[U-Boot] [STATUS] v2011.06 release, Merge Window is OPEN

[U-Boot] [STATUS] v2011.06 release, Merge Window is OPEN

[Albert ARIBAUD]

Hi Prafulla,

Le 30/06/2011 10:06, Prafulla Wadaskar a ?crit :
>
>
>> -----Original Message-----
>> From: u-boot-bounces at lists.denx.de [mailto:u-boot-bounces at lists.denx.de]
>> On Behalf Of Albert ARIBAUD
>> Sent: Thursday, June 30, 2011 12:08 AM
>> To: u-boot at lists.denx.de
>> Subject: Re: [U-Boot] [STATUS] v2011.06 release, Merge Window is OPEN
>>
>> Hi all,
>>
>> Le 28/06/2011 12:55, Wolfgang Denk a ?crit :
>>> Hello all,
>>>
>>> U-Boot v2011.06 has been released and is available from the git
>>> repository and the FTP server.
>>>
>>> KNOWN ISSUES:
>>>
>>> - The cleanup after the reorganization of the ARM code has not been
>>>     completed yet. At the moment, approapprox, 100+ ARM boards are
>>>     *broken* and *do not compile*.
>>>
>>>     Board maintainers or other interested parties are requested to
>>>     adapt their boards within the current merge window. All boards that
>>>     have not been fixed within the first week of the merge window are
>>>     considered unmaintained and without interest to the community and
>>>     will be removed.
>>>
>>>     This is the last such warning.
>>>
>>> - We still have not found a new network custodian yet.  Are there any
>>>     volunteers?
>>>
>>> The Merge Window for the next release (v2011.09) is open until
>>> Sat Jul 16, 2011, 23:59:59 CEST = 18 days remaining.
>>>
>>> The next release v2011.09 is scheduled for September 04, 2011.
>>
>> For information only, here are patches that were pending on
>> u-boot-arm/next and were thus moved to u-boot-arm/master, or were added
>> to it since the window opened:
>
> Hi Albert
> There are few patches sitting on u-boot-marvell.git next branch for which pull request was already there.
>
> Would you pull them? Or do I need to any needful?

I have applied them to u-boot-arm/master, thanks.

> Regards..
> Prafulla . .

Amicalement,
-- 
Albert.

[U-Boot] [STATUS] v2011.06 release, Merge Window is OPEN

[Albert ARIBAUD]

Hi all,

Le 28/06/2011 12:55, Wolfgang Denk a ?crit :
> Hello all,
>
> U-Boot v2011.06 has been released and is available from the git
> repository and the FTP server.
>
> KNOWN ISSUES:
>
> - The cleanup after the reorganization of the ARM code has not been
>    completed yet. At the moment, approapprox, 100+ ARM boards are
>    *broken* and *do not compile*.
>
>    Board maintainers or other interested parties are requested to
>    adapt their boards within the current merge window. All boards that
>    have not been fixed within the first week of the merge window are
>    considered unmaintained and without interest to the community and
>    will be removed.
>
>    This is the last such warning.
>
> - We still have not found a new network custodian yet.  Are there any
>    volunteers?
>
> The Merge Window for the next release (v2011.09) is open until
> Sat Jul 16, 2011, 23:59:59 CEST = 18 days remaining.
>
> The next release v2011.09 is scheduled for September 04, 2011.

For information only, here are patches that were pending on 
u-boot-arm/next and were thus moved to u-boot-arm/master, or were added 
to it since the window opened:

Aneesh V (9):
       arm: make default implementation of cache_flush() weakly linked
       armv7: cache maintenance operations for armv7
       armv7: rename cache related CONFIG flags
       armv7: integrate cache maintenance support
       arm: minor fixes for cache and mmu handling
       armv7: add PL310 support to u-boot
       armv7: adapt omap4 to the new cache maintenance framework
       armv7: adapt omap3 to the new cache maintenance framework
       armv7: adapt s5pc1xx to the new cache maintenance framework

David M?ller (ELSOFT AG) (3):
       VCMA9: remove unneeded config.mk
       VCMA9: use CFI driver (and remove the old one)
       VCMA9: various cleanups/code style fixes

Igor Grinberg (1):
       arm: omap2: apollon: fix broken build

John Rigby (1):
       OMAP[34]: fix broken timer

Matthias Weisser (1):
       arm: Update jadecpu board

Tom Warren (2):
       GPIO: Tegra2: add GPIO driver for Tegra2
       arm: Tegra2: GPIO: enable GPIO for Tegra2 boards

More to follow.

Amicalement,
-- 
Albert.

