All of lore.kernel.org
 help / color / mirror / Atom feed
From: "Lukáš Doktor" <ldoktor@redhat.com>
To: KVM list <kvm@vger.kernel.org>,
	Autotest mailing list <autotest@test.kernel.org>
Subject: Re: [KVM-AUTOTEST PATCH 2/2] Add KSM test
Date: Tue, 01 Sep 2009 10:50:02 +0200	[thread overview]
Message-ID: <4A9CE03A.4010706@redhat.com> (raw)
In-Reply-To: <4A9B9C57.2020408@redhat.com>

[-- Attachment #1: Type: text/plain, Size: 86 bytes --]

I'm sorry but thunderbird apparently crippled the path. Resending as the 
attachment.

[-- Attachment #2: 0002--Add-ksm-test.patch --]
[-- Type: text/x-patch, Size: 23749 bytes --]

diff --git a/client/tests/kvm/kvm.py b/client/tests/kvm/kvm.py
index 4930e80..b9839df 100644
--- a/client/tests/kvm/kvm.py
+++ b/client/tests/kvm/kvm.py
@@ -53,6 +53,8 @@ class kvm(test.test):
                 "yum_update":   test_routine("kvm_tests", "run_yum_update"),
                 "autotest":     test_routine("kvm_tests", "run_autotest"),
                 "kvm_install":  test_routine("kvm_install", "run_kvm_install"),
+                "ksm":
+                                test_routine("kvm_tests", "run_ksm"),
                 "linux_s3":     test_routine("kvm_tests", "run_linux_s3"),
                 "stress_boot":  test_routine("kvm_tests", "run_stress_boot"),
                 "timedrift":    test_routine("kvm_tests", "run_timedrift"),
diff --git a/client/tests/kvm/kvm_tests.cfg.sample b/client/tests/kvm/kvm_tests.cfg.sample
index a83ef9b..f4a41b9 100644
--- a/client/tests/kvm/kvm_tests.cfg.sample
+++ b/client/tests/kvm/kvm_tests.cfg.sample
@@ -100,6 +100,23 @@ variants:
                 test_name = disktest
                 test_control_file = disktest.control
 
+    - ksm:
+        # Don't preprocess any vms as we need to change it's params
+        vms = ''
+        image_snapshot = yes
+        kill_vm_gracefully = no
+        type = ksm
+        variants:
+            - ratio_3:
+                ksm_ratio = 3
+            - ratio_10:
+                ksm_ratio = 10
+        variants:
+            - serial 
+                ksm_test_size = "serial"
+            - paralel
+                ksm_test_size = "paralel"
+
     - linux_s3:     install setup
         type = linux_s3
 
diff --git a/client/tests/kvm/kvm_tests.py b/client/tests/kvm/kvm_tests.py
index b100269..ada4c6b 100644
--- a/client/tests/kvm/kvm_tests.py
+++ b/client/tests/kvm/kvm_tests.py
@@ -462,6 +462,554 @@ def run_yum_update(test, params, env):
 
     session.close()
 
