2.6.26-rc6 snd-pcsp: "Timer resolution is not sufficient"

2.6.26-rc6 snd-pcsp: "Timer resolution is not sufficient"

[Rene Herman]

Hi Stas.

What's this? 2.6.26-rc6:

===
input: PC Speaker as /class/input/input5
PCSP: Timer resolution is not sufficient (4000250nS)
PCSP: Make sure you have HPET and ACPI enabled.
PC-Speaker initialization failed.
pcspkr: probe of pcspkr failed with error -5
===

A HPET I do not have, ACPI is enabled and the driver worked fine on a 
previous -rc.

Rene.

Re: 2.6.26-rc6 snd-pcsp: "Timer resolution is not sufficient"

[Stas Sergeev]

Hi.

Rene Herman wrote:
> What's this? 2.6.26-rc6:
> ===
> input: PC Speaker as /class/input/input5
> PCSP: Timer resolution is not sufficient (4000250nS)
> PCSP: Make sure you have HPET and ACPI enabled.
> PC-Speaker initialization failed.
> pcspkr: probe of pcspkr failed with error -5
> ===
> A HPET I do not have, ACPI is enabled and the driver worked fine on a
> previous -rc.
That means that the high-res timer
mode is not available. See
cat /proc/timer_list
It should contain the lines like
  .resolution: 1 nsecs
1 nsecs means a high-res mode.
Some large values (like 4000250)
means low-res.
Try adding the hrtimers people to
CC if this is a problem.

Re: 2.6.26-rc6 snd-pcsp: "Timer resolution is not sufficient"

[Rene Herman]

On 20-06-08 05:57, Stas Sergeev wrote:

CCed onto linux-kernel to possibly help future googlers...

> Rene Herman wrote:

>> What's this? 2.6.26-rc6:
>> ===
>> input: PC Speaker as /class/input/input5
>> PCSP: Timer resolution is not sufficient (4000250nS)
>> PCSP: Make sure you have HPET and ACPI enabled.
>> PC-Speaker initialization failed.
>> pcspkr: probe of pcspkr failed with error -5
>> ===
>> A HPET I do not have, ACPI is enabled and the driver worked fine on a
>> previous -rc.
> 
> That means that the high-res timer > mode is not available. See
> cat /proc/timer_list
> It should contain the lines like
>   .resolution: 1 nsecs
> 1 nsecs means a high-res mode.
> Some large values (like 4000250)
> means low-res.
> Try adding the hrtimers people to
> CC if this is a problem.

In this case the problem was the ACPI PM-Timer (CONFIG_X86_PM_TIMER) got 
disabled. Re-enabling it, snd-pcsp is working fine again.

It does seem a bit off that you needs something as (relatively) modern 
as an ACPI timing source (or HPET, or ...) to drive something quite as 
legacy as the PC speaker, but oh well.

Rene.

Re: 2.6.26-rc6 snd-pcsp: "Timer resolution is not sufficient"

[Rene Herman]

On 20-06-08 05:57, Stas Sergeev wrote:

CCed onto linux-kernel to possibly help future googlers...

> Rene Herman wrote:

>> What's this? 2.6.26-rc6:
>> ===
>> input: PC Speaker as /class/input/input5
>> PCSP: Timer resolution is not sufficient (4000250nS)
>> PCSP: Make sure you have HPET and ACPI enabled.
>> PC-Speaker initialization failed.
>> pcspkr: probe of pcspkr failed with error -5
>> ===
>> A HPET I do not have, ACPI is enabled and the driver worked fine on a
>> previous -rc.
> 
> That means that the high-res timer > mode is not available. See
> cat /proc/timer_list
> It should contain the lines like
>   .resolution: 1 nsecs
> 1 nsecs means a high-res mode.
> Some large values (like 4000250)
> means low-res.
> Try adding the hrtimers people to
> CC if this is a problem.

In this case the problem was the ACPI PM-Timer (CONFIG_X86_PM_TIMER) got
disabled. Re-enabling it, snd-pcsp is working fine again.

It does seem a bit off that you needs something as (relatively) modern
as an ACPI timing source (or HPET, or ...) to drive something quite as
legacy as the PC speaker, but oh well.

Rene.

Re: 2.6.26-rc6 snd-pcsp: "Timer resolution is not sufficient"

[Stas Sergeev]

Hello.

Rene Herman wrote:
> In this case the problem was the ACPI PM-Timer (CONFIG_X86_PM_TIMER) got
> disabled. Re-enabling it, snd-pcsp is working fine again.
Note that this option is available
only if you enable CONFIG_EMBEDDED.
Most people will just never see it.