Bug Report on A1286 (Macbook Pro Mid 2012)

Bug Report on A1286 (Macbook Pro Mid 2012)

[Evan Foss]

Hi Folks,

I did some other bug reports here a while back. I am back again
because I updated my kernel from 3.19.1 to linux-4.8.10-gentoo (if you
want I can test the mainline too). On boot all my GPU's turn on. If I
turn them off via
echo "OFF"> /sys/kernel/debug/vgaswitcheroo/switch
I can't turn them back on. They also do not turn on if I try to change
GPU's. Trying to stop xdm locks the machine so I can't even turn it
off. Suspend/resume still works. None of these problems existed in
3.19.1. I know you will need more info to track down the problem but I
wanted to open with this.

From my lspci
00:02.0 VGA compatible controller: Intel Corporation 3rd Gen Core
processor Graphics Controller (rev 09)
01:00.0 VGA compatible controller: NVIDIA Corporation GK107M [GeForce
GT 650M Mac Edition] (rev ff)

Thanks,
Evan

-- 
Home
http://evanfoss.googlepages.com/
Work
http://forge.abcd.harvard.edu/gf/project/epl_engineering/wiki/

-----BEGIN PGP PUBLIC KEY BLOCK-----
Version: GnuPG v2
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=Ta4p
-----END PGP PUBLIC KEY BLOCK-----
_______________________________________________
Nouveau mailing list
Nouveau@lists.freedesktop.org
https://lists.freedesktop.org/mailman/listinfo/nouveau

Re: Bug Report on A1286 (Macbook Pro Mid 2012)

[Lukas Wunner]

On Sat, Nov 26, 2016 at 06:09:34AM +0000, Evan Foss wrote:
> I did some other bug reports here a while back. I am back again
> because I updated my kernel from 3.19.1 to linux-4.8.10-gentoo (if you
> want I can test the mainline too). On boot all my GPU's turn on. If I
> turn them off via
> echo "OFF"> /sys/kernel/debug/vgaswitcheroo/switch
> I can't turn them back on. They also do not turn on if I try to change
> GPU's. Trying to stop xdm locks the machine so I can't even turn it
> off. Suspend/resume still works. None of these problems existed in
> 3.19.1. I know you will need more info to track down the problem but I
> wanted to open with this.

I have the same machine and it works for me.  System sleep is only
supposed to work if both GPUs or ON upon suspend.  Are you issuing
OFF while X11 is running?  Does it work if X11 is stopped?

Best regards,

Lukas
_______________________________________________
Nouveau mailing list
Nouveau@lists.freedesktop.org
https://lists.freedesktop.org/mailman/listinfo/nouveau

Re: Bug Report on A1286 (Macbook Pro Mid 2012)

[Evan Foss]

On Sun, Nov 27, 2016 at 4:13 AM, Lukas Wunner <lukas@wunner.de> wrote:
> On Sat, Nov 26, 2016 at 06:09:34AM +0000, Evan Foss wrote:
>> I did some other bug reports here a while back. I am back again
>> because I updated my kernel from 3.19.1 to linux-4.8.10-gentoo (if you
>> want I can test the mainline too). On boot all my GPU's turn on. If I
>> turn them off via
>> echo "OFF"> /sys/kernel/debug/vgaswitcheroo/switch
>> I can't turn them back on. They also do not turn on if I try to change
>> GPU's. Trying to stop xdm locks the machine so I can't even turn it
>> off. Suspend/resume still works. None of these problems existed in
>> 3.19.1. I know you will need more info to track down the problem but I
>> wanted to open with this.
>
> I have the same machine and it works for me.  System sleep is only
> supposed to work if both GPUs or ON upon suspend.  Are you issuing
> OFF while X11 is running?  Does it work if X11 is stopped?

1. Boot with the intel GPU driving the screen.
2. In mate desktop turn off the nvidia gpu via echo "OFF" >
/sys/kernel/.../switch
3. Try to do any of the following and the machine locks up turn on the
nvidia GPU, suspend the machine, try to change gpus, stop X (via
/etc/init.d/xdm stop)

Yes I issue OFF while it is running and it works perfectly to turn off
the GPU's. I can tell because the machine gets a lot cooler.