+def run_ksm(test, params, env):
+    """
+    Test how KSM (Kernel Shared Memory) act with more than physical memory is
+    used. In second part is also tested, how KVM can handle the situation,
+    when the host runs out of memory (expected is to pause the guest system,
+    wait until some process returns the memory and bring the guest back to life)
+
+    @param test: kvm test object.
+    @param params: Dictionary with test parameters.
+    @param env: Dictionary with the test wnvironment.
+    """
+    # We are going to create the main VM so we use kvm_preprocess functions
+    # FIXME: not a nice thing
+    import kvm_preprocessing
+    import random
+    import socket
+    import select
+    import math
+
+    class allocator_com:
+        """
+        This class is used for communication with the allocator
+        """
+        def __init__(self, vm, _port, _host='127.0.0.1'):
+            self.vm = vm
+            self.PORT = _port
+            self.HOST = _host
+            self.socket = socket.socket(socket.AF_INET, socket.SOCK_STREAM)
+            self.isConnect = False
+
+        def __str__(self):
+            return self.vm + ":" + self.HOST + ":" + str(self.PORT)
+
+        def connect(self):
+            print self
+            logging.debug("ALLOC: connect to %s", self.vm)
+            try:
+                self.socket.connect((self.HOST, self.PORT))
+            except:
+                raise error.TestFail("ALLOC: Could not establish the "\
+                                     "communication with %s" % (self.vm))
+            self.isConnect = True
+        
+        def isConnected(self):
+            return self.isConnect;
+
+        def readsize(self):
+            read,write,error = select.select([self.socket.fileno()],[],[],0.5)
+            size = 0
+            if (self.socket.fileno() in read):
+                data = self.socket.recv(1);
+                size = "";
+                while data[0] != ':':
+                    size = size + data[0]
+                    data = self.socket.recv(1)
+            return int(size)
+
+        def _recv(self):
+            msg = ""
+            read, write, error = select.select([self.socket.fileno()],\
+                                               [], [], 0.5)
+            if (self.socket.fileno() in read):
+                size = self.readsize()
+                msg = self.socket.recv(size)
+                if (len(msg) < size):
+                    raise error.TestFail("ALLOC: Could not recive the message")
+            
+            logging.debug("ALLOC: output '%s' from %s" % (msg, self.vm))
+            return msg
+
+        def recv(self, wait=1, loops=20):
+            out = ""
+            log = ""
+            while not out.startswith("PASS") and not out.startswith("FAIL"):
+                logging.debug("Sleep(%d)" % (wait))
+                time.sleep(wait)
+                log += out
+                out = self._recv()
+
+                if loops == 0:
+                    logging.error(repr(out))
+                    raise error.TestFail("Command wasn't finished until DL")
+                loops = loops - 1
+
+            if not out.startswith("PASS"):
+                logging.error("Allocator failed on guest %s\nAttaching the"\
+                              "recent log"  % (self.vm))
+                raise error.TestFail(log)
+
+            return out
+            
+
+        def send(self, command, data=""):
+            msg = str(len(command) + len(data) + 3)
+            msg += ":" + command + ":" + data + ";"
+            logging.debug("ALLOC: execute %s on %s" %(repr(msg), self.vm))
+            try:
+                self.socket.sendall(msg)
+            except:
+                raise error.TestFail("ALLOC: Could not send the message")
+
+        def disconnect(self):
+            logging.debug("ALLOC: disconnect")
+            self.send("exit")
+            self.recv()
+            time.sleep(5)
+            self.socket.close()
+            self.isConnect = False
+
+    def get_stat(lvms):
+        """
+        Get statistics in format:
+        Host: memfree = XXXM; Guests memsh = {XXX,XXX,...}
+
+        @params lvms: List of VMs
+        """
+        if not isinstance(lvms, list):
+            raise error.TestError("get_stat: parameter have to be proper list")
+
+        try:
+            stat = "Host: memfree = "
+            stat += str(int(os.popen("cat /proc/meminfo | grep MemFree")\
+                                     .readline().split()[1]) / 1024) + "M; "
+            stat += "swapfree = "
+            stat += str(int(os.popen("cat /proc/meminfo | grep SwapFree")\
+                                     .readline().split()[1]) / 1024) + "M; "
+        except:
+            raise error.TestFail("Could not fetch free memory info")
+
+
+        stat += "Guests memsh = {"
+        for vm in lvms:
+            try:
+                cmd = "cat /proc/%d/statm" % vm.pid
+                shm = int(os.popen(cmd).readline().split()[2])
+                # statm stores informations in pages, recalculate to MB
+                shm = shm * 4 / 1024
+                stat += "%dM; " % (shm)
+            except:
+                raise error.TestError("Could not fetch shmem info from proc")
+        stat = stat[0:-2] + "}"
+        return stat
+    
+    
+    
+
+
+    logging.info("Starting phase 0: Initialization")
+    # host_reserve: mem reserve keept for the host system to run
