35.98%,-2.79%,17.02%,10.85%,10.97%,11.32%,11.87%,-22.27%,-29.80%,-33.64%,-34.83%
redis,redis_small_256_PING_INLINE,-1.39%,10.06%,2.20%,-4.30%,-1.23%,-1.07%,-0.58%,0.23%,6.95%,8.56%,9.47%,9.77%
redis,redis_small_256_PING_BULK,11.76%,-10.53%,5.10%,22.90%,11.61%,11.45%,10.99%,10.24%,-4.85%,-7.80%,-9.46%,-10.00%
redis,redis_small_256_MSET_10,-3.11%,-11.83%,-10.76%,-17.19%,-3.36%,-3.61%,-4.34%,-5.53%,-11.54%,-11.69%,-11.78%,-11.81%
redis,redis_small_256_LRANGE_600,0.87%,0.29%,0.80%,1.36%,0.87%,0.88%,0.89%,0.91%,0.39%,0.34%,0.31%,0.30%
redis,redis_small_256_LRANGE_500,0.53%,-0.95%,-0.01%,-0.02%,0.52%,0.52%,0.51%,0.50%,-0.59%,-0.77%,-0.88%,-0.91%
redis,redis_small_256_LRANGE_300,2.26%,1.28%,1.68%,1.12%,2.24%,2.22%,2.16%,2.05%,1.57%,1.42%,1.34%,1.31%
redis,redis_small_256_LRANGE_100,-14.97%,6.62%,-6.97%,-10.56%,-14.77%,-14.58%,-14.00%,-13.05%,1.35%,3.99%,5.57%,6.09%
redis,redis_small_256_LPUSH,-11.28%,5.64%,-3.39%,-10.89%,-10.14%,-9.00%,-5.66%,-0.32%,17.99%,11.41%,7.86%,6.74%
redis,redis_small_256_LPOP,2.16%,14.41%,8.81%,7.50%,2.11%,2.06%,1.91%,1.66%,15.53%,14.97%,14.63%,14.52%
redis,redis_small_256_INCR,25.51%,-9.65%,14.99%,22.49%,25.35%,25.20%,24.75%,24.03%,2.18%,-4.11%,-7.51%,-8.59%
redis,redis_small_256_GET,5.50%,28.25%,21.94%,39.46%,5.54%,5.58%,5.70%,5.90%,27.68%,27.97%,28.14%,28.20%
redis,redis_medium_max_SPOP,-4.05%,-3.44%,0.23%,0.66%,-3.75%,-3.46%,-2.57%,-1.09%,-0.28%,-1.89%,-2.83%,-3.13%
redis,redis_medium_max_SET,-1.05%,-0.34%,-1.15%,-0.15%,-1.13%,-1.22%,-1.47%,-1.88%,-0.65%,-0.49%,-0.40%,-0.37%
redis,redis_medium_max_SADD,-3.17%,9.03%,0.84%,-1.67%,-2.98%,-2.80%,-2.25%,-1.34%,4.74%,6.89%,8.18%,8.60%
redis,redis_medium_max_PING_INLINE,0.39%,0.32%,-2.88%,-4.12%,0.27%,0.16%,-0.18%,-0.73%,-3.12%,-1.40%,-0.36%,-0.02%
redis,redis_medium_max_PING_BULK,-4.10%,-11.44%,-5.65%,-3.40%,-3.95%,-3.80%,-3.36%,-2.61%,-10.02%,-10.74%,-11.17%,-11.30%
redis,redis_medium_max_MSET_10,-4.09%,-6.40%,-4.61%,-4.08%,-4.04%,-4.00%,-3.87%,-3.65%,-5.96%,-6.19%,-6.32%,-6.36%
redis,redis_medium_max_LRANGE_600,0.40%,-1.51%,-2.05%,-3.07%,0.22%,0.05%,-0.46%,-1.30%,-1.80%,-1.65%,-1.56%,-1.53%
redis,redis_medium_max_LRANGE_500,-1.29%,-0.71%,-1.31%,-1.89%,-1.29%,-1.29%,-1.28%,-1.27%,-0.99%,-0.85%,-0.77%,-0.74%
redis,redis_medium_max_LRANGE_300,-2.76%,-0.17%,-1.40%,-1.46%,-2.72%,-2.69%,-2.58%,-2.40%,-0.41%,-0.29%,-0.22%,-0.20%