> Best regards,
>
> Lukas



-- 
Home
http://evanfoss.googlepages.com/
Work
http://forge.abcd.harvard.edu/gf/project/epl_engineering/wiki/

-----BEGIN PGP PUBLIC KEY BLOCK-----
Version: GnuPG v2

mQENBFYy4RYBCAC183JomLtbdAlcKiaPDoVHq52LDmVmH75aiEc69m7YxDt54/ai
VtYCAobbGVIyn3Hlz3uhF6LnPl/6Lm1VdnCfpwu3KQhCO6ds10ow2C30X4ohCqOd
hCVg5C+ILmQkEffFrFODy3ji+PYTF4pADvHCWsTMv0hf0llwFOJsBCK6cl02IffE
JPqy4PjM1nZ9HpzT84JBaG/4OGvTZ8SQ2yFUl265jagvygPTf88H1xpZHH1r8dB1
stjUHLmPH8AOyDgKxFchgGeDc3p/vJtgDDIXAFfDXG0NSRovLmtaQdGxe47Zf/go
bXiEM7YL2WqQe5zfEA919JxkEwlDKYniOSVzABEBAAG0N0V2YW4gRm9zcyAoVGhp
cyBpcyBteSBwdWJsaWMga2V5LikgPGV2YW5mb3NzQGdtYWlsLmNvbT6JATkEEwEC
ACMFAlYy4RYCGwMHCwkIBwMCAQYVCAIJCgsEFgIDAQIeAQIXgAAKCRCIpQTcE8nN
bbBaCACAm8pU5lG1ev2Fsw68Axtcl57SJrYieqX96c3YuYH9JpqMqJRnd9nDKw9X
tQuvuH7tUk0VbOaDqReOYJVI/4c5wb9AaOFp6K2DUcupq6XhgXpvz3HzoPwjAdIj
XuQzdRUx5+innTJrSkGuBYW/CZ2zqEx4xfLlq4rO0hoTUMR8QVp2cCrkw6BT0m86
APIw/ZnjoxM8IEzr7MxfRIg3qpzrZk28rmhx+k78Jyk61UhwcCPGIm/pjUopTwYJ
3YBdRB2cYD2aN7A1JVf5cRmSQYooHBGpH0kYvomGk97PKqypVuJ7OpG9xM58wUcC
qUVt9hKlePLzP8csYjt8onqI7qIIuQENBFYy4RYBCADlH8spG3WkCx62vB5mr5Z0
SCDd/RcyA4A5y5EOj5KurQkrSWpgi9Ho1yKruMJ6blQR2qkc66KqH9pnXDm/ZI1M
K/wdW3ngETxBmXoozzFMT89aEWIVR5/PFodWK1elekE9iJxACuR98Zg2QttTD3x8
A9w8VEyMLOXcDTrPFpHegMKswFBg5iuMulAdXAoGejWTI3n+qKFpabHm2Lfs6wjk
5rjucpTdeFK6UeWF1xAvNxXibuu5BlGwv53930qIXRwO/Gn2Rh5DXWxKU2fEIme/
xgQQmIsDeUoWbfybdjw/x7Q0LW4mINiLDQcGHHRQKFIxbAJCT3USPLGh5xwE9/Er
ABEBAAGJAR8EGAECAAkFAlYy4RYCGwwACgkQiKUE3BPJzW0uYAf9Hf30n8tM3mR2
Zo6ESE0ivgdgjaJtAWrBUx7JzAzPjBnBOlNnu5Y9lVEqetvUPH6e3PvaHYUuaUU8
0HwxuKBW9nUprgV6uIu1DZmlcp+SxpbuCy7RDpNocRLNWWFMaYYzznmTgfnTgD4D
gCq8Mf1mcfrluTkOAo+QNqbMfl1GISClopRqxVuAo59ewgMnFujwgd8w12BwWl24
CzqOs5HqcUslePj+LzcjSNgVCklYwKl+0dsb/fctMOCtHodwqm2CBJ+zydvNmYkD
fxda/J91Z1xrah5ec++FL0L4vs+jCiIWJeupJFKlr1hCMZiiGH7W554loK5l4jv3
EY347EidAw==
=Ta4p
-----END PGP PUBLIC KEY BLOCK-----
_______________________________________________
Nouveau mailing list
Nouveau@lists.freedesktop.org
https://lists.freedesktop.org/mailman/listinfo/nouveau