+    host_reserve = 256
+    # guest_reserve: mem reserve which is not used by allocator on the guests
+    guest_reserve = 256
+    max_alloc = 10
+    max_vms = params.get("max_vms")
+    if max_vms:
+        max_vms = int(max_vms)
+    else:
+        max_vms = 2
+    overcommit = params.get("ksm_overcommit_ratio")
+    if overcommit:
+        overcommit = float(overcommit)
+    else:
+        overcommit = 2.0
+    # vmsc: count of all used VMs
+    vmsc = int(overcommit) + 1
+    vmsc = max(vmsc, max_vms)
+    
+    if (params['ksm_test_size'] == "paralel") :
+        host_mem = (int(os.popen("grep MemTotal: /proc/meminfo")\
+                       .readline().split()[1]) / 1024 - host_reserve)
+        vmsc = 1
+        overcommit = 1
+        mem = host_mem
+        # 32bit system adjustment
+        if not params['image_name'].endswith("64"):
+            logging.debug("Probably i386 guest architecture, "\
+                          "max allocator mem = 2G")
+            # Guest can have more than 2G but kvm mem + 1MB (allocator itself) can't
+            if (host_mem > 2048):
+                mem = 2047 
+                
+                
+        if os.popen("uname -i").readline().startswith("i386"):
+            logging.debug("Host is i386 architecture, max guest mem is 2G")
+            # Guest system with qemu overhead (64M) can't have more than 2G
+            if mem > 2048 - 64:
+                mem = 2048 - 64
+        
+    else:
+        host_mem = (int(os.popen("grep MemTotal: /proc/meminfo")\
+                       .readline().split()[1]) / 1024 - host_reserve)
+        # mem: Memory of the guest systems. Maximum must be less than amount of the 
+        # host's physical ram
+        mem = int(overcommit * host_mem / vmsc)
+    
+        # 32bit system adjustment
+        if not params['image_name'].endswith("64"):
+            logging.debug("Probably i386 guest architecture, "\
+                          "max allocator mem = 2G")
+            # Guest can have more than 2G but kvm mem + 1MB (allocator itself) can't
+            if mem-guest_reserve-1 > 2048:
+                vmsc = int(math.ceil((host_mem*overcommit)/(2048.0+guest_reserve))) 
+                mem = int(math.floor(host_mem*overcommit/vmsc))
+                
+        if os.popen("uname -i").readline().startswith("i386"):
+            logging.debug("Host is i386 architecture, max guest mem is 2G")
+            # Guest system with qemu overhead (64M) can't have more than 2G
+            if mem > 2048 - 64:
+                vmsc = int(math.ceil((host_mem*overcommit)/(2048 - 64.0))) 
+                mem = int(math.floor(host_mem*overcommit/vmsc))
+    
+    
+    logging.info("overcommit = %f" % (overcommit))
+    logging.info("true overcommit = %f " % (float(vmsc*mem) / float(host_mem)))
+    logging.info("host mem = %dM" % (host_mem))
+    logging.info("mem = %dM" % (mem))
+    logging.info("swap = %dM" %\
+                 (int(os.popen("cat /proc/meminfo | grep SwapTotal")\
+                              .readline().split()[1]) / 1024))
+    logging.info("max_vms = %d" % (max_vms))
+    logging.info("vmsc = %d" % (vmsc))
+
+    # Generate unique keys for random series
+    skeys = []
+    dkeys = []
+    for i in range(0, max(vmsc, max_alloc)):
+        key = "%03s" % (random.randrange(0,999))
+        while key in skeys:
+            key = "%03s" % (random.randrange(0,999))
+        skeys.append(key)
+
+        key = "%03s" % (random.randrange(0,999))
+        while key in dkeys:
+            key = "%03s" % (random.randrange(0,999))
+        dkeys.append(key)
+    
+    lvms = []
+    lsessions = []
+    lallocators = []
+    alloc_port = 31284
+
+    # As we don't know the number and memory amount of VMs in advance, we need 
+    # to specify and create them here (FIXME: not a nice thing)
+    params['mem'] = mem
+    params['vms'] = params.get("main_vm")
+    # ksm_size: amount of memory used by allocator
+    ksm_size = mem - guest_reserve
+    logging.info("ksm_size = %dM" % (ksm_size))
+
+    
+    params['redirs'] += ' alloc0'
+    params['guest_port_alloc0'] = str(alloc_port)
+    
+    if (params['ksm_test_size'] == "paralel") :
+        for j in range(1, max_alloc):
+            params['redirs'] += ' alloc' + str(j)
+            params['guest_port_alloc' + str(j)] = str(alloc_port + j)
+
+    # Creating of the first guest
+    kvm_preprocessing.preprocess_vm(test, params, env, params['vms'])
+    lvms.append(kvm_utils.env_get_vm(env, params.get("main_vm")))
+    if not lvms[0]:
+        raise error.TestError("VM object not found in environment")
+    if not lvms[0].is_alive():
+        raise error.TestError("VM seems to be dead; Test requires a living VM")
+
+    logging.info("Booting the first guest %s" % lvms[0].name)
+
+    lsessions.append(kvm_utils.wait_for(lvms[0].ssh_login, 360, 0, 2))
+    if not lsessions[0]:
+        raise error.TestFail("Could not log into first guest")
+    
+    
+    lallocators.append(allocator_com(lvms[0].name, lvms[0].redirs[alloc_port]))
+    if not lallocators[0]:
+        raise error.TestFail("Could not create allocator_com class for vm1")
+    
+
+    
+    # Creating of other guest systems
+    for i in range(1, vmsc):
+        vm_name = "vm" + str(i + 1)
+        # Last VM is later used to run more allocators simultaneously
+        """for j in range(1, max_alloc):
+            params['redirs'] += ' alloc' + str(j)
