no IRQ from USB on MPC8248

no IRQ from USB on MPC8248

[Nathael PAJANI]

Hi all!

As I said previously I started a backport of the hcd driver from 
sourceforge (http://cpm2usb.sourceforge.net/) to linux 2.6.9 for an 
actis board (VSBC6848) based on a MPC8248 (MPC8272 family)
I have a running 2.6.9 kernel for this board, and no other, that's why 
I'm doing a backport of the driver. (for those who might wonder)

I managed to have the core up:

---> insmod usbcore.ko
Using usbcore.ko
usbcore: registered new driver usbfs
usbcore: registered new driver hub
---> mount /proc/bus/usb
---> insmod m82xx-hcd.ko
Using m82xx-hcd.ko
=> driver mpc82xx-hcd, 0.02
mpc82xx-hcd mpc82xx-hcd3: PQ2 intergrated USB controller v0.1
mpc82xx-hcd mpc82xx-hcd3: new USB bus registered, assigned bus number 1
hub 1-0:1.0: USB hub found
hub 1-0:1.0: 1 port detected
PQ2USB: debug file creation
---> Done
~ #

so this is OK

then, when plugging a device, I got this:
usb 1-1: new full speed USB device using address 2
usb 1-1: control timeout on ep0out
mpc82xx-hcd mpc82xx-hcd3: Unlink after no-IRQ? Different ACPI or APIC 
settings may help.
usb 1-1: control timeout on ep0out
usb 1-1: device not accepting address 2, error -110
usb 1-1: new full speed USB device using address 3
usb 1-1: control timeout on ep0out
usb 1-1: control timeout on ep0out
usb 1-1: device not accepting address 3, error -110

which means the hub detects a device, and tries to configure it.
On the device (MP3player) I have an LCD display, and the text switches 
to "USB-C" and comes back, which means something has been received. 
Let's consider the device is working fine, I have then two possibilities:

first: the device receives incoherent stuff, and does not dare 
responding, but I got no way to check on the device. (I consider the 
usbcore tries to send cohenrent stuff!)

second: the device is happy to see a request and replies correctly.... 
but there's no interrupt fired, whether using SUI_INT_USB (==11) or the 
SCC3 interrupt (==42)


I've been looking for many things allready, but did not find a clue of 
what might happen... If you have some, I'll be pleased to hear about them.

I also had a look at the debug file:

~ # cat /proc/driver/m8xxhci_privateh
===> Misc stats:
sof = 0 isrs = 0 cpm_irqs = 0 overrun = 0
rxb = 0 txb = 0 bsy = 0 sof = 0
txe[0] = 0 txe[1] = 0 txe[2] = 0 txe[3] = 0
nak[0] = 0 nak[1] = 0 nak[2] = 0 nak[3] = 0
to[0] = 0 to[1] = 0 to[2] = 0 to[3] = 0
stall[0] = 0 stall[1] = 0 stall[2] = 0 stall[3] = 0
tx_err = 0 tx_nak = 0 tx_stal = 0 tx_to = 0 tx_un = 0
enqs[ISO] = 0 enqs[INTR] = 0 enqs[CTRL] = 4 enqs[BULK] = 0
cpls[ISO] = 0 cpls[INTR] = 0 cpls[CTRL] = 4 cpls[BULK] = 0
===> Periodic schedule:
~ #

but as I do not know what might be expected, I do not know what to think 
about it.

The sof, isrs, and cpm_irqs counters confirm that there have been no 
irqs ...

please, help me if you can.
and anyway, have fun :) :)

Re: no IRQ from USB on MPC8248

[Mike Rapoport]

Nathael PAJANI wrote:

[snip]

> which means the hub detects a device, and tries to configure it.

The root hub is virtual and implemented in SW. It detects the device any 
time there's a pull-up on one of the D+ or D- lines, no matter if 
controller is working properly or not.

>
> second: the device is happy to see a request and replies correctly.... 
> but there's no interrupt fired, whether using SUI_INT_USB (==11) or 
> the SCC3 interrupt (==42)
>
Make sure you've adopted the following functions to your board:
    static int board_configure(struct m8xxhci_private *hp)
    static int setup_usb_clock(struct m8xxhci_private *hp)
so the controller will get proper USB clock.

-- 
Sincerely yours,
Mike Rapoport