Re: Bug Report on A1286 (Macbook Pro Mid 2012)

[Lukas Wunner]

On Tue, Nov 29, 2016 at 05:42:51PM -0500, Evan Foss wrote:
> On Sun, Nov 27, 2016 at 4:13 AM, Lukas Wunner <lukas@wunner.de> wrote:
> > On Sat, Nov 26, 2016 at 06:09:34AM +0000, Evan Foss wrote:
> >> I did some other bug reports here a while back. I am back again
> >> because I updated my kernel from 3.19.1 to linux-4.8.10-gentoo (if you
> >> want I can test the mainline too). On boot all my GPU's turn on. If I
> >> turn them off via
> >> echo "OFF"> /sys/kernel/debug/vgaswitcheroo/switch
> >> I can't turn them back on. They also do not turn on if I try to change
> >> GPU's. Trying to stop xdm locks the machine so I can't even turn it
> >> off. Suspend/resume still works. None of these problems existed in
> >> 3.19.1. I know you will need more info to track down the problem but I
> >> wanted to open with this.
> >
> > I have the same machine and it works for me.  System sleep is only
> > supposed to work if both GPUs or ON upon suspend.  Are you issuing
> > OFF while X11 is running?  Does it work if X11 is stopped?
> 
> 1. Boot with the intel GPU driving the screen.
> 2. In mate desktop turn off the nvidia gpu via echo "OFF" >
> /sys/kernel/.../switch
> 3. Try to do any of the following and the machine locks up turn on the
> nvidia GPU, suspend the machine, try to change gpus, stop X (via
> /etc/init.d/xdm stop)
> 
> Yes I issue OFF while it is running and it works perfectly to turn off
> the GPU's. I can tell because the machine gets a lot cooler.

On my machine issuing ON or OFF or switching always works but I only
issue the commands on the console, without X11 running.  Does that
work for you as well?

Manual power control via ON and OFF is a hack, it powers the GPU
up and down behind the PM core's back.  It's a stopgap until
runtime PM works for muxed machines.  That's the reason at least
for the lockup on resume, I know what causes this.  (The PCI core
invalidates the saved_state of the device.)  I don't know why
turning on the GPU or stopping X causes a lockup, presumably on
stopping X the card is accessed even though it's powered down.

There are some half-baked patches for runtime PM on this branch:
https://github.com/l1k/linux/commits/mbp_switcheroo_runpm_wip

Alas, a rework of vga_switcheroo audio handling is necessary to
bring up runtime PM for muxed machines properly:
https://www.mail-archive.com/nouveau@lists.freedesktop.org/msg24997.html

Rafael Wysocki's functional dependencies patches, which are a
prerequisite for this rework, are now queued for 4.10.  I'll
probably look into this in December/January.

Switching while X is running won't work anytime soon, I'm not
working on it and Dave Airlie has basically said that it has no
priority for him:
https://www.mail-archive.com/intel-gfx@lists.freedesktop.org/msg81981.html

On the bright side, you got Thunderbolt when you updated to 4.8 and
in 4.11 it'll even power itself down when nothing is plugged in and
save you 1.7 Watts. ;-)

Best regards,

Lukas
_______________________________________________
Nouveau mailing list
Nouveau@lists.freedesktop.org
https://lists.freedesktop.org/mailman/listinfo/nouveau

Re: Bug Report on A1286 (Macbook Pro Mid 2012)

[Evan Foss]