+            params['guest_port_alloc' + str(j)] = str(alloc_port + j)"""
+        
+        lvms.append(lvms[0].clone(vm_name, params))
+        kvm_utils.env_register_vm(env, vm_name, lvms[i])
+        params['vms'] += " " + vm_name
+
+        logging.info("Booting guest %s" % lvms[i].name)
+        if not lvms[i].create():
+            raise error.TestFail("Cannot create VM %s" % lvms[i].name)
+        if not lvms[i].is_alive():
+            raise error.TestError("VM %s seems to be dead; Test requires a"\
+                                  "living VM" % lvms[i].name)
+
+        lsessions.append(kvm_utils.wait_for(lvms[i].ssh_login, 360, 0, 2))
+        if not lsessions[i]:
+            raise error.TestFail("Could not log into guest %s" % lvms[i].name)
+
+        lallocators.append(allocator_com(lvms[i].name,\
+                                         lvms[i].redirs[alloc_port]))
+        if not lallocators[i]:
+            raise error.TestFail("Could not create allocator_com class for %s"\
+                                 % (lvms[i].name))
+        
+
+    # Let systems take a rest :-)
+    time.sleep(vmsc * 2)
+    logging.info(get_stat(lvms))
+
+    # Copy the allocator.c into guests
+    pwd = os.path.join(os.environ['AUTODIR'],'tests/kvm')
+    vksmd_src = os.path.join(pwd, "allocator.c")
+    dst_dir = "/tmp"
+    for vm in lvms:
+        if not vm.scp_to_remote(vksmd_src, dst_dir):
+            raise error.TestFail("Remote scp failed %s" % (vm.name))
+    logging.info("Phase 0 => passed")
+
+    def phase_1():
+        """ Inicialize virtual machine """
+        logging.info("Starting phase 1: filling with 0")
+        logging.info("Preparing the guests and fill in pages by zero")
+        for session in lsessions:
+            vm = lvms[lsessions.index(session)]
+            allocator = lallocators[lsessions.index(session)]
+            # Build the test suite
+            ret = session.get_command_status("gcc -o /tmp/allocator "\
+                                             "/tmp/allocator.c",\
+                                             timeout=300)
+            if ret == None or ret:
+                raise error.TestFail("Failed to build vksmd in the %s"\
+                                     % (vm.name))
+    
+            # Start the daemon
+            ret = session.get_command_status("/tmp/allocator %d %d" % (ksm_size,\
+                                                                      alloc_port))
+            if ret == None:
+                raise error.TestFail("Could not run vksmd in guest %s"\
+                                     % (vm.name))
+            if ret:
+                raise error.TestFail("Could not run vksmd in %s errno: %d"\
+                                      % (vm.name, ret))
+    
+            ret = session.get_command_status("iptables -F;"\
+                                             "iptables -P INPUT ACCEPT;")
+    
+            allocator.connect()
+            allocator.recv((ksm_size / 200), 100)
+            
+            # Let kksmd works (until shared mem rich expected value)
+            shm = 0
+            i = 0
+            cmd = "cat /proc/%d/statm" % vm.pid
+            while shm < ksm_size:
+                if i > 64:
+                    logging.info(get_stat(lvms))
+                    raise error.TestError("SHM didn't merged the memory until "\
+					  "the DL")
+                logging.debug("Sleep(%d)" % (ksm_size / 200))
+                time.sleep(ksm_size / 200)
+                try:
+                    shm = int(os.popen(cmd).readline().split()[2])
+                    shm = shm * 4 / 1024
+                    i = i + 1
+                except:
+                    raise error.TestError("Could not fetch shmem info from "
+					  "the /proc")
+    
+        # Keep some reserve
+        time.sleep(ksm_size / 200)
+    
+        # Set allocator keys
+        for i in range(0, vmsc):
+            lallocators[i].send("init", "%s%s" % (skeys[i], dkeys[i]))
+            lallocators[i].recv(1, 10)
+        logging.info(get_stat(lvms))
+        logging.info("Phase 1 => passed")
+
+    def phase_2():
+        """ Separate first guest memory by generate a special random series """
+        logging.info("Starting phase 2: Split the pages on the first guest")
+    
+        lallocators[0].send("srandom")
+        out = lallocators[0].recv(ksm_size / 500, 50)
+        out = int(out.split()[4])
+        logging.info("PERFORMANCE: %dMB * 1000 / %dms = %dMB/s"\
+                     % (ksm_size, out, (ksm_size * 1000 / out)))
+        logging.info(get_stat(lvms))
+        logging.info("Phase 2 => passed")
+
+    def phase_3():
+        """ Sequentional split of pages on guests up to memory limit """
+        logging.info("Starting phase 3a: Sequentional split of pages on guests up "\
+                     "to memory limit")
+        last_vm = 0
+        for i in range(1, vmsc):
+            vm = lvms[i]
+            session = lsessions[i]
+            allocator = lallocators[i]
+    
+            allocator.send("srandom")
+            out = ""
+            while not out.startswith("PASS") and not out.startswith("FAIL"):
+                free_mem = int(os.popen("grep MemFree /proc/meminfo")\
+                             .readline().split()[1])
+                logging.debug("FreeMem = %d" % (free_mem))
+                # We need to keep some memory for python to run.