redis,redis_medium_max_LRANGE_100,-1.49%,4.13%,0.50%,1.15%,-1.51%,-1.52%,-1.55%,-1.61%,2.62%,3.38%,3.83%,3.98%
redis,redis_medium_max_LPUSH,-3.46%,-2.93%,-2.56%,-0.71%,-2.69%,-1.93%,0.33%,4.05%,-7.89%,-5.40%,-3.91%,-3.42%
redis,redis_medium_max_LPOP,-7.24%,2.66%,-4.39%,-6.46%,-7.22%,-7.20%,-7.13%,-7.03%,-0.26%,1.21%,2.08%,2.37%
redis,redis_medium_max_INCR,-4.55%,0.10%,-2.82%,-2.34%,-4.47%,-4.38%,-4.13%,-3.72%,-1.91%,-0.91%,-0.30%,-0.10%
redis,redis_medium_max_GET,-0.23%,1.32%,-0.45%,-2.60%,-0.48%,-0.73%,-1.47%,-2.68%,2.85%,2.08%,1.62%,1.47%
redis,redis_medium_256_SPOP,-4.05%,-3.44%,0.23%,0.66%,-3.75%,-3.46%,-2.57%,-1.09%,-0.28%,-1.89%,-2.83%,-3.13%
redis,redis_medium_256_SET,-1.05%,-0.34%,-1.15%,-0.15%,-1.13%,-1.22%,-1.47%,-1.88%,-0.65%,-0.49%,-0.40%,-0.37%
redis,redis_medium_256_SADD,-3.17%,9.03%,0.84%,-1.67%,-2.98%,-2.80%,-2.25%,-1.34%,4.74%,6.89%,8.18%,8.60%
redis,redis_medium_256_PING_INLINE,0.39%,0.32%,-2.88%,-4.12%,0.27%,0.16%,-0.18%,-0.73%,-3.12%,-1.40%,-0.36%,-0.02%
redis,redis_medium_256_PING_BULK,-4.10%,-11.44%,-5.65%,-3.40%,-3.95%,-3.80%,-3.36%,-2.61%,-10.02%,-10.74%,-11.17%,-11.30%
redis,redis_medium_256_MSET_10,-4.09%,-6.40%,-4.61%,-4.08%,-4.04%,-4.00%,-3.87%,-3.65%,-5.96%,-6.19%,-6.32%,-6.36%
redis,redis_medium_256_LRANGE_600,0.40%,-1.51%,-2.05%,-3.07%,0.22%,0.05%,-0.46%,-1.30%,-1.80%,-1.65%,-1.56%,-1.53%
redis,redis_medium_256_LRANGE_500,-1.29%,-0.71%,-1.31%,-1.89%,-1.29%,-1.29%,-1.28%,-1.27%,-0.99%,-0.85%,-0.77%,-0.74%
redis,redis_medium_256_LRANGE_300,-2.76%,-0.17%,-1.40%,-1.46%,-2.72%,-2.69%,-2.58%,-2.40%,-0.41%,-0.29%,-0.22%,-0.20%
redis,redis_medium_256_LRANGE_100,-1.49%,4.13%,0.50%,1.15%,-1.51%,-1.52%,-1.55%,-1.61%,2.62%,3.38%,3.83%,3.98%
redis,redis_medium_256_LPUSH,-3.46%,-2.93%,-2.56%,-0.71%,-2.69%,-1.93%,0.33%,4.05%,-7.89%,-5.40%,-3.91%,-3.42%
redis,redis_medium_256_LPOP,-7.24%,2.66%,-4.39%,-6.46%,-7.22%,-7.20%,-7.13%,-7.03%,-0.26%,1.21%,2.08%,2.37%
redis,redis_medium_256_INCR,-4.55%,0.10%,-2.82%,-2.34%,-4.47%,-4.38%,-4.13%,-3.72%,-1.91%,-0.91%,-0.30%,-0.10%
redis,redis_medium_256_GET,-0.23%,1.32%,-0.45%,-2.60%,-0.48%,-0.73%,-1.47%,-2.68%,2.85%,2.08%,1.62%,1.47%
redis,SUnreclaim,35.48%,31.68%,32.93%,33.42%,29.98%,27.85%,28.88%,31.35%,33.79%,33.38%,32.93%,32.14%
redis,SReclaimable,23.17%,19.49%,17.17%,17.08%,18.20%,16.00%,14.96%,15.40%,18.45%,18.19%,19.14%,19.66%
,,,,,,,,,,,,,