On Tue, Nov 29, 2016 at 11:31 PM, Lukas Wunner <lukas@wunner.de> wrote:
> On Tue, Nov 29, 2016 at 05:42:51PM -0500, Evan Foss wrote:
>> On Sun, Nov 27, 2016 at 4:13 AM, Lukas Wunner <lukas@wunner.de> wrote:
>> > On Sat, Nov 26, 2016 at 06:09:34AM +0000, Evan Foss wrote:
>> >> I did some other bug reports here a while back. I am back again
>> >> because I updated my kernel from 3.19.1 to linux-4.8.10-gentoo (if you
>> >> want I can test the mainline too). On boot all my GPU's turn on. If I
>> >> turn them off via
>> >> echo "OFF"> /sys/kernel/debug/vgaswitcheroo/switch
>> >> I can't turn them back on. They also do not turn on if I try to change
>> >> GPU's. Trying to stop xdm locks the machine so I can't even turn it
>> >> off. Suspend/resume still works. None of these problems existed in
>> >> 3.19.1. I know you will need more info to track down the problem but I
>> >> wanted to open with this.
>> >
>> > I have the same machine and it works for me.  System sleep is only
>> > supposed to work if both GPUs or ON upon suspend.  Are you issuing
>> > OFF while X11 is running?  Does it work if X11 is stopped?
>>
>> 1. Boot with the intel GPU driving the screen.
>> 2. In mate desktop turn off the nvidia gpu via echo "OFF" >
>> /sys/kernel/.../switch
>> 3. Try to do any of the following and the machine locks up turn on the
>> nvidia GPU, suspend the machine, try to change gpus, stop X (via
>> /etc/init.d/xdm stop)

Correction suspend works but hibernate does not.

>> Yes I issue OFF while it is running and it works perfectly to turn off
>> the GPU's. I can tell because the machine gets a lot cooler.
>
> On my machine issuing ON or OFF or switching always works but I only
> issue the commands on the console, without X11 running.  Does that
> work for you as well?

I am using a console inside mate. xdm runs at startup. I tried

1. stopping xdm
2. turning off the nvidia gpu at the console
3. starting xdm
and then each of the following
stoping xdm, turning off the computer, both work.

I don't care about changing GPU's with X running. That never worked
but I used to be able to turn them on and off with out having to leave
X. I don't understand why turning off a GPU that isn't generating any
video is a feature that got removed? Is there something as a
user/tester that I can do to help bring this back?

I don't expect GPU switching with X running to work any time soon.

> Manual power control via ON and OFF is a hack, it powers the GPU
> up and down behind the PM core's back.  It's a stopgap until
> runtime PM works for muxed machines.  That's the reason at least
> for the lockup on resume, I know what causes this.  (The PCI core
> invalidates the saved_state of the device.)  I don't know why
> turning on the GPU or stopping X causes a lockup, presumably on
> stopping X the card is accessed even though it's powered down.
>
> There are some half-baked patches for runtime PM on this branch:
> https://github.com/l1k/linux/commits/mbp_switcheroo_runpm_wip
>
> Alas, a rework of vga_switcheroo audio handling is necessary to
> bring up runtime PM for muxed machines properly:
> https://www.mail-archive.com/nouveau@lists.freedesktop.org/msg24997.html

I have only had trouble with the microphone input.

> Rafael Wysocki's functional dependencies patches, which are a
> prerequisite for this rework, are now queued for 4.10.  I'll
> probably look into this in December/January.
>
> Switching while X is running won't work anytime soon, I'm not
> working on it and Dave Airlie has basically said that it has no
> priority for him:
> https://www.mail-archive.com/intel-gfx@lists.freedesktop.org/msg81981.html
>
> On the bright side, you got Thunderbolt when you updated to 4.8 and
> in 4.11 it'll even power itself down when nothing is plugged in and
> save you 1.7 Watts. ;-)

Thanks I didn't know that.

> Best regards,
>
> Lukas

Thank you,
Evan

-- 
Home
http://evanfoss.googlepages.com/
Work
http://forge.abcd.harvard.edu/gf/project/epl_engineering/wiki/

-----BEGIN PGP PUBLIC KEY BLOCK-----
Version: GnuPG v2
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=Ta4p
-----END PGP PUBLIC KEY BLOCK-----
_______________________________________________
Nouveau mailing list
Nouveau@lists.freedesktop.org
https://lists.freedesktop.org/mailman/listinfo/nouveau