Re: [PATCH v4 00/10] klp-convert livepatch build tooling

[Miroslav Benes <mbenes@suse.cz>]

On Tue, 25 Jun 2019, Joe Lawrence wrote:

> On Tue, Jun 25, 2019 at 01:36:37PM +0200, Miroslav Benes wrote:
> >
> > [ ... snip ... ]
> >
> > If I revert commit d59cadc0a8f8 ("[squash] klp-convert: make
> > convert_rela() list-safe") (from Joe's expanded github tree), the problem
> > disappears.
> >
> > I haven't spotted any problem in the code and I cannot explain a
> > dependency on GCC version. Any ideas?
> >
> 
> I can confirm that test_klp_convert1.ko crashes with RHEL-7 and its
> older gcc.  I added some debugging printf's to klp-convert and see:
> 
>   % ./scripts/livepatch/klp-convert \
>           ./Symbols.list \
>           lib/livepatch/test_klp_convert1.klp.o \
>           lib/livepatch/test_klp_convert1.ko | \
>           grep saved_command_line
> 
>   convert_rela: oldsec: .rela.text rela @ 0x1279670 rela->sym @ 0x12791f0 (.klp.sym.vmlinux.saved_command_line,0) offset: 0x3
>   convert_rela: oldsec: .rela.text rela @ 0x1279cd0 rela->sym @ 0x12791f0 (.klp.sym.vmlinux.saved_command_line,0) offset: 0x9a
>   move_rela: rela @ 0x1279670 rela->sym @ 0x12791f0 (.klp.sym.vmlinux.saved_command_line,0) offset: 0x3
>   main: skipping rela @ 0x1279cd0 rela->sym @ 0x12791f0 (.klp.sym.vmlinux.saved_command_line,0) (!must_convert)
> 
> I think the problem is:
> 
> - Relas at different offsets, but for the same symbol may share symbol
>   storage.  Note the same rela->sym value above.
> 
> - Before d59cadc0a8f8 ("[squash] klp-convert: make convert_rela()
>   list-safe"), convert_rela() iterated through the entire section's
>   relas, moving any of the same name.  This was determined not to be
>   list safe when moving consecutive relas in the linked list.
> 
> - After d59cadc0a8f8 ("[squash] klp-convert: make convert_rela()
>   list-safe"), convert_rela() still iterates through the section relas,
>   but only updates r1->sym->klp_rela_sec instead of moving them.
>   move_rela() was added to be called by the for-each-rela loop in
>   main().
> 
>   - Bug 1: klp_rela_sec probably belongs in struct rela and not struct
>     symbol
> 
>   - Bug 2: the main loop skips over second, third, etc. matching relas
>     anyway as the shared symbol name will have already been converted

Yes, it explains the issue.
 
> The following fix might not be elegant, but I can't think of a clever
> way to handle the original issue d59cadc0a8f8 ("[squash] klp-convert:
> make convert_rela() list-safe") as well as these resulting regressions.
> So I broke out the moving of relas to a seperate loop.

It works. Thanks Joe.

> That is probably
> worth a comment and at the same time we might be able to drop some of
> these other "safe" loop traversals for ordinary list_for_each_entry.

I think _safe from list_for_each_entry_safe(rela, tmprela, &sec->relas, 
list) in the main loop could be dropped, because convert_rela() only marks 
relas and does not move them anywhere. 
Similarly, list_for_each_entry_safe(r1, r2, &oldsec->relas, list) in 
convert_rela() itself.

Miroslav