benchmark_name,metric_name,min,max,mean,median,p1,p2,p5,p10,p90,p95,p98,p99
stream,stream_single_triad,2.12%,1.44%,1.55%,1.10%,2.10%,2.08%,2.02%,1.92%,1.37%,1.40%,1.42%,1.43%
stream,stream_single_copy,2.05%,1.59%,1.79%,1.74%,2.04%,2.04%,2.02%,1.99%,1.62%,1.60%,1.59%,1.59%
stream,stream_single_cale,2.36%,0.73%,1.51%,1.46%,2.35%,2.33%,2.27%,2.18%,0.87%,0.80%,0.76%,0.75%
stream,stream_single_add,1.82%,1.18%,1.41%,1.24%,1.81%,1.80%,1.76%,1.70%,1.19%,1.19%,1.18%,1.18%
stream,stream_omp_nodes_triad,2.26%,0.36%,1.09%,0.68%,2.22%,2.19%,2.10%,1.94%,0.42%,0.39%,0.37%,0.37%
stream,stream_omp_nodes_spread_triad,0.63%,0.52%,0.58%,0.59%,0.62%,0.62%,0.62%,0.62%,0.54%,0.53%,0.53%,0.53%
stream,stream_omp_nodes_spread_copy,1.15%,1.29%,1.18%,1.08%,1.15%,1.15%,1.15%,1.14%,1.25%,1.27%,1.28%,1.29%
stream,stream_omp_nodes_spread_cale,1.49%,1.56%,1.50%,1.43%,1.49%,1.49%,1.49%,1.48%,1.54%,1.55%,1.56%,1.56%
stream,stream_omp_nodes_spread_add,0.88%,0.61%,0.79%,0.88%,0.88%,0.88%,0.88%,0.88%,0.67%,0.64%,0.63%,0.62%
stream,stream_omp_nodes_copy,2.13%,0.35%,0.99%,0.53%,2.10%,2.07%,1.97%,1.81%,0.39%,0.37%,0.36%,0.36%
stream,stream_omp_nodes_cale,2.75%,0.72%,1.44%,0.87%,2.71%,2.68%,2.56%,2.37%,0.75%,0.73%,0.72%,0.72%
stream,stream_omp_nodes_add,2.10%,0.53%,1.06%,0.56%,2.07%,2.04%,1.94%,1.79%,0.54%,0.54%,0.54%,0.54%
stream,stream_omp_llcs_triad,1.24%,0.79%,1.14%,1.40%,1.24%,1.25%,1.26%,1.27%,0.91%,0.85%,0.82%,0.80%
stream,stream_omp_llcs_spread_triad,0.65%,0.15%,0.34%,0.23%,0.64%,0.63%,0.61%,0.57%,0.16%,0.15%,0.15%,0.15%
stream,stream_omp_llcs_spread_copy,1.04%,0.92%,0.96%,0.92%,1.04%,1.04%,1.03%,1.02%,0.92%,0.92%,0.92%,0.92%
stream,stream_omp_llcs_spread_cale,0.95%,0.81%,0.84%,0.75%,0.95%,0.94%,0.93%,0.91%,0.80%,0.81%,0.81%,0.81%
stream,stream_omp_llcs_spread_add,0.66%,0.46%,0.55%,0.53%,0.65%,0.65%,0.64%,0.63%,0.47%,0.46%,0.46%,0.46%
stream,stream_omp_llcs_copy,2.16%,0.75%,1.45%,1.44%,2.15%,2.14%,2.09%,2.02%,0.89%,0.82%,0.78%,0.77%
stream,stream_omp_llcs_cale,1.69%,0.58%,1.26%,1.52%,1.68%,1.68%,1.67%,1.65%,0.77%,0.67%,0.62%,0.60%
stream,stream_omp_llcs_add,0.78%,0.82%,0.91%,1.12%,0.78%,0.79%,0.81%,0.85%,0.88%,0.85%,0.84%,0.83%
stream,SUnreclaim,64.35%,27.31%,28.12%,27.21%,51.76%,46.02%,32.05%,26.48%,27.64%,27.63%,27.49%,27.49%
stream,SReclaimable,8.62%,8.07%,7.69%,7.27%,10.02%,10.99%,9.02%,7.91%,7.79%,7.91%,8.11%,8.07%

