what happened to SECURITY_DAC?

what happened to SECURITY_DAC?

[Randy Dunlap]

wow.  Commit 70b62c25665f636c9f6c700b26af7df296b0887e
from last Sept. 14, 2018, total commit description says:

    LoadPin: Initialize as ordered LSM
    
    This converts LoadPin from being a direct "minor" LSM into an ordered LSM.

Nowhere does it say anything like "this also deletes any notions of
DEFAULT_SECURITY and DAC."

Was this deletion a (sekrit) security issue that was not being highlighted on purpose?


and what do you recommend for simple DAC-like security?

thanks.  :(

-- 
~Randy

Re: what happened to SECURITY_DAC?

[Kees Cook]

On Wed, Mar 20, 2019 at 5:39 PM Randy Dunlap <rdunlap@infradead.org> wrote:
>
> wow.  Commit 70b62c25665f636c9f6c700b26af7df296b0887e
> from last Sept. 14, 2018, total commit description says:
>
>     LoadPin: Initialize as ordered LSM
>
>     This converts LoadPin from being a direct "minor" LSM into an ordered LSM.
>
> Nowhere does it say anything like "this also deletes any notions of
> DEFAULT_SECURITY and DAC."

This was a mistaken merge of chunks from a larger series that Casey
and I were working on. It should have been split out.

> Was this deletion a (sekrit) security issue that was not being highlighted on purpose?

No, just an error while refactoring to in creating CONFIG_LSM.

> and what do you recommend for simple DAC-like security?

See CONFIG_LSM. There are some related issues getting discussed here, too:
https://lore.kernel.org/linux-security-module/f23d0fad-dc72-0e53-cac6-31abfd12a050@I-love.SAKURA.ne.jp/


-- 
Kees Cook