[U-Boot] [STATUS] v2011.06 release, Merge Window is OPEN

[Wolfgang Denk]

Dear Lo?c,

In message <20110628152416.GC31789@bee.dooz.org> you wrote:
...
> >   Board maintainers or other interested parties are requested to
> >   adapt their boards within the current merge window. All boards that
> >   have not been fixed within the first week of the merge window are
> >   considered unmaintained and without interest to the community and
> >   will be removed.
>
>  It's funny how this reminds me of package build failures in Debian; in
>  such cases, we start by publishing the list of affected packages
>  ideally with links to build logs and the name of corresponding
>  maintainers.  After a while, we actually start Cc:ing the maintainers
>  or filing bug reports against each failing package.

This has started with v2010.09, and deadlines have been made clear.
I have no intentions to discuss this much longer now.  Either it
builds, or it gets removed.

>  Would it make sense to publish such a list of broken boards and
>  corresponding maintainers?  (Maybe some makeall + scripts magic?)

No kind of script magic is needed. Just run "./MAKEALL arm".

And a list has been posted before. See

06/22 To:u-boot at lists.d  [U-Boot] [STATUS] v2011.06-rc3 released

http://article.gmane.org/gmane.comp.boot-loaders.u-boot/101894


Best regards,

Wolfgang Denk

-- 
DENX Software Engineering GmbH,     MD: Wolfgang Denk & Detlev Zundel
HRB 165235 Munich, Office: Kirchenstr.5, D-82194 Groebenzell, Germany
Phone: (+49)-8142-66989-10 Fax: (+49)-8142-66989-80 Email: wd at denx.de
I have often regretted my speech, never my silence.

[U-Boot] [STATUS] v2011.06 release, Merge Window is OPEN

[Loïc Minier]

On Tue, Jun 28, 2011, Wolfgang Denk wrote:
> - The cleanup after the reorganization of the ARM code has not been
>   completed yet. At the moment, approapprox, 100+ ARM boards are
>   *broken* and *do not compile*.
> 
>   Board maintainers or other interested parties are requested to
>   adapt their boards within the current merge window. All boards that
>   have not been fixed within the first week of the merge window are
>   considered unmaintained and without interest to the community and
>   will be removed.

 It's funny how this reminds me of package build failures in Debian; in
 such cases, we start by publishing the list of affected packages
 ideally with links to build logs and the name of corresponding
 maintainers.  After a while, we actually start Cc:ing the maintainers
 or filing bug reports against each failing package.

 Would it make sense to publish such a list of broken boards and
 corresponding maintainers?  (Maybe some makeall + scripts magic?)

 This is a sample list of Debian packages not declaring the upstream
 "Homepage" properly:
    http://lists.debian.org/debian-devel/2011/02/msg00367.html

-- 
Lo?c Minier

[U-Boot] [STATUS] v2011.06 release, Merge Window is OPEN

[Wolfgang Denk]

Hello all,

U-Boot v2011.06 has been released and is available from the git
repository and the FTP server.


KNOWN ISSUES:

- The cleanup after the reorganization of the ARM code has not been
  completed yet. At the moment, approapprox, 100+ ARM boards are
  *broken* and *do not compile*.

  Board maintainers or other interested parties are requested to
  adapt their boards within the current merge window. All boards that
  have not been fixed within the first week of the merge window are
  considered unmaintained and without interest to the community and
  will be removed.

  This is the last such warning.

- We still have not found a new network custodian yet.  Are there any
  volunteers?

The Merge Window for the next release (v2011.09) is open until
Sat Jul 16, 2011, 23:59:59 CEST = 18 days remaining. 

The next release v2011.09 is scheduled for September 04, 2011. 


A little statistics [1] - changes since release v2011.03:

Processed 678 csets from 135 developers
26 employers found
A total of 48114 lines added, 36696 removed (delta 11418)

Developers with the most changesets
Mike Frysinger              63 (9.3%)
Luca Ceresoli               28 (4.1%)
Heiko Schocher              26 (3.8%)
Fabio Estevam               23 (3.4%)
Andreas Bie?mann            21 (3.1%)
Kumar Gala                  21 (3.1%)
Holger Brunck               20 (2.9%)
Reinhard Meyer              18 (2.7%)
Macpaul Lin                 18 (2.7%)
Wolfgang Denk               17 (2.5%)
...

Developers with the most changed lines
Mike Frysinger            10802 (16.0%)
Wolfgang Denk             8365 (12.4%)
Andy Fleming              4724 (7.0%)
Heiko Schocher            2787 (4.1%)
John Rigby                2243 (3.3%)
Luca Ceresoli             1779 (2.6%)
Daniel Schwierzeck        1726 (2.6%)
Michael Schwingen         1689 (2.5%)
Chander Kashyap           1671 (2.5%)
Macpaul Lin               1503 (2.2%)
...