^ permalink raw reply	[flat|nested] 13+ messages in thread

* Re: [LSF/MM/BPF TOPIC] SLOB+SLAB allocators removal and future SLUB improvements
  2023-03-22 13:02   ` Hyeonggon Yoo
  2023-03-22 13:24     ` Binder Makin
@ 2023-03-22 13:30     ` Binder Makin
  1 sibling, 0 replies; 13+ messages in thread
From: Binder Makin @ 2023-03-22 13:30 UTC (permalink / raw)
  To: Hyeonggon Yoo
  Cc: Vlastimil Babka, lsf-pc, linux-fsdevel, linux-mm, linux-block,
	bpf, linux-xfs, David Rientjes, Christoph Lameter, Pekka Enberg,
	Joonsoo Kim, Roman Gushchin

Blah, sorry, lets try this.
https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/e/2PACX-1vS1uiw85AIpzgcVlvNlDCD9PuCIubiaJvBrKIC5OyAQURZHogOuCtpFNsC-zGHZ4-XNKJVcGgkpL-KH/pubhtml

On Wed, Mar 22, 2023 at 9:02 AM Hyeonggon Yoo <42.hyeyoo@gmail.com> wrote:
>
> On Wed, Mar 22, 2023 at 08:15:28AM -0400, Binder Makin wrote:
> > Was looking at SLAB removal and started by running A/B tests of SLAB vs
> > SLUB.  Please note these are only preliminary results.
> >
> > These were run using 6.1.13 configured for SLAB/SLUB.
> > Machines were standard datacenter servers.
> >
> > Hackbench shows completion time, so smaller is better.
> > On all others larger is better.
> > https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/e/2PACX-1vQ47Mekl8BOp3ekCefwL6wL8SQiv6Qvp5avkU2ssQSh41gntjivE-aKM4PkwzkC4N_s_MxUdcsokhhz/pubhtml
> >
> > Some notes:
> > SUnreclaim and SReclaimable shows unreclaimable and reclaimable memory.
> > Substantially higher with SLUB, but I believe that is to be expected.
> >
> > Various results showing a 5-10% degradation with SLUB.  That feels
> > concerning to me, but I'm not sure what others' tolerance would be.
>
> Hello Binder,
>
> Thank you for sharing the data on which workloads
> SLUB performs worse than SLAB. This information is critical for
> improving SLUB and deprecating SLAB.
>
> By the way, it appears that the spreadsheet is currently set to private.
> Could you make it public for me to access?
>
> I am really interested in performing similar experiments on my machines
> to obtain comparable data that can be utilized to enhance SLUB.
>
> Thanks,
> Hyeonggon
>
> > redis results on AMD show some pretty bad degredations.  10-20% range
> > netpipe on Intel also has issues.. 10-17%
> >
> > On Tue, Mar 14, 2023 at 4:05 AM Vlastimil Babka <vbabka@suse.cz> wrote:
> >
> > > As you're probably aware, my plan is to get rid of SLOB and SLAB, leaving
> > > only SLUB going forward. The removal of SLOB seems to be going well, there
> > > were no objections to the deprecation and I've posted v1 of the removal
> > > itself [1] so it could be in -next soon.
> > >
> > > The immediate benefit of that is that we can allow kfree() (and
> > > kfree_rcu())
> > > to free objects from kmem_cache_alloc() - something that IIRC at least xfs
> > > people wanted in the past, and SLOB was incompatible with that.
> > >
> > > For SLAB removal I haven't yet heard any objections (but also didn't
> > > deprecate it yet) but if there are any users due to particular workloads
> > > doing better with SLAB than SLUB, we can discuss why those would regress
> > > and
> > > what can be done about that in SLUB.
> > >
> > > Once we have just one slab allocator in the kernel, we can take a closer
> > > look at what the users are missing from it that forces them to create own
> > > allocators (e.g. BPF), and could be considered to be added as a generic
> > > implementation to SLUB.
> > >
> > > Thanks,
> > > Vlastimil
> > >
> > > [1] https://lore.kernel.org/all/20230310103210.22372-1-vbabka@suse.cz/

