Re: Access to raw memory: remove or make boolean?

[Topi Miettinen <toiwoton@gmail.com>]

On 25.2.2020 2.27, Russell Coker wrote:
> On Tuesday, 25 February 2020 2:56:01 AM AEDT Topi Miettinen wrote:
>> The PR would make all these conditional to new boolean,
>> allow_raw_memory_access.
> 
> So if someone needs one of those many accesses (klogd_t or hald_t seems
> likely) then they also get access for things that aren't needed on most
> systems nowadays (EG xserver_t) and things that never made any sense (such as
> colord_t).
> 
> I think it would be best to remove most of those /dev/mem access rules and add
> them back only after testing with recent software and comments about why they
> are needed.
> 
>>> A quick grep of the latest policy turned up the above access to /dev/mem.
>>> Do ddcprobe_t, vbetool_t, and the X server still do that?  mcelog_t, and
>>> klogd_t might have good uses, as might sosreport_t (don't even know what
>>> it does but guessing it's like klogd_t).  rpm_t should maybe transition
>>> to a different domain for whatever it was doing and the same for kudzo_t.
>>>   Vmware  is a bit ugly, so vmware_t might actually do that.  iscsi_t,
>>> mdadm_t, colord_t, and initrc_t should never have needed that.  hald_t,
>>> hald_mac_t and
>>> devicekit_disk_t might have needed it, but hopefully that was fixed a long
>>> time ago.
>>>
>>> Interestingly bootloader_t doesn't have such access even though a quick
>>> inspection of the LILO source code shows that it still probes the boot
>>> order by directly reading the BIOS memory.  I guess no-one uses LILO with
>>> SE Linux.
>> I also don't know most of these programs. Direct memory access was
>> probably needed for X server during SVGA times, at least NVIDIA driver
>> on my system does not seem to need it.
> 
> I think it was needed before KMS.  Is it even possible to run without KMS
> nowadays?

No idea. I'll update the PR so that only ddcprobe_t, vbetool_t, 
mcelog_t, klogd_t, sosreport_t and vmware_t keep the access (subject to 
boolean) and for others it's just removed unconditionally.

-Topi