Developers with the most lines removed
Wolfgang Denk             7936 (21.6%)
Daniel Schwierzeck        1500 (4.1%)
Eric Benard                895 (2.4%)
Holger Brunck              545 (1.5%)
Scott Wood                 503 (1.4%)
Kumar Gala                 496 (1.4%)
David M?ller (ELSOFT AG)  377 (1.0%)
Alessandro Rubini          363 (1.0%)
Andreas Bie?mann          275 (0.7%)
Reinhard Meyer             159 (0.4%)
...

Developers with the most signoffs (total 282)
Kumar Gala                  80 (28.4%)
Sandeep Paulraj             32 (11.3%)
Valentin Longchamp          23 (8.2%)
Holger Brunck               19 (6.7%)
Stefan Roese                15 (5.3%)
Mike Frysinger              13 (4.6%)
Andy Fleming                12 (4.3%)
Minkyu Kang                 11 (3.9%)
Scott Wood                   8 (2.8%)
Shinya Kuribayashi           6 (2.1%)
...

Developers with the most reviews (total 0)

Developers with the most test credits (total 10)
Mike Frysinger               1 (10.0%)
Andreas Bie?mann            1 (10.0%)
Anatolij Gustschin           1 (10.0%)
Fabio Estevam                1 (10.0%)
Graeme Russ                  1 (10.0%)
Stefano Babic                1 (10.0%)
Felix Radensky               1 (10.0%)
Magnus Lilja                 1 (10.0%)
Andre Schwarz                1 (10.0%)
Sughosh Ganu                 1 (10.0%)

Developers who gave the most tested-by credits (total 10)
Fabio Estevam                2 (20.0%)
Kim Phillips                 2 (20.0%)
Anatolij Gustschin           1 (10.0%)
Stefano Babic                1 (10.0%)
Stefan Roese                 1 (10.0%)
Scott Wood                   1 (10.0%)
Priyanka Jain                1 (10.0%)
Jens Scharsig                1 (10.0%)

Developers with the most report credits (total 5)
Andre Schwarz                1 (20.0%)
Kumar Gala                   1 (20.0%)
Wolfgang Denk                1 (20.0%)
Michael Weiss                1 (20.0%)
Jianxi Fu                    1 (20.0%)

Developers who gave the most report credits (total 5)
Mike Frysinger               2 (40.0%)
Kim Phillips                 1 (20.0%)
Anatolij Gustschin           1 (20.0%)
Peter Tyser                  1 (20.0%)

Top changeset contributors by employer
(Unknown)                  267 (39.4%)
Freescale                  127 (18.7%)
Analog Devices              66 (9.7%)
DENX Software Engineering   63 (9.3%)
Keymile                     34 (5.0%)
Texas Instruments           10 (1.5%)
Guntermann & Drunck          9 (1.3%)
CompuLab                     9 (1.3%)
Graeme Russ                  7 (1.0%)
Samsung                      7 (1.0%)
...

Top lines changed by employer
(Unknown)                 22719 (33.6%)
Freescale                 13914 (20.6%)
Analog Devices            12353 (18.3%)
DENX Software Engineering 11824 (17.5%)
Keymile                   2635 (3.9%)
Mistral                    891 (1.3%)
Bluewater Systems          420 (0.6%)
Graeme Russ                396 (0.6%)
Universita di Pavia        378 (0.6%)
Transmode Systems          323 (0.5%)
...

Employers with the most signoffs (total 282)
Freescale                  128 (45.4%)
Keymile                     48 (17.0%)
Texas Instruments           36 (12.8%)
DENX Software Engineering   21 (7.4%)
(Unknown)                   19 (6.7%)
Analog Devices              13 (4.6%)
Samsung                     13 (4.6%)
Intel                        2 (0.7%)
Xentech Solutions            1 (0.4%)
Psyent                       1 (0.4%)

Employers with the most hackers (total 137)
(Unknown)                   71 (51.8%)
Freescale                   27 (19.7%)
Keymile                      6 (4.4%)
DENX Software Engineering    6 (4.4%)
Texas Instruments            3 (2.2%)
Analog Devices               3 (2.2%)
Samsung                      2 (1.5%)
Mistral                      1 (0.7%)
Bluewater Systems            1 (0.7%)
Graeme Russ                  1 (0.7%)
...

[1] See http://www.denx.de/wiki/U-Boot/UbootStat_2011_06 for full
    statistics, and http://www.denx.de/wiki/UBoot/ReleaseCycle
    for links to statistics for earlier releases.


Best regards,

Wolfgang Denk

-- 
DENX Software Engineering GmbH,     MD: Wolfgang Denk & Detlev Zundel
HRB 165235 Munich, Office: Kirchenstr.5, D-82194 Groebenzell, Germany
Phone: (+49)-8142-66989-10 Fax: (+49)-8142-66989-80 Email: wd at denx.de
Nothing ever becomes real till it is experienced -- even a proverb is
no proverb to you till your life has illustrated it.     - John Keats