+                if free_mem < 32000:
+                    logging.debug("Only %s free memory, killing 0 - %d hosts"\
+                                  % (free_mem, (i-1)))
+                    for j in range(0, i):
+                        lvms[j].destroy(gracefully = False)
+                    last_vm = i
+                    break
+                out = allocator._recv()
+            if last_vm != 0:
+                break
+    
+        allocator.recv(mem / 500, 50)
+        logging.info("Memory filled by the guest %s" % (vm.name))
+        logging.info("Phase 3a => passed")
+        
+        """ Check if memory in max loading guest is allright"""
+        logging.info("Starting phase 3b")
+        allocator.send("srverify")
+        allocator.recv(mem / 200, 50)
+        allocator.disconnect()
+        # We are going to use the last VM later
+        if i != (vmsc):
+            session.close()
+            vm.destroy(gracefully = False)
+            for i in range(last_vm + 1, vmsc):
+                lallocators[i].send("verify")
+                lallocators[i].recv(mem / 200, 50)
+                lallocators[i].disconnect()
+                # We are going to use the last VM later
+                if i != (vmsc - 1):
+                    lsessions[i].close()
+                    lvms[i].destroy(gracefully = False)
+        logging.info(get_stat([lvms[i]]))
+        logging.info("Phase 3b => passed")
+
+    def phase_4():
+        """ Paralel page spliting """
+        logging.info("Phase 4: Paralel page spliting")
+        # We have to wait until allocator is finished (it waits 5 seconds to clean
+        # the socket
+        
+        session = lsessions[0]
+        vm = lvms[0]
+        
+        ret = session.get_command_status("gcc -o /tmp/allocator "\
+                                             "/tmp/allocator.c",\
+                                             timeout=300)
+        if ret == None or ret:
+            raise error.TestFail("Failed to build vksmd in the %s"\
+                                  % (vm.name))
+                                  
+        for all in lallocators:
+            if all.isConnected():
+                all.disconnect()
+        
+        del lallocators[:]
+        ret = session.get_command_status("iptables -F;"\
+                                    "iptables -P INPUT ACCEPT;")
+         
+        for i in range(0, max_alloc):
+            ret = session.get_command_status("/tmp/allocator %d %d" 
+                                   % (ksm_size / max_alloc, alloc_port + i))
+            if ret == None:
+                raise error.TestFail("Could not run vksmd in guest %s"\
+                                     % (vm.name))
+            if ret:
+                raise error.TestFail("Could not run allocator in %s errno: %d"\
+                                     % (vm.name, ret))
+        
+            lallocators.append(allocator_com(vm.name,\
+                                             vm.redirs[alloc_port + i]))
+            if not lallocators[i]:
+                raise error.TestFail("Could not create allocator_com class for"\
+				     " %s" % (vm.name))
+        
+        logging.info("Phase 4a: Simultaneous merging")
+        for i in range(0, max_alloc):
+            lallocators[i].connect()
+        
+        for i in range(0, max_alloc):
+            lallocators[i].recv((ksm_size / 200), 100)
+        # Wait until kksmd merges the pages (3 x ksm_size / 3)
+        shm = 0
+        i = 0
+        cmd = "cat /proc/%d/statm" % vm.pid
+        while shm < ksm_size:
+            if i > 64:
+                logging.info(get_stat(lvms))
+                raise error.TestError("SHM didn't merged the memory until DL")
+            logging.debug("Sleep(%d)" % (ksm_size / 200))
+            time.sleep(ksm_size / 200)
+            try:
+                shm = int(os.popen(cmd).readline().split()[2])
+                shm = shm * 4 / 1024
+            except:
+                raise error.TestError("Could not fetch shmem info from proc")
+        logging.info(get_stat([vm]))
+    
+    
+        logging.info("Phases 4b: Simultaneous spliting")
+        # Set keys
+        for i in range(0, max_alloc):
+            lallocators[i].send("init", "%s%s" % (skeys[i], dkeys[i]))
+            lallocators[i].recv(1, 10)
+    
+        # Actual splitting
+        for i in range(0, max_alloc):
+            lallocators[i].send("srandom")
+        
+        for i in range(0, max_alloc):
+            out = lallocators[i].recv(ksm_size / 500, 50)
+            out = int(out.split()[4])
+            logging.info("PERFORMANCE: %dMB * 1000 / %dms = %dMB/s"\
+                         % (ksm_size, out, (ksm_size * 1000 / out / max_alloc)))
+        logging.info(get_stat([vm]))
+    
+        logging.info("Phase 4c: Simultaneous verification")
+        for i in range(0, max_alloc):
+            lallocators[i].send("srverify")
+        for i in range(0, max_alloc):
+            lallocators[i].recv(mem / 200, 50)
+        logging.info(get_stat([vm]))
+    
+        logging.info("Phase 4 => passed")
+        # Clean-up
+        for i in range(0, max_alloc):
+            lallocators[i].disconnect()
+        session.close()
+        vm.destroy(gracefully = False)
+        
+    if params['ksm_test_size'] == "paralel":
+        phase_4()
+    elif params['ksm_test_size'] == "serial":
+        phase_1()
+        phase_2()
+        phase_3()
+        
 
