Re: Re: directory inclusion in ext2/ext3

Re: Re: directory inclusion in ext2/ext3

[softpro]

Scott McDermott <vaxerdec () frontiernet ! net> on 2003-07-23 20:04:26:

>> i have been looking for the possibility to display the
>> contents of several directories in another one, but have
>> so far not found anything suitable.

>This sounds like Al Viro's unionfs if I'm not mistaken.

well, not really. unionfs is close because with a "mount -o bind" and 
additive mounting my problem would be solved, but what i'm looking for is a 
very high-level solution. as i said, my idea of solving this is to have an 
inclusion directive in directory-files...

has nobody ever felt the lack of such functionality??

Johannes

Re: directory inclusion in ext2/ext3

[Mike Fedyk]

On Wed, Jul 23, 2003 at 10:22:24PM +0200, softpro@gmx.net wrote:
> well, not really. unionfs is close because with a "mount -o bind" and 
> additive mounting my problem would be solved, but what i'm looking for is a 
> very high-level solution. as i said, my idea of solving this is to have an 
> inclusion directive in directory-files...
> 
> has nobody ever felt the lack of such functionality??

I guess not.

What exactly does this help you to do?

What do you want to accomplish?

Re: directory inclusion in ext2/ext3

[Grant Miner]

I would also like this enhancement.  Plan 9 is built around this 
feature, and it does it as an int argument 'flag' to mount, such that 
'flag' may be (these are defined in a header):

MREPL: Replace the old file by the new one. Henceforth, an evaluation of 
old will be translated to the new file. If they are directories (for 
mount, this condition is true by definition), old becomes a union 
directory consisting of one directory (the new file).

MBEFORE: Both the old and new files must be directories. Add the 
constituent files of the new directory to the union directory at old so 
its contents appear first in the union. After an MBEFORE bind or mount, 
the new directory will be searched first when evaluating file names in 
the union directory.

MAFTER: Like MBEFORE but the new directory goes at the end of the union.

In addition, there is an MCREATE flag that can be OR'd with any of the 
above. When a /create /system call (see /open/(2)) 
<http://plan9.bell-labs.com/magic/man2html/2/open> attempts to create in 
a union directory, and the file does not exist, the elements of the 
union are searched in order until one is found with MCREATE set. The 
file is created in that directory; if that attempt fails, the /create 
/fails.
...
(from http://plan9.bell-labs.com/magic/man2html/2/bind )

Further rationale can be provided if desired; just ask.