^ permalink raw reply	[flat|nested] 13+ messages in thread

* Re: [LSF/MM/BPF TOPIC] SLOB+SLAB allocators removal and future SLUB improvements
  2023-03-22 12:30 ` Binder Makin
@ 2023-04-04 16:03   ` Vlastimil Babka
  2023-04-05 19:54     ` Binder Makin
  0 siblings, 1 reply; 13+ messages in thread
From: Vlastimil Babka @ 2023-04-04 16:03 UTC (permalink / raw)
  To: Binder Makin
  Cc: lsf-pc, linux-fsdevel, linux-mm, linux-block, bpf, linux-xfs,
	David Rientjes, Christoph Lameter, Pekka Enberg, Joonsoo Kim,
	Hyeonggon Yoo, Roman Gushchin

On 3/22/23 13:30, Binder Makin wrote:
> Was looking at SLAB removal and started by running A/B tests of SLAB
> vs SLUB.  Please note these are only preliminary results.

Thanks, that's very useful.

> These were run using 6.1.13 configured for SLAB/SLUB.
> Machines were standard datacenter servers.
> 
> Hackbench shows completion time, so smaller is better.
> On all others larger is better.
> https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/e/2PACX-1vQ47Mekl8BOp3ekCefwL6wL8SQiv6Qvp5avkU2ssQSh41gntjivE-aKM4PkwzkC4N_s_MxUdcsokhhz/pubhtml
> 
> Some notes:
> SUnreclaim and SReclaimable shows unreclaimable and reclaimable memory.
> Substantially higher with SLUB, but I believe that is to be expected.
> 
> Various results showing a 5-10% degradation with SLUB.  That feels
> concerning to me, but I'm not sure what others' tolerance would be.
> 
> redis results on AMD show some pretty bad degredations.  10-20% range
> netpipe on Intel also has issues.. 10-17%

I guess one question is which ones are genuine SLAB/SLUB differences and not
e.g. some artifact of different cache layout or something. For example it
seems suspicious if results are widely different between architectures.

E.g. will-it-scale writeseek3_scalability regresses on arm64 and amd, but
improves on intel? Or is something wrong with the data, all columns for that
whole benchmark suite are identical.

hackbench ("smaller is better") seems drastically better on arm64 (30%
median time reduction?) and amd (80% reduction?!?), but 10% slower intel?

redis seems a bit improved on arm64, slightly worse on intel but much worse
on amd.

specjbb similar story, also I thought it was a java focused benchmark,
should it really be exercising kernel slab allocators in such notable way?

I guess netpipe is the least surprising as networking was always mentioned
in SLAB vs SLUB discussions.

> On Tue, Mar 14, 2023 at 4:05 AM Vlastimil Babka <vbabka@suse.cz> wrote:
>>
>> As you're probably aware, my plan is to get rid of SLOB and SLAB, leaving
>> only SLUB going forward. The removal of SLOB seems to be going well, there
>> were no objections to the deprecation and I've posted v1 of the removal
>> itself [1] so it could be in -next soon.
>>
>> The immediate benefit of that is that we can allow kfree() (and kfree_rcu())
>> to free objects from kmem_cache_alloc() - something that IIRC at least xfs
>> people wanted in the past, and SLOB was incompatible with that.
>>
>> For SLAB removal I haven't yet heard any objections (but also didn't
>> deprecate it yet) but if there are any users due to particular workloads
>> doing better with SLAB than SLUB, we can discuss why those would regress and
>> what can be done about that in SLUB.
>>
>> Once we have just one slab allocator in the kernel, we can take a closer
>> look at what the users are missing from it that forces them to create own
>> allocators (e.g. BPF), and could be considered to be added as a generic
>> implementation to SLUB.
>>
>> Thanks,
>> Vlastimil
>>
>> [1] https://lore.kernel.org/all/20230310103210.22372-1-vbabka@suse.cz/
>>


^ permalink raw reply	[flat|nested] 13+ messages in thread

* Re: [LSF/MM/BPF TOPIC] SLOB+SLAB allocators removal and future SLUB improvements
  2023-04-04 16:03   ` Vlastimil Babka
@ 2023-04-05 19:54     ` Binder Makin
  2023-04-27  8:29       ` Vlastimil Babka
  0 siblings, 1 reply; 13+ messages in thread
From: Binder Makin @ 2023-04-05 19:54 UTC (permalink / raw)
  To: Vlastimil Babka
  Cc: lsf-pc, linux-fsdevel, linux-mm, linux-block, bpf, linux-xfs,
	David Rientjes, Christoph Lameter, Pekka Enberg, Joonsoo Kim,
	Hyeonggon Yoo, Roman Gushchin

I'm still running tests to explore some of these questions.
The machines I am using are roughly as follows.