 def run_linux_s3(test, params, env):
     """

  reply	other threads:[~2009-09-01  8:50 UTC|newest]

Thread overview: 8+ messages / expand[flat|nested]  mbox.gz  Atom feed  top
2009-08-31  9:29 [KVM-AUTOTEST PATCH 0/2] Add KSM test Lukáš Doktor
2009-08-31  9:35 ` [KVM-AUTOTEST PATCH 1/2] " Lukáš Doktor
2009-09-01  8:49   ` Lukáš Doktor
2009-09-07 12:03   ` Dor Laor
2009-08-31  9:48 ` [KVM-AUTOTEST PATCH 2/2] " Lukáš Doktor
2009-09-01  8:50   ` Lukáš Doktor [this message]
2009-09-07 13:00   ` Dor Laor
2009-09-07 12:37 ` [KVM-AUTOTEST PATCH 0/2] " Uri Lublin

Reply instructions:

You may reply publicly to this message via plain-text email
using any one of the following methods:

* Save the following mbox file, import it into your mail client,
  and reply-to-all from there: mbox

  Avoid top-posting and favor interleaved quoting:
  https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Posting_style#Interleaved_style

* Reply using the --to, --cc, and --in-reply-to
  switches of git-send-email(1):

  git send-email \
    --in-reply-to=4A9CE03A.4010706@redhat.com \
    --to=ldoktor@redhat.com \
    --cc=autotest@test.kernel.org \
    --cc=kvm@vger.kernel.org \
    /path/to/YOUR_REPLY

  https://kernel.org/pub/software/scm/git/docs/git-send-email.html

* If your mail client supports setting the In-Reply-To header
  via mailto: links, try the mailto: link
Be sure your reply has a Subject: header at the top and a blank line before the message body.
This is an external index of several public inboxes,
see mirroring instructions on how to clone and mirror
all data and code used by this external index.