Re: [PATCH net-next v2 3/4] dt-bindings: net: Add RGMII internal delay for DP83869

[Dan Murphy <dmurphy@ti.com>]

Andrew

On 5/20/20 2:27 PM, Andrew Lunn wrote:
> Hi Dan
>
>> UGH I think I just got volunteered to do make them common.
> There is code you can copy from PHY drivers. :-)
>
> What would be kind of nice is if the validate was in the core as
> well. Pass a list of possible delays in pS, and it will do a
> phydev_err() if what is in DT does not match one of the listed
> delays. Take a look around at what current drivers do and see if you
> can find a nice abstraction which will work for a few drivers. We
> cannot easily convert existing drivers without breaking DT, but a
> design which works in theory for what we currently have has a good
> chance of working for any new PHY driver.

I think adding it in the core would be a bit of a challenge.  I think 
each PHY driver needs to handle parsing and validating this property on 
its own (like fifo-depth).  It is a PHY specific setting.

Take the DP83867/9 and the ADIN1200/ADIN1300.

The 8386X devices has a delta granularity of 250pS and the AD devices is 
200pS per each setting

And the 867/9 has 3x more values (15) vs only 5 for the AD PHY.

And the Atheros AR803x PHY does use rgmii-id in the yaml, which I guess 
is what you were pointing out, that if set the PHY uses a default 2nS 
delay and it is not configurable.

Same with the Broadcomm.

Ack to not changing already existing drivers which is only 2 the AD PHY 
and the DP83867 PHY.  But I can update the yaml for the 83867 and mark 
the TI specific properties as deprecated in favor of the new properties 
like I did with fifo-depth.

Dan


>       Andrew