Intel dual socket 56 total cores
192-384GB ram
LEVEL1_ICACHE_SIZE                 32768
LEVEL1_DCACHE_SIZE                 32768
LEVEL2_CACHE_SIZE                  1048576
LEVEL3_CACHE_SIZE                  40370176

Amd dual socket 128 total cores
1TB ram
LEVEL1_ICACHE_SIZE                 32768
LEVEL1_DCACHE_SIZE                 32768
LEVEL2_CACHE_SIZE                  524288
LEVEL3_CACHE_SIZE                  268435456

Arm single socket 64 total cores
256GB rma
LEVEL1_ICACHE_SIZE                 65536
LEVEL1_DCACHE_SIZE                 65536
LEVEL2_CACHE_SIZE                  1048576
LEVEL3_CACHE_SIZE                  33554432

On Tue, Apr 4, 2023 at 12:03 PM Vlastimil Babka <vbabka@suse.cz> wrote:
>
> On 3/22/23 13:30, Binder Makin wrote:
> > Was looking at SLAB removal and started by running A/B tests of SLAB
> > vs SLUB.  Please note these are only preliminary results.
>
> Thanks, that's very useful.
>
> > These were run using 6.1.13 configured for SLAB/SLUB.
> > Machines were standard datacenter servers.
> >
> > Hackbench shows completion time, so smaller is better.
> > On all others larger is better.
> > https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/e/2PACX-1vQ47Mekl8BOp3ekCefwL6wL8SQiv6Qvp5avkU2ssQSh41gntjivE-aKM4PkwzkC4N_s_MxUdcsokhhz/pubhtml
> >
> > Some notes:
> > SUnreclaim and SReclaimable shows unreclaimable and reclaimable memory.
> > Substantially higher with SLUB, but I believe that is to be expected.
> >
> > Various results showing a 5-10% degradation with SLUB.  That feels
> > concerning to me, but I'm not sure what others' tolerance would be.
> >
> > redis results on AMD show some pretty bad degredations.  10-20% range
> > netpipe on Intel also has issues.. 10-17%
>
> I guess one question is which ones are genuine SLAB/SLUB differences and not
> e.g. some artifact of different cache layout or something. For example it
> seems suspicious if results are widely different between architectures.
>
> E.g. will-it-scale writeseek3_scalability regresses on arm64 and amd, but
> improves on intel? Or is something wrong with the data, all columns for that
> whole benchmark suite are identical.
>
> hackbench ("smaller is better") seems drastically better on arm64 (30%
> median time reduction?) and amd (80% reduction?!?), but 10% slower intel?
>
> redis seems a bit improved on arm64, slightly worse on intel but much worse
> on amd.
>
> specjbb similar story, also I thought it was a java focused benchmark,
> should it really be exercising kernel slab allocators in such notable way?
>
> I guess netpipe is the least surprising as networking was always mentioned
> in SLAB vs SLUB discussions.
>
> > On Tue, Mar 14, 2023 at 4:05 AM Vlastimil Babka <vbabka@suse.cz> wrote:
> >>
> >> As you're probably aware, my plan is to get rid of SLOB and SLAB, leaving
> >> only SLUB going forward. The removal of SLOB seems to be going well, there
> >> were no objections to the deprecation and I've posted v1 of the removal
> >> itself [1] so it could be in -next soon.
> >>
> >> The immediate benefit of that is that we can allow kfree() (and kfree_rcu())
> >> to free objects from kmem_cache_alloc() - something that IIRC at least xfs
> >> people wanted in the past, and SLOB was incompatible with that.
> >>
> >> For SLAB removal I haven't yet heard any objections (but also didn't
> >> deprecate it yet) but if there are any users due to particular workloads
> >> doing better with SLAB than SLUB, we can discuss why those would regress and
> >> what can be done about that in SLUB.
> >>
> >> Once we have just one slab allocator in the kernel, we can take a closer
> >> look at what the users are missing from it that forces them to create own
> >> allocators (e.g. BPF), and could be considered to be added as a generic
> >> implementation to SLUB.
> >>
> >> Thanks,
> >> Vlastimil
> >>
> >> [1] https://lore.kernel.org/all/20230310103210.22372-1-vbabka@suse.cz/
> >>
>

