Re: [PATCH 1/5] ACPI: battery: Do not unload battery hooks on single error

[Armin Wolf <W_Armin@gmx.de>]

Am 19.09.22 um 21:12 schrieb Armin Wolf:

> Am 19.09.22 um 18:27 schrieb Rafael J. Wysocki:
>
>> On Mon, Sep 19, 2022 at 12:42 PM Hans de Goede <hdegoede@redhat.com> 
>> wrote:
>>> Hi,
>>>
>>> On 9/12/22 13:53, Armin Wolf wrote:
>>>> Currently, battery hooks are being unloaded if they return
>>>> an error when adding a single battery.
>>>> This however also causes the removal of successfully added
>>>> hooks if they return -ENODEV for a single unsupported
>>>> battery.
>>>>
>>>> Do not unload battery hooks in such cases since the hook
>>>> handles any cleanup actions.
>>>>
>>>> Signed-off-by: Armin Wolf <W_Armin@gmx.de>
>>> Maybe instead of removing all error checking, allow -ENODEV
>>> and behave as before when the error is not -ENODEV ?
>>>
>>> Otherwise we should probably make the add / remove callbacks
>>> void to indicate that any errors are ignored.
>>>
>>> Rafael, do you have any opinion on this?
>> IMV this is not a completely safe change, because things may simply
>> not work in the cases in which an error is returned.
>>
>> It would be somewhat better to use a special error code to indicate
>> "no support" (eg. -ENOTSUPP) and ignore that one only.
>
> I would favor -ENODEV then, since it is already used by quiet a few 
> drivers
> to indicate a unsupported battery.
>
> Armin Wolf
>
While checking all instances where the battery hook mechanism is currently used,
i found out that all but a single battery hook return -ENODEV for all errors they
encounter, the exception being the huawei-wmi driver.

I do not know the reason for this, but i fear unloading the extension on for
example -ENOTSUP will result in similar behavior by hooks wanting to avoid being
unloaded on harmless errors.

However, i agree that when ignoring all errors, battery extensions which provide
similar attributes may currently delete each others attributes.

Any idea on how to solve this?

Armin Wolf

>>>> ---
>>>>   drivers/acpi/battery.c | 24 +++---------------------
>>>>   1 file changed, 3 insertions(+), 21 deletions(-)
>>>>
>>>> diff --git a/drivers/acpi/battery.c b/drivers/acpi/battery.c
>>>> index 306513fec1e1..e59c261c7c59 100644
>>>> --- a/drivers/acpi/battery.c
>>>> +++ b/drivers/acpi/battery.c
>>>> @@ -724,20 +724,10 @@ void battery_hook_register(struct 
>>>> acpi_battery_hook *hook)
>>>>         * its attributes.
>>>>         */
>>>>        list_for_each_entry(battery, &acpi_battery_list, list) {
>>>> -             if (hook->add_battery(battery->bat)) {
>>>> -                     /*
>>>> -                      * If a add-battery returns non-zero,
>>>> -                      * the registration of the extension has failed,
>>>> -                      * and we will not add it to the list of loaded
>>>> -                      * hooks.
>>>> -                      */
>>>> -                     pr_err("extension failed to load: %s", 
>>>> hook->name);
>>>> -                     __battery_hook_unregister(hook, 0);
>>>> -                     goto end;
>>>> -             }
>>>> +             hook->add_battery(battery->bat);
>>>>        }
>>>>        pr_info("new extension: %s\n", hook->name);
>>>> -end:
>>>> +
>>>>        mutex_unlock(&hook_mutex);
>>>>   }
>>>>   EXPORT_SYMBOL_GPL(battery_hook_register);
>>>> @@ -762,15 +752,7 @@ static void battery_hook_add_battery(struct 
>>>> acpi_battery *battery)
>>>>         * during the battery module initialization.
>>>>         */
>>>>        list_for_each_entry_safe(hook_node, tmp, &battery_hook_list, 
>>>> list) {
>>>> -             if (hook_node->add_battery(battery->bat)) {
>>>> -                     /*
>>>> -                      * The notification of the extensions has 
>>>> failed, to
>>>> -                      * prevent further errors we will unload the 
>>>> extension.
>>>> -                      */
>>>> -                     pr_err("error in extension, unloading: %s",
>>>> -                                     hook_node->name);
>>>> -                     __battery_hook_unregister(hook_node, 0);
>>>> -             }
>>>> +             hook_node->add_battery(battery->bat);
>>>>        }
>>>>        mutex_unlock(&hook_mutex);
>>>>   }
>>>> -- 
>>>> 2.30.2
>>>>