Re: GPMI iMX6ull timeout on DMA

[Christian Eggers <ceggers@arri.de>]

+ set PHYTEC developers on (B)CC

On Monday, 4 October 2021, 18:06:20 CEST, Han Xu wrote:
> 
> Could you please try to add clock dis/enable when setting clock rate, in case
> clock glitches.
> 
> clk_disable_unprepare(r->clock[0]);
> clk_set_rate(r->clock[0], hw->clk_rate);
> clk_prepare_enable(r->clock[0]);
> 

With this change, we made over 2000 successful reboots without any GPMI DMA
timeout problems!

From PHYTEC (our BSP supplier), I got some possible background for this
problem. For older revisions of IMX6DQ there was an errata (ERR007117, [1])
in the ROM bootloader which triggers a similar / the same behavior:

> For raw NAND boot, ROM switches the source of enfc_clk_root from PLL2_PFD2
> to PLL3. The root clock is required to be gated before switching the source
> clock. If the root clock is not gated, clock glitches might be passed to
> the divider that follows the clock mux, and the divider might behave
> unpredictably.
> ...
> This problem can also occur elsewhere in application code if the root clock
> is not properly gated when the clock configuration is changed.

In my case (Linux boot on i.MX6ULL), I recognized that on the 3rd call of
gpmi_nfc_apply_timings(), the rate of r->clock[0] is changed 

- from: 22 MHz (CS2CDR::ENFC_CLK_PRED=6 and CS2CDR::ENFC_CLK_PODF=3)
- to:  100 MHz (CS2CDR::ENFC_CLK_PRED=4 and CS2CDR::ENFC_CLK_PODF=1)

The proposal from from Han Xu
> clk_disable_unprepare(r->clock[0]);
> clk_set_rate(r->clock[0], hw->clk_rate);
> clk_prepare_enable(r->clock[0]);
disables only CCGR4::CG14 [RAWNAND_U_GPMI_BCH_INPUT_GPMI_IO_CLK_ENABLE] during
the rate change. While this works very fine on my system, this probably doesn't
fulfill the requirements in the errata description:

> For other occurrences in application code, the following procedure should be
> followed to change the clock configuration for the enfc_clk_root:
> 1) Gate (disable) the GPMI/BCH clocks in register CCM_CCGR4.
> 2) Gate (disable) the enfc_clk_root before changing the enfc_clk_root source
>    or dividers by clearing CCM_CCGR2[CG7] to 2’b00. This disables the
>    iomux_ipt_clk_io_clk.
> 3) Configure CCM_CS2CDR for the new clock source configuration.
> 4) Enable enfc_clk_root by setting CCM_CCGR2[CG7] to 2’b11. This enables the
>    iomux_ipt_clk_io_clk.
> 5) Enable the GPMI/BCH clocks in register CCM_CCGR4

I got another solution from PHYTEC ([2], not lengthy tested yet), which
disables all GPMI/BCH clocks on CCGR4 (verified with a JTAG debugger):
- CCGR4::CG15  [RAWNAND_U_GPMI_INPUT_APB_CLK_ENABLE]
- CCGR4::CG14  [RAWNAND_U_GPMI_BCH_INPUT_GPMI_IO_CLK_ENABLE]
- CCGR4::CG13  [RAWNAND_U_GPMI_BCH_INPUT_BCH_CLK_ENABLE]
- CCGR4::CG12  [RAWNAND_U_BCH_INPUT_APB_CLK_ENABLE]
- CCGR4::CG6   [PL301_MX6QPER1_BCHCLK_ENABLE]

CCM_CCGR2[CG7] is used for IOMUX_IPT_CLK_IO_ENABLE on i.MX6ULL, so step 2.
seems not to apply here. Actually I don't know how to gate ENFC_CLK_ROOT.

I will cyclic test the solution from PHYTEC over the weekend.

@Han Xu: Should I prefer the solution from PHYTEC?
@Stefan Riedmueller: Are you willing to commit this upstream?

regards
Christian


[1] https://www.nxp.com/docs/en/errata/IMX6DQCE.pdf
[2] https://git.phytec.de/linux-mainline/commit/?h=v5.10.48-phy&id=866939ea8110764d9c12af960d746e2f7f5debe3




______________________________________________________
Linux MTD discussion mailing list
http://lists.infradead.org/mailman/listinfo/linux-mtd/