^ permalink raw reply	[flat|nested] 13+ messages in thread

* Re: [LSF/MM/BPF TOPIC] SLOB+SLAB allocators removal and future SLUB improvements
  2023-04-05 19:54     ` Binder Makin
@ 2023-04-27  8:29       ` Vlastimil Babka
  2023-05-05 19:44         ` Binder Makin
  0 siblings, 1 reply; 13+ messages in thread
From: Vlastimil Babka @ 2023-04-27  8:29 UTC (permalink / raw)
  To: Binder Makin
  Cc: lsf-pc, linux-fsdevel, linux-mm, linux-block, bpf, linux-xfs,
	David Rientjes, Christoph Lameter, Pekka Enberg, Joonsoo Kim,
	Hyeonggon Yoo, Roman Gushchin

On 4/5/23 21:54, Binder Makin wrote:
> I'm still running tests to explore some of these questions.
> The machines I am using are roughly as follows.
> 
> Intel dual socket 56 total cores
> 192-384GB ram
> LEVEL1_ICACHE_SIZE                 32768
> LEVEL1_DCACHE_SIZE                 32768
> LEVEL2_CACHE_SIZE                  1048576
> LEVEL3_CACHE_SIZE                  40370176
> 
> Amd dual socket 128 total cores
> 1TB ram
> LEVEL1_ICACHE_SIZE                 32768
> LEVEL1_DCACHE_SIZE                 32768
> LEVEL2_CACHE_SIZE                  524288
> LEVEL3_CACHE_SIZE                  268435456
> 
> Arm single socket 64 total cores
> 256GB rma
> LEVEL1_ICACHE_SIZE                 65536
> LEVEL1_DCACHE_SIZE                 65536
> LEVEL2_CACHE_SIZE                  1048576
> LEVEL3_CACHE_SIZE                  33554432

So with "some artifact of different cache layout" I didn't mean the
different cache sizes of the processors, but possible differences how
objects end up placed in memory by SLAB vs SLUB causing them to collide in
the cache of cause false sharing less or more. This kind of interference can
make interpreting (micro)benchmark results hard.

Anyway, how I'd hope to approach this topic would be that SLAB removal is
proposed, and anyone who opposes that because they can't switch from SLAB to
SLUB would describe why they can't. I'd hope the "why" to be based on
testing with actual workloads, not just benchmarks. Benchmarks are then of
course useful if they can indeed distill the reason why the actual workload
regresses, as then anyone can reproduce that locally and develop/test fixes
etc. My hope is that if some kind of regression is found (e.g. due to lack
of percpu array in SLUB), it can be dealt with by improving SLUB.

Historically I recall that we (SUSE) objected somwhat to SLAB removal as our
distro kernels were using it, but we have switched since. Then networking
had concerns (possibly related to the lack percpu array) but seems bulk
allocations helped and they use SLUB these days [1]. And IIRC Google was
also sticking to SLAB, which led to some attempts to augment SLUB for those
workloads years ago, but those were never finished. So I'd be curious if we
should restart those effors or can just remove SLAB now.

[1] https://lore.kernel.org/all/93665604-5420-be5d-2104-17850288b955@redhat.com/



^ permalink raw reply	[flat|nested] 13+ messages in thread

* Re: [LSF/MM/BPF TOPIC] SLOB+SLAB allocators removal and future SLUB improvements
  2023-04-27  8:29       ` Vlastimil Babka
@ 2023-05-05 19:44         ` Binder Makin
  0 siblings, 0 replies; 13+ messages in thread
From: Binder Makin @ 2023-05-05 19:44 UTC (permalink / raw)
  To: Vlastimil Babka
  Cc: lsf-pc, linux-fsdevel, linux-mm, linux-block, bpf, linux-xfs,
	David Rientjes, Christoph Lameter, Pekka Enberg, Joonsoo Kim,
	Hyeonggon Yoo, Roman Gushchin

Here are the results of my research.
One doc is an overview fo the data and the other is a pdf of the raw data.

https://drive.google.com/file/d/1DE8QMri1Rsr7L27fORHFCmwgrMtdfPfu/view?usp=share_link

https://drive.google.com/file/d/1UwnTeqsKB0jgpnZodJ0_cM2bOHx5aR_v/view?usp=share_link

On Thu, Apr 27, 2023 at 4:29 AM Vlastimil Babka <vbabka@suse.cz> wrote:
>
> On 4/5/23 21:54, Binder Makin wrote:
> > I'm still running tests to explore some of these questions.
> > The machines I am using are roughly as follows.
> >
> > Intel dual socket 56 total cores
> > 192-384GB ram
> > LEVEL1_ICACHE_SIZE                 32768
> > LEVEL1_DCACHE_SIZE                 32768
> > LEVEL2_CACHE_SIZE                  1048576
> > LEVEL3_CACHE_SIZE                  40370176
> >
> > Amd dual socket 128 total cores
> > 1TB ram
> > LEVEL1_ICACHE_SIZE                 32768
> > LEVEL1_DCACHE_SIZE                 32768
> > LEVEL2_CACHE_SIZE                  524288
> > LEVEL3_CACHE_SIZE                  268435456
> >
> > Arm single socket 64 total cores
> > 256GB rma
> > LEVEL1_ICACHE_SIZE                 65536
> > LEVEL1_DCACHE_SIZE                 65536
> > LEVEL2_CACHE_SIZE                  1048576
> > LEVEL3_CACHE_SIZE                  33554432
>
> So with "some artifact of different cache layout" I didn't mean the
> different cache sizes of the processors, but possible differences how
> objects end up placed in memory by SLAB vs SLUB causing them to collide in
> the cache of cause false sharing less or more. This kind of interference can
> make interpreting (micro)benchmark results hard.
>
> Anyway, how I'd hope to approach this topic would be that SLAB removal is
> proposed, and anyone who opposes that because they can't switch from SLAB to
> SLUB would describe why they can't. I'd hope the "why" to be based on
> testing with actual workloads, not just benchmarks. Benchmarks are then of
> course useful if they can indeed distill the reason why the actual workload
> regresses, as then anyone can reproduce that locally and develop/test fixes
> etc. My hope is that if some kind of regression is found (e.g. due to lack
> of percpu array in SLUB), it can be dealt with by improving SLUB.
>
> Historically I recall that we (SUSE) objected somwhat to SLAB removal as our
> distro kernels were using it, but we have switched since. Then networking
> had concerns (possibly related to the lack percpu array) but seems bulk
> allocations helped and they use SLUB these days [1]. And IIRC Google was
> also sticking to SLAB, which led to some attempts to augment SLUB for those
> workloads years ago, but those were never finished. So I'd be curious if we
> should restart those effors or can just remove SLAB now.
>
> [1] https://lore.kernel.org/all/93665604-5420-be5d-2104-17850288b955@redhat.com/
>
>

^ permalink raw reply	[flat|nested] 13+ messages in thread

end of thread, other threads:[~2023-05-05 19:44 UTC | newest]

Thread overview: 13+ messages (download: mbox.gz / follow: Atom feed)
-- links below jump to the message on this page --
2023-03-14  8:05 [LSF/MM/BPF TOPIC] SLOB+SLAB allocators removal and future SLUB improvements Vlastimil Babka
2023-03-14 13:06 ` Matthew Wilcox
2023-03-15  2:54 ` Roman Gushchin
2023-03-16  8:18   ` Vlastimil Babka
2023-03-16 20:20     ` Roman Gushchin
2023-03-22 12:30 ` Binder Makin
2023-04-04 16:03   ` Vlastimil Babka
2023-04-05 19:54     ` Binder Makin
2023-04-27  8:29       ` Vlastimil Babka
2023-05-05 19:44         ` Binder Makin
     [not found] ` <CAANmLtzajny8ZK_QKVYOxLc8L9gyWG6Uu7YyL-CR-qfwphVTzg@mail.gmail.com>
2023-03-22 13:02   ` Hyeonggon Yoo
2023-03-22 13:24     ` Binder Makin
2023-03-22 13:30     ` Binder Makin

This is a public inbox, see mirroring instructions
for how to clone and mirror all data and code used for this inbox;
as well as URLs for NNTP